Similarities And Differences Between The Black Cat And The Tell Tale Heart

Improved Essays
Edgar Allan Poe often demonstrates a type of madness in his short stories. Many times it comes from the first-person narrator. While the narrators are similar in the fact that they are both insane, they also have a lot of differences in the way that they are insane. A great way to compare the way the insanity differs in the narrators, is to compare two of Poe’s stories. Stories such as “The Black Cat” and “The Tell-Tale Heart” do a good job showing the similarities and differences between the insanity in both of the stories, as well as the insanity in other short stories of Edgar Allan Poe’s. “The Black Cat” and “The Tell-Tale Heart” are both very similar stories. In both texts the narrators are crazy and unreliable storytellers. The smallest …show more content…
In “The Tell-Tale Heart” the narrator claims that he is not crazy, but in “The Black Cat” the narrator says that he does not expect the readers to believe his story (“The Tell-Tale Heart” 81)(“The Black Cat” 115). The narrator in “The Tell-Tale Heart” seems to always have been a little unhinged. Whereas, in “The Black Cat”, he seems sane in the beginning. “The Tell-Tale Heart” has a constant madness to it. The narrator is just crazy and does not really know it. In “The Black Cat” though, the madness is brought on with alcohol and rage. The character is slowly going mad, but is helpless to stop it. The narrator in “The Black Cat” goes into sudden bouts of violence. When the cat almost tripped him, he went into a rage and tried to kill it, but his wife tried to stop him and became the victim of his fury (“The Black Cat” 120). “The Black Cat”s narrator’s madness is instant and wild, unlike the narrator of “The Tell-Tale Heart”, who is meticulous and cautious about his planning. The narrator of “The Tell-Tale Heart” had planned the murder for a week before following through (“The Tell-Tale Heart” 81). The two narrators may both be crazy, but it is not in the same way. Even though the narrators are not exactly alike, they do have things in common with themselves and with other narrators in Edgar Allan Poe’s …show more content…
Short stories of Edgar Allan Poe’s often have similar attributes, like being insane. For example, in “The Cask of Amontillado” he is also a murderer. His style of murder thought is more closely related to “The Tell-Tale Heart” narrator than to the narrator of “The Black Cat”. In both “The Cask of Amontillado” and “The Tell-Tale Heart” the murder is planned. Though “The Cask of Amontillado” is also different from both the other stories. In “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat” the narrators are caught with the murder, but in “The Cask of Amontillado” he is not caught. One of the more contrasting stories of Edgar Allan Poe’s is “The Pit and the Pendulum”. Although this narrator is also unreliable, it is because of different reasons. This narrator has been drugged and is the one that is supposed to be killed. Even though readers cannot take his word because he has been drugged, he does not seem to be unhinged like the narrators in the other stories. “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat” may not be similar to all other stories of Edgar Allan Poe’s, but they can be easily

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    “The guilt obsessed narrator is possessed by a profound self-destructive impulse just as Poe was”(Johnson 28). The narrator’s “irrational urge to kill proceeds out of an inborn sense of fear and blends into the urge to suicide”(Graham). The narrator, afflicted with the spirit of perverseness, is also an obsessive talker with a need to tell of his crimes(Johnson 89). When the narrator takes in his second cat, his fondness for it “turned to annoyance and eventually into hatred;” he even kills his wife “in one insane paroxysm” because she tries to stop him(Bloom 48, Johnson 59). Bloom claims “The narrator becomes overcome by evil…

    • 2011 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the 19th century, many of the mental instabilities we recognize today did not exist in the medical field. While it is clear that the authors would not have known that these instabilities would become legitimate, that would have been impossible. But the perception is a possibility, as both authors have personal ties to their narrators. Perkins Gilman suffered from a similar depressive state as described in The Yellow Wallpaper and Poe is often considered an extreme paranoid personality, because of his alcohol and drug abuses. I would say that these similarities lend themselves useful to the authors in the perpetuation of the narrators’ mental instabilities.…

    • 1961 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Throughout the story, the man realizes his ?mental deterioration? and tries to prevent it; however, he is not able to, and he spirals into ?madness?. [endnoteRef:3] Another story by Poe in which a man spirals into madness is The Tell-Tale Heart. These two stories are often linked together due to the ?profound psychological elements these two works share.? [endnoteRef:4] [2: (Lombardi, 'The Black Cat '- Short Story By Edgar Allan Poe)] [3:…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat” are frightening stories told by nameless narrators. Both narrators, who are clearly disturbed, commit murder in the stories. Through the narrators’ accounts of the events leading up to their respective crimes, Poe’s tales explore themes of abnormal psychology and give the reader insight into the minds and thought processes of two fictional perpetrators of homicide. The two narrators are very similar in their character and in their actions, and both of their stories reflect Romantic ideology. By acting irrationally, blaming their actions on things other than themselves, and assuring the reader that they are sane despite copious evidence to the contrary, both the narrator of “The Tell-Tale…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He suddenly grows a strange desire to torture his pet cat, Pluto. The author portrayed the author as a lunatic in a creepy yet intense tone who abuses his cat in his own house. Meanwhile his wife doesn’t show sign of care towards her husband’s actions. The actions he performs are cruel and is expected for a man who abuses his wife and alcohol. What really allows us to comprehend the story is the setting because it reflects the character(s) emotions and actions.…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Black Cat Analysis

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Compare and contrast the way in which the narrators of The Tell-Tale Heart and The Black are presented as psychotic In the shorts stories ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ and ‘The Black Cat’ by Edgar Allan Poe, both of the narrators are presented as psychotic. Psychosis is a mental disorder characterised by symptoms, such as delusions or hallucinations. In The-Tale Heart the unnamed narrator decides to kill the old man- not for money, but rather a fear of the man’s pale blue eye. Similarly, the narrator in The Black Cat kills his wife and his cat for no reason other than his psychosis. What is interesting for the reader, is to compare the motivation for the murders in both short stories, which in term helps us to infer the extent of each character’s psychosis.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Tell-Tale Heart Poe proposes the narrator is insane by the storyteller's cases of madness, the storyteller's activities draw out the irony of the story, and the storyteller is crazy as indicated by the meaning of unreliability as it applies to "The Tell-Tale Heart." He is trying from the earliest starting point of the story to put forth a defense of his madness. However, the short story he tells impairs and is inconsistent with his declaration of madness. All through his account, he reviews the occasions that drove him to kill the old man and after that his admittance to the crime. He tries to outline his “perceptive sensibility” with illustrations.…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The short stories of “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat” share many similarities with one another but they are also very different in many ways. A similarity which both accomplish is the themes they represent of murder and the belief in supernatural events caused by their own insanity. “The Tell-Tale Heart” can be perfectly summarized in a short sentence by Brett Zimmerman being “Poe 's confessional tale features a psychologically ill protagonist who recalls his grisly murder of an old man” (Zimmerman 342). As mentioned it was about a man who felt justified in killing another person on account of that the main character suffered from some type of mental illness. It was clearly shown that there was something wrong with the mentality of the narrator when he mentioned.…

    • 1082 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    My source titled, “Untold story: the lying narrator in the Black cat” By Susan Amper, discus the theory that the narrator is deceiving us. She points out a lot of incongruences in the narrator story that indicate the falsehood of his tale and claims that the entire story is false. In her eyes the narrator tries to deceive us so that he convince us of his innocence, and that his cations were the result of supernatural elements beyond his control. First, to prove her point she cites the murder of his wife as our best guest to find the truth. Since the narrator claims he killed her and hide her body in the same day, it raises questions.…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What separates the mentally ill from the insane? The knowledge that they too are crazy. Some people suffering from Insanity have a condition known as anosognosia, which is the lack of awareness towards an illness. In Edgar Allan Poe’s short story The Tell-Tale Heart, the narrator is believed to suffer from anosognosia. Edgar Allan Poe allows his readers to examine the characters with his use of an unreliable narrator, the theme of the story, and his unique approach on the lack of character development.…

    • 2198 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays