Collectivization In Robert Conquest's Book 'Harvest Of Sorrow'

Improved Essays
The plan was to increasingly industrialize the Soviet Union in an unrealistically short period of time, using grain exports to pay for Western machinery. The major feature of the Five-Year plan was collectivization. Collectivization is the socialization of agriculture, ending private ownership of agricultural production. This meant that the class of private ownership, the Kulaks, no longer existed within the Soviet Union and would be liquidated as a class. In theory, collectivization would lead to more industrial workers in factories which the Soviet Union needed to industrialize; Soviet officials believed that collectivization would increase crop yields and help fund other programs. This led to food shortages and famine on a large scale which Stalin and his officials kept hidden during the famine at the cost of millions of additional lives that might have been saved had the famine not been covered up. …show more content…
In Robert Conquest's book The Harvest of Sorrow, he explains the ghastly process of the Soviet Union concealing the starvation of millions of people. From the opposite view and now widely regarded as hate literature, Douglas Tottle's book Fraud, Famine and Fascism, he denies the tremendous loss of life and attributes the death of the Kulak class to their disobedience to the Kremlin. In Lynne Viola’s book Peasant Rebels Under Stalin, she blames the high death toll on peasants resisting the Kremlin, but only because they were resisting unfair policies placed on them by Stalin’s regime. Still others like Dr. Andrew Cairns, who in 1932 spent over four months traveling and studying agriculture in the Soviet Union, claimed that accusations of genocide in the Soviet Union were simply “propaganda about the terrible competitive menace of Bolshevik agriculture” produced by the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Andrei Romanovich Chikatilo was born in October 16, 1936, in the village of Yablochnoye, a part of Ukrainian state of the USSR during Stalin’s regime ( Serial Killers: Unmasked par 2). Ukraine being the “breadbasket” of the Soviet Union, Stalin’s agricultural collectivization polices brought famine and starvation in the village during Chikatilo childhood (McCarthy par 2). He was forced to eat grass and leaves to stay alive, and had not tasted bread till he was 12 (Goss, Gray & Villalvazo par 5-6). Moreover, things worsened when USSR went to war with Germany during WWII, where in 1942 Chikatilo’s father, Roman was drafted to serve in the Red Army, leaving the farm laborer family behind in the crossfire of the German Blitz (Andrei Chikatilo,…

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    attempts at famine relief were seen to be shoddy and slow” so there is uncertainty about how much aid was given to the peasantry and how quickly it was received. Nonetheless, it is clear that Alexander gave more relief than both Lenin and Stalin as the famine affected between 14,000,000 to 20,000,000 people, of which 375,000 to 400,000 died. When compared to the famine of 1921 which killed an estimated 6,000,000 and the famine of 1932 in which 6,000,000 people died within a period of seven months. Consequently, it is clear that Alexander III’s treatment of the peasantry was substantially better than that of Lenin and Stalin. Lenin's policies can be seen as the main cause of the 1921 famine as Hutchinson claims it was the “economic reforms of the…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Stalin’s role in exasperating the famine in Ukraine beginning in 1931 is far more complex than simple aggression. What dictated much of Stalin’s actions was that he could not permit his own policies in Ukraine, such as collectivization, to be of blame for the famine. He thus placed it at the feet of Ukrainian Communist party (Snyder, p. 35).…

    • 59 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Joseph Stalin Dbq

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Kulaks were seen as an “enemy” to the government and the peasant class because they were trying to make money on the side. The expropriation of the Kulaks is wrong, it is encouraged by the government and Stalin, and having a farm seized that has been in some of these kulak’s families for generations weakens the economy. An entire social class is now being threatened by Stalin, when he states “Now we are able to carry on a determined offensive against the kulaks”, Stalin is implying that he will execute kulaks on sight, even if they were following the collective farm laws. Document 9, Famine of Tatiana Pawlichka supports the claim above, “The villagers tried to go out in the fields to look for grain left behind by the harvest; the communists would arrest them and shoot at…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dbq War Communism

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages

    However this argument from Figes could be disputed as the government continued to take grain far beyond that of what was needed as between the years 1918 and 1921 requisition squads systematically terrorised the countryside for grain and any agriculture that they could find. As well as this , the government persisted in a brutal treatment of the kulaks; this is shown by Lenin in a letter of 1920, who gave instructions for 100 kulaks to be hanged in public in order to terrify the population. This suggests that if war communism was just a short-term measure then both Lenin and the government took it far beyond what was necessary and so this brings into question Figes’s statement. This evidence is supported by historian Vladimir Brovkin who suggests that the “NEP was never conceived of as a path to socialism but as a detour, as a temporary obstacle to overcome”.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Tethered to global, everyday life are a myriad of political ideologies constructing many individuals’ identities and experiences. These ideologies--Anarchism, Conservatism, Fascism, and Communism to name a few--have reshaped as time has progressed to suit the plights and desires of humanity’s dynamic existence. But many times, unfortunately, these systems fail to serve any beneficial purpose; they exploit the population, and they destroy. Especially notorious for the exploitation of its citizens is Communism, which has endured much hatred and failed implementation. Within her piece “Novostroïka,” native Ukrainian Maria Reva satirizes the inadequacy of this particular ideology through the lens of Daniil Blinov and his family struggling to exist in the collapsing Soviet Union.…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Countries like Germany acted to Militarism as a way to pick the country back up from its feet. The Soviet Union president Joseph Stalin forced farms to give the government products for cheap. Historians estimated that an approximate of 20 million people have died from starvation and deliberate…

    • 2143 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Embedding emotion and familiarity, Goldman allows the reader the opportunity to build up a connection between them and the events that are going to take place. The author does excellently of not diving right into the frenzy of the Great Terror which, even at the beginning, is a complex and confusing moment of time especially for someone with no prior knowledge of its cause and reasoning. To help demonstrate necessary alignment to the social climate within Russia, the author achieves greater insight on the exchanges between the top functionaries and the lower workers by vividly using archived documents for narration. Chronicling the lead to Stalin’s murderous reign in the 1930s, Wendy Z. Goldman highlights issues such as mass starvation, forced loans, scarce housing, the stripping of union power, and the large gaps between workers’ wages and the price of goods. Due to Bolshevik policies on agriculture, many workers felt that the nations wish to fully industrialize became more important than the well-being of those helping build it.…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stalin And Mao Case Study

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Stalin continued on with the second and third 5 Year Plans in 1933 and 1938, respectively in addition to the economic policy of collectivization. However, Mao realized that the Soviet model for industrial development was not working in China due to China’s high ratio of people to resources and what first started off as Soviet aid had now turned into excessive loans and exploitation. Therefore, Mao modified the goals of the first 5 Year Plan and progressed towards the Great Leap Forward as his version of the second 5 Year Plan. While Stalin’s second and third 5 Year Plans set more realistic targets and focused on a greater production of machinery and arms for defence, they were considerably effective. Production of consumer goods and food was apparent however towards the third 5 Year Plan and the forthcoming of war, consumer production was once again put on hold.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Soviet Union lasted for 69 years from 1922 to 1991, and Joseph Stalin was the dictator from 1929 to 1953. Stalin was notorious for being a liar and a manipulator, but many people still do not know that he is responsible for 6 million more deaths than Adolf Hitler. In fact, Stalin was directly responsible for the deaths of 2-7 million poor Ukrainian farmers during the Holomodor (man-made famine) from 1932-1933. Not only was he responsible for the famine, but he actively allowed it to continue. Kevin Cunningham wrote, in his biography Joseph Stalin and the Soviet Union, “Stalin and his lieutenants not only prevented relief from going to Ukraine but also denied that people were starving…”…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout human history, food has been a commodity used and traded by many cultures. In the era of the Neolithic Revolution, food also became an investment as many withdrew from their nomadic days of hunting and gathering, in favor of agriculture. As time proceeded, food had found its way for many other uses that would benefit some, but prove detrimental to others. In “An Edible History of Humanity”, the exploitation of food led to new warfare strategies, food-based governmental regimes, and an expansion in scientific research under the Green Revolution.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Dbq Italy Totalitarianism

    • 1102 Words
    • 5 Pages

    As well as the Soviet Union foreign policy was looking a bit more different as well. In Document 2 it states, " In 1928, Stalin reversed his policy and inaugurated collectivization of agriculture and the- Five year plan. Ruthless measures were taken against the kulaks, the farmers who had risen to prosperity under the New EconomicPolicy. " This quotes proves that the dictator Stalin, created a new policy to create more power for him and take control over the country.…

    • 1102 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Russian Revolution is portrayed in the famous novel Animal Farm by the talented George Orwell. Throughout the novel, the readers are introduced to a farm taken over and ran by animals that follow the written commandments established by the noble pigs. We are introduced to Napoleon, a stubborn pig who eventually takes over Animal Farm when Snowball gets chased away by his army of dogs. Napoleon is portraying Joseph Stalin, a dictator who killed millions of people. He was associated with memorable horrific events that shaped Russia and Ukraine into a socialist state.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stalin and Napoleon both share very similar personalities as Stalin was said to be a “cold and unaffectionate man” much like Napoleon is depicted in the novel, “… was a large, rather fierce-looking Berkshire on the farm, not much of a talker but with a reputation for getting his own way,” (9). Stalin and Napoleon commit horrible acts to their citizens / fellow farm animals. Under Stalin’s rule an estimated 26 million deaths were directly and indirectly his responsibility. Orwell uses the rebellion of the hens to illustrate the mass forced-farmers famine, “Napoleon acted swiftly and ruthlessly. He ordered the hens’ rations to be stopped, and decreed that any animal giving so much as a grain of corn to a hen should be punished by death,” (51) in comparison to the Soviets sealing off the boarders of Ukraine preventing any food from entering the country, killing an estimated 6-7 million people.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    ➢ Collectivization: introduced by Stalin which wiped out the Kulaks, those who opposed the First 5 Year Plan – this led to famine and the deaths of millions – it was required of peasants to sell a large portion of their food production at a cheap price but did let them sell the extra food - essentially, it destroyed the idea of private ownership and grouped together tinier farms privately owned by peasants and created larger farms, beginning in 1928. The belief behind this was that by grouping together peasants’ land and food production, the government would have an easier time controlling the regulation of food in order to feed employees in Russia’s new factories. Those who opposed of this were known as “Kulaks” and were punished severely.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays