Review Of Philippe Bourgois's In Search Of Respect

Improved Essays
In the book, In Search of Respect, Philippe Bourgois, an anthropologist conducts an ethnography on the people of Harlem. As Bourgois noted in the introduction of his book, according to the Federal Census, almost ~40% of the people in Harlem are living under poverty. That is to suggest, that the people of Harlem shouldn't be able to sustain themselves given the income they earn. However, the people of East Harlem are able make ends need, therefore they must be adjusting their lifestyle in some way, such as operating an underground economy. For that reason, Bourgeois' initial intentions were to understand the underground economy of East Harlem, specifically drug dealing, as the first half of the book attempts to justify why Caesar and Primo became …show more content…
He then suggests that these world wide structural oppressions is the reason why Primo and Caesar does not have the appropriate cultural capital to work in the F.I.R.E. sector. Before the colonization, most Puerto Ricans were subsistence farmers which were very stable to begin with. When Puerto Rico was colonized, the government redistributed the land to U.S. corporations, and farms were then monetized by large corporations,drastically changing the lives of Puerto Ricans. Bourgois makes an assumption that Primo and Caesar’s parents were peasants and were affected by the sudden industrialization of Puerto Rico. Therefore, their parents immigrated to New York around the time of 1940s and 1950s, which at that time was an industrial capital. However, these jobs were then moved to oversea due to cheaper labor cost and lack of labor regulations. By 1987, “almost half a million factory workers lost their jobs as manufacturing employment dropped by 50 percent in New York City” …show more content…
First was the big migration of Puerto Rico, and the other was the global restructuring of capitalism. To clarify, the migration of Puerto Rico, placed Primo and Caesar in a disadvantage. Unlike the typical immigrant story, the moment Primo and Caesar entered New york, there was the restructuring of capitalism, as jobs were leaving New York City. Bourgois then questions the “Step Ladder” theory, which suggests that assimilation happens on a generation level similar to a ladder. However, the first rung of the ladder for Primo and Caesar disappeared right when Caesar and Primo entered the workforce. It seemed reasonable to Primo and Caesar to drop out of high school to become a factory worker. To repeat, Primo and Caesar did not drop out of highschool to deal drugs, but to commit to back-breaking occupation. However, in the eyes of Bourgois, he believes it is an economic

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Contributing to existing scholarship does not always mean forging a new or innovative methodology. Sometimes a book can be a worthwhile read and follow the structure of earlier works. It is in this manner that readers will most appreciate Timothy Silver’s A New Face on the Countryside: Indians, colonists, and slaves in South Atlantic forests. The author quickly acknowledges his appreciation for two earlier works in environmental history that inspired this book, Alfred W. Crosby Jr.’s…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Throughout the introduction and first two chapters of his book, In Search of Respect: Selling Crack in El Barrio, Bourgois describes the multiple causes of impoverished living within the Hispanic and Black society. He attributes the colonization of Puerto Rico and the immigration of its people to the United States as the central impediment to the welfare of Hispanics living in East Harlem during the time he conducted his research. The immigrants from Puerto Rico were not only expected to adapt to a foreign society and economic system, but to do so while suffering intense racism from white supremacists. In order for them to acclimate, they had to abandon their previous values and customs that shaped their identity. This process of settler racism…

    • 237 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “Let us walk into the conference room as equals and not second class citizens” once said by Martin McGuinness, an Irish republican. McGuinness’ quote talks about social classes just like Marxist Criticism talks about social classes like in Fitzgerald’s novel, The Great Gatsby. Marxist Criticism is a theory about different social classes that can be found in any movie, book, fairytale, and real life. F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote the famous novel is a good point to Marxist Criticism that include inequality between social classes and how they interact with one another. Being in different social classes, people treasure their belongings based on how wealthy they are and who they are trying to impress.…

    • 196 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There was even socio-economical differences in those who did the renting: higher-class families, lower-class families, single men. Another theme of this text is identity. Those who emigrated from Europe, no matter what their social standing was, came with a larger zeal and zest for America…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    1) What, according to Marx in The Communist Manifesto, must one understand in order to understand the course of historical development? What, in other words, is it that moves history along? The Communist Manifesto opens to the reader by stating, “The history of all hitherto societies has been the history of class struggles”, meaning that there is a perpetual tug-of-war struggle between class status between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat (Marx, 1). Marx states that the bourgeoisie are those who set up the production as “the class of modern capitalists”, whereas the proletariat is the group that works beneath the means of production from the bourgeoisie, “having no means of production of their own” (footnote, 1).…

    • 1536 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With this new generation of mill workers and immigrants there is a shift in the working class. “The Slovaks came; and once more there was a general displacement. The Irish began to invade the better parts of the town, while those Americans and English who could afford it fled into Pittsburgh’s suburbs” (Bell 122). As immigrants continued to travel to America contempt for them grew. At the time many Americans were against immigration.…

    • 1874 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Film Review: The Poniente What does it take to grow a tomato plant? For most people, perhaps a handful of seeds, a bag of fertilizer, and the occasionally trimming and watering would be sufficient enough to harvest the fruits in a few months’ time. Yet, as the film The Poniente has showed, the real cost behind these seemly average household items, are often beyond our imaginations. The Poniente tells the story of a single mother, Lucia, who tried to lead the family business in a rural costal town.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Puerto Ricans

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Puerto Ricans: citizens yet foreigners Today Puerto Ricans make up about 2.8 million of the population in America. Versus the island of Puerto Rico itself making up 3.8 million The authors parents came to America with one of the first big waves in 1946. His parents Juan and Florinda arrived at the airport from San Juan. In 1932 his grandfather who was an engineer died of pneumonia. Which consequently spiraled his family into poverty.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    S. E. Hilton’s novel and popular film The Outsiders expresses a variety of internal and external conflicts including the main conflict in the novel, which is the division and struggle among social class. The two groups, Socs and Greasers, are drastically different, but also similar in a variety of ways. Socs and the Greasers are merely adolescents struggling with personal and social complications that unfold within society. As the greasers are portrayed as low-life scum no-good-for-nothing-dirt-bags, and on the other hand, Socs are depicted as privileged rich kids who catch all the “big breaks.” What determines to where each member of society belongs which group is the individual’s appearance and finance.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Collector by John Fowles is a tale expressing the dark side of what could occur when someone not used to the power that comes with money suddenly falls into large sums of it. The book takes the most dark possible view and shows a man from the lower class known as Clegg taking advantage of his newfound power to kidnap and hold a member of the educated middle class named Miranda captive. When discussing the class relations he references the ideology of the two classes, Aristoi or the educated and Hoi Polloi or the masses, created by greek philosopher Heraclitus, Fowles states that “the dividing line must run through individuals, not between them” Fowles clearly means to speak to the animosity in the modern class system, he seems to believe…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This division of labor described in the previous paragraph is a clear sentiment to Marx’s theories and philosophies on the bourgeoisie and the proletariat. Essentially, Rose and her brother are laborers, proletariat, and Rose’s mother and father are the bourgeoisie in this human harvesting scheme. Rose along with her brother have the competence to terminate this entire lucrative arrangement due to the fact that they are basically the wheels of this machine. Without Rose or her brother acquiring new victims to undergo the transplantation of well to do Caucasians’ brain into their captive African Americans’ bodies, the entire business would merely fall to shambles. This being said, the likeliness of Rose and her brother turning their backs on their bosses/ parents is extremely low.…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Fahrenheit 451, a dystopian novel by Ray Bradbury, the government controls its citizens by eliminating books and other forms of mental stimulation, which are replaced by mind-numbing television shows and school programs. The control exerted on citizens by the government and media reflects Karl Marx’s theory of social classes, which can be seen in the novel's characters, as well as it’s description of government control. Fahrenheit was written in the 1950’s, during the Red Scare. This was a time when Americans feared communism and it’s possible infiltration of the government and society. Jonathan Eller points out that “the book was conceived while Josef Stalin was still in power in Russia and published before Sen. Joseph McCarthy was censured…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the analysis of the novel, The Adventure of Don Chipote or, When Parrots Breast-Feed by Daniel Venegas, it was of utmost importance to note Nicolás Kanellos put great effort into the circulation of said novel in Spanish and English. Kanellos, in his findings, contends that Spanish-language immigrant novels more accurately present the wickedness of American society such as the oppression of immigrant workers. Presumptuously, Kanellos could have felt so passionately about circulating this particular novel due to the fact that Venegas’ novel clearly represents the native in their homeland, the immigrant, and the exile cultures experienced in a foreign land. Don Chipote is a picaresque and satire novel that address the representation of the…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine putting on lenses, in which one can uncover underlying issues; one understands the topic but does not fully comprehend it. While most people in the world understand that there are economic separations between the rich and the poor, the concept that the separation is not just economically but is in fact a range of dimensions such as education, family structure, etc often becomes lost in translation. The Marxist lens discusses this issue; it uncovers that the class divide between the rich and the poor has been around since the beginning of civilization. In fact, Shakespeare, a famous playwright, experienced such class divide which can be read in his tragedy Hamlet. In Hamlet, the class divide is prominent with the oppressive actions Claudius and the readiness of the bourgeoisie to please the royals, showcasing the Marxist theory.…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    MC / Vocab Practice #2 - Jack London, What Life Means to Me Paraphrase Paragraph 1: London has been overworked to the point that it affected his health Reduced to a beggar that went from door to door Paragraph 2: London has lost his position in the working class He has fallen into poverty, the area ignored by society Paragraph 3: Due to his poverty, London saw the simplicity of society Every person had a commodity to sell Man inherently sold items to satisfy basic needs Labor only contained the commodity of muscle Paragraph 4: Laborers are unable to restock on their commodity Muscle disappears over time, leaving the laborer poor Once the muscle has disappeared, poverty ensues Paragraph 5: The brain was a commodity just like muscle Brain sellers…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays