Audit Case Study

Improved Essays
Individual Assignment 1
Submitted by Jeewan Koirala
Answer 1
Audit firms adopt the approaches for auditing the specified audit assignment which will be the key factor to determine the outcome of that audit. Risk based audit approach is related towards the company’s financial statements that may contain misstatements which can happen by omission or error as risk consequences faced by business. If auditors failed to go for correct approach there is more likeliness of failing of audit and this failure will lead to legal case against the audit firm and also will damage the reputation of the firm. Risk based audit approach is implemented by effectively and in systematic way by focusing in nature,timimg and auditing to the most potential areas that
…show more content…
Going concern principle is mainly used to prepare a financial report. As an auditor he/she should be responsible to go through all things to make an decision and come to conclusion.Follwing things should be taken by an auditor
I:Proper accounting standards have been used while applying financial information
II: Relevant laws have been complied
III:Auditors knowledge of entity should reflect on financial statement.
IV:All relevant materials should be disclosed for the true representation of financial information. Duty of care is compulsory and should be established between Auditor and third party for an auditor to held them responsible for the tort of negligence towards third party than to primary client.Caparo industries v dickman (1990) 2 AC 605 which is also known as “caparo test” has done recognition of duty of care between third party and auditor when : I:loss of plaintiff was reasonably foreseeable because of defendants conduct
II:Sufficient proximate relationship between parties
III:it is Fair,just and reasonable to impose duty of care by court
Similar case for this will be Esanda finance v peat Marwick hungerfords(1997) 188 CLR 241.This case ruling
…show more content…
There are dfferent approaches by courts when they decide on which auditors owes a duty of care to the third party for which they don’t have any contractual relationship.The responsibility assumption test from Heldy byrne and co ltd v Heller and partners ltd(1964) AC 465 and threefold test which is ruled in Caparo has given guidance for this case.
An auditor is only held responsible to owe third party duty of care if it can prove that they knew about the facts while auditing the financial statements, Audiotrs clients have communicated about the facts about a particular transaction and after whether that auditor has acted responsibly to other than his client is to be decided objectively by reference to all the circumstances of the case.
In conclusion in this given case of King & Queen and EFL as any Proximity cannot be established and it was also not foreseeable that EFL would use unprofessional financial report without consulting their interest with the audit firm.So King & queen is not liable to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The team will also focus on the citing the failure by the management to record the liabilities that are warranty-related. The auditing team will look to cite any signs of undisclosed legal unforeseen events. The team will therefore seek to cite any indications of inadequate disclosures. Asset valuation is an important component. Fraudulent inflation of the valuation of assets is way of manipulating profits that is common and is the aspect that the audit team will be looking out for as part of the ways of detecting anomalies.…

    • 1728 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since James Hardie is listed on ASX, the company is obligated to disclose relevant information as per the listing rules of ASX. In addition, any information that a reasonable person would expect to be market sensitive and can potentially impact on the price or value of a company’s security, must be immediately disclosed to ASX, as mentioned under Chaper 3 of the ASX Listing Rules. With the reference to our case, the above rules imply that the directors of James Hardie have also failed the obligations of continuous disclosure in relation to the misleading and deceptive misstatement about the legal indemnity for asbestos claims, as they were aware of the statement and did not provide any supplementary document to correct the deficiency. Conclusion James Hardie and its directors have clearly contravened their obligations of continuous disclosure and breached directors’ duties under both general and statutory law, given the fact that they have made and approved misleading statements about the company’s underfunded asbestos compensation foundation. Therefore, the High Court ruled against the directors and the overturned decision made by the New South Wales Court of Appeal, and hence ordered the case to be returned to the Appeal Court to decide the outstanding matter including penalties which are set out in sections 1317E and 1317G of the…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aicpa Case Study

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages

    AICPA The role of the external auditor is to identify items that might be causing DOW’s transfer of financial assets account to somehow make their financial statements materially misstated by designing and executing auditing tests. As I stated before DOW trades accounts receivable with many third party clients and conduits, in effect making the transfer of financial assets section of their company to be very complicated and susceptible to fraud. When an auditor is approached to complete an audit of DOW’s transfer of financial assets, there are a few steps that need to be taken in order for the auditor to protect himself. The auditor needs to learn about DOW and its environment, assess the risk of material misstatement and look into designing and planning audit procedures needed to complete the…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At that point, the client will proceed as they see fit, whether they take heed to the recommendations or not. The IRS also got involved in providing requirements to the tax preparers who are practicing before the IRS. Bolt-Lee & Moody (2009) notes the establishment of Circular 230 with provisions to specify technical and ethical restrictions on the tax practitioner (p.16). Additionally, penalty provisions of tax law provide sanctions for noncompliance--including monetary fines and imprisonment by both the AICPA Codes and the IRS Circular…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also, if a company is relying on a specific program that generates their income and then an employee decides to tell the company’s competitor their program specifics, those actions would significantly hurt the company’s profit margin. When either of these examples arise within a company, the company should have strict procedures in place before the situation escalades. A risk management system would allow the company to think about these scenarios and have a plan in place to safe guard the company from losing profits. Therefore, it is important that the company understand the SOX Act and incorporate its law into their risk management plan so that the entire company fully understands how the company will react in these situations, but also the punishment that is handed down for…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Audit committee oversees the internal audit department and periodic reporting which includes summarizing any significant issues including internal control weaknesses. 2. Oversee financial reporting The audit committee monitors the financial statements integrity and company’s financial performance prior to any formal release. The committee ensures that all its members were aware of the accounting policy and disclosure issues upfront to take proper action if needed. Key functionalities includes the following, a.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result, the auditors ensure that they determine the reasonability and integrity of the management team during review of their assumptions and validation of accounting estimates. Alternatively, there are criminal and civil liabilities plus penalties for those corporations and their auditors who fail to act accordingly. The forms of punishments are economic, legal, and political costs. The second factor is the client’s preferences since the auditor’s wealth is dependent on their customers (Allen, Ramanna, and Roychowdhury 2014). The company’s executives make decisions to keep or fire the auditors, and therefore, the auditors firm may act in an unethical manner to maintain the client as a customer.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Case 11.1: Accounting/Finance Ethics Scenarios Main Ethical Issue(s) Financial professionals are often confronted with fiduciary issues which challenge their integrity, honesty, and ability to be transparent with stockholders and customers. They may be pressured to make decisions or participate in accounting practices that are clearly against company policy, financial or accounting rules, regulations, and code of ethics. In all three scenarios, employees are asked to make such decisions. Concepts and Theories Relevant to Case Economics and the bottom line are often the driving force behind decisions that are made within the organization. In an effort to make the bottom line appear better than it might actually be, finance and accounting employees…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this essay I will consider why Accounting Conceptual frameworks have been devised; what are the main principles to be considered when drawing up any accounting statements and who uses them. I will also consider what different financial statements can be produced and what the key elements are in these statements. Finally I will discuss some issues arising from the use of accounting conceptual frameworks. Accounting Concepts and Principles are conventions that give a structure for financial reporting. Financial reporting uses the professional judgments of accountants to stop its users from being misled.…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    SOX 302 stated that the management has responsibility for financial reports. The CEO and CFO must prepare the financial statements fairly and make full disclosures. Doug and Sam didn’t present the financial statements fairly and willfully certified the reports which contained material…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays