Benevolence Vs Self Love Analysis

Good Essays
In the past many philosophers have claim to the idea that there is an undeniable conflict between self-love and benevolence. Some, such as Thomas Hobbes and Niccolo Machiavelli have argued that time devoted to either self-love or benevolence is time drawn away from the other. For instance, they argue that time devoted to benevolence is the same as taking upon an injury to oneself to love thy neighbor. They argue that the opposite is also true. Their ideas are not without opposition however, and Bishop Joseph Butler argued openly against their ideas. Butler characterized the other philosophers as being out of touch with reality and lacking knowledge of human nature. He argues instead that human nature consists of four separate pieces working …show more content…
Conscience is therefore based on the two principles self-love and benevolence. When we determine the proper way to characterize a human being we reflect our perspectives on the actions being performed. We are able to develop a conscience that guide us direction-wise in seeking a sense of right and wrong. Butler states that conscience helps recognize that any ordinary person follow their sense of moral rightness and wrongness. Conscience makes it so a person can not view acts differing in nature the same as well. It allows reflectiveness through this viewing of past actions. An example of this would be if a person helps an individual in one instance, and harms a good-natured person in another, they can not view these acts the same. Good conscience leads a person to recognize the first act as good, and the second as one that is immoral. Self love is one’s concern for their well being in the long term. Thought egoists would state that they are equatable with desires for wealth, pleasure, power or fame, a key difference in Bishop’s theory is that he feels they are not to be equated. Bishop felt as if self-love should lead to security and long-term happiness for individuals, and the indulgences egoists related to this concept are immoral in nature. People who utilize elements of self-love engage in more productive activities such as love and respect …show more content…
It can include “evils” such as lust, greed and the other deadly sins, but at the same time can reflect desires to reproduce, reputation a need to socialize, and others. What is interesting about specific passions is their tug and pull with self-love and benevolence. It can either aid or hinder either of them.
Self-love receives aid from specific passions regarding desire to use talents, and yearning for respect and dignity from others. This interaction is not without its downsides however, as specific passions can harm self-love in various ways at well. Greed specifically is harmful as it relates to self-love. it can lead to overindulgence, such as a need or desire to drink, eat too much, or even become lazy. The way in which greed harms self-love is through a yearning for the indulgences. A lack of those indulgences, and a feeling of need for them leads to discomfort with one’s being.
Benevolence interacts with specific passions as well. Benevolence in combination with specific passions benefits human esteem for success. Furthermore it aids courage, and our contempt for vice. Contempt for vice is an especially important element considering it not only builds a quality person, but increases their resistance to temptation, and other evils. This allows the person to cement their

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    According to Robert Thurman’s “Wisdom,” the alternative method of obtaining happiness is through selflessness. Both Gilbert and Thurman illustrate throughout their essays that the more control one has on his or her environment and one’s brain, the less happiness he or she will experience. The ideas of how needing explanation, deliberating fabricating facts, and feeling regret proves that having control can lead to unhappiness. There is a famous…

    • 1980 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Our will must be good to want to cause the most pleasure and minimize suffering. Since one has a good will, they will most likely carry out the right act, whether that is an effective act is irrelevant. Voice 2: And here we come back to one of our first points, one does not have to have good will to do good. Yes, the good willed are more likely to carry out an act that maximizes happiness but it is not necessary to happen. Even if the person did not mean good, if we praise them then maybe they can be persuaded to act so that it maximizes everyone’s happiness and not just their own.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rejection can have really adverse effects on people, so the psychological immune system kicks in to tune out this negativity because its job is to preserve a positive outlook. In following this process, it can be concluded that a person can be happy because they live without rejection and with acceptance. This only further enforces the point that people’s happiness partially depends on their acceptance from others. It is said that, “Being rejected by a large and diverse group of people is a demoralizing experience because it is so thoroughly unambiguous” (Gilbert 134). This demonstrates that, similar to how Solomon describes wanting to be accepted by others was a priority in achieving happiness, when people are rejected by others, they experience decreased happiness.…

    • 1414 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Aristotle's Virtue

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There are three bad shapes of character: vice, incontinence, and brutishness. Contrary to these are the virtue, continence, and superhuman virtue. A virtuous person’s wishes are aligned with a reasonable rationale so that virtuous act is satisfying and leading to happiness. According to Aristotle, one of an essential condition for a person to be virtuous is that he takes pleasure in acting virtuously. Whereas, a continent individual acts according to virtue and does so for the right reason but his desires are wrong.…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If we have been habituated to feel pleasure and pain the right way, then those attitudes become second nature to us. The way that this ties into virtue and acting virtuously is because acting virtuously is not the same as being virtuous, but being virtuous is the means to becoming virtuous. It’s all about what’s at the root of habituation, and that is…

    • 1885 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Decent people should not desire to be base. Vicious people are guided by non-rational parts of their souls, and have lives guided by feelings. They overvalue money, honors, and bodily pleasures, and desire what appears advantageous to them. They allow the spirited and appetitive parts of their souls to overtake their rational part, and live base lives. Vicious people are competitive: they try overreaching to gratify only non-rational parts of their souls which consequently involves harming others.…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    While warning Othello of the dangers of jealousy, namely that it makes a fool of those who succumb to it, he begins to stoke that very vice in Othello’s heart. Iago also makes an interesting and astute insight into human nature. He proposes that those who no longer feel love towards the one whom they know betrayed them have the better lot. Those who are unsure and unable to severe the bond between them and the one they feel betrayed by suffer most because they still strongly desire that love but are unsure whether it exists. They are thus tormented.…

    • 1621 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It has come to mean self-obsessed, narcissistic, and vain. People are sometimes wary to show that they are proud of themselves for fear of being labeled as ‘egotistical’ or ‘egocentric’/ Though, the words “ego” means a person’s self-esteem or self-worth. People should be allowed to focus on themselves or to have pride without fear of how others view them. Anthem is very good at expressing a human’s need to be recognized as an individual. As well as it is excellent at showing the base need for ‘ego’ and the benefits of ego in a person.…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Envy that helps individuals envision dreams and conceptions of self. In analyzing others' and seeking to develop the same for ourselves is where envy might play a powerful role for good. (Ashley Kannan). In Conclusion, envy is wanting what someone else has and resenting them for having it. Envy is a very powerful emotion, it can be harmful and helpful depending on how you portray the word.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Dishonesty Research Paper

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Often times in different aspects of life, including relationships, situations arise where one has the choice to be honest or dishonest. Much of the time, dishonesty seems like the optimal choice, but it is the wrong one. When one does something generally immoral or unapproved by another person closely involved with one, who is unaware of this immorality, one can express the whole truth about what happened, or one can be dishonest about it. Because the event that occurred would upset the person involved with one, one can be tempted to not tell the truth about what happened, in order to avoid an unpleasant reaction from this person. Dishonesty can consist of completely lying about a situation, or simply not including certain details.…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics