Cultural Homogamy Vs Traditional Family Analysis

Improved Essays
In the U.S., the biggest changes in the family are in its structure and changing priorities. In the past century, and particularly in recent decades, the definition of the family has widened to be inclusive of a spectrum of family structures, not just nuclear or traditional families. Less people are getting married and the divorce rate has increased, as have single parent homes and cohabitation, while birth rates have decreased. Ideas about gender roles in families have also been challenged with the women’s rights movement and the legalization of same sex marriage. There has also been an increase in interracial and interreligious marriages. (Moore and Asay, pg. 28, 35).
Vasant and Champa had an arranged, traditional Indian marriage and a traditional
…show more content…
The use of Biodata sheets allows the family, mainly Ravi’s parents, to ensure that whatever girl he chooses will be of their same race, religion, and be a Patel. Many of the theories mentioned in the text agree that “to raise children responsibly, to provide economic support, and to give family members emotional security” (Moore and Asay, pg. 31) are three essential functions of a family. The concept of cultural homogamy and maintaining it allows families to ensure that their partners and their children’s partners will have an identical or at least very similar set of values to themselves. This consensus on morals and values makes it easier for families to make decisions about how to best achieve these three functions, and could reduce the need for arguments and the need compromising their opinions, priorities, or cultural traditions and values. While this may have worked fairly easily for the Patel’s in India, it becomes much more difficult to achieve while living in the U.S, where homogamy is becoming less important in many families, and in the culture overall, especially in the generation that Ravi and Geeta are a part of. According to the text, interracial U.S. marriages have gone from 0.7% of all messages to 5% in three decades. (Moore an Asay, pg. 35). Religious homogamy is even less of a priority, with 37% of US marriages not being in religious homogamy. (Moore …show more content…
Vasant and Champa live in the US, and the differences between Indian and American culture have an effect on them and particularly on their children. Ravi and Geeta, as well as the parents, are part of two cultures, as are many families in the U.S. Families in this situation often find themselves trying to balance “value systems and behaviors” in order to belong in both of the cultures that they belong to, which can lead to significant conflict and need to compromise. (Moore and Asay, pg. 107). By contrast, the extended family in India is completely immersed in Indian culture, and when Ravi and the family go to visit, Ravi finds that the extended family in India doesn’t even question the traditional system for marriage there. Some of Ravi’s American friends at home have the opposite influence. There is a scene where they are all having lunch together, and Ravi’s friends are acting very confused about the idea of arranged marriage, and while they don’t directly say they are against it, it appears to make some of them somewhat uncomfortable, as it is an idea that they’re not used

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Each culture has its own unique perspective of significant events that occur during one’s lifetime, including arranged marriages. Traditionally in the Indian culture, nearly 70 per cent of marriages are arranged nowadays (The Times of India). Many people from the Indian descent believe that marriages should be a result of a perfect match for one another based on specific factors such as education, salary and property.. An example of this can be found in the novel, The Hero's Walk, when Putti and her mother, Ammayya are discussing marriage suggestions. Putti is used to her mother giving her little opinion as Ammayya states “Yes, my pearl, don’t you worry about anything.…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Non Traditional Families

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As early as the fourth paragraph they call to attention the amount of non-traditional families that are living in the U.S., “They rarely talk about… the 30 percent of parents who are not married or the 18 percent of families with children who are in poverty” (Par. 4). They directly call out two specific groups of non-traditional families in the U.S. and there are many more ways a family could be non-traditional, such as interracial and same-sex parents. By stating those two statistics, the authors imply that a large proportion of families living in the United States are non-traditional and that politicians are not talking to most of American families. The authors then show how Democrats and Republicans use arguments and ideas to argue how they have differing views on what is good for families, yet only think and talk about traditional families, “Democrats cite families when they advocate for more regulation and stronger government programs, while Republicans hold up the family when calling for lower taxes and less government.” (par. 11).…

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “What is Cultural Identity,” by Elise Trumbull and Maria Pacheco, they describe India’s marital values as, “Arranged marriage has long been a cultural practice in India based on the belief that families of potential spouse’s best know who would make a desirable match. More and more frequently, however, individuals reject…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Home: Warm, Bond Elaine Tyler May’s book Homeward Bound: American Families in the Cold War Era explores the reason postwar Americans approached marriage and parenthood with greater commitment and enthusiasm than their parents and children did. It is common for wars to have lasting impacts on the society, especially to those who engage in the war. The American situation was peculiar considering that the country took a leading role in the World War II that ended up defining the fate of the country as a world superpower. As the most valued social fabric, the family had a bigger role to play during the war.…

    • 1689 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the book, The Way We Never Were: American Families and the Nostalgia Trap by Stephanie Coontz, the author deconstructs various types of stereotypes and myths embodied by television shows that romanticize family life and gender roles. Coontz (1992) states that these idealizations promote the “traditional family” myth which she describes as “an ahistorical amalgam of structures, values, and behaviors that never coexisted in time and place” (p.9). The notions derived from this myth are a compound of characteristics that resemble mid-nineteenth century and early 20th century paradigms concerning family life (Coontz, 1992, p.9). Coontz (1992) describes both components in detail in Chapter 1 describing the first as a mother-child oriented family…

    • 1998 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, the author is at first “enthusiastic” about a certain match, but then learns about factors she hadn’t even considered. Her friend tells Serena “The family has so many daughters, how will they be able to provide nicely for any of them?” This and other statements show the financial and even racial bias still present in India today. Nanda argues her ethical and cultural views by rebuking that “the quality of the girls themselves made up for any deficiency in the elaborateness of the wedding.”…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (2.1.335-336) As you can imagine, having a great amount of money is not bad, especially for this time. But, what is the downside to this? The downside here is that it is an arranged marriage. While this practice is very common in eastern countries, most other countries have either stopped or never have had this as a regular practice. In this case, arranged marriages were business arrangements and was about the dowry, not about love on a personal level.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1: While taking a vacation trip to Bulgaria this past summer, my whole family stayed at a town called Dobrinishte for a couple of days to swim in the mineral water pool there. However, one day, inclement, cloudy weather compelled us to alter our pool plans for that day and find another activity to do instead. Being new to the place, we had to ask the hotel owners if they knew of any interesting historical places around the area, and they informed us of a monastery up in the mountains about two hours walking distance away from the town. Nevertheless, the hotel owners assured us that once we passed a couple turns on the main highway and turned off onto the main, dirt-road trail leading up through the mountains to the monastery, the path would…

    • 1886 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Dream and American Society have sensed changed from the Leave it to Beaver, nuclear family of the 1950s and sixties. From the suburban household with a husband at work, wife at home and their children, playing in the front yard. Brought upon many changes in the past couple of years to the staple of the nuclear family. Yet the traditional family still survives today, only to integrate and become a category among the varied families that now shape the new American society. This melting pot of families has emerged out of decades of movements and events, though the twenty-first century brought a surge of change to what is now viewed as the many faces of the modern American family.…

    • 1414 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author through this stories showed that this is a tradition that dates back centuries and most Indian families that still believe this one of the ways that can preserve their “Indian-ness” especially those living in the United States. It is also worth pointing out that while Vinay, and Vibha’s parents are arranging marriages spouse for them, they still allowed them autonomy and the ability to walk away from a person they are not comfortable with. I believe this is some positive improvement from days when the children didn’t even have a say in the choice of their partners. While most of the parents said it worked for them, and that young adults are often focused on not so important things like appearance when selecting a spouse often necessitating the need for parents to step in, I believe the couple should still be allowed to make this decision though with some…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Bharati moved to America to study creative writing for two years. After her two years in America, she was to move back to India and marry the man her father picked out. Things did not happen the way she had originally planned. In America, you have the freedom to marry whomever you desire, unlike in India. While doing her schooling, she met a fellow student, an American of Canadian parentage, and they got married.…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Intercultural marriage is defined as marriage between people who come from two different cultural backgrounds, throughout the years . In the story “A Red Girl's Reasoning” E. Pauline Johnson defines the different views on marriage within a cultural and religious marriage, she also speaks upon the equality of race, beliefs, and about how there is no superior ethnicity. Marriage rights and customs morally depend on culture and religion, many christians believe that marriage should involve a ceremony and consent from a priest or magistrate, while on the other hand, Indian rites consist of a feast and a couple that shall agree to live only with and for each other. The married couple in the story, Charlie and Christine, argue about how a proper marriage should propose and why marriage should be either be religious or cultural. In the story “A Red Girl’s Reasoning”, the couple defines and differs the meaning of cultural beliefs, the customs and legality of how a marriage should occur, and finally the rituals of an Indigenous and Christian marriage.…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Family life has changed dramatically over the last century. The delay of marriage is one of the biggest changes that has occurred in American families. People are waiting until they have finished their education to marry, which has an impact on parenting when they become parents. Another significant change that has occurred in American families is the structure of a typical family, so much so that the typical family of a father, mother and 2.5 children has all but disappeared. The family structure can be the popular image of a mother, father and children or it can be a divorced mother or father and children or a mother or father and their partner and children.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Family Introduction Paper Traditionally, family is defined by the title and relationship of the ancestry. However the modern day definition has evolved to include anyone with an intimate and or both vital connections to the relationship.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Traditionally, women in cultures that are primarily Hindu are treated less favorably than men. This is just the way of life in places like India. From a western perspective, it is hard to understand and justify the hardships the women experience on a day to day basis. The culture of Hinduism promotes this behavior and gender roles are certainly prevalent. However, as modern ideas surface, stricter laws and rules have been implemented which have begun to pry the religion open and raise questions.…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics