Moral And Ethical Barriers To Genetic Screening

Improved Essays
Can you imagine a world where everyone got to pick their children 's genetic traits like picking clothes from a magazine? Being able to choose characteristics like their hair and eye color, or even in a pursuit of perceived genetic and financial advantage can take place if we allow genetic engineering in humans. Genetic screening is defined as an assessment of an individual 's genetic makeup to detect inheritable defects that may be transmitted to offspring. There are many moral and ethical barriers for genetic screening; barriers such as pushing society toward "designer babies," or if a baby is said to have a certain genetic defect is it appropriate to terminate their pregnancy? Another barrier for genetic screening is that, genetic screening and "designer babies" would lead to requiring experimentation on women as well as on children. Many people argue that genetic screening can help treat diseases for future generations. It is unacceptable to use genetic screening to produce genetically healthy, or even “designer" babies. Moral and ethical barriers exist when beginning to change a humans genes. Many have feared the …show more content…
Women and children would have to be experimented on extensively just to find results for genetically modifying babies genetic makeup. There are some pros for genetically screening and modifying babies genetic makeup, like possibly curing diseases in the future. Even though genetic technology can put parents at ease, these same genetic technologies will allow forms of genetic manipulation that could endanger equality, social justice, human rights, and other core progressive values (Hayes). Because this form of genetic engineering could endanger duality, social justice, human rights, and other progressive values, it is unacceptable to use genetic screening to produce genetically healthy, or even “designer"

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In “Genetically Modified Humans? No Thanks,” Richard Hayes argues against Ronald M. Green, a professor of Emeritus of Religion and of Ethics and Human Values at Dartmouth College, specifically responding to his essay about using genetic technology to change children’s DNA. Hayes, who holds a Ph.D. in Energy and Resource, which saluted the United States to ban human cloning worldwide, believes it would disrupt human nature and the human future. As he states, “granted, new human technologies have real potential to help prevent or cure many terrible diseases, and I support research directed towards that end. But these same technologies also have potential for real harm” (Hayes 245). Hayes wants not only medical students and scientists to read the article but also the international community and parents interested in having…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through all the examples provided, man’s desire to control the genetic development of children pushes genetic engineering in the wrong direction. Although parents facilitate a child’s internal development by preventing disease, the temptation for further genetic modification overrides a parent’s potential to enhance…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    First, scientists would have a lot of power when deciding the features of the baby (Doc. 1). Equally, they would probably test ideas on babies thinking it would be a good idea (Doc. 1). Additionally, people who have the mutated gene of PRDM12 might not be able to protect themselves from danger (Doc. 2). This means they could burn their hand and not even notice until it is too late (Doc. 2). Furthermore, parents who are wealthy enough could transform their baby to be superior to others (Doc. 3). The parents could do this by making child smarter or blonde hair with blue eyes (Doc. 3). To stop parents or scientist to who want to change the baby in unnecessary ways, rules should be added that could limit this from occurring. One way we could do this is to make a company who will monitor genetic engineering (OI). Moreover, parents would have to tell the company they are genetically engineering their baby before they do it (OI). To sum it up, limitations should be made, or genetic engineering could get out of hand really quick.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Crispr Code Of Ethics

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For example, people might want to have higher intelligence levels in their progeny or have desired traits such as eye color, height, skin color and much more. The problem with this is that it would raise many other problematic issues. For instance, "The eugenic movement put an abstraction, the human gene pool, above the fundamental units of society, the family".As a result, the unconditional love and care of parents for their children would become conditional and the sacred relationship between parents and children would be undermined by giving parents complete control of the characteristics to have in their offspring 's. Moreover, we should draw lessons from the history of eugenics to sterilize the unfit population which significantly harmed and oppressed the racial minority and the people with disabilities. Similarly like eugenics crispr use would lead to social inequality and discrimination for people in society who might not be able to afford the use of this…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When it comes to determining the ethicality for a human being to alter a fellow human’s DNA in the hopes of eradicating genetic disorders, every individual is going to have a different opinion on the matter. This idea is observed in the two articles; “Gene Therapy: Human Germline Genetic Modifications– Assessing the Scientific, Socio-ethical and Religious Issues” by Qiana Matthews, PhD and David Curiel, MD, PhD and “Gene Therapy: Theoretical and Bioethics Concepts” written by Kevin Smith, PhD. Matthews and Curiel’s article was published in the Southern Medical Journal in 2007, while the article by Kevin Smith was published in 2003 by the Archives of Medical Research. While these two sources have similar aspects, such as the type of evidence…

    • 1107 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I had the opportunity to watch the movie, Gattaca, during one of my medical ethics class this semester. We had to determine if future genetic engineering is ethical or not. However, at first it seems ethical with a society genetically perfect, but to be marked as an “invalid” or insufficient enough, from birth restricts a person to a career not requiring an education, such as a cleaner. Creation of a new form of prejudice produces the idea of having greater or second-rate genes.…

    • 351 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Firstly, the main ethical issue concerning the morality of genetically engineering human beings and whether we should interfere with nature to such an extent? One of the ethical issues tied to genetically engineered humans is fictionally referred to in the movie as “genoism”, the discrimination resulting from differences in an individual’s genome. Your worth as a human being is tied directly to your genetic superiority; as the film points out, you are either “valid” or “in-valid.” Although this film was made almost twenty years ago, there is one parallel I noticed that comes about as a result of the successful mapping of human genes by the Human Genome Project. Currently, this information is being used to carry out genetic testing to determine your predisposition…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this rapidly changing world, scientists are creating new ways to improve the human race. They have turned to genetic engineering to accomplish the job. Genetic engineering is adding new DNA to an organism manually with the purpose of trying to produce traits that are not originally in the organism, and it has been a part of history since the early 1900s starting with crops and farm animals, and they also started to clone animals such as cows, sheep, pigs, and mice. The time for humans is here, and it is scary. I see no need to alter a child’s genes for the parent’s own purposes. Changing the genes of a human is a dangerous and risky procedure even for the supposed prevention of diseases. In addition, a new race could be formed along with…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Designer Babies” is a layman’s term used to describe what is known in the medical field as genetically engineered of human gametes, zygotes and embryos also known as germ line modification, (Wikipedia). There are countless problems surrounding designer babies, an example being a gene does not code just for one function, thus a gene medication can be used to solve a problem while it causes another problem involuntarily, (world press 2013, April 28). People have questions about this process such as; is designing a baby ethical? Then there are problems attached to this process that give rise to questions that are impossible to answer, such as; If the process were made acceptable and ethical by members of society and would the parent be modifying only for medical purposes or in hopes to have the most “perfect baby”, (Debate.org). The biggest concern is what designer babies have to offer in today’s modern society, giving rise to the real question in all this: Are there social barriers that could be created by designer babies? And any sane man would answer “Y.E.S.” and I would make it easier for those people by justifying their educated guess by giving the significance of this research question which will hopefully convince society not to tamper with the nature of their offspring, also to…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    New Forms Of Eugenics

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Critics have argued that new technologies such as DNA testing allow for the potential development of new forms of eugenics. What might these forms include? What are the potential dangers involved with these new technologies?…

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gene therapy for example has some ethical issues of how they decide which cases gene therapy is acceptable and which is not, high costs may only make it available to the wealthy, and possibly make society less accepting of different people (What Is Gene Therapy). Another problem arises with this, where does it stop? While in some cases it may be very helpful to cure a disease, people may take advantage and start using this therapy to try to alter things like athleticism, intelligence, or other traits they may wish to change. Those ethical problems are also similar ones we are seeing today with the designer baby, especially the social gap. Being able to design your child with specific traits that give them an advantage would then make a big gap between the rich and poor, being that rich can pick the traits out for a “better child”. This could create even more social separation between the rich and the poor than we see today. The last major ethical problem is that we do not know the true side effects that it could have on the kids in the future. Do we really want to be putting kids at risk later on in their life, just so they can have “desirable” traits, like hair or eye color? These ethnical issues are hard to ignore when thinking about gene therapy, and designer…

    • 1365 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The other side of the coin is the fear, as expressed by organizations such as Human Genetics Alert, that the genetic research will become driven by financial greed rather than medical need” (Shields, 2012). For their benefit, if this becomes available to the public, the rich could use this procedure to make the baby that they have always wanted. Their reputations are on the line. Whether it be having a child that is intelligent, or a child that could be one of the best athletes. This could cause an epidemic that could change the world forever, and not for the better. Now, just because the rich could use this to benefit themselves, does not mean that the baby would be what they expected. Changing the color of the child’s eyes or hair might not necessarily mean that it will work. They might have the eye color that the parents wanted, but might have some other feature that they may not have…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Embryo Pros And Cons

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The issue that I am going to write my paper over is about genetically engineered embryos and whether or not further research should be done to allow the altering of an unborn fetus. My first topic that came to my mind when I heard about this assignment was actually abortion. Then we were shown a list of banned topics and abortion was number one on the list which was disappointing. Later when we went to the library to search for our topics, I ran across an article that interested me. It was about babies that were genetically engineered. I remember hearing this often in my AP Biology class in high school, and I read more into it. I cannot seem to be able to imagine that scientist would be able to make the “perfect” human being. In the past few years there has been studies to further improve embryos. They are called GM babies and GM is short for genetically modified. There has been controversy on whether or not GM babies or better yet embryos should be tested on in certain countries.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    The Pros And Cons Of Babies

    • 2056 Words
    • 9 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited

    The increase of knowledge regarding the topic altering genes has become rapid and have open and paved the hope of designing your own perfect baby. Even today, the use of reforming and adjusting the genes of an unborn child is being put in effect. “Techniques of genetic screening are already being used, whereby embryos can be selected by sex and checked for certain disease-bearing genes. This can lead to either the termination of a pregnancy, or if analyzed at a pre-implantation stage when using In Vitro Fertilization (IVF), can enable the pregnancy to be created using only non-disease bearing genes” (Steere, 2011, para. 6). Altering the babies genes can not only harm the baby, however, can also terminate the baby. Genetic screening have only showed negative effects as the result, therefore, only showing that the process for creating a designer baby will be…

    • 2056 Words
    • 9 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited
    Brilliant Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Couples are able to pick and choose genes that they want their baby to inherit. Choosing such things has height, eye color, hair color, and intelligence are all included in the process. The procedure is unfortunately, quite pricey. Much of society believes that this will create a generation of “haves and have-nots”; as it will be out of reach for most Americans, and not to say other countries. This ultimately leads to bigger problems. The genetically designed will have the advantage in most situations such as sports, school, and life its self. The “normal” population will be the ones left behind trying the meet the same standards. Even if it is the next step for mankind, is it worth risking “playing God” (Long)? As Human genetic engineering continues to move forward, it will always bring the good and the bad along with it. It is up to us to choose to the risks or…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics