Hirschi's Control Theory

Improved Essays
Through childhood and adolescence, society teaches and pressures citizens to conform to certain expectations to allow for a peaceful and flourishing society, and the vast majority of people give in and see the logical reasoning behind these expectations. However, some citizens, such as Justin Bourque of Moncton, New Brunsick, do not. Some examples of social deviance include illegal substance abuse, driving under the influence, or in the case of Bourque, three counts of first degree murder. When criminologists look at criminals, they want to understand why, because when they learn why, they can potentially stop crime. This research has led to the development of many theories that each attempt to explain why crime is committed, including Hirschi’s …show more content…
(O’Grady, 2014) This specific theory applies to Bourque’s crime as he was not bonded properly to society in his childhood, thereby making it more likely that his egocentric impulses would be prominent. Merton’s Strain Theory suggests that society has culturally defined goals and institutionalized means to achieve them; if you don’t follow the means to achieve the culturally acceptable goal, you’re demonstrating deviant behaviour that is not to be tolerated. (O’Grady, 2014) This theory applies well to Bourque’s crime due to his demeanour and attitude towards authoritative an government figures as well as his rejection of wealth.
Using both Hirschi’s Control Theory and Merton’s Strain Theory, it can be established that a lack of familial and social bonding leads to individuals rejecting cultural norms and expectations, and ultimately leading to showing criminal behaviour and committing criminal acts as shown by Justin Bourque and his murder of three RCMP
…show more content…
In the case of murderer Justin Bourque, Hirschi’s Control Theory and Merton’s Strain Theory fits him best, due to his obvious lack of social bonds as well as his lack of culturally defined goals and his disinterest in the institutionalized means to achieve the goals. This ultimately suggests that a lack of familial and social bonding leads to individuals rejecting cultural norms and expectations, and ultimately leading to showing criminal behaviour and committing criminal acts as shown by Justin Bourque and his murder of three RCMP officers and attempted murder of two

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Wortopolis Case Study

    • 1050 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The relative deprivation theory can only explain crime that was committed by people who may not be as fortunate as others may. It can only explain crime that was committed by people who were relatively deprived in comparison to the standard. The social bond theory faces a limitation when it comes to establishment as a reason behind crime. The social bond theory has elements, which are difficult to establish because they are often personal. The four categories of attachment, commitment, involvement, and belief are often held internally and can only be measured when it has an impact on society through crime.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Blow Social Strain Theory

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Criminology Theories Based on the Movie “Blow” Why do people commit crimes? The study of crime and why some people cannot get away from criminal activities while others never have any problems have been examined for decades. The study of criminology targets why individuals commit crimes and why criminals behave in certain situations. This leads to a breakdown based on a true story of the movie “Blow” which tells the story of George Jung, one of the largest cocaine traffickers in the United States in the 1970’s.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Rebellion: The Case of Justin Bourque Crime can be critically assessed from many different sociological and criminological theories. The reasons why people commit crimes are their own, and can be a result of copious amounts of factors that get compounded, driving offenders to commit certain acts. These factors can be numerous, and range from internal factors such as mental diagnoses, to outside environmental factors, affecting the individual, such as peer associations and unstable family relations. The goal of this paper is to critically assess the tragic events of June 4, 2014 in Moncton, New Brunswick, from two criminological theories. This paper will provide assessments of the offender and offences committed, from the view points of…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Siegel and Welsh, “Inhabitants of a disorganized inner-city area feel isolated, frustrated, ostracized from the economic mainstream, hopeless, and eventually angry. These are all signs of what sociologists call strain” (2014, p. 104). In order to relieve these strains, sociologists have developed theories to demonstrates how these feelings of strain produce criminal activity. According to Robert Agnew’s theory, there are numerous life experiences that produce strain.…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Child abuse and neglect, excessive physical punishment, negative relations among friends and negative school events can be the stimulation needed for prompting deviant behaviors. The general strain theory encompasses the belief that experiences and strains among the individuals life are why certain individuals become criminals. With this theory, criminals are not born but made. With the strain triggers, the general strain theory has been expanded to when criminal behavior will likely result from. Strains that are more likely to result in crime can be seen unjust which provokes anger, in high magnitude which generate more anger since one’s ability to cope in a nonviolent way is unsettled, associated in low social control formed from the labor market, and creation of pressure or incentive to engage in criminal coping (Riedel, Welsh, 2016).…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Merton that strain theory, and crime is not created by society alone. Agnew, and Merton differ in their definition of strain theory in two ways; one being that Agnew takes a more individualist approach to strain theory, and Merton takes a more society based approach to explain crime (AGNEW, 1997, Pg. 50, & Merton, 1938, Pg.672). Agnew argues that Merton definition of strain theory is not able to explain why only some individuals do to their strain turn to crime/delinquency, and also that Merton definition neglects every other aspect of strains other than monetary (AGNEW, 1997, Pg. 50). Agnew ideal of strain theory is that immediate goals such as educational goals should also be taken into consideration when looking at strains that cause individuals to commit crimes (AGNEW, 1997, Pg. 72). Also that bad influence/stimuli, removal of positive values, and failure to achieve positive goals all create a strain on the individuals that can lead him or her into delinquency (AGNEW, 1997, Pg. 72).…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Merton, he developed his version of Strain Theory and in doing so influenced the subsequent development of General Strain Theory by Robert Agnew. When focusing on Merton’s Strain Theory, the main cause of crime is identified as ambition. Specifically, Merton claimed with Structurally Induced Strain that the “[p]oor people are not taught to be satisfied with their lot but rather are instructed to pursue the ‘American Dream’” (67). This is not to say that the so-called American Dream is bad thing but instead that some people will do whatever it takes to achieve this dream even if it means committing criminal acts. This relates to the point that “Bauskett was so anxious to raise money for a business venture that he risked 138 of his slaves by pledging them as collateral for a small loan that amounted to a mere fraction of their value” (Butterfield 24).…

    • 1729 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction This paper will set out to critically evaluate Robert K. Merton’s theory of anomie and strain. Merton's theories of anomie have been said to be among the most widely examined theories of criminilaity (Murphy, 2008). When observing criminality in society, Merton observes that some individuals feel greater pressures towards deviance than others. Merton states that certain people feel pressures towards nonconforming when society fails to provide people with equal, and acceptable opportunities to achieve aspirations and goals that are uniformly encouraged across society (Chamlin, 2013).…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hirschi believed that the “variation in the strength of social controls is what explains variation in the extent to which people engage in crime” (page 119). If the bond is stronger, criminality is less enticing and the person is more likely to conform. If the bond is weaker, then the person is more likely to submit to crime behavior. Strong bonds will only remain so if they are continuously supported and…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Agnew builds the strain theory based on the theorist Robert Merton. Merton argues that crimes caused mainly by strain, such as the difference between a person’s economic aspirations and their actual means to attain these aspirations (Merton, 1949). Merton argued that when people were unlikely to meet their goals through legitimate methods they could turn to illegal methods to attain their life objectives. However, Merton theory only concentrated on the lower social classes that engaged in crimes (Agnew, 2014). Further, Merton could not explain the reason he reacted based on criminal characteristics when faced with strain.…

    • 1778 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sociologists and criminologists have studied trends amongst individuals and their familes, as well as their environments, to determine what can be attributed to causing people to commit crime. These theories differ vastly, from assuming an entire environmental cause, to a genetic disposition, to a a desire to achieve more than is realistically plausible. The causes of crime are difficult to narrow down and say with complete confidence that this is the reason, but the studies have many times spanned much more than a glances worth of time in order to investigate the causes. I chose to look into two specific theories which I find to be the most interesting as well as the most realistic; culture conflict theory and strain theory – two theories…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They both deal with the causation aspect of criminology. Both theories note that there are several contributing factors that lead to individuals committing crime, yet each theorist believes his reasoning reigns king. Many theories are formed based upon the effects of criminal behavior and activities, yet these two attempt to spear the root cause of such occurrences. Another similarity exhibited by these two theories is that they were replaced by either derived theories or psychological theories. In regards to the strain theory, several derived theories such as the General Strain theory and the Institutional Anomie Theory trace their roots back to the strain theory.…

    • 1553 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    More specifically, this theory holds “crime occurs when members of the lower class experience anger and frustration over their inability to achieve success” (Siegel, p. 143). Individuals feel this way because they fail to achieve what they deem as success through traditional societal means. Considering the individual does not feel successful, the “strain” pushes them to seek other means for success, such as criminal activities. Understanding the background of the strain theory is valuable in order to understand the main concept. Inspired by the Great Depression, Robert K. Merton developed the first major strain theory, which explains why the concept primarily focuses on an individual 's inability to achieve monetary success (Agnew, p. 30).…

    • 1771 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In this essay I will reflect on the few assumptions and understandings I had about crime and see how they have changed. Upon arriving at De Montfort University to study Criminology and Criminal Justice, I had average knowledge about crime and punishment i.e. insight into biological and psychological perspectives of crime having studied A-level Law and Psychology beforehand. However I did expect to delve so deep into the history and other aspects of Criminology during this first semester. During A-level Law I have read many case studies of murder, manslaughter, GBH, rape etc. I found the main reasons behind committing these crimes were usually motives for revenge, loss of control, hate, rage, and biological inheritance of 'criminal genes ' such as Monoamine oxidase A which makes individuals more prone to exert violence.…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Summary Criminology studies the reasoning and factors as to why individuals engage in criminal activities. In classical criminology, social philosophers Cesare Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham developed a theory of crime that criminologist and theorist still use today (Akers 2017). In classical criminology, an individual commits a crime by making a rational decision. That decision is based off of whether the benefits that one might receive by offending outweighs the consequences such as being caught and cited or sentenced. Individuals base their decision to offend or not offend on what they have seen others suffer, their knowledge of what consequences they may endure and their own personal experiences.…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics