Buffalo Creek Disaster Summary

Superior Essays
Buffalo Creek Disaster Rough Draft
The buffalo creek disaster is one of the worst coal mining incidents in the history of the united states. The Book Buffalo Creek disaster written by Gerald Stern is an expose on the wrongdoings of the NewYork based Pittston company but also a summation of the events leading to the 13.5-million-dollar settlement awarded to the victims. The book also serves the purpose of a basic depiction of how the court systems in America work. Gerald Stern served as a champion for the victims of the flood. With his background in civil rights cases, Stern could empathize with the flood victims and use his expertise to navigate the court systems and the Pittston company. Stern was devoted to the idea that the Pittston Company
…show more content…
Reducing liability for shareholders helps create a corporate veil. Pittston claimed that it was merely a stockholder, so they would be protected from being prosecuted thus making it harder for Stern to “ pierce the corporate veil”. “A Pittston brief pointed out “A planted seeking to persuade a court to ignore separate corporate entries must not show only an excessive degree of control over the subsidiary, but the purposeful exercise of that importer dominance to commit…()”.Stern had to tackle this issue. He knew that if he sued the Buffalo Mining Company the case would be reduced to a state court and the coal mining companies would have too many connections as opposed to a federal court(Stern,71).To deter this first, he needed to secure the documents from the AdHoc company proving that the Buffalo Mining Company was a division of the Pittston Company. The key word was division. To Stern division does not mean separate but a part of. Stern found the evidence needed on stationary of the Buffalo Mining Company that stated:” A division of a Pittston Company” and a sign with a similar statement(Stern,75). Additionally, Stern also had evidence that there was little to no documentation of board and shareholder meetings. The minutes submitted stated …show more content…
Most of the modern day legal system is based on precedents which are used as a guideline for Judges to make consistent rulings. The Pittston company already had an advantage when it came to precedents in the West Virginia Court System. To set the scene, the Pittston Company believed that 33 of the plaintiffs should be dismissed because none of them were in immediate danger during the flood or saw someone in immediate danger, therefore, the psychic impairment claim should be dismissed(Stern,219). Stern could have complied, but he felt that Judge Hall would essentially undermine all the psychic impairment claims of those who were not directly affected by the flood( in the water, or saw no one in the water)(Stern, 220). Stern had his work cut out for him. To undermine him the Pittston company used a case in 1899. where the Virginia Court system overturned a verdict of Claude Davis on the backing that he had suffered mental injury with no physical injury,” Mental suffering alone, and unaccompanied by other injury, cannot sustain in action for damages or be considered as an element of damages”(Stern,222). Pittston also used the 1945 case of Theresa Monteleone after she was awarded then stripped of her 5000$ reward due to the fact the courts decided that there was no correlation between the scars that the shattered glass made on her face and mental illness( Stern,223). Pittston

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The case of Stern v. Lucy Webb Hayes (1984) was a class action lawsuit in which M. Stern and the patients of Sibley Memorial Hospital sued the Lucy Webb Hayes National Training School for Deaconesses and Missionaries, five financial institutions, and five members of Sibley Memorial Hospital’s Board of Trustees. Plaintiffs alleged the defendants conspired to monetarily benefit from the financial management of the hospital through use of the financial institutions to which they were affiliated. Plaintiffs also alleged breach of fiduciary duty by trustees. During this case the plaintiffs attempted to establish the conspiracy they had alleged by presenting specific incidences to which questionable financial activity occurred.…

    • 312 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Due to the facts found by Mr. Robinson and the hearing outcome, he ordered that Mr. Sterne be restore to his original position and rank, and be compensated for any back pay and benefits that he had lost since his demotion. Additionally, Robinson found that there was irregularities with how the discipline was handed out and there was no due process and progressive discipline before demotion and loss of pay, thus Sterne was discriminated against an was due his return to his past position with back pay. This case again shows, specific issues with retaliation being taken against subordinates without due process and could actual fall into a Title VII Civil Rights Act case, but the District of Columbia has a Civil Process for adjudicating employee…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The case Robertson verses Hunter Panels LLC and Carlisle Construction Materials Inc., was a civil rights – Title VII Employment – Retaliation, workplace Harassment, Gender Discrimination suit. Sandra Robertson had worked for Hunter Panels LLC since 2006. Robertson filed a lawsuit against Hunter Panels LLC and Carlisle Construction Materials Inc. in April 2013, for harassment on the job, and gender discrimination. Mrs. Robertson was fired in 2012, after telling a human resource employee that gender discrimination was a on going problem at Hunter Panels LLC (Packel, 2016). Mrs. Robertson a twenty-year veteran of the Untied States Air Force, the discrimination started after she was hired at Hunter Panels LLC.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unit 10 DB 1 Lawyer and Lawyer v. City of Council Bluffs, Iowa The case of Timothy LAWYER and Michael Lawyer, Plaintiffs, v. CITY OF COUNCIL BLUFFS, IOWA was very interesting. Once this learner reviewed the video she understood the law, but also understood the Lawyers fear as well. This case went from bad to worst in the worst way. Lawyer and Lawyer Lawyer and Lawyer, two brothers about 17 and age 23 were pulled over for a traffic stop in regards to speeding on the 26th of March, 1999, at about 2am.…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1998, Hugh Caperton filed a lawsuit against A.T. Massey Coal Co., Inc and was found liable for $50 million in damages in a state trial court in West Virginia. Prior to the hearing, Caperton motioned for the presiding justice in the case, Brent Benjamin, to recuse himself, seeing as though Massey’s C.E.O. had donated nearly $3 million dollars to Benjamin’s campaign. In 2009, the United States Supreme Court ruled that Benjamin’s failure to recuse himself, seeing as he had a personal connection to one of the parties in the case, was a direct violation of the Due Process Clause stated in the fourth teeth amendment (CAPERTON v. A.T. MASSEY COAL CO., INC.). The Caperton v. Massey case proposed the question, “how much power and impact does election campaigning have on judicial bias. Should state judges be appointed over elected?”…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Bukowski v. Clarkson University In 2012, the case of Bukowski v. Clarkson University made it all the way to the highest New York state court. This case involved the plaintiff, Shawn Bukowski, suing his school on the grounds of negligence by the defendant (Lippman, 2012). Shawn Bukowski was a pitcher for the baseball team at Clarkson University, where, during an indoor practice, was hit by a line drive in the jaw and sustained an injury. Bukowski felt that Clarkson University and their baseball coach had acted negligently and put him in unreasonable risk of harm, because there were conditions on the field that enhanced his risk to sustaining this type of injury (Lippman, 2012).…

    • 2119 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    McBurney v Young Oral Arguments The oral arguments were presented to the United States of Supreme Court on February 20th of 2013 in the McBurney & Young Case. The Appellant’s attorney, Deepak Gupta, presented the case for the petitioner McBurney. The respondent’s attorney, Solicitor General of Virginia E. Duncan Getchell, Jr. presented the case for the State of Virginia. Having to read and write about the case prior to listening to the actual argument was a quite bewildering experience that is difficult to evaluate at first glance.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Drobner V. Lancet Case

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages

    1. The issue in this case is if the Drobner v. Peters case should be used as a precedent to dismiss the Woods v. Lancet case, that is whether or not an infant plaintiff could recover damages for injuries allegedly sustained in the mother’s womb during the ninth month of pregnancy resulting in serious injuries, permanently damaging the infant. Citing Drobner v. Peters, the Special Term granted the motion and dismissed the suit on the grounds that infant plaintiff’s failed to state a cause of action, thus taking the position that its allegations, though true, gave the infant no right to recover damages in the courts of New York. The defendant also claimed that there was no medical evidence that proved the plaintiff’s injuries resulted from her…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The strongest members of the tribe had departed days before on what seemed like another hopeless attempt to hunt; an attempt to survive. Conditions had been very difficult for the Cheyenne and Arapaho tribes, but their fearless leaders worked frivolously to attain peace with the white troops and settlers and meet the needs of their people. On the morning of November 29, 1864 women, children, and the elderly tribe members awoke to a horrific situation that would come to be known as the Sand Creek Massacre. Despite the Cheyenne and Arapaho tribes ongoing effort to maintain peace and sustain their way of life, they suffered greatly at the hands of the US troops who throughout history have been thought to have heroically conquered and claimed the Wild West.…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Van Orden v. Perry Ramos, 2 Van Orden v. Perry: Government Involvement in Religious Practices Frank Ramos Liberty High School AP Government 3AB Van Orden v. Perry was a U.S. Supreme Court case held in 2005, about a Texas resident that argued that the capital of Texas was violating the Establishment Clause by having the Ten Commandments on the grounds of the state capital building (Chicago-Kent College of Law, 2015). The Establishment Clause is found in the first amendment and states that no law shall be passed ? respecting an establishment of religion?…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    INTRODUCTION Appellate litigation has played a major role in the development and progress of the Unite States. One case in particular, Gideon v. Wainwright, stands out to me as it has been one of the many motivating factors in my decision to purse of law degree. Gideon v. Wainwright, a case involving an indigent man by the name Clarence Gideon, who was denied counsel. This case not only changed America when the supreme court ruled the government must provide free counsel to accused criminals who cannot afford counsel for themselves, but this case as also had a huge impact on my family life and in my decision making when it came to my career path. GIDEON V. WAINWRIGHT Clarence Gideon was charged with breaking an entry into a pool hall in Florida.…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fields Vs Fields

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This is the Supreme Court opinion on the case of United States v. Fields. Abel Fields, a resident of California, is being tried for violating the Stolen Valor Act which was signed into law in 2006. I will be reviewing this cases and cases like it to better determine a decision. In 2011, Abel Fields attended a city meeting about public safety.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Kennewick Man Case

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Process Paper When I started my topic search, I established a simple criterion: it had to be a local story and it needed to have a strong connection to a contemporary issue. Considering where I live—a desert city of seventy-five thousand—the search wouldn’t be simple. There was the Hanford project of course, but while it’s a monumental piece of history, I wasn’t interested in the topic. I wanted to research something complex and challenging, something that encouraged me to think differently. It was through my History advisor that I finally found my topic.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The writer’s intention was to address disasters that are brought due to mining companies. He wanted to bright to light the challenges that victims of man-made disasters face. The book shows how irresponsible corporates are and are always focusing on profitability. The book also indicates how some disasters are preventable. If proper safety measures were put in place in advance, the disaster could have been prevented.…

    • 2151 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are two cardinal principles in today’s western corporate law: the first is, the ‘separate juridical personality’ of each company with rights and duties separate from its shareholders and the second is, politically based ‘limited liability’, shielding shareholders (originally ultimate investors), from personal liability for company’s obligations, by limiting their potential liability to the amount of their capital investment. The above principles, among others, facilitated the separation of ownership and control. 1.1 Separate Legal Personality Legal personality refers to the general and abstract capacity of a certain entity to operate as a legal subject. It suggests that a company is to be treated as a separate legal entity with an independent existence…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays