Dulce Et Decorum Est Comparison Analysis

Good Essays
World War 1 was believed to be the war that would end all wars. It was new, exciting and was expected to be over before the Christmas of 1914. Then, 4 years later, after gruesome trench warfare and severe casualties, our views on war changed completely. The days of enthusiastic enlistment dissolved, while the horrifying reality about the battlefield emerged. This change in beliefs, and the influence of generations, can be seen accurately through the poems, “Dulce Et Decorum Est” by Wilfred Owen and “Pro Patria” by Owen Seaman. “Pro Patria” portrays the patriotic and nationalistic beliefs of the older generation prior to World War 1. However, “Dulce Et Decorum Est,” written by a soldier, represents anti-war feelings procured by the gruesome …show more content…
This technique allows the reader to imagine seeing the man’s body disintegrating, hear the blood gurgling in his lungs and to imagine the situation. This reinforces the severity of war and forces the reader to form their own opinion on what is being said. This is also used in “Pro Patria” through “honour calls you, go you must” and “but by the seal which you set your hand”. However, this technique is used specifically as a call to action, singling out the younger generation and highlighting their important role in joining the war. This is also combined with inclusive pronouns of “we” and “our”. This technique creates a sense of community and comradery which reinforces the strong patriotic and noble beliefs that the poem is trying to convey.
Similarly, “Pro Patria” uses an overall cheerful and proud tone. Seaman portrayed this in examples of “for other’s greater need” and “our fortunes we confide”. This tone is used to conjure proud heroism, similar to the honour that the soldiers would feel once they fight in the war for their country. In contrast, Owen wrote using a sarcastic, bitter and angry tone. This was used effectively to highlight the anger aimed at the older generation who spread lies about dying in the war as an honourable
…show more content…
For example, when the soldiers were attacked with poisonous gas they had to “watch the white eyes writhing in his face” and hear “the blood come gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs”. This imagery grossly depicts the everyday relentlessness of war including the contrast of “incurable sores on innocent tongues”, with war being incurable and the soldiers innocent. This recurring imagery contrasts against the title as it depicts nothing as sweet an honourable and further reinforces the irony. Contributing to this, similes such as “like old beggars under sacks” and metaphors such as “haunting flares” and “drunk with fatigue” are used. These techniques create vivid imagery and allow the unfamiliarity of war to be easily associated with everyday representations that anyone can understand. On the other hand, Seaman wrote using a blunt patriotic discourse and doggerel. These patriotic beliefs reflect the general consensus prior to World War 1. For example, “brotherhood”, “for others’ greater need” and “where honour calls you, go you must”. Additionally, metaphorical language is used, such as “to steel our souls”, “burden is to watch” and “brute sword”. Together, this language discourses the patriotic and nationalistic beliefs of the older generation and aims to evoke a sense of unity within Great Britain. However, this is not as effective as it doesn’t convey a clear cut meaning. The doggerel causes the poem to feature

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Likewise, Tennyson tried to develop a similar theme: honoring the soldiers for sacrificing their lives for the sake of war and defending their country; “honor the charge they made! Honor the light brigade.” Conversely, Borden and Owen’s themes were completely different to those of Lovelace and Tennyson. Borden condemns the wasteful slaughter of people, just as Owen who finds war a waste of lives and tries to reveal why people should not go to war throughout his poem. This is conveyed at the last two lines from “Dulce et Decorum Est”: “The old lie: Dulce et Decorum est Pro Patria mori;” which is the Latin for “it is sweet and honorable to die for one’s country,” where Owen presented it as an old…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In that image, Owen enables the responders to visualise the terrifying suffering the soldiers endured, during the war. Similarly, in ‘Dulce Et Decorum Est’ Owen confronts us with the utter exhaustion of the soldiers. The powerful image ‘like old beggars under sacks’ not only evokes the difficulty of the soldier’s movements through the sludge, but it also shows the degradation that war brings. From this visual effect, the responders are shown Owen’s image of war, as a demonic force that tortures and consumes…

    • 1383 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The author uses excellence and killing in the same sentence to show the mindset of the soldiers and their leaders. This can be a great way to protest a war because it shows the brutality of the men. Another quote from “War is Kind” shows an excellent example of irony to protest war. The author writes about the men once again and says, “ Point for them the virtue of slaughter”(20). This quote expresses the slaughter as being a good thing.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Examples of this are, “--Only the monstrous anger of the guns. / Only the stuttering rifles’ rapid rattle.” (Owen 2-3). Wilfred Owen uses descriptive figurative language to enhance the real meaning of courage and sacrifice throughout the poem. “Over the Top” is about the bravery and sacrifice soldiers had before going into the war which contrasts “Anthem for Doomed Youth” because this poem is about the courageous act and ramifications of war. “Over the Top” also utilizes more similes instead of personification and the similes give a good sense of how the soldiers really feel before beginning to fight.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Sniper And War Is Kind

    • 2390 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Whereas O’Flaherty uses personification in his story to add a dramatic effect to “The Sniper,” to empathize war’s happenings and what it does to its participants, Crane uses it in order to stress the verbal irony. The personification “a machine gun tore up the ground” is a really powerful and thrilling one because it shows that not guns kill people, and people themselves do it to each other. Crane’s speaker, on the other hand, merely tries to convince everyone that war is not a horrible as it seems to be by saying that it is “kind.” Both the speaker and the reader understand that in reality it isn’t like that, but it leaves a sort of confusion as to the reason why he said so. The different types of irony in both texts has the same effect. After finding out that the sniper murdered his brother in cold blood, a state of confusion strikes because not only is the reader not given a continuation, but also the fact…

    • 2390 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    He is disgusted with the death, hardship, strife, and troubles it causes for the soldiers and their families. Owen bring it all together in the last few lines of the poem. "It is sweet and becoming to die for one 's country,” is the English translation for the Latin phrase "Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori". Owen disproves this phrase by using excellent figurative language, diction, and graphic imagery to help the reader feel disgusted at what war is capable of. This poem is extremely effective as an anti-war poem, making war seem horrible and disgusting, just as Wilfred Owen wanted to do.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    First we look at the quote, “Obscene as cancer, bitter as the cud. Of vile, incurable sores on innocent tongues” This has obvious imagery and an underlying sound device in the reoccuring hard ‘c’ sound. Typically this sound is used to show a harshness, which correlates well with the horrific images. Most predominantly is the word ‘Cancer,’ because a vast majority of readers can relate to cancer some how emotionally. Also, the metaphor “Of vile, incurable sores on innocent tongues” emphasizes how terrible it was to be soldier in the war, because they were practically children and still had to deal with the terror of war.…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As one reads more into the poem, the more violent it becomes, and as a result the author uses irony to emphasize on how much more violent the war becomes. The effect of irony, in the first line highlights the horrible condition of the soldiers. In fact, the author uses the importance of irony as a way to start the poem in order to set the setting. The author also uses irony within the title to actually contradict with the last two lines of the poem which is also in latin. ¨The old lie: Dulce et decorum est Pro patria mori.¨ It is sweet and glorious to die for your country.…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Furthermore in paragraphs twenty two by using extreme examples of Hitler’s persecution and the freedom fighters, Dr. King uses history in order to depict the fact that sometimes what is legal is unjust and what is illegal is actually just. In that way he reasons with the reader and points out the fallacies in the clergymen’s argument once again. His logos appeal allows him to take a slow approach by gently providing example to convince them of his ideas. Through his logos appeal, he also does build ethos as he shows he is knowledgeable in this cause and justified to speak of the manner, furthermore the cause has directly affected him as he has been included in the segregation, and put in jail due to civil disobedience showing how he can speak on this matter. By using icons from the bible as examples, he also builds pathos as many people are Christians who can relate to icons, and as a result Dr. King is able to appeal to the reader through pathos, ethos, and most prominently logos so show how civil disobedience is…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    With this passage, the author wants to show the readers how the series of disasters that can happen in war are able to degrade a person’s character and make them succumb under pressure. In addition, this story is important to notice the fact that even though the character Rat Kiley acted in a way that could be considered as cowardly by shooting himself to get dismissed from war, the other soldiers understand that as an act of courage. By presenting this situation, the author shows how soldiers are connected as one unit when fighting together because they can relate to the situation, once they have lived through similar events. With this in mind, this passage also helps the perceiving of the platoon as a common entity, so it…

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays