Environmental Racism In Land

Improved Essays
Native Americans have endured a long history of environmental racism; beginning with the destruction of native ecosystems in the late 15th century through the Spanish introduction of non-native plants and animals, the indigenous population of the US has not been unfamiliar with disproportionate levels of pollution, land degradation and resource extraction on their lands. This form of racism has been exemplified in the Black Mesa area, home to both Navajo and Hopi tribes, in which the natural resource corporation Peabody Energy has, until recently, extracted vast amounts of coal and water from the Black Mesa plateau. Peabody’s actions have resulted in a severe decline in aquifer levels and the contamination of water sources. However, due to …show more content…
However, this dilemma sparked new forms of activism among the two tribes, namely, the drive to transition to a sustainable economy that is more culturally relevant and environmentally sound. One of the most influential organizations in this process has been the Black Mesa Water Coalition, an inter-tribal organization “dedicated to preserving and protecting Mother Earth and the integrity of Indigenous People’s cultures, with the vision of building sustainable and healthy communities.” Emphasizing the fact that a fossil fuel base economy makes tribes dependent on their own “cultural destruction” by ignoring traditional Navajo and Hopi teachings of environmental stewardship, the BMWC aims to offset the economic burden of lost coal royalties and jobs by reinvesting the annual revenues from the sale of pollution credits into renewable energy on tribal lands, such as wind and solar …show more content…
Though the community-led drive to shut down the destructive practice made starkly clear the tribes’ dependence on fossil fuel extraction for economic development and income, this difficult situation has allowed community groups such as the Black Mesa Water Coalition to rethink the tenets tribal economies are based on. Rather than going against traditional tribal beliefs and continuing destructive natural resource extraction, these organizations are at the forefront of creating a ‘just transition’ from fossil fuels to one based on environmental sustainability, resilience and cultural heritage. Though a herculean effort is needed to overcome centuries of economic, social and environmental deprivation as a result of ethnocentric policies of the US government and corporations, organizations such as the BMWC are showing that through community empowerment, the scars of environmental degradation can be

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Environmental racism has been a problem for many years. Some people have died, some people have went to jail over this and some has gotten very sick. The government has placed hazardous toxics all over the world in minority communities. Environmental racism is something that effects people in different ways everywhere.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cadillac Desert 1 Summary

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ironically, the government provides many subsidies of public power production to local farmers, so that farmers can grow many water-hungry crops for nearly free that some farmers in the east cannot afford to grow. In Arizona, there is a variety of attempts to transform the Grand Canyon to a battery of reservoirs. The author also criticizes the Central Arizona Projects. Because of its wrong economics and politics, when farmers believed they the Congress can always protect them from going broke. But some Indian tribes realize they can request more because they have secured water…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Pinedale Pros And Cons

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The small town of Pinedale, Wyoming is known for a diverse number of things. By and large, the community has always been known for its beautiful surrounding scenery, but also for the ranching community feel and the cowboy characters that live there. Imagine an area with an abundance of culture being affected by an industrial boom. Suddenly, the small town feel is gone, new people have moved in, and the appreciation for the culture that once existed there has been depleted by everyone ’s need to economically benefit from the environment’s existing natural resources.…

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Dakota Access Pipeline has sparked controversy throughout America primarily in the past year due to differing beliefs about the sacred land that construction supposedly is ruining. After months of protests and spirit camps, the Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe, a tribe that was relatively silent while others took action to protect their water supply , is taking the DAPL case to court using two deliberately planned legal strategies. Although the pipeline is complete and oil could start flowing any day, the tribe refuses to back down. However, funding legal battles can be tough, which is why the tribe has created a funding campaign on CrowdJustice, a platform to increase awareness and raise money for legal cases. While the protest camps have been forcefully evacuated, hope is not lost.…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For more than seven months Native Americans protested against changes in their sacred land to keep tradition and to preserve the primitive land. The Native Americans were, for the first time, joined by other Americans to protest against the Dakota Access Pipeline. In “An Indian Protest for Everyone”, David Treuer explains and builds an argument that Native Americans at Standing Rock have developed a new method of protesting. Treuer uses different language choices and persuasive elements to strengthen his argument.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hidden away in South Dakota lies the forgotten Indigenous people of The Pine Ridge Reservation. The Pine Ridge reservation was established in 1878. It is the second largest reservation in the United States, bigger than Delaware and Rhode Island combined. The reservation is about 2.7 million acres but only half of it belongs to the Lakota people, it is the home to about 28,000 to 40,000 people in Lakota and Sioux tribes. According to an demographics article, 35 percent of the population is under 18 and only half of the population are registered tribal members.…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The history of Native Americans is entirely made up of violence since then, as the hostile government policies of today and demolition of cultural identities further strip what were problems since the 1830s and beyond. The Standing Rock Sioux fear the pipeline will pollute their drinking water, and claim that it will disturb ancient burial grounds and has violated the terms of a prior 1851…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shepherd Krech argues that the Indian’s practices lacked scientific reasoning and their methods of wildland management were based merely on necessity and inner beliefs rather than an aim towards conservation ideals. Additionally, based on empirical evidence of ecosystem degradation, he questions the value of fire as a management tool and undermines the Native Americans’ ecological impact on the ecosystem. On the other hand, Kat Anderson argues that Indians cared about the land rather than managing it. They worked together with nature by utilizing sustainable harvesting and gathering strategies along with the use of fire for subsistence to create a cycle that allowed for landscape use and its regeneration. Although Indians did not have scientific understanding of ecosystem dynamics nor previous experience on landscape management practices, I still find Kat Anderson’s argument…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the articles, the authors highlight important notions such as “sovereignty,” “recognition,” “separateness,” “domestic dependent nations,” “dominate the physical space,” “reform the minds,” and “absorb the economic”. The authors argue that the legal and juridical sovereignty of American Indian provides them with the right to maintain and protect their traditional distinct political and cultural communities. In this pretext, to deal with the growing environmental problems at an alarming level, the tribal governments have inherent and statutory right to set their own environmental standards to meet the emerging environmental challenges. These challenges are serious threats to their socio-cultural, economic, politicolegal, spatial, and temporal…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The indigenous cultures that resided in the Pacific Northwest lost things that even now remain outside of the understanding of the colonists that took over their lands and reshaped them in ways that leave them unrecognizable as the places that were here before. The far reaching impact these changes had on the landscape and ecology of the Pacific Northwest resulted in loss of lifestyle and tradition in addition to the loss of place. The sudden and unexpected remodeling of the landscape caused the lands that settler treaties distinguished as reservations to lose any value they may have had prior to the treaty. Nothing prevented new settlers from redirecting the rivers that fed the reservations or dumping waste on tribal lands in an effort to…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Winona LaDuke, a Native American activist, stated, “In the end, there is no absence of irony: the integrity of what is sacred to Native Americans will be determined by the [U.S] government that has been responsible for doing everything in its power to destroy Native American cultures” (cite). This paper argues that the Dakota Access Pipeline is represented in the media as government intrusion and exploitation of Native Americans through environmental racism. The Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL) is 1,172 miles long and made to carry oil from North Dakota to southern Illinois; however, this project is controversial, sparking protests, due to it crossing the drinking water source of the Standing Rock Sioux, a Native American tribe. The first news…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is a way of life that is to be protected by the United States government as Executive Branch is required to protect Native American Tribe sacred sites (Cama and Wilson 18). This is not about money for the Native Americans, as it is for many of the pipeline supporters. These protestors cannot consider whether this will be good for the city’s economy as it will bring in property taxes to the rural economy. They are not like Steve Reed from West Central Electric Co-op who contends that it would give a long-term economic boost for the Co-op and its members (Ray). They cannot consider these things because they are fighting for an integral part of their lifestyle.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Environmental racism is something that affects many people around the world mostly some that live in low income neighborhoods like Blacks, Hispanics, and a few others. The people in specific though are the ones that live in Black Harlem neighborhoods Polk County’s Mulberry. One of the landmarks that went through environmental justice movement was Warren County, North Carolina. Warren County was a very poor county in the state, and had a very high percentage of black residents; Afton, the community chosen for the landfill was over 84 percent black.…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The water crisis in Flint, Michigan served as an example of what can happen to any city’s residents if they allow their government to think they can get away with taking shortcuts. Poor communities across America must be vigilant of environmental racism. In “Racism in the Air You Breathe:…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The contrast between indigenous people and those who voluntarily arrived by ship has been emphasized more than commonalities constructing the “ecological Indian” as a pinnacle or at the least something that “Man…” is not. The hunting practices employed by many indigenous tribes was ritualistic in nature with a right and wrong methodology to utilize (Krech 129), however, colonizers would question these practices with regards to buffalos in comparison to the European “proper” and “sporting” methods of hunting (Krech 130). Additionally, the prioritization of economic security over environmentalist concerns can be understood as very human, but increased pressure and scrutiny from outside of a reservation is placed on indigenous populations because they have been held up to the standard of an “ecological Indian” (Krech 226-227). This is another example of a socially constructed “fundamental truth” because these criticisms do not acknowledge the history that forced the tribal leaders to choose between two detrimental…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays