Contrasting Views Of Tom Robinson's Trial

Improved Essays
Contrasting Views

The views of Tom Robinson’s trial are viewed very differently between the people in Maycomb County. The trial itself shows the hatred between black and whites in the community. People see the trial in all different angles, most of which are thought to be considered right.
The children’s view of the trial is what any innocent child would see, which is that they thought it was unfair and Tom Robinson was not guilty. The children were shocked on the way it turned out. Jem had full confidence in his father and had no doubt that they were going to win. During the trial Jem was confident in saying “...but don’t fret, we’ve won it...don’t see how any jury could convict on what we heard”(pg.279). Jem didn’t think that the
…show more content…
He proves that Bob Ewell was responsible for the crime. He gave it his best shot that he could but the jury was so caught up on Tom Robinson’s skin color. Atticus was not surprised by the conviction but was mad at how racism in Maycomb county can overrule the Justice System. In court he talks about how the jury would buy into the assumption that all blacks are evil and immoral. He then states that this assumption is false and that all men are created equal no matter what skin color. The jury didn’t agree with what he had said and based it off of skin color. Atticus knew that he couldn 't do anything more to persuade the jury which bothered him but knew that he had done the right thing. Although he had not won the case he had kept the jury so long that Miss Maudie said that he had made a step in the right …show more content…
They base their beliefs solely on racism. Most townspeople believe that Tom Robinson should be killed for what he was accused of doing. There were those few people who deep down knew the truth that Tom Robinson was innocent. But those people were too afraid to admit it because they would be looked at differently by everybody in town just as Atticus was. The community was content on the verdict of the trial. Bob Ewell was very mad at Atticus and spat on him at the post office. This made Atticus afraid and nervous of Bob hurting his children. Some people such as Mr. Cunningham were not happy with the final decision because they believed Tom was innocent.
The blacks in the community had gained a lot of respect toward Atticus for standing up for Tom Robinson when he was being shunned by the whole community of Maycomb. They believed that Atticus was the only person that had a possible chance in proving Tom Robinson innocent. By the end of the trial they knew that Atticus had done enough to prove Tom innocent but the jury had thought otherwise. The black community had always been treated poorly but at this trial they felt as if they were being treated

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    To begin with, when Tom felt bad for Mayella the whole courtroom was shocked. To explain this in more detail, when Tom says, ““Yes suh, I felt right sorry for her”” (264), and then Scout thinks, “Below us nobody liked Tom Robinsons answer” (264). This means that although Tom Robinson might have more money, works harder, and is more respected in the black society, he’s still black, and that’s below any white person, and since the society thinks you can’t pity anyone higher than you, they got offended. In fact, when the court session was over, the jury and the audience knew Tom wasn’t guilty, but voted that he was. To prove this statement, during Atticus’ final statement he says, ““This case is as simple as black and white.”” (271), and ““The defendant is not guilty, but somebody in this courtroom is.”” (271). In other words, the court members, and audience vote Tom as guilty, because he is black, and in Maycomb there is no way he will get a fair trial. Since the town is racist, even if Tom is innocent, he was sent to prison, because the jury is still stuck in that mindset. Not to mention, when Tom was in prison, he tried to escape, but the police shot him many times, and killed him. When Atticus came to tell everyone what happened, he said, “They fired a few shots in the air, then to kill ... seventeen bullet holes in him” (315) and also said, “ they didn’t…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Tom Robinson, a black man in the novel, is accused of raping and beating a white woman, Mayella Ewell. In the trial, it is revealed through Atticus Finch’s questioning of witnesses that Tom Robinsons was innocent of the crime as he could not have physically raped Mayella Ewell. It is clear to everyone in the courtroom that Tom was innocent yet he was still convicted and found guilty by the jury. This shows that the jury, completely made up of white men, decided to convict a black man, not because they believe he had committed the crime, but because that is what they were taught should happen to a black man who was accused of committing a crime against a white person. Those adults were of the belief that all black men do terrible things and are beneath them. The adults of Maycomb County show this attitude many times. Mrs. Dubose, an elderly woman who lives down the street from the main character, calls her and her father filthy names and insults the children as they pass by her house, simply because her father is defending a black man. This is seen as a bad idea to many citizens of the town and they hurl insults towards the Finch family. Elders such as Mrs.Dubose all shun Atticus in their own way for defending a black man in the trial because he is accused of harming someone of a different race, a white woman. This prejudice and…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Primarily, Tom Robinson is affected by racism through the Maycomb townspeople, and particularly by Mayella and Mr. Ewell. Racism is, at first, bullying and discriminative on a basic level, Atticus says, “ In our courts all men are created equal” (Lee 233). Here Atticus is trying to talk to the jury’s inside humanity. He is trying to convince people with what is right and how they should be looking at this case. They should look at the evidence provided, the real hard evidence not circumstantial evidence to base such a crime on. In Maycoumb the townspeople do not put themselves in the black people’s shoes. Tom Robinson says to Atticus, “ Mr. Finch if you was a nigger like me you’d be scared too” (Lee 222). This shows how blacks feel towards the society; they are scared and…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Unfortunately for Tom he lived in Maycomb, a rather racist town, and he was far too nice to white people that treated him terribly. “ Tom was a dead man the minute Mayella Ewell opened her mouth and screamed” (Lee, 244). Even Scout knew and she was only six. It seemed that everyone in town knew, including Tom, the outcome of this trial. The only people who did not know that Tom Robinson would be convicted where the children, innocence is shown through age. “I don’t know, but they did it. They’ve done it before and they did it tonight and they’ll do it again and when they do it-seems that only children weep” (Lee, 215). This shows how morally grounded Atticus is, he knows that his client is innocent and that he is only being prosecuted for his skin color. The reason that only children will be weeping is because they have yet to be corrupted in their views, especially their views when it comes to right and wrong. Children have not yet learned to “see color” and treat someone who is not the same color as them with disrespect. Unfortunately that is a learned trait that only older people seem to have absorbed. Tom knew what his fate was from the start, which is why he took off running; he knew that if he were caught in a situation like that he would be hanged. So when the jury found him guilty he felt that there was only one way out and that was on his own. He was not going to let…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Atticus is one of the most prominent citizens in Maycomb during the Great Depression. Unwilling to abide the town’s ingrained racial prejudice, he agrees to defend Tom Robinson, a black man. Where Tom Robinson is being accused of raping a nineteen year old girl by the name of Mayella Ewell. During the trial the court states ¨You know the court appointed him to defend this nigger¨. ¨Yeah but Atticus aims to defend him’’. ¨That´s what I don't like about it.¨ (Lee) (Page 218). This quote means that the court decided that Atticus is gonna defend Tom Robinson in the trial. Atticus wants to defend Tom because he wants to prove that he's innocent and the court should support Tom because he's innocent because he did not rape Mayella and so Atticus is gonna prove it. No one can…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After Atticus is appointed to defend Tom Robinson, a black man, the people of Maycomb show prejudice towards him. Atticus wants to provide Tom Robinson with a proper defense. The townspeople disagree with this and do not think that a black person should be given a proper defense, but Atticus does not care because he does not believe in racism or prejudice, he believes in equal rights. Many of the townspeople will say very mean things about Atticus. Many people do not believe that Atticus should help Tom because he is a black man, they think that black people do not deserve to be tried, that they are automatically guilty. Bob Ewell comes up to Atticus after the trial, spits in his face and says “‘Too proud to fight, you n___-lovin’ bastard?’... ‘No, too old’” (Lee 217). Atticus knows that he did the right thing by providing Tom Robinson with a good defense, so he does not care about what Bob Ewell has to…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Just the fact that he was black alone, proved to be the reason of the verdict. There 's prejudice in that itself, if he was white, he was innocent. The acts of the white people of Maycomb were prejudice as well, everyone was happy, and when Tom died, no one even cared. The black people were the only true people, as they showed compassion for their lost friend, and for Atticus as well. They gave him food as a thank you gift for just supporting the black community of Maycomb for defending Mr. Robinson. How Atticus reacted to this, it was rather emotional. Atticus had tested up and couldn 't speak for a moment, then he finally found his words. “Tell them I 'm very grateful,” he said. “Tell them-tell them they must never do this again. Times are too hard….”(Lee 286). Atticus realized what he had done for the black people I think, and he knew that times were hard, money and emotionally wise. He didn 't think he had done that much for them though, he 's too humble. And when Tom basically committed suicide, emotions rose even higher. Besides the verdict, there was still prejudice in the courtroom, and that was from the white citizens and the cross examination given by Mr. Gilmer. Gilmer was prejudice through the entire thing. “What 'd the nigger look like when you got through with him?”(Lee 262). That was just one example, it continued. “Had your eye on her a long time, hadn 't you boy?” “Then you were mighty polite…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In To Kill a Mockingbird, the community had, “the evil assumption-that all Negroes lie, that all Negroes are immoral beings… (Lee 273).” The character in To Kill a Mockingbird, and The Scottsboro Trials, obviously looked past the fact that there was an obvious sketchiness to the testimony and evidence in the case. In Hollace Ransdall’s work she stated, “neither of the girls showed signs of any rough handling on their bodies, it made not an impression upon her (Ransdall)”. In, To Kill a Mockingbird, Atticus brings to attention, “The state has not produced one iota of medical evidence to the effect that the crime Tom Robinson is charged with ever took place (Lee 271).” The insufficient amount of evidence didn’t change the minds of the character’s involved in the case because there was a lack judgement in the wat Negroes were treated. The extreme way in which the Scottsboro Boys were arrested is proof that the white folks had biased opinions that affected their actions. A posse of white men from Paint Rock, Alabama collected the Negroes from the scene. The Negroes were then tied together and taken to a jail (Linder, The Trials of “The Scottsboro Boys”). The actions were cruel to the Negroes and the language of white people as well. Mayella Ewell degraded Tom Robinson, the defendant in To Kill a Mockingbird, by saying, “come here, nigger, and bust up this chiffarobe for me… (Lee 241).” She thought that talking down to the ‘niggers’ was justified.…

    • 1677 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Atticus knows that he does not have a good chance to win the trial because he is defending Tom Robinson, who is a black man, but this does not stop Atticus from following what he believes is right. Atticus is not in an ideal situation because the people of Maycomb have never given equal rights to people of color. Atticus announces, “I’m no idealist to believe firmly of our courts and in the jury system-- that is no ideal to me, it is a living, working reality.…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The town of Maycomb was just getting out of the time where most coloured people were seen as objects to be taken advantage of. Since living alongside coloured people was new to them, many still haboured their ignorant beliefs that they were superior. Most citizens thought of coloured people as people to be afraid of because all they did was cause hurt and distress to others. Throughout the story we see many coloured people targeted by the “higher class,” but the most controversial injustice was when Tom Robinson was wrongly accused for raping Mayella Ewell. Robinson was proved to be innocent by Atticus Finch, but because the jury was composed of Caucasian men, Tom Robinson was convicted as guilty. Although everyone could clearly understand Robinson was innocent, the jury still went against him because it was not a matter of wrong and right, it was a matter of race. Unfortunately for Tom, it was a perceived superior word against his own. Calpurnia too was wrongly judged by Aunt Alexandria, when she would not allow Scout to go to her home. She did this for fear of Scout being exposed to an unfamiliar culture and gossip by the townspeople. Another instance of poor treatment of coloured people is the second class citizen mentality amongst the Caucasian people of the town. This is shown when coloured people must enter or exit a place only after all of the Caucasian…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Atticus’ trial provides a stepping stone for the community, “...we’re making a step- it 's just a baby step, but it 's a step.” Atticus provides a different perspective for the community. Sometimes it is hard to rise above the hate that everyone has been giving an individual, in both situations of Atticus Finch and Tom Robinson, but Atticus stands tall and Tom tries to stand with him. Even though Tom is not said to be innocent, the trial has changed the minds of many townsfolk. The trail is an opportunity for people to realize that race is not the key factor of whether you are guilty or innocent. Every race is a just a difference in the pigment in skin, it is not something that deserves prejudice. Individuals should be judged on their actions. A whole race, gender, religion, etc. should not receive prejudice based off of one individual 's actions. Atticus did not go out trying to make a huge change in the community, but how he handles his obstacles influences a slight change in the community to take a different look at the…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whites in the Maycomb county always assumed the colored folks are worse than them. During the trial, Atticus said, “The evil assumption that all Negroes lie, that all Negroes are basically immoral beings, that all Negro men are not to be trusted around our women…” (Lee 275). Tom is an innocent man, he committed no crime, but his only crime was the fact that he was born with a dark tone of his skin color. This “crime” was enough to make any colored man guilty. In addition, Tom Robinson was known as a humble well-respected negro, and the fact that he helped Mayella even when he was busy and tired, showed that he respects women and that he is a good man. Secondly, Even though Atticus and Tom knew that they were going to lose the case, Atticus wanted to prove something, he wanted to show the citizens of the county proof the racism and stereotypes are wrong. It was obvious that Atticus and Tom won, but the jury would never let a black man win over a white man because The jury would never want out from the norm, Society taught people certain rules and guidelines that they had to follow. Atticus took the case to prove to the county that colored people and whites are the same, they're both being accountable for what they…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Atticus Finch Quotes

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Its against the law, all right,” said my father, “and it’s certainly bad, when a man spends his relief checks on green whiskey his children have a way of crying from hunger pains. I don’t know if any landowner around here who be grudges any game their father can hit.” ( Lee.31). This quote shows readers that he can recognize social issues and be aware of the injustice that goes on around him. Awareness of the issues are the first step to solving them. Atticus also defends racial justice in Tom Robinson’s case, even though the people of the town antagonize him for being the defense attorney for a black man. When the jury announces that they’ve found Tom guilty without any evidence, this is an example of how Atticus cares for humanity no matter what color skin color they are. The jury made their decision the day they found out Tom Robinson was a black man, but this didn’t stop Atticus from fighting for Tom. Atticus still had tried his best to prove that the Ewells were lying, and that Tom was an innocent…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Atticus has used every tool available to free men to save Tom Robinson, but in the secret court of men’s hearts, Atticus had no case. Tom was a dead man the minute Mayella opened her mouth and screamed” (Lee 245). Although Tom had done no wrong against Mayella, his skin color mattered more to the jury than his right to a fair trial. It became clear to Scout how Maycomb thinks of negroes contemptuously. They sit in their own section of the courthouse, and live in their own separate part of town among themselves and the Ewell’s. Even in her own home Scout is spoon fed prejudice from her bratty cousin Francis. “Grandma says it’s bad enough he [Atticus] lets you all run wild, but now he’s turned out a nigger-lover we’ll never be able to walk the streets of Maycomb agin [Sic]. He's ruinin’ the family that's what he's doing” (Lee 85). Francis’ views of blacks speak for a majority of people in Maycomb, including Mrs.Dubose, Aunt Alexandra, and more. Through it all, it didn't matter from the start that Tom was innocent of the crimes facing him; he was guilty all along in the eyes of the jury and Maycomb county for being a black…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tom Robinson is falsely accused of rape and Atticus defends him in court no matter what anybody in Maycomb thought about it. Atticus knows he has no chance with winning the case, but to him trying is all that matters. For example, Most citizens of Maycomb consider Atticus a “Nigger-lover” for it and they refuse to agree that he should defend Tom but of course this doesn't stop him. Atticus explains, “Simply because we were licked a hundred years before we started is no reason for us not to try to win” (Lee 78). Here, what can be seen is that racism was so strong at this time and black people had no rights but it didn't stop Atticus from putting in all his effort. Atticus defends tom because he knows it's the right thing to do, even if it is making him the talk of the town. Being able to survive all the hate through the trial made atticus a stronger person and shows the amount of courage he carries.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays