Compare And Contrast The Black Cat And The Tell Tale Heart

Superior Essays
Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat” are frightening stories told by nameless narrators. Both narrators, who are clearly disturbed, commit murder in the stories. Through the narrators’ accounts of the events leading up to their respective crimes, Poe’s tales explore themes of abnormal psychology and give the reader insight into the minds and thought processes of two fictional perpetrators of homicide. The two narrators are very similar in their character and in their actions, and both of their stories reflect Romantic ideology. By acting irrationally, blaming their actions on things other than themselves, and assuring the reader that they are sane despite copious evidence to the contrary, both the narrator of “The Tell-Tale …show more content…
In “The Tell-Tale Heart,” after the narrator murders the old man with whom he lives and hides the old man’s dismembered body underneath the floorboards of the bedroom, he imagines the dead man’s heart beating (Poe 694). In “The Black Cat,” after hanging and killing his first cat Pluto, the narrator imagines that his second cat’s white spot turns into the shape of a gallows (Poe 699). It is arguable that these auditory and visual hallucinations are the product of the narrators’ guilty conscience. The narrator of “The Tell-Tale Heart” hears the sound of the dead man’s heartbeat while in the presence of the police, suggesting an overwhelming need to confess his terrible deed (Poe 694). Likewise, the narrator of “The Black Cat” finds the second cat and notices its white spot that looks like a gallows shortly after hanging Pluto, suggesting a feeling of remorse for what he had done to Pluto (Poe 699). Furthermore, these illusions contribute to the mental breakdown of both narrators. The imaginary heartbeat leads the narrator of “The Tell-Tale Heart” to become so overwhelmed by guilt that he confesses his crime to the police even after convincing them of his innocence (Poe 691). Similarly, the spot that looks like a gallows causes the narrator of “The Black Cat” to become afraid of the cat that bears the spot and causes his hatred for the cat to increase as it follows him around his home day after day (Poe 699). This ultimately leads him to swing at the cat with an axe and to kill his wife with the axe after she attempts to keep him from hurting the cat (Poe 699). According to writer Veronica Mueller, “Throughout Mr. Poe’s works, his characters are usually dominated by their emotions. This characterization explains much of the erratic behavior of the characters in his stories” (Mueller). Essentially, both narrators are controlled by their emotions

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    As it is later alluded to, the cat's owner soon becomes a convicted felon and is awaiting his mandatory death. Additionally, it is a symbolization of his further descent into madness. For example, the fur upon the cat slowly takes the form of the gallows. Similar to his madness, it progresses slowly but suddenly is recognized. Furthermore, the discoloration occurs as the narrator loathes the cat even more.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Short stories of Edgar Allan Poe’s often have similar attributes, like being insane. For example, in “The Cask of Amontillado” he is also a murderer. His style of murder thought is more closely related to “The Tell-Tale Heart” narrator than to the narrator of “The Black Cat”. In both “The Cask of Amontillado” and “The Tell-Tale Heart” the murder is planned. Though “The Cask of Amontillado” is also different from both the other stories.…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    “The guilt obsessed narrator is possessed by a profound self-destructive impulse just as Poe was”(Johnson 28). The narrator’s “irrational urge to kill proceeds out of an inborn sense of fear and blends into the urge to suicide”(Graham). The narrator, afflicted with the spirit of perverseness, is also an obsessive talker with a need to tell of his crimes(Johnson 89). When the narrator takes in his second cat, his fondness for it “turned to annoyance and eventually into hatred;” he even kills his wife “in one insane paroxysm” because she tries to stop him(Bloom 48, Johnson 59). Bloom claims “The narrator becomes overcome by evil…

    • 2011 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How does “The Black Cat” demonstrate the American Gothic idea of the struggle against evil and the ultimate loss of the battle? The Black Cat” represents the American Gothics when he applauds himself for not killing Pluto but cuts his eye out of the socket. He was in a drunken stupor and the constant violence he displays the cat became afraid and scratches him. He feels justified when he cut the cat eye out of the socket. Alcoholism is his struggle and his madness intensifies that result into the rage.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In “The Black Cat,” the protagonist finds himself obsessed with his wife’s cat after his life is changed by a newfound addiction to alcohol. Despite being an animal lover, in a drunk fit, he kills the cat out of spite. The guilt eats away at the man, and when he finds a cat similar to the dead one, and he cannot escape it because he is too afraid to kill it. His obsession with the cat strengthens every day, until he cannot stand its presence any longer and his resolve breaks. In an attempt to kill the cat, he kills his wife instead, causing him to sink further into insanity.…

    • 2088 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Black Cat Analysis

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Compare and contrast the way in which the narrators of The Tell-Tale Heart and The Black are presented as psychotic In the shorts stories ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ and ‘The Black Cat’ by Edgar Allan Poe, both of the narrators are presented as psychotic. Psychosis is a mental disorder characterised by symptoms, such as delusions or hallucinations. In The-Tale Heart the unnamed narrator decides to kill the old man- not for money, but rather a fear of the man’s pale blue eye. Similarly, the narrator in The Black Cat kills his wife and his cat for no reason other than his psychosis. What is interesting for the reader, is to compare the motivation for the murders in both short stories, which in term helps us to infer the extent of each character’s psychosis.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Black Cat Response

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Black Cat is a short story and there were four main characters including the man, his wife, and two black cats. This story is about the man is a murder who kill the first cat and his wife. He had a large, beautiful and black cat and Pluto was the cat's name. One night, he deliberately cut the black cat's eyes under the influence of alcohol. Afterwards, he slipped a noose about cat's neck and hung it to the limb of a tree.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “The Black Cat” the character tortures and murders an innocent, loving cat simply because he had a little too much to drink and was in a foul mood. His temperament would continue to escalate until he would murder his wife. Without any remorse or concern for his actions, he simply buries her in the wall. Unknowingly, he also buries the second cat with her. Much to his surprise, the cat will achieve its revenge and ensure his master receives his due reward.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Guilt and Sanity: A Comparison Ever notice how doing something questionable leaves a shadow of guilt around you? In the plots of a short story and a thriller movie, guilt and sanity are connected at the hip. In “The Tell Tale Heart,” a character murders an aged man and guilt eventually floods over him. In The Call, a man is guilt ridden by the death of his sister and goes to maximum lengths to try to mend his deadlock. “The Tale Tale Heart,” by Edgar Allen Poe and The Call, by director Brad Anderson both illustrate that guilt and the question of sanity are connected; this can be seen by looking at sequence of events, observing motives, and cataloging actions.…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Lost Cat Analysis

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This meant encountering the lost black cat that momentarily destroyed his relationship and permanently damaged his image as seen through his lover’s eyes. This cat’s symbolic black hue encouraged a man’s lying, destroyed his previously untainted image in his relationship, and added to the agony of his wife’s untimely death. Because of the many symbols attached to this initially overlooked character, and its representation as the challenges faced by this Native American couple, the lost black cat should be viewed as the main focus of the short story instead of David or…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays