Gerald Graff's Response: Hidden Intellectualism

Superior Essays
Samual Yisehak
C. Petitti
ENGL 1105-42R
29 September 2016
Hidden Intellectualism Response Gerald Graff, a professor of English at the University of Illinois, wrote Hidden Intellectualism, an excerpt from the book They Say/I Say. The essay tackles the issue that one cannot be intelligent in any context except for the academic world. Intellectualism by any other subject is just as academic. I agree with Graff’s main point, however, I take umbrage with small details used in the essay. In any other world of that has interests or hobbies, that specific brand of intellectualism is just as important as academic intellectualism.
Graff writes that colleges and schools argue that subjects that are not inherently weighty and academic are not worth improving our intellects: “We assume that it’s possible to wax intellectual about Plato,
…show more content…
Being book smart was necessary among the former group, but the latter group did not appreciate book smarts at all. Graff needed to know both of the groups’ protocols and accurately distinguish between both of them, and apply those protocols accordingly. Both groups have their own values, thoughts, actions, modus operandi, and norms that separate them from one another. Learning about both of them is intellectual in itself.
Graff then states that in his seeming anti-intellectual proceedings with his friends about toughness and sports, he “learned the rudiments of intellectual life: how to make an argument, weigh different kinds of evidence, move between particulars and generalizations, summarize the views of others, and enter a conversation about ideas” (Graff). Though he did not go through your average academic debates, the rules of engagement are one in the same; one shares ideas, has discussions, disagreements, and debates. The stringency of the debate rules is largely the only changing

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Sadly, many people believe that being street smart is a waste of time, and students should spend more time on their school work than wasting time on things like popular culture and sports. Graff started practicing being an intellectual even before he knew that was what he would be (Graff, 2001). While arguing about toughness and other subjects with his friends, he acquired the rudiments of developing an argument, weighing the different types of evidence, particulars and generalizations, and summarizing the views of others before entering a conversation about ideas. In addition, he was learning elementary semiotics in the…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hidden Intellectualism has been become a controversial topic for educators of late and needs to be assessed so that educators can address this particular issue and modify classroom teachiwhether or not a person with a highly evolved “street smarts” and who does poorly in an academic environment should be considered any less intellectual than one who is well acclimated to academia and categorized as an excellent student On the one hand gerald graff argues that “real intellectuals turn any subject how ever lightweight it may seem, into gist for their mill through the thoughtful questions they bring to it. Whereas a dullard will find a way to drain even the richest subject”. The essence of Gerald Graff 's argument is that students should be…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Critical thinkers “need a keen power of observation… need to become facile with abstract though and to be able to share abstractions in coherent ways with others” (Petress). As Kelly states, there is general harmony that critical thinking includes developing skills and having a disposition to it. Yet, students without critical thinking skills whether due to lack of having them or lack of them being developed…

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pronunciation Of Diction

    • 1120 Words
    • 4 Pages

    We were also really good in giving examples relating with the essay topics. Giving them ideas on some arguments, thesis, introduction, etc. c. What was seminar not effective in teaching clearly? We were not very good at explain the Why’s of the essay. For example not being able to explain why the introduction contains an anecdote and not a general description of the thesis.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, it was difficult not to ask specific questions based on answers he gave me while still maintaining a smooth interview. It was also challenging to keep a straight face through out the interview and nod my head in agreement with everything he said. On a side note, I found it useful to picture myself conducting an interview as a news reporter would. The answers that were provided to me by my interviewee are going to help steer my research towards a direction of questioning why so many young adults are unimpressed by civil action. If I am researching what qualifies as legitimate social activism, I should research whether the difference in ages influences the types of involvement or outcomes in civil movements.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    McShane’s teaching style. McShane taught us these skills not by scribbling them out on the board, through a handout, or a textbook reading, but as they were discovered throughout The Iliad. He asked questions that revealed the hidden doors too us, then made us find our way back to see how we came across it in the first place. His self-directed style of learning made me want to be involved in the process rather than the result. He connected with us by almost disassociating himself from what he was teaching.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First, it can take away form the students ability to make moral decisions. Also regulating hate speech can take away learning opportunities from the students. Being exposed to views that are out in the world, no matter if they may be wrong or just something you disagree with, is important. College can serve as a good place for these conversations about these controversial topics to happen. I think that my debate team did well in creating thorough arguments against the regulation of hate speech on college campuses.…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When they question each action, they are challenging their perspectives, giving themselves an opportunity to be diverse in their own expressions and thoughts. He concludes his editorial with stating how universities “restrain speech” that they find unsettling. The purpose of Zimmer’s editorial is to show the effects of limiting speech within the universities. The author’s purpose is not to cast blame on either side, but to challenge his audience, the students of universities, to step up and reclaim their voice as the next generation. While Zimmer explains the…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the article “Hidden Intellectualism” by Gerald Graff, he writes about how the American society views street smarts in the lines,” Nor do we consider one of the major reasons why schools and colleges overlook the intellectual potential of street smarts: the fact that we associate those street smarts with anti intellectual concerns. We associate the educated life, the life of the mind, too narrowly and exclusively with subjects and texts that we consider inheritably weighty and academic. We assume that it’s possible to wax intellectual about Pluto, Shakespeare, the French Revolution, and nuclear fission, but not about cars, dating, fashion, sports, TV, or Video Games.” (Graff…

    • 1647 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    James Baldwin Reflection

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It was challenging because I was forced to flesh out my own ideas, it was difficult to communicate an argument that analyzes the use of language, while making an argument about how the author demonstrates how to uses that language. It was basically and argument about language and the use of language. Even discussing my argument to family and friends was difficult. Although, I still believe that this essay needs to be fleshed out a little bit more, I am proud of the fact that I was writing about something that truly challenged me, instead of writing an essay that would be easy to support and even easier to complete. This essay was a complex idea to communicate, but it was an idea that I was…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays