External Forces In Bacchae

Improved Essays
There are two external forces that control the universe in the Bacchae, man made traditions and the gods’ control of humanity. Euripides emphasizes that humanity needs to balance the laws and customs of civilization (reasoning) and the sensual and mystical forces of nature (“spiritual” exploration) in order to avoid chaos and self-destruction. He does this by contrasting masculine and feminine characteristics of Pentheus and the Maenads women, particularly Pentheus’ mother Agave. The inexperienced king, Pentheus, has the tragic flaw of having overconfidence when attempting to understand the situation or problem in front of him. He represents the extreme side of nomos and does not wish to change tradition. Pentheus attempts to control the uncontrollable, …show more content…
Agave, although is forced into the hysteria of Dionysus, tore off her son’s head “not by her own strength / no, the god gave a special ease to her hands.” (1127-1128). She tragically lets go of sanity and control, which cause her destruction. The mind is the most powerful tool humanity posses, for it has the ability to create and destroy, and Dionysus’s manipulation represents when one loses self-control. When Dionysus controls Agave’s mind, he causes her to envision her son’s head as the head of a lion. It is ironic that Pentheus’ head was imagined to be a lion, seen as confident, powerful, and full of pride, because although these characteristics are deemed highly in civilization, it was what caused Pentheus’s downfall. In addition, Agave was described to having the “speed of a dove” (1089) when attacking Pentheus. The dove symbolizes purity, the heavenly messenger, and grace; to have the women described as hunting as a pack of doves demonstrates that one’s inner desires can drastically change one’s intentions and character. The women felt empowerment and confidence under their possession, which terrified Pentheus because it prevented him from being in control. Since Agave and all the other Maenads women were strapped down by the rules and constraints of man made law, it caused them to significantly suffer the consequences of appealing to one’s natural instincts and …show more content…
This reflects the inconsistencies within humans. At the beginning of the tragedy Pentheus was stubborn, unwilling to accept the irrational and due to natural curiosity he indulged his sexual curiosity of the when dressing as a woman to spy on the Maenads. Agave, on the other end of the spectrum, weakly falls into passion and when she regains reason and custom law she lost all her confidence and power. There are duals within humans, both male and female inclinations that need to be controlled and release, and it is unwise to favor on side of oneself over the other. Reasoning and spiritual, psychological, or intellectual exploration should be kept in harmony or less one will either destroy one’s sanity or never acquire

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Texts can be interpreted in many different ways. Being able to understand a reading is key in filling yourself with knowledge. In Ovid's collection of stories, Metamorphoses, different readers misconstrue what they are told, while others understand the true meaning of what is said to them. Pentheus is an eisegetic reader which means he interprets a text by forcing his own ideas upon it. Pyrrha is a literal reader which means she can only see one meaning and can not recognize symbols or metaphors.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Chronicling the fate of the House of Atreus - a bloodline destined to beget suffering and bleed until it is bled dry - the closing moments of Aeschylus’ Oresteia depict, more optimistically, the very best of what Aeschylus hoped society could be. Yet to ignore the issues of gender and sexuality - the binary opposition and conflicting gendering of its two female ‘heroines’ and their subsequent inversion of societal norms, for example - is to confine the text and its characters unnecessarily. It is a disservice to limit Aeschylus’ sprawling text - to fail to see the unambiguous connection between justice and feminism, or to ignore the blaring gender issues within The Oresteia, is to allow the text’s reception and its lasting relevance to begin and end in antiquity. A multifaceted analytical approach is essential in order to gauge the social significance of a feminist reading of Agamemnon. The study of classical reception…

    • 1868 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Within the first few lines of Agamemnon (11) Clytemnestra is described by the watchman as a ‘woman in passionate heart and man in strength of purpose.’ This statement provides a clear distinction between gender roles but also presents Clytemnestra has having ‘manly’ qualities. The chorus reinforces this idea when they state ‘Lady, you speak as wisely as a prudent man’ (Agamemnon 351). These ‘manly’ qualities are best demonstrated in Clytemnestra’s use of language, particular examples include ‘I stand where I dealt the blow; my purpose is achieved. Thus have I done the deed; deny it I will not’ and ‘You are testing me as if I were a witless woman’ (Agamemnon 1379-80; 1402).…

    • 173 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The definition of the word religion is the belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, especially a personal God or gods. The Greeks and Romans, during the Trojan War, prayed, and made sacrifices to their gods, to better their chances of winning the war, or simply beating their opponent; in literature, the relationship between gods and devotees are portrayed much differently. Even though the stories contain different religions, Euripides’s the Bacchae, Homer’s the Odyssey, and Virgil’s the Aeneid discusses religion in terms of personal needs, or popularity, amongst the gods, rather than devotion and good deeds. The Bacchae by Euripides is an ancient Greek tragedy based on the myth of King Pentheus of Thebes and his mother, Agave,…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He sees his sexuality only as it applies to his coveted virginity. He sees his piety only as it applies to his patron goddess. And he sees soundness of mind as important only when it concerns other things that he cares about; he expected Theseus to be reasonable when condemning him to death, but when he condemned Phaedra to death, he does not seem to so much as countenance the thought of clemency. In both cases,…

    • 184 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Men sensing women because they find arousal in viewing women as objects they consequently crave to touch them along with take advantage of them. Harshly viewed as birth giver,peasants who have to obey any commandment given to them such as cutting off one breast to be able to shoot a bow and leaving the other breast to breast feed. They are not sensitised gradually not seen as anything more but an object. Distressing the fact that they are unworthy of being anything more. Agammenon goes to meet Odysseus in the underworld…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women are everywhere. Fifty percent of every species is a female, yet only human females are treated differently, as less. This is not a new attitude, and while it cannot be determined if it goes back to the beginning of the human race, it can be traced back to one of the first stories ever recorded, The Odyssey. In The Odyssey, by Homer, the main character, Odysseus, faces a series of trials, many of which include women. In this work, women often must use what society expects from them to gain power; often they fail due to being depicted as seductresses who tempt men, and have little to no rights, while being mistrusted based only on their gender.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pentheus's Point Of View

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages

    It’s interesting to see since everyone was aware that the Bakkhai were being controlled by Dionysos and everyone knew Pentheus didn’t approve of the Bakkhai and the worship of Dionysos. He even “went to mock the god and [their] bakkhic rituals” as claimed by Kadmos, but when news came back of Pentheus’s death, everyone was quick to blame Agave, who wasn’t even aware of what she had done until well after the fact (Carson 66). I found it notable since the only woman in the story other than the Bakkhai to haver her own speaking part, which only happened at the end when she was demonstrating how crazy she was after killing her son, was the only one charged with anything even though Kadmos went to participate in the Bakkhai, Dionysos orchestrated the whole thing including Pentheus’ murder, and Pentheus was seen multiple times speaking ill of Dionysos. Dionysos didn’t even state that he was mad at Agave until the end, “You squandered your chance to worship me… And you insulted me,” (Carson 68).…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Anatomy of the Heart In Chrétien de Troyes’ Cligès, lovers can effectively communicate with their eyes. While “the eye is the heart’s window” (708-709), unlike the eye the heart appears as less a physical organ than a mental entity that is capable of commanding one’s action. However, when Alexander falls in love with Sordamour, he bemoans that this unrequited love brings him the pain that goes to his heart, although he cannot see any wounds (687, 697-698). Since the heart is susceptible to pain, it is also corporeal despite its mental power.…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Aeschylus’s trilogy, The Oresteia, presents one reason for Clytemnestra murdering Agamemnon: as revenge for the sacrificial murder of her daughter, Iphigenia. While this is not the only reason for Clytemnestra’s action, it is the most ambiguous; for example, Clytemnestra presents herself as a devoted mother, but she constantly contradicts her actions with her words. For instance, Clytemnestra, acting as a loving mother, vowed to avenge her daughter’s death, but later on goes to curse her own son, Orestes. Clytemnestra even claims to send Orestes off with loving intentions, rather it was for her own security. Furthermore, The Libation Bearers questions Clytemnestra’s motherhood with a disturbing serpent metaphor.…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Hippolytus, free will is best defined as the power to choose your own course of action. Euripides explores a portion of human autonomy where we “know what’s good and recognize it”(Euripides 2001: 380) yet struggle to “accomplish it”(Euripides 2001: 381). That is to say, a struggle between different courses of action takes place and leads to a conflicted free will. Therefore, Euripides’ quotes can help shape the argument that free will, while strained by the actions of a god, is still functional. This paper will focus on how the motifs of arrogance and internal conflict establish an explanation for where responsibility for an action lies.…

    • 1456 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When Dionysus asks Pentheus whether he would like to watch the Bacchae, unrestrained and dancing, Dionysus is appealing to and drawing out the hidden part of Pentheus he had seen previously. By dangling this natural inclination of Pentheus in front of him, Dionysus tempts Pentheus. We are not privy to Pentheus’s internal thoughts, but in the end, he threw away his propriety to instead follow his desire. Thereinafter, he is submissive to Dionysus and protests only once against him. Even then, Pentheus objects only briefly to Dionysus’s idea to disguise Pentheus as a woman, which suggests that it was not a serious protest but merely one last pretend attempt at holding onto his front of masculinity as dictated by his position in Theban society.…

    • 1742 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many characters in Greek and Roman literature are subject to divine manipulation, and the gods’ furor can result in disastrous effects on cities and their citizens. The furor of the characters in the Aeneid is volatile and often dangerous. Regardless of whether it begins with a human or a god, it can leave disaster in its wake, particularly when the gods play a role. Although Dido is subject to Venus and Juno 's interference, she is ultimately responsible for losing control because the motivation for her actions originated within herself; similarly, Amata retains some free will despite being influenced by the gods, and both her future and her city suffer as a result. Dido suffers greatly as a result of being struck by Cupid 's arrow: her city falls to the wayside and its development slows to a halt as she falls for Aeneas.…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He can not allow merely woman to go against his order. Because, if he does, this may result in him being seen as an unreliable leader unable to protect civic order of the society which would cause his people to go against him. When Pentheus first hears of the women going outside the city to frolic in the woods, he proclaims, “In no time at all I shall have them trapped in iron nets and stop…

    • 1370 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Within The Aeneid, Vergil, as the author, placed an undisputable, misogynistic point of view upon the female characters of the epic poem. His sexist perspective, coming from the ancient Roman society’s values and view on women, is hinted at in his description and depiction of the women, having them supposedly “serve” as troublemakers and/or suitors and potential lovers. From a modern, feminist perspective, Vergil’s misogyny only made the female characters appear stronger and against the norm of Roman societal views on women. Women have pivotal parts within The Aeneid and have some of the most power positions in the story, despite Vergil depicting the women as weak and underneath the men. Vergil attempts to assign women a negative connotation…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays