Comparing Goetz's Analysis Of Gentrification In Black And White

Improved Essays
In “Gentrification in Black and White: The Racial Impact of Public Housing”, Edward Goetz highlights the disproportionate displacement of African Americans stemming from the demolition of public housing projects. Goetz asserts that through the U.S.’s housing policy, particularly the demolition of public housing and the displacement of its residents- a majority of whom are African Americans, local governments are able to instigate neighborhood change and gentrification. In “Gentrification in Black and White”, Goetz effectively highlights the intersection of race and class through his analysis of the phenomenon of “Black Gentrification”, in which the gentrifiers are Black middle-class homeowners who displace low-income Black residents, as well …show more content…
While Goetz explains “Black Gentrification” as the displacement of low-income Black households by middle-class Black families, he emphasizes that this phenomenon is a result of a legacy of racial segregation and inclusion, coupled with the restricted mobility of the Black middle class (Goetz 1583). By highlighting the phenomenon roots in institutional racism and classism, Goetz reveals the intrinsic connection between the racialization of African Americans as the non-white “Other” and the capitalist, wealth-based hierarchy has served to further marginalize low-income Black households. Additionally, Goetz’s analysis of the greater frequency of state-sponsored demolition of public housing developments in predominantly African American communities with a high concentration of poverty and families receiving welfare assistance further highlights the neoliberal US housing policy, in which the displacement of low-income Black communities serves to reimagine urban spaces in ways that are favorable to private investments (Goetz 1582). Goetz’s analysis illuminates how dilapidation and neglect of housing projects in low-income, Black communities is intrinsically tied to how the US Department of …show more content…
Goetz’s work opens doors for further discussion regarding the government’s emphasis on neoliberal, urban redevelopment and support of the reimagination of urban spaces in favor of corporate interests over the protection of low-income, minority

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In her book “Southside,” Natalie Moore addresses the means of segregation within Chicago’s neighborhoods, by focusing on racial preference, diversity, identity, and effects it has on black neighborhoods. Natalie Moore shares her own view as a black women living in the south side of Chicago, examining how racial segregation within communities has created a “white” and “black’ Chicago, leading to racial inequalities. Moore asserts the importance of diversity within Chicago, but suggests that racial inequalities and the “legacy of segregation and its ongoing policies have kept the city divided” (Moore#). She links problems such as underemployment and violence which are directly associated to the south side, and connects it all back to segregation. Even more, segregation of the white and black communities has lead to preference making which naturally segregates black and white neighborhoods.…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Arnold Hirsch Book Review

    • 113 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Author, Arnold R. Hirsch is a History Professor at the University of New Orleans. In his book Hirsch argues that post-depression Chicago was the leading runner in developing new concepts for housing segregation. Hirsch explains the legal framework for the national urban renewal effort. He writes how Chicago’s South Side raged with racial struggles and at times violent segregation. His book has received many praises’ for its deep thoroughly researched study.…

    • 113 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gentrification has been a long topic that has been recently discussed as if effects all across the United States. In the podcast “Mouth to Ear” the Black and Latino communities their were renovations to their community when showed that whites were moving into their community. As a result of this rent increased, the area around them started to become more expensive, and this led to low-income residents moving out because they did not have the money, or was force out. The podcasts gave several examples of low-income residents forced out their homes because they did not have the money the landowners wanted. The podcast gave an example of a women living in Bedford Stuyvesant was forced out of her apartment new building owners bought the building.…

    • 226 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Places of their own: African-American Suburbanization by Andrew Wiese examines the forces behind the suburbanization of Black Americans in the 20th century and the challenges they faced in doing so. The author emphasized the importance of black suburbanization for the growth of the 20th century the United States. Establishment of suburbs was critical to the study of Black Americans in the United States. The emergence of suburbs was a representative of the new generation of black American, who were socially and economically advanced compared to the past.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These riots resulted in a devastation in the neighborhood’s economy and public housing began to flourish. Federal housing policy reforms were intended to prioritise housing of the poorest , single mothers on welfare and the homeless. Soon the public housing of projects will soon serve as a home to over millions of people over the years. But in 2011 chicago last high rising public housing homes came tumbling down and for those who were living in the projects, there’s a piece of them that was also knocked down. The public housing destruction resulted in many low income people being forced from their homes and forced to struggle to find new affordable housing that offers equal or greater…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the article “Robert Taylor Homes” from the Chicago Days, Flynn McRoberts wrote about the failure of the Robert Taylor Homes --a part of the housing projects -- which were high-rise buildings crammed with thousands of poor black families. It was seen that the Robert Taylor Homes increased the amount of crime in the city when McRoberts wrote, “In CHA developments unemployment ran as high as 90 percent, and residents were at least twice as likely to be the victims of serious crime as other Chicagoans” (McRoberts). McRoberts used these statistics to emphasize how big the housing projects issue really was. Shoving a large number of uneducated and unemployed people into a small vicinity will only bring anger and frustration. These homes gave the blacks a place to start crime and to escalate the violence that comes with it.…

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Knocking the Hustle: Against the Neoliberal Turn in Black Politics, Lester Spence examines the predominance of neoliberalism in Black communities. He challenges policies over the last forty years, which produced profit under the guise of community development. Spence finds that the neoliberal policies have the worse impact on Black communities. This paper will argue that because of the idea of the hustle, charter schools, and Black political actors, urban Black communities remain tied to poverty because neoliberalism deprives dependent communities of resources in the false hope of the private sector or market using their resources to help society.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He argues that African Americans were denied not only access to many of the more affluent American suburbs but also recognition that they not only hungered for but attained “places of their own.” The Author Andrew Weise traces African American suburbanization from the nineteenth-century to the Twenty-first century. He starts with black enclaves on the edges of most southern and many northern towns to the sprawling automobile suburbs of today. When those who could afford to do so moved away from urban problems.…

    • 2192 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Black On The Block Summary

    • 1841 Words
    • 8 Pages

    These economic and political aspects had greatly defined social homogeny and stratification. Although this book focuses on a study about the historic rise and the renewal of Chicago’s North Kenwood–Oakland neighborhood, Pattillo firmly states that "... this book is not a study in the causes and consequences of gentrification," (Pattillo, 20). However, it is about urban renewal, public housing, and mixed-income communities where the Black community negotiate with each other, the outside players, and various layers of public decisions that frame what is preferable and what is possible…

    • 1841 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Their research defines gentrification as “the process of white people” supposedly claiming back or “reclaiming the inner cities by moving into” African American communities (94). Not only are these white people coming into these African American neighborhoods reclaiming them, but they are breaking up the culture asset of these communities as well. When gentrification occurs, the thought of a community transforming because now the communities are profit driven instead of culture driven. When a community is culture driven it means that the local businesses are owned and supported by the local community members. To add, there is a lot of community communication with a culture driven neighborhood.…

    • 1960 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This fact that black neighborhoods where crowed forced black residents to push on the harsh constraints imposed on them by pitiful white landlords and a racist culture. Black Detroiters tried many ways to manage their community's expansion but Sugrue argues that white people experienced these tactics as threats to their own economic and social well being. Sugrue is quick to point out the white violence against black people, or the fast paced abandonment of beat down areas. Sugrue's knowledge of economic and social history helps us better understand the decisions of Detroit residents in the 1940s through 1960s. Surgues main point of this book is how Detroit transformed from a wartime boomtown to a city struggling with post war recession and how the effect of African Americans fleeing to the city had a toll on the city.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ms. Moore starts off with an incisive criticism of segregation, its underlying causes and the apparent unwillingness of Chicago Mayors to focus on it. However, Moore argues that even so, the South Side is a “magical place”. She describes it as a strong community with “vibrant business, bars, funeral homes”. The author briefly describes what is beautiful about having been raised in the South Side and then proceeds to relay her point to the readers: Diversity is worth celebrating, high-poverty segregation is not. She then explores the negative effects of segregation and then proceeds to briefly examine the effects on segregation the housing crisis had.…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The pressure builds up as wealthier people start moving in replacing those who left or will leave. Furthermore, when housing and renting prices rise, those who are unable to afford it will be forced to plan an alternative way to save their homes. In Saki Knafo’s article, “Is Gentrification a Human Rights Violation?,” he expresses his concern, “what happens to those people who can’t afford to stay in these “revitalized” neighborhoods? ,” (Knafo 12). Often, these low-income residents who can’t manage to pay will either struggle to compensate for the payments until they face eviction or eventually be forced to move out instantly.…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction Gentrification is a trend in urban communities that causes the displacement of lower income, long-time residents and small businesses with affluent middle class households. Due to the shift in culture and socio-economic status of these urban communities, there is an increase in property and rental taxes, which makes it impossible for the lower income families to compete with the rising housing rates. Gentrification has been identified as a social problem. The Fair Housing Act of 1968 was implemented to address discrimination in the housing market. This public policy can also be utilized to tackle the social injustice of gentrification.…

    • 1943 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many commentators have claimed that this concentration of poverty has produced enormously negative societal consequences.” Written by Michael R. Diamond, these two sentences describe perfectly how public housing was used as a tool for segregation and aided in the failure of…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays