The Modern Asylum Summary

Improved Essays
Christine Montross, in her opinion article, “The Modern Asylum” on The New York Times identifies the problem of placing mentally ill patients in psychiatric hospitals. Throughout the article, Montross explains how unreasonable it is to institutionalize mentally ill patients in repressing psychiatric hospitals. Montross writes from the point of view of a psychiatric doctor to defend her opinion that mentally ill patients belong in group homes, not psychiatric hospitals. Christine Montross argues how inadequate it is to place mentally ill patients in psychiatric hospitals a way that brings insight and interest into current issue.
Christine Montross introduces her unpopular opinion that placing mentally ill placing in psychiatric hospitals not

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The book Asylums by Madeleine Roux is about a sixteen year old boy named Dan Crawford who is going to a college prep school in New Hampshire but when Dan arrives it is not what he expected. Dan later learns that the college used to be an Asylum. Dan meets new friends along the way Jordan and Abby. As Dan and his friends unravel the truth behind what the Asylum did to its patients.…

    • 74 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The treatment of mentally ill people has evolved over time as the medical community had increased its understanding of the underlying causes of the disabilities. Asylums, places that housed the mentally ill in the 19th century, used harsh, painful, and inhumane methods to treat their patients. These methods of treatment began to change after Dorothea Dix, a teacher and nurse in the Civil War, began visiting asylums and reporting it to the public what she had witnessed. Dorothea Dix studied these patients and the treatments used on them for nearly her whole life, then helped a movement along to help asylums be better. Her criticisms of the asylum system would begin to change public opinion which was leading to laws being enacted to reform the…

    • 1785 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Overview of 19th/20th Century Asylums: After 1808, parliament approved public financed hospitals for the mentally ill public, and 20 were assembled. Following 1845 it got to be obligatory for areas to construct asylums, and a Lunacy Commission was set up to screen them . Before the centuries over there were upwards of 120 new lunacy hospitals in England and Wales, lodging more than 100,000 individuals . “Ground plan of Tone Vale Hospital, Bishops Lydeard” -Feb 1947 Sympathy toward the affliction from what was considered dysfunctional behaviour steadily expanded and was especially grasped in the social and political approach of the Victorian time. District asylums were the proposal of a House of Commons select advisory group, which had…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Finally, months have passed since our media have published a chilling inside story of the life in the Sonoma County jail (Main Adult Detention Facility) that remained unsolved by experts for years. The most important subject publicized from this magnificent source, was that this immoral county jail has lacked the quality of serious attention for prisoners with mental health disabilities. There are mental health resources in the Sonoma County jail. These programs are available for ordinary inmates in certain modules, but restricted for disoriented inmates that would benefit through these therapeutic programs. These mentally ill inmates who need excessive therapy and support locked away and neglected in segregation for days, months or many years, causing psychological and physical deterioration.…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pfeiffer’s article “A Death in the Box” discusses the unfortunate reality that the mentally ill are forced to face within the criminal justice system by detailing the life and tragic suicide of a young mentally ill woman named Jessica Roger. The article centers on the debate about the punishments given to mentally deficient inmates and reveals the main underlying problem the system faces in that “when people with mental illness end up in prison, the need to treat them collides with the need to keep prison order, and everything about the system favors the latter” (Pfeiffer 3). While maintaining order may seem to be more important at first glance, misinformation and improper treatment of the mentally ill inmates can lead to a worsening of the condition, behavior, or even physical and psychological harm to the people involved. Even worse that the neglectful actions the prisons exhibit when treating the patients, the disciplinary action enforced on those suffering from illness are unjust as the “mentally ill inmates are punished for exhibiting symptoms of illness that the system has failed to treat” (Pfeiffer 3). Therefore, not only does the criminal justice system neglect to provide the mentally ill with assistance and treatment, but also forces disciplinary action upon those they fail in the process leading to a population of mentally deficient inmates slowly having their life sucked away by a corrupt…

    • 1267 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Jfk Mental Health Case

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages

    During the law’s development period, the United States housed over 559,000 mentally ill patients in state-mandated hospitals (Dowdall, 1999). Many hospitals were cited for violation of regulations and inhumane conditions in which patients were living. During the 1950’s, new antipsychotic drugs was introduced that produced an effective rate of mental health stabilization for patients (Torrey, 1997). The public view of the mentally ill had changed from “incurable” and “inhumane” to “curable” and human beings with rights, who were not “different” than other “normal” individuals (Rochefort, 1993). The National Institution of Mental Health (NIMH) advocated along with…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Frontline video documentary, “The Released,” is a follow-up film of Frontline’s “The New Asylum” which is a documentary about how correctional facilities became a dumping ground for our society’s mentally ill criminals after state psychiatric hospitals closed down in the 1970’s. The movie, “The Released” however, focuses on what happens to people with chronic mental health issues after being released from prisons and jails. The film shows us that most of these mentally ill inmates end up repeating the same cycles that ultimately result in a life-time of recidivism. The conclusion of “The Released” clearly conveys that deinstitutionalization and our mental health system currently in place is a failure.…

    • 1559 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Throughout time mental illness has been looked upon in numerous ways from people. The time period in history can tell us a lot about the ways people were living and how they believed behavior affected certain mental illnesses. In my writing I will describe a man who is mentally ill during the early 1700’s. I will also describe an African American in a Georgia asylum and also a middle-class woman in a water treatment spa in upstate New York. I will detail what each of these individuals does on a daily basis such as their hygiene, what kind of clothing they wear and also how the person may interact with others.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Based on the video “The Released and The New Asylums” we watched in class mentally ill people are treated unfair and unjustly within the society, mental health system, and criminal justice system. They are groups of people who are classified as undesirable or someone who’s deviant. I do not understand why we decide to imprison the mentally ill people and wasting money in prisons instead of building an actual facility where they can be treated better. Where mentally ill will have help from people and take the medicine daily. But instead, the criminal justice system is just sending them out in the streets with two weeks’ worth of medicines and to follow up with a physician.…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mentally ill is stigmatized as dangerous and we criminalize and lack mentally ill in prisons to protect the society. From The New Asylums: 4. The New Asylums has 5 main sections (once you click on “Watch the Full Program Online”). Please watch each section (Therapy inside a Prison, Inmates in Crisis, etc.) and offer a few comments about each section.…

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    People with mental illnesses face policing with the lack of funding to help people in need. Liat Ben Moshe addresses this problem in her article, “Institution Yet to come.” Moshe discusses the ill treatment of people who have mental illness due to the lack of support they receive from medicine and law. The creation of prisons has created an environment where all public spaces that proved help mentally and physically to be reduced to mental hospitals. Mental hospitals do not have the same label as prisons but that’s what they ultimately are.…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mental Illness In Prison

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages

    By definition, mental illness is “an affliction with a mental disease or mental condition which is manifested by a disorder or disturbance in behavior, feeling, thinking, or judgment to such an extent that the person afflicted requires care, treatment and rehabilitation” (Hall, Miraglia, Lee, 2011). This definition of mental illness provides a broad overview of what many individuals in our society are dealing with every day. Although it may be seen as a problem in mainstream society, it is often overlooked in prison. Upwards of 61 percent of prisoners who committed a violent offense suffer from mental illness (CITE).…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mentally Ill In Prison

    • 114 Words
    • 1 Pages

    This popular book, explains how mentally ill people are being incarcerated and criminalized because of the failure of community mental health, and the deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill. Most people do not realize that the prisons are rapidly becoming the largest providers of mental health services, as is the case in Texas. This book becomes a rant for diagnosing all inmates as PTSD, which is Post traumatic stress disorder just because they are in prison. I believe the book reports on many problems in a lot of prisons. The issue of the mentally ill in prison is a growing problem.…

    • 114 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Incarceration In Prisons

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Today, over 50 percent of prison and jail inmates in the United States have a diagnosed mental illness, a rate nearly five times greater than that of the general adult population” (188). Prisons are not equipped with doctors, physiatrists or medications for the treatment and care these people need, an issue usually followed with violent reactions from poorly coping mentally ill. The cruel incarceration of the mentally ill decreases their ability to recover from the trauma they have survived and increases their mental instability and should, upon diagnosis, be placed into hospitals instead. Prisons were made to reform and help our most troubled citizens, but these people aren't given the chance they deserve due to their handicaps. These disabilities may not define them but they are defining their success when we purposefully ignore them.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The treatment of people with mental illnesses and handicaps has been a long lasting problem because of the misunderstandings of police, mental hospitals, and society. Many documentaries and movies have been made to show the lives lead in mental hospitals and institutions. News reports have talked about police shooting suspects who have been mentally ill. Most of these events could have been avoided if people could try and learn about mental illnesses, instead of hiding them away from the rest of the world. Just because they are physically or mentally different from the norm, society expects them to be maintained at an institution like dogs in a dog pound.…

    • 2391 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays