# Essay on Crime and Philosophy

14413 Words Apr 28th, 2014 58 Pages
1. Getting started
It is a matter of some interest that logic and the law should share so many of their foundational concepts – concepts such as proof, evidence, truth, inference, probability, plausibility, presumption and reasonableness – and yet should have had very little to say to one another within living memory. It is not especially surprising that logic and the law should have suffered (I use the word in its Latin sense) this alienation. With regard to its foundational concepts – for example, the concept of proof beyond a reasonable doubt, the concept of the balance of probabilities, the concept of the reasonable person – the law embeds am implied epistemology of implicity. There exists among practitioners, especially judges, the
In the course of this examination, we will find occasion to discuss three rather nasty-looking problems which I shall call the criminal abduction paradox, the no-reason-to-doubt problem and the no-rival problem. I will close the paper with a brief discussion of what I call data-tampering.
2. Verdicts as abductive
In the common law tradition, a conviction at the criminal bar is constituted by a verdict of guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Verdicts reflect an interpretation of the evidence heard at trial and an assessment of the competing parties’ theories of it. A theory of the evidence is an inference to the best explanation, which is said to be the most common form of abductive reasoning.1 So we may say that a guilty verdict is said to be
1 Non-explanatory modes of abduction appear prominently in the “reverse mathematics” pioneered by Harvey Friedman and his colleagues, e.g., [Friedman and Simpson, 2000]. The idea of reverse mathematics originates with Russell’s notion of the regressive method in mathematics ([Russell, 1907/1973]), and is also present in some remarks of Gödel (1944, 1946/1990]). For more about this, see [Irvine, 1989]. We should also remark that, on some philosophical construals of the concept of interpretation, inferences to the best explanation are not abductive in my sense. This is discussed in

## Related Documents

• ###### Essay The Philosophy Of Philosophy And Philosophy

Referring to a reality beyond and greater than human perception, the term metaphysics literally means “after the things of nature.” In philosophy, therefore, metaphysics is a renowned sector that utilizes extensive postulations to define both reality and humanity’s understanding of it. Immanuel Kant, an eighteenth-century German philosopher, devoted his elevated thinking to the concept of morality. In his 1797 work “Metaphysics of Morals,” Kant provides a clarifying basis of the principles of ethics…

Words: 842 - Pages: 4
• ###### Essay The Crime Of Crime And Crime

Crime has always existed, even long ago during biblical times crimes was evident. Several factors made it more visual in our society. In the early 1900’s the Uniform Crime Report became the most common way of tracking crime. The media has also brought crime and its high rates to the forefront. There is never a news broadcast be it local or national news that does not report on at least one account of crime. The rates at which crime takes place has changed over the last 100 or so years, along with…

Words: 2213 - Pages: 9
• ###### Essay Philosophy : Philosophy And Philosophy

As a student at Richland college, I have never studied philosophy before, and I have heard very bizarre claims about what philosophy is. For that reason, I wanted to take a philosophy class so I can learn more about it. Due to lack of knowledge, I used to think philosophy as involving a kind of mystical significant, sometimes resulting from observing problems without solutions. In addition, sometimes I accustomed that philosophy is nothing more than a name that does nothing more than feelings of…

Words: 1136 - Pages: 5
• ###### Essay The Philosophy Of Philosophy

of whether philosophy from hundreds of years ago, are still relevant to today and the society of which we live? The answer, simply put is yes. It is still relevant because we still do question everything, we still wonder about topics that were discussed back then, and because philosophy is the basis of critical thinking, a quality that is still useful today. We often ask questions, which in turn led us to the discovery of the discipline of philosophy. The primary reason for philosophy is to gain…

Words: 1122 - Pages: 5
• ###### Essay Crimes Of Crime And Crime

Crimes happen every day, all across the world, and many different types of people commit crimes. For a crime to be committed, in the eyes of the law, the person must have a mens rea, the intent on doing said crime, and an actus reus, which is actually committing the crime itself (“Mens Rea”, para. 2). If the person is missing either of those two elements, they have not actually perpetrated a crime. It is not uncommon for people to think about doing a crime, whether it is a thought about hurting someone…

Words: 1988 - Pages: 8
• ###### Essay Crime : Crime And Crime

Crime rates have an effect on everyone in one way or another. Whether you have experienced criminal activity first hand or have heard of a crime that was committed on some type of mass media resource. According to Jeffrey M. Jones in his article in “Gallup” “Twenty-six percent of Americans say they or another member of their household were the victim of some type of property or physical crime in the last 12 months, ranging from theft to sexual assault, according to Gallup 's index of crime victimization”…

Words: 1725 - Pages:
• ###### Essay The Philosophy Of Philosophy And Philosophy

The love of wisdom, commonly referred to as philosophy, is the study of the ultimate nature of knowledge, reality, and existence. In philosophy, we ask ourselves questions like: “what is knowledge?” A regular person may answer that knowledge is being smart, but a philosophers would answer that knowledge is in knowing we really know nothing. Philosophy involves not only creating answers to metaphysics, epistemology, and logic questions, but also looking for influence or inspiration from the way in…

Words: 1591 - Pages: 7
• ###### Essay My Philosophy On Philosophy And Philosophy

These last three weeks of introduction to philosophy have taught me a lot and I have come to find philosophy quite interesting actually. In the beginning, I took this class because I thought it would be pretty easy. I didn’t expect to be contemplating and even changing beliefs that I have held ever since I can remember. Some of my beliefs have changed and some have stayed the same. This class has definitely pushed me to think beyond what I thought I knew and believed. I’m glad that I decided to…

Words: 1064 - Pages: 5
• ###### Essay The Crime And Crime Statistics

Crime statistics are the numbers which compiles the different kinds of offences made in a particular jurisdiction in a specific time period. These records may be made after some certain criteria such as: the actual number of crimes happened in a given time and space, how the crimes are distributed between the population and the counts of criminal incidents as an indicator of the population. In the following lines I will highlight the struggle to understand the levels of crime in UK using criminal…

Words: 986 - Pages: 4
• ###### Essay Crime : Crime And Crime

Crime has been on the decline over the past decade yet public perception now more than ever is that there an increase in crime. Those who are not involved with law or criminal justice rarely view statistical information about crime directly from the government on such websites as the uniform crime report. So the first question one must ask is where do people get the information that creates their opinion? Media and entertainment have become infatuated with crime in the last ten years and as a result…

Words: 838 - Pages: 4