Use LEFT and RIGHT arrow keys to navigate between flashcards;
Use UP and DOWN arrow keys to flip the card;
H to show hint;
A reads text to speech;
293 Cards in this Set
- Front
- Back
sex
|
Sex refers to a biological way of distinguishing male from female: genitalia, chromosomes, etc.
|
|
gender
|
a society’s division
of people into differentiated categories of “men” and “women” |
|
sex/gender system
|
no pure uncultured, asocial sex on the one hand and a cultured, social gender on the other—they become conjoined
|
|
institutions (examples)
|
family, school, religion, medicine
|
|
gender shapes (individual level)
|
-how we perceive ourselves
-how we present ourselves -how we are perceived by others |
|
cyclical nature of gender
|
gendered interactions/socialization/roles
differences create gendered organizations/institutions |
|
sex assignment
|
given to you at birth by doctors, then becomes gendered
|
|
gender roles
|
norms that a society assigns to each gender for how they should act
|
|
gender attribution
|
giving gender to people: as a result differential treatment/expectations/roles
|
|
gender _____ social structure
|
gender creates social structure
|
|
dual sex/gender system
|
is hegemonic. only two categories: male and female
|
|
disease/illness
|
disease - bio aspects of poor health
illness - the social/cultural aspects of disease |
|
biomedical model assumptions about disease
|
- diseases have specific causes that can be located in the body
That illnesses have the same symptoms and outcomes in any social situation disease is a deviation from normal physiological functioning |
|
Social constructionists
|
the way in which we come to know, make meaning out of, or give voice to our experiences are mediated through culture—are socially constructed.
-trying to understand.explain disease/pain/suffering puts it in a social process |
|
WHO def. of health
|
complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease
prerequisites: - freedom from war - equal opportunity - basic food, water, sanitation, edcation,housing - secure work - useful role in society - political will and public support _ health is relational, and embedded in bodies |
|
models of health
biomed vs. social |
individiuals vs community
biomedical solutions to ill health vs social & political solutions to ill health |
|
cultural capital
|
The ideas and knowledge people draw on as they participate in social life
|
|
Social Stratification
|
ranking large groups of people into a hierarchy according to their relative privilege
social process: wealth, power, and prestige are distributed systematically and unequally |
|
Gender Stratification
|
-heirarchy acording to gender
-unequal access according to gender |
|
ideology
|
works sublty through institutions
ideas/doctrines of dom social group |
|
sexism
|
ideology - women are unequal to men
institutional practices by which women are controlled and discrim against |
|
intersexuality
|
sex characteristics that somehow fall outside the range of what is considered normal male or normal female.
|
|
concept of normal
|
relies on variation but we forget about this
|
|
disorders of sex development prevlances
|
1 in 1000 to 1 in 10,000
1/100 have bodies diff from male or female 1-2/1000 receive surgry to normalize genital experience |
|
medicalization
|
The process by which aspects of life previously outside of the realm of medicine come to be seen as medical problems
Certain behaviors, conditions, or experiences are given medical meaning -- defined in terms of health and illness. Look to medicine for solution. |
|
john money
|
- did sex surgeries
- impt to "fix" ambiguous sex - if body matched gender assignments socialization would be normal |
|
medical model for intersexuality (3 elements)
|
- its a medical problem
(usually not, makes them feel abnormal when they have so many surgeries) - secrecy - sex can be medically assigned |
|
goals of medically assigning sex
|
- preservation of reproductive capacity (ie. tendency to restructure as female)
- preservation/construction of socially acceptable/functional/hetrosexual penis |
|
how is medical sex assignment gendered?
|
masculinity:
- needs to be able to penetrate a woman - needs to be normal when compared to other boys feminity: - sexual pleasure not impt only ability to reproduce |
|
Intersexuality as a battle site about sex/gender theory
|
Medical management of intersexuality highlights the profound discomfort that occurs when the link between body shape and gender dichotomy is disrupted.
**Forces us to question 2-sex/binary system |
|
social change (intersexuality)
|
ISNA advocates for end to surgical treatment of intersex conditions
|
|
concealment centered model vs. patient centered model
|
concealment
- abnormality, rare - gender determined by nurture -psychosocial emergency, asap surgery - gender assigned at birth should be decided by doctors based on tests and surgery to mimic that gender (clit reduction, construction of vagina, penis) patient centered - variation, uncommon - whether nature or nuture is irrelevant, accept them for who they are - only do surgery if they want it - gender assigned at birth should be assigned after tests and with input of parents but no surgery until child is old enough to decide |
|
1945, women start living longer. why?
|
theory: women are predisposed to live longer, women dying during birth brought down life expectancy but after 1945 less women died from giving birth
|
|
lfie expectancy convergence, diff in men/women in countries with high LE vs. low LE
|
2030
- LLE: women have more health problems: aids, childbirth HLE: women and men have 5 years diff |
|
NA cause of death (men vs. women)
|
- men more: heart disease, ciculatory disease, lng cancer,
- more cancer, cirrhosis, accidence and violence, suicide women - more HIV/AIDS -breast cancer -lung cancer is actually increasing while mens is going down |
|
women and illness
|
- 2x as likely to report anxiety/depression
- bedridden for 35% more days - 25% more restricted in activities cause of health probs |
|
LE sex differences explained by phgy
|
- more female fetuses spontaneously aborted and stillborn
- menopause - estrogen might protect from heart probs (testosterone increases cholestrol) - maternal mortality |
|
LE sex diff explained social/clturally
|
Occupation (women less employed)
Violence Education Income (lower for females) |
|
LE sex diff explained by behaviour
|
Accidents,
motor vehicles, homicide Smoking |
|
women and stress
|
they have more
|
|
LE sex diff explained by social construction of masculinity
|
hegemonic masculinity
culturally normative ideal of male behavior exists, which is calculated to guarantee the dominant position of some men over others, and the subordination of women over men. |
|
hegemonic masculinity (characteristics)
|
- aggressiveness, strength, ambition, and self-reliance
- Violence against women and against other men - most socially endorsed |
|
Gender relations
|
Signifies a power differential, not just “different” but their relative status in relation to one another
|
|
amplification
|
differences in biology are enhanced by socialization (ie. men born stronger, encouraged to work out more)
|
|
supression
|
differences in biology are reduced by socialization (ie. women born to live longer, but live shorter cause of hardships)
|
|
Differential Exposure Hypothesis
|
accumulation of different (and often gender-specific) factors that modify health throughout the lifetime. For example (not any data; armchair speculation, really), at a time when women primarily stayed in the home, they would be exposed to a host of different chemicals from cleaning, cooking, etc. And of course this is socially shaped. Different activites-> Different related health outcomes.
|
|
Differential Vulnerability Hypothesis
|
shift in psychological methods for coping with stress whose effects later have deleterious health effects. These effects are posited to stem from differential exposure to certain stressors in early childhood (i.e. young girls are more likely to be sexually assaulted).
|
|
endocrine disruptors
|
chemicals that interfere with hormone (endocrine) systems
|
|
women's health as a civil rights issue
|
- bodies a site of oppression against women (forced reproduction/sterility)
- medicine is a patriarchal institution - reconception of medical problems as political problems |
|
sociological imagination
|
Rethink individuals’ health problems as social and political problems.
|
|
oppression of women in biomedicine
|
1) as patients (service)
2) as providers (lowest status/lowest paid) |
|
What makes a social movement emerge at a particular time?
|
Structural conditions
1)Skills and knowledge of collective action other social movements going on at the same time (ie. civil rights) 2)Substantive Issues things that are present issues (ie. thalidomide controversy, abortion & birth control) |
|
abortion/contraception legality
|
- illegal in canada till 1969 (hospitalized), clinical/other illegal until 1988
>unless serving the public good - was statified by race & class |
|
roe vs. wade
|
made abortion legal in states in 1973
|
|
teratogenic
|
causing problems in the fetus
|
|
reconfiguring knowledge
|
Knowledge seen as means to empower women in biomedical encounters.
- medical knowledge should not be exclusive to physicians (reduce power in role) |
|
why no tests for drugs on women?
|
- thought it could hurt pregnant women
- easier to clear a drug with homogeneous testing population (less variation), still exists cause ppl with comorbidities are excluded even tho they are most likely to use drugs |
|
why is unrestricted abortion seen as problematic by feminists?
|
- makes abortion an escape rather than dealing with upstream causes of why women need abortions to begin with
|
|
symmetrical relationships in women-centred clinics
|
(knowledge and power intentionally & explicitly shared)
|
|
McGill Birth Control Handbook (1968)
|
- talked about racist double standard of abortion/birth control
- bc pill empowered women but testing was done on stratified people - one of the first references like this to exist - using bc to stunt pop growth of certain demographics (racist) |
|
diversity/inequality in womens health movement
|
White middle class women: focus on education, self-help and empowerment, and legislative changes. (healthcare)
Women of color, poor and working class women, and Third World women: focus on fundamental issues of economic justice. (health status) |
|
stratified reproduction
|
priv: want access to contraception
non-priv: want safe health care, resist non consensual sterilization |
|
margaret sanger
|
- racist, approved of eugenics
- started birth control movement |
|
lesbians and womens health movement
|
- movement not radical enough
- too much focus on reproduction, abortion (straight issues) - no/less lesbian voices |
|
co-optation
|
- “To take or assume for one's own use; appropriate”
- done by biomedicine to womens health movement ex: PMS drugs ex: tampon commercials |
|
stratified health
|
unequal distribution of health and illness
|
|
how health is stratified by class
|
countries with less gap b/w ric and poor have HLE and better health outcmes
|
|
class impacts health (3 ways)
|
social capital
early life-course effects neighbourhood effects |
|
early life-course effects
|
development is altered by early life course differences
|
|
what are negative neighbourhood effects (3) ?
|
1. environmental degradation
2. high concentration or fear of violence 3. less access to protective factors ie. outdoor space, healthy foods, "food deserts" |
|
elements of a hood (3 groups)
|
context
physical space subjective/psych space collection of resources and institutions unit of measurement (census, political ridings) compostion collection of ppl with indivudal and aggregate characteristics collective social, cultural, historical characteristics of a place |
|
food desert
|
- less/no access to fresh produce
- less markets - less healthy food compared to HI areas even after controlling for income |
|
asthma case study
|
hypothesis: material and social resources cluster on hood level and impact asthma rates
methodology - use age 45-64 - sort on SES (household income, % poverty, household rent) Housing data (% subsidized, age & condition of buildings Environmental load profile (proxies: source polluting facilities, noxious land uses, truck routes) results - asthma and low income correlate - environmental load and low SES correlate |
|
Why is there a Race & SES link?
|
Segregation.
Pathways Segregation > segregated schools > limited education opportunity limited employment |
|
example for race as SDOH
|
SES controlled for, whites and black in same hood, infant mortality is higher for black than white
|
|
class is a relational SDOH
|
effects are conditioned by other SDOHs (ie. sexuality, race,age, gender)
|
|
predetermined biological explnation for racial disparities in health (3 flawed assumptions)
|
-race is a valid biological category
-genes that determine race are the same genes that determine health -health of a population is largely determined by the biological constitution of the population. |
|
how does racism impact access/quality of care?
|
- physician treatment of patients and biases
|
|
canadian stats on racism
|
- blacks have less jobs and less income even though they are equally educated
- racialized women have had less pap tests - less analgesic given to racialized people |
|
physician ratings (racism)
|
Controlling for: patient age, sex, race, SES, health status; physician age, sex, race/ethnicity, specialty.
Physicians’ ratings: B<W no risk of alcohol/drug abuse B<W no risk for noncompliance B<W desiring active lifestyle B<W no risk for low social support B<W “kind of person could be friends with” B less intelligent & educated 51% less likely “very intelligent” 63% less likely “very/somewhat educated” |
|
Bem's gender role orientation theory
|
two scales one for high/low masc and one for high/low feminity
- health benefits for masculine role traits for both men and women |
|
Where can we see how hegemonic masculinity affects men’s health?
|
Men and occupation
Men and sport |
|
concussions
|
multiple concussions are the real risk
|
|
CTE chronic traumatic encephalopathy
|
alzheimers symptoms but at 40s-50s
|
|
teens in sports
|
high risk of head injury
kids forced to get MRIs according to youth hockey canada higher risk for students than professional atheletes |
|
impacts of racism on childbirth
|
- high stress triggers labour (often premature)
- constricts placenta (less nourishment for child) - inflames uterus wall |
|
african americans at all SES (racism effects) are less likely to:
|
- get job interviews (even if clean record compared to white criminals)
- denied mortgages more often |
|
how often you think about your race
|
more as a racialized individual
|
|
structural racism
|
ex: labour market, legislative representation
|
|
interpersonal racism
|
ex: constant suspicion, marginalization (observed or experienced), HCP interactions, fault assumption, surprise @ competence
|
|
internalized racism
|
ex: stereotype threat, mental space
|
|
medicalization of things that used to be considered:
|
- normal
- under the realm of other social institutions |
|
postive consequences of medicalization
|
Alleviates blame
Decriminalize Open up space for treatment and relief of suffering Breaks silence Garners resources (money, research, technology) to a previously ignored problem Prevents discrimination (i.e., ineligibility for certain jobs, for insurance) |
|
negative consequences of medicalization
|
May be stigmatized
once diagnosed may be socially isolated or shunned. Reinforce dominant ideologies Delineation of “normal” vs. “abnormal” There is an inherent power differential in medicalization: Dependence on physicians or other actors of medicine. May shift attention away from other potential responses and remedies. Turns a “social problem” into a purely medical problem. |
|
sources of medicalization
|
- Cultural Climate
- Medical Profession - Pharmaceutical Industry - People Experiencing Symptoms - The State |
|
feminist response to medicalization
|
women’s bodies have been paradoxically medicalized and excluded from medicine
|
|
co-optative medicalization
|
expansion of medicine into women’s lives for upper and middle class white women.
ex2: reproductive functions medicalized |
|
exclusionary disciplining
|
simultaneous exclusionary nature of medicine. This has meant ignoring the needs of particularly women of color and poor women and erecting barriers to care.
ex2: women were not beleived to be able to suffer from heart disease, discluded from clinical trials |
|
dual tendencies of medicalization/stratified medicalization
|
co-optative properties/exclusionary properties
|
|
liberal feminist vs. radical feminist
|
liberal feminist
- right to vote, equal pay, equal vote radical feminist - those things dont change the institution, need more than equality. these are systemic |
|
process of medicalization
|
Psychologization>medicalization>behavior and lifestyle> geneticization?
-all of these individualize conditions and pathologize them -puts responsibility on people individual |
|
morality and health
|
- moral good citizens take care of their bodies
ie. people who are fat are lazy and bad human beings |
|
prozac et SSRIs
|
depression (diagnoses of depression greatly increased)
|
|
Sarafem
|
for pre menstrual disorder
- prozac patent was about to expire (2001), so gave it a new name and use and for PreMenstrual Discordance Disorder (same compound: fluroxetine) - doctors can prescribe it off-label (even if someone doesnt have PMDD (more severe than PMS) the doctor can give it to PMS patients -viagara is a good example of this, was approved for a small subset of men and now can be prescribed by anyone |
|
Horomone Replacement Therapy
|
for menopause. but menopause is normal for aging population. why dont we have hormone treatment for aging then?
|
|
Birth Control (seasonale)
|
to treat/get rid of regular periods (4 per year rather than 12)
|
|
Viagara
|
impotence/ sexual performance
|
|
testosterone patch
|
for menopausal syndomes
|
|
why the medicalization of PMS
|
- gynecologists could be trying to legitimize existence when fewer babies are being born
- could be due to pharmaceutical company driven medicalization - could also be medicine addressing symptoms women have been dealing with for years |
|
diagnostic bracket creep
|
expansion of drug use beyond originally approved uses
non drug examples: high cholestrol (the threshold for high cholesterol has consistently dropped) |
|
the negatives to medicalization of appearance
|
Fragments the body
pathologizes its parts Surgery= treatment to the “pathologies” Becomes easier to justify the invasive and often dangerous procedures on otherwise and apparently healthy bodies |
|
medicalization of appearances examples
|
cosmetic surgery, obesity, botox, baldness, laser hair removal
|
|
medicine and standards of beauty
|
standards of appearance are coming from popular culture, they are ALSO coming from medicine
- And these ideals are themselves shaped by racist ideologies (everyone wants to look white) |
|
Dr. Kenneth Kim
|
does surgery for korean people (1 in 9 koreans get plastic surgery) to look more white (nose lifts, double eyelids, etc)
|
|
medicalization of lifestyle (why? 3 reasons)
(examples? 3 examples) |
Medicine to improve:
Quality of life Lifestyle characteristics Inconveniences Examples: BCP for mild acne Seasonale for fewer periods Baldness medications |
|
early medicalization that impacted males more than females
|
alcoholism
hyperactivity (ADHD drugs given mostly to boys in early days) homosexuality |
|
how are men medicalized?
|
- to fit hegemonic masculine ideals/Type A personality
|
|
medicalization of male aging
|
- testosterone replacement
- viagara |
|
androgel
|
- a testosterone sex hormone gel that is making $27 mil a year
|
|
3 stages of medicalization relatng to gender
|
1) not gender specific
2) gendered to women 3) gendered to both men and women |
|
models of health (3 kinds)
|
biomedical model
constructivism social model |
|
diff b/w poor/rich blacks vs. poor/rich whites
|
the income gap and LE gap is much smaller in the whites
|
|
segregation's impact on health (4 categories
|
1 poor housing
2 less public transport/municipal services 3 more crime, noise, less clean 4 targeted ads to groups is easier cause theyre segregated |
|
current day eugenics
|
fertility treatment
|
|
bill 312
|
bill that tries to make what is considered life different (essentially make abortion illegal)
|
|
radical handmaids
|
group protesting bill 312
|
|
pro-life arguements (2 of them)
|
- women can find support one way or another
- killing a human being/gift from god |
|
US - virginia bill
|
doctors rally against being mandated to perform medically unwarranted experience
|
|
thalidomide ttesting
|
done only on men
|
|
howard from movie
|
severe hypospadios|
surgery at 3 months still doesnt have well formed or functional penis |
|
rick and tina movie
|
ended up giving their child surgery, her vaginal canal was closed
- 30% chance to be homosexual - not medically neccesary - congenital adrenal hyperplasia |
|
androgen receptor defect
|
can have a Y chromosome but not be a boy
|
|
chromosomes vs. hormones determining sex
|
chromosomes only play a role for first 6-7 weeks, afterwards, its hormones
|
|
mosaic pattern
|
both XX and XY cells in the same body
|
|
point of the Bird and Reiker reading
|
research on health has to find the biological and social forces that together shape elements of mens and womens health
|
|
intersex society movement was helped by (2):
|
- que*r activism
- transgender activism |
|
point of the Jordan-Young and Karkazis reading
|
sex testing in sports should not happen, use what is legally written on their documents
|
|
in underdeveloped countries, life expectancies for women and men are ____ why?
|
the same , cause of AIDS affects moer women mostly
|
|
amplification and suppression
|
a biological difference being icnreased by society
a biological difference being decreased by society |
|
black people with same education as rest of canadians:
|
- make less money
- have fewer jobs |
|
androgel
|
a testosterone gel that is trying to increase off-label use through promoting testosterone level testing
|
|
point of zimmerman readings on WHM
|
medicine is an agent of social control,
there are tensions in the womens health movement (race, sexuality) |
|
point of Kline reading (WHM)
|
- describes our bodies, ourselves book
- says that individual experiences are connected to cultural constraints, and presents letters to the editors of our bodies, ourselves |
|
zeldes and stephenson reading (WHM)
|
- just to refirm our bodies ourselves book
- says that its been translated and adapted for different cultures across the world |
|
williams 2002 reading (race)
|
- race comparisons must be made in health even among minorities
- health of minorities is influenced by their geographic, social, political, cultural contexts |
|
cummings and jackson (intersectionality)
|
Black women who hold a college degree report worse health
than White men, White women, and Black men with a high school diploma |
|
annanandale and hunt (1993) (masc/fem and health)
|
more masculity traits in both males and females is better health outcomes
|
|
courtenay 2000 (masculinity and health)
|
that masculine ideals push men to be less healthy, and women to be more healthy. this is a weakness in men and can rip some privelege from under their feet??
|
|
conrad and leiter (medicalization and markets)
|
- consumers, physicians, insurance and pharmas all contribute to medicalization
- corporations/consumers and insurers are becomin bigger players in the contribution to medicalization because of ability to promote directly they can skip the physician |
|
riska (gendered medicalization)
|
- liberal feminists: consumer approach, want more medical care, just better informed
- mens health has also becomes gendered (sexuality) |
|
kaw (asian plastic surgery)
|
medicalization based on gender and race ideologies is what pushes people to get these surgeries
medicine promotes these ideals along with consumerism |
|
mamo and fosket (seasonale)
|
- seasonale is redefining what we think of as feminity
- periods are not normal and are somethign we shoudl strive to get rid of |
|
murray (fatness and medicalization)
|
- our society tells us it is morally wrong to be fat, from individual weakness and unmanaged desires
|
|
heterosexism
|
characteristics of an ideological system that denies, denigrates, and stigmatizes any non-heterosexual form of behavior, identity, relationship, or community
|
|
3 social factors of health to focus on with sexual minorities
|
Sustainable (social) resources
Social justice Equity |
|
problem of visibility
|
more info about sexual minority health
|
|
heteronormativity in healthcare
|
a major issue in sexual minority health, need to improve attitudes in professionals and society
|
|
major themes of sex. minority health (4)
|
problem of visibility, heteronormativity in healthcare, multiple aspects of health, diversity within the community
|
|
defining and measuring LGB population in canada:
|
- canadians community health survey, other surveys, bisexual womens health outcomes
|
|
major disparities in sex. minority health (5)
|
Substance and alcohol abuse
STIs and HIV/AIDS Suicidal ideation Depression, minority stress and anxiety Cancer (smoking rates in non-heterosexual women) |
|
majority of sexual minority health info is for
|
gay males and men who have sex with men (MSM). distinct needs for those who are out, and those closeted
|
|
lesbian health needs excluded from (2)
|
mainstream politics
qu*er politics |
|
mediating/aggrevating factors in health for sexual minorities (3)
|
additive stress model,
age, bisexuality |
|
Bisexuality— ‘just a phase’
|
Bisexual women may have less access to social support, given the often negative attitudes of both heterosexuals and gays and lesbians toward bisexuality
|
|
on the down low
|
heterosexual racialized men have homosexual sex while in M-F long term relationships
- marginalized and subordinate masculinities combined |
|
bisexual bridge
|
transmitting HIV from homosexual minority to heterosexual minority
|
|
issues of accessibiltiy for sexual minorities (3)
|
que*r freindly physicians, information, centres and resources
|
|
social justice for sexual minorities and legislation
|
- not being covered under health insurance
- less screening/preventative care - legislative rights not reflected at frontline. - forward strides: expanding definitions, training on diversity, specific programs for LGB |
|
fenway health
|
an example of an LGB clinic in boston
|
|
lombardi (transgender health)
|
- needs to have specific educational tools
- need to validate their identity - remove discrimination |
|
feinberg (transgender health)
|
- talks about experiences with being denied healthcare
- the need to show trans population that it is ok to seek healthcare |
|
dysart-gale (nursing and LGBTIQ health)
|
- that people, esp youth still face discrim attitudes despite legislative change
- prejudice has negative impacts on their health |
|
LG patients and HCPs (accessibility)
|
- less than half thought their insurance plan allowed them to find an LGB doctor
- those who did were more likely to be old, white, male and feel comfortable discussing sex - lesbians have a harder time disclosing sexual orientation and finding an LG provider |
|
Lesbian health needs
|
- cervical/breast cancer screening
- WSW need STI info - lesbian friendly spaces needed |
|
historical context of sex. minorities in sociology
|
- 1940s: not recognized
- post war: feminist, counter culture movements, - 1960s: homosexuality is deviance -1970s: more focus on homosexuality (could be nature) |
|
gay & lesbian politics divide
|
political organizing as primarily reflecting interests of white, middle-class gay men
conflicts over issues of racialization & sexuality exclusion of lesbian identities and interests |
|
que*r theory
|
- rejection of a unified homosexual subject
*IDs are multiple and changing - radical politics of difference (the imptance of ID differences and what shapes them) |
|
GRID and gay plague prevention (vs. AIDS prevention)
|
homophobic response to the discovery of HIV/AIDS
- focus on specific sexual risk group vs. -focus on universal risk practices |
|
transvestite
|
- early 20th C; term applied primarily to men who wear women’s clothing
medical: ICD F64.1: fetishistic transvestism |
|
Transsexual (early meaning/disorder)
|
medicalized as “gender identity disorder”
medical: DSM; ICD F64.0 – transsexualism - someone who had medical intervention |
|
transgender
|
- transsexual person without medical intervention
- encompasses a wide range of fluid and variable sex and gender variances (from qu*er theory) - someone who has a perceived difference in secondary sex characteristics |
|
major trans health issues (3)
|
overall health & well-being
HIV/AIDS mental health |
|
unique trans helth issues (2)
|
- health effects of hormone and surgical interventions (are they health promoting vs. increased risks)
- accessing healthcare (refusal/substandard treatment/shopping for transpositive providers) |
|
street hormones (example)
|
- used by trans people who want to have hormone therapy but without medical supervision
- billy tipton, the jazz musician died this way |
|
strategies for improving trans health (5)
|
Acknowledge authenticity of transgender individuals’ identities
0. avoid medicalized approach (i.e. gender identity disorder) 1.Lack of tolerance for discriminatory treatment/refusal to treat 2.Support for youth questioning their gender identity 3.Increased and better access to services 4.Cultural relevancy in research, policy, education, prevention, etc |
|
public health/womens health view of abortion (4)
|
*Women are dying from unsafe abortions
*Women’s health depends on access to safe abortions *Women will seek out abortions whether legal or not, or safe or not. Therefore, it is necessary to make sure that women are safe and healthy. *Aim to reduce the number of abortions overall through public health measures |
|
abortion rates drop in countries where it is ______. abortion in these countries is (safe/unsafe). This country (is/is not) contributing for the reduction in # of abortions. It is also probably a (developed/developing) country
|
legal, safe, is responsible, developed
|
|
40% of women live countries where abortion has (restrictive/no law)
|
restrictive law
|
|
barriers to safe abortions (5)
|
1) knowledge and awareness
2) high cost 3) lack of doctors 4) lack of confidentiality 5) legality |
|
abortion is legal in these countries but hard to access (2)
|
india, zambia
|
|
clandestine abortion numbers in developing countries, categories of types (5)
|
numbers vary largely from place to place.
1) women themselves 2) woman to another woman 3)mexico ru46 abortion pill on black market 4) pharmacist performed 5)doctor/nurse/midwife |
|
what to do about global abortions?
|
***Need to reduce number of unintended pregnancies
1/3 of all pregnancies are unintended 2/3 of those are due to lack of contraception ***Contraception rates are increasing globally ***More needs to be done in order to reduce maternal mortality- 1 woman dies every minute |
|
WHO definition of reproductive health
|
people are able to have a responsible, satisfying and safe sex life and that they have the capability to reproduce and the freedom to decide if, when, and how often to do so
|
|
contraception vs. family planning
|
contraception is the tool for family planning (choosing # of children)
|
|
types of contraception + examples (4)
|
“Natural”: Fertility awareness, withdrawal, natural family planning
Barrier/Mechanical: Condoms, diaphragm and cervical cap, spermicides, intrauterine devices (IUD) Hormonal: Oral contraceptives, contraceptive patch, vaginal ring, injectable, implants, intrauterine systems (IUS) Surgical: Vasectomy and tubal ligation |
|
most common methods of contraception (3)
|
Most common methods: Oral contraceptives, male condom, sterilization. male methods are common at every age
|
|
plan B
|
Prevents pregnancy when taken within 72 hours after unprotected intercourse
Reduces the risk of unplanned pregnancy by 90% EC ≠ RU486 (medical abortion) Will not interrupt an established pregnancy Safe for almost all women |
|
unintended pregnancy (what it is, prevalnce, outcomes)
|
both unwanted OR mistimed, 49% of pregnancies, 43% abortion, 48% live birth, 9% miscarriage
|
|
adverse impacts of unintended pregnancies (4)
|
Delayed prenatal care,
increased rates of premature birth, lower rates of smoking cessation & breastfeeding, large economic costs |
|
Finer and Henshaw (unitended pregnancy disparities)
|
- poor/rich disparties have increased in the US, overall numbers have remained the same
|
|
abortion prevalence in US and Canada
|
1/4 of Canadian women will have had an abortion by the age of 44
1/3 of American women will have had an abortion by the age of 44 |
|
abortions by gestational age in US/Can
|
most before 9 weeks, 80% before 10 wks
|
|
access to abortion in US and Can is restricted by (3)
|
Provider shortage (geographic area in the country matters)
Anti-abortion legislation at federal, state and provincial level Funding restrictions Facility regulation Targeted harassment of abortion patients and providers |
|
Why do women have unintended pregnancies?
|
- 52% no contraception
- the rest, contraception failed |
|
issues with contraception methods (3)
|
1) No method 100% effective
2) Pros and cons to every method: Side effects Contraindications Cost Efficacy 3) Difficult to achieve “perfect use” with the most commonly used reversible methods (pill, condoms) |
|
issues with contraception usage (8)
|
1. Perception of low-risk of pregnancy (36%)
2. Ambivalence about pregnancy (23%) 3. Unprepared for sexual activity (17%) 4. Dissatisfaction with method (14%) 5. Partner issues (13%) 6. Life change 7. Problems accessing methods 8. Provider dissatisfaction (not happy with HCP) |
|
structural barriers to contraception in US vs. Canada
|
US
1. Lack of mandated insurance coverage of contraception 2. Caps on refills 3. Short visits=poor counseling 4. Provider misinformation 5. Conscience clauses () Canada: 1. Difficulty locating primary care physician 2. Inconsistency of care 3. Short visits=poor counseling 4. Provider misinformation |
|
conscience clauses
|
HCPs in the US can refuse service to contraceptions if it goes against their religion
|
|
How can we reduce rates of unintended pregnancy?
|
Increase use of long-acting contraceptives such as the IUD, include discussion of life change and life circumstance in contraceptive appointments
|
|
Roberts (birth control movement and eugenics)
|
-margaret sanger was a eugenicist
- the double standard of reproductive freedom/sterilization |
|
girlmom.com
|
a website for yougn teen mothers, with open views about abortion and the ability of teens to raise children
|
|
why did childbirth shift to hospitals from the home? (4 reasons)
|
>Proliferation of hospitals in the 20th Century
Beds that needed patients >Development of modern nursing provided continuous observation and care >Structured medical education need for large numbers of women to be in one place for medical student experience >Emergence of obstetrics as a specialization |
|
stratified medicalization in childbirth (4)
|
>At first, it was upper and middle class women who moved to hospitals
>Poor women and rural women still gave birth at home >Physicians for rich women, midwives for poor women >Exclusion of midwives from hospitals until the 1970s in the US and UK |
|
medical authority in childbirth (2 methods)
|
- using technologies to assist childbirth
- creating idea of medical problem, then being the ony one to solve it |
|
one-two punch (c-section as example)
|
- technology undermines the natural system
- then technology is seen as the solution to fix it *restrictive labour positions, epidurals (reduce pain), cause increased baby heart rate, c-section is determined to be needed |
|
Twilight sleep (what it does, what it means for medicalization, who wants it)
|
- amnesia after labour
- only administered in hospitals - required extra care: restraints, nurse attention - desire for twilight sleep came from women themselves as well (medicalization of society) |
|
effects of medicalization of childbirth (3)
|
- followed surgical model, different rooms
- woman is alone for labour and delivery - fetus emerges as the 2nd patient (ultrasound, electronic monitoring, increased c-sections) |
|
why have c-sections increased if birth has not become more dangerous??? (5)
|
1. Convenience for doctors/hospital staff
2. A way to make money for hospitals? 3. Fear of litigation/malpractice- use of other technologies 4, Patient choice 5. Belief that Cesareans are safer |
|
epidural rates (US/CAN, vs UK)
|
59%, 45.7%: England 12%
|
|
Responses to medicalization of childbirth (3, and explanations)
|
1) Welcoming
Women who want greater “choice,” relief from pain and who agree that childbirth is an experience best managed by medicine. 2) Resistance There has always been continuous lay and professional midwives offering home birth to a growing number of women as well as women who choose to have unassisted births. Here, the idea that childbirth is a medical problem is totally rejected. 3) Pragmatic resistance and welcoming Strategically draw from both of these models they believe that pregnancy and childbirth are not medical “problems” per se, but that they can usefully benefit from some of what medicine has to offer, while also drawing on alternative models. Rise in birthing centres and midwife-assisted hospital births are examples of this. |
|
leavitt (twilight sleep)
|
- that feminist women wanted it cause they thoguht it was liberating
- they wanted to make their choice of painless or painful birth - this was co-opted and make twilight sleep contribute to medicalization |
|
macdonald (contemporary midwfery)
|
- natural childbirth is being defined by contemporary midwifery
- this is dangerous cause modern midwives use technoligies and hospital spaces - also carries the message that women should be naturally competent and knowing - each birth is individual |
|
illegal midwives on call article
|
- there is a black market for midwives in mtl cause the demand for them is so high and the formal education is not appropriate
|
|
rise in new reproductive technologies attributed to (3)
|
1) The women’s health movement
2) Expansion of medical knowledge and technologies 3) Medicalization of reproduction |
|
pitosin
|
helps contractions increase during birth
|
|
birth control (good things, bad things)
|
De-coupling reproduction from sex
Freeing women from the constraints of unwanted motherhood Made the argument about “choice” of parenthood bad: Double-standard: Testing of early Pill on minorities Coercive use of long-lasting hormonal contraceptive for sterilization |
|
types of assisted reproductive technologies (3)
|
1) sperm donation (usually done through a sperm bank)
2) intrauterine insemination 3) in vitro fertilization (not always effective, allows women to have children later in life) |
|
bodily commodification
|
the transformation of goods and services (or things that may not normally be regarded as goods or services) into a commodity– giving something economic/market value where it didn’t have it before. DONE WITH BODY PARTS. organs, blood, issue, sperm, eggs, embryos, breast milk
|
|
canadian law on buying eggs/sperm/gametes
|
strict compared to US
illigeal here, you con import from the US as of this year |
|
consequences of bodily commodification (2)
|
1. bodily autonomy (if it belongs to me, its my right to sell it)
2. there is potential for coersion in these transactions cause of social/economic differences |
|
new users of reproductive technologies
|
lesbian users: using technologies designed for infertile women
|
|
quebec IVF policy (arguments for/against)
|
-medicare funding for IVF
pros: 1) Fertility is a disease, reproductive right issue 2) Public health protection to prevent multiple births 3) Equal access rather than just those who can afford it 4) Can put other kinds of restrictions/eligibility requirements/state’s interference in reproduction cons: 1) $$ cost the system 2) Infertility isn’t a disease (social problem?) 3) Resource allocation– what’s not getting funded? 4) Reinforces cultural norms |
|
who are reproductive tech. available to?
|
- single women? G&L? surrogacy (pay someone to be a surrogate mother), age restrictions?? gamete donation
|
|
donating eggs vs. sperm (differences in value)
|
- sex difference in value (sperms worth less, but egg donors might be getting paid less than they deserve cause of risks)
-racial difference in value - do biological or cultural ideas shape this?? |
|
what shapes market for eggs and sperm (4 clases of factors)
|
1) Biological factors: bodily cells produced by male and female bodies
2) Economic factors: supply and demand for these materials 3) Cultural Factors: gendered norms of parenthood, desire for biological children 4) Structural Factors: organized model of fertility clinics for marketing, recruiting and procuring gametes |
|
sperm and egg sale advertising
|
- people want donors who are like them
- certain traits can be selected for |
|
sibling registry
|
- prevents incestuous results from 1 sperm donor donating to 100 different women
|
|
sex selection (how its done)
|
1. preimplantation gender diagnosis (knwoing what the sex of an IVF will be)
2. prenatal screening followed by selective termination |
|
legality of sex selection in NA
|
- can be done cause of abortion laws and access to assited reproduction therapies
|
|
feminist ethics vs. social harm caused by sex selection
|
feminist ethics - isnt this a personal choice??
social harm: 1. child sex ratios in some parts of the world, reinforces structural sexism and patriarchy 2. permissive approach in northern industrialized countries could have dangerous effects beyond their borders – global accountability approach 3. Reproductive autonomy is not expansive reproductive choices always affect others |
|
sex selection (in india)
|
- is illegal
- indian immigrants are most likley for their third child to be a boy - 1.36 - 1.0 ratio |
|
mamo 2007 (lesbians and assisted reproduction technologies)
|
lesbians pathways to pregnancy are hybrid technological practices
- combine women's health and biomedical knowledge in a way thats beneficial for them (pragmatic adjustments) -they do not accept biomedicine blindly -technologies of the self |
|
almeling 2007 (egg/sperm markets)
|
- more altruistic rhetoric for egg donors, they are also valued much more (cause of gender roles and perceived rarity)
- costs of sperm donation: long term committment, abstinence - costs of egg donation: reisk of hyperstimulation disorder, hormone therapy - gift vs. commodity: how it influences our interpretation of a child |
|
scully (2006) (morals of sex selection)
|
- people offered many reasons why reproductive choice might be problematic
- sex selection is undesirable because it is an expression of parental prefernce rather than response to need of the child - captured by a model of relational autonomy |
|
puri et al 2011 (reasons for indian sex selection)
|
1)sociocultural roots of son preference; 2) women’s early socialization around the
importance of sons; 3) the different forms of pressure to have sons that women experienced from female in-laws and husbands; 4) the spectrum of verbal and physical abuse that women faced when they did not have male children and/or when they found out they were carrying a female fetus; 5) the ambivalence with which women regarded their own experience of reproductive “choice.” |
|
most common cancer among canadian women
|
breast cancer
|
|
risk factors for breast cancer
|
very many:
Genetics (BRCA I and II)/ Family history Gender Age Breast density Early menstruation/Late menopause Radiation exposure Reproduction Breastfeeding Hormone replacement therapy Oral contraceptives Body weight Physical activity Alcohol use Tobacco smoke Environmental Exposures?? |
|
funded biomedical model of cancer (2 focuses)
|
1) Focuses on producing knowledge about the biology of the disease
2) Developing better screening, detection, treatment, risk assessment, and risk reduction technologies |
|
grassroots environmental model of cancer (2 focuses)
|
1) Focuses on toxic substances and suspected carcinogens
2) Goal is to understand what causes cancer and to eliminate or reduce exposures to such causal factors: to create a safer environment. |
|
environmental health movement (3 aspects to focus on)
|
1)Structural inequality
2)Racism 3)Corporate and govt. responsibility |
|
Activist critiques of breast cancer movement (2 points)
|
1) Risk reduction/treatment rather than prevention
Working within the medical model of cancer- not questioning it Blame the victim? Individual causes vs. structural/systemic ones “downstream” rather than “upstream” focus 2) Commodification- pink ribbon marketing campaigns Breast cancer awareness = commodified Profiteering on other people’s suffering Appearing “charitable” when it’s really for money Companies donating money also use carcinogens in their products |
|
pink ribbons as co-optation
|
- co-optation of WHM by the biomedical institution, pretending to care about women`s health but still in the medical model
|
|
pinkwashing
|
making a horrible disease breast cancer palatable for the masses rather than showing the reality of it
- people who are dying of it blame themselves for nto getting past it |
|
gender and breast cancer activism
|
- breast cancer might garner attention cause its about breasts
- the view of women as mothers and sisters - making emotionality permissible by women -women activists are also sometimes discredited because of ``emotionality` and feminine characteristics (a gender bias in science) |
|
bioethics
|
multidisciplinary study of ethical controversies brought
about by advances in medicine & the life sciences balancing values, interests, benefits, burdens & resources |
|
feminist approaches to science, technology (3)
|
1. scripts approach (that users of biotechnology are meant for certain scripts)
2. designers and users of technologies( have intended vs excluded users, gendered, sexed, racialized) 3. resistance to scripting |
|
HPV (what. types)
|
- common, contagious virus
- mostly asymptomatic - 2 main types of symptomatic infections: . low risk: warts high risk: cancers of genitals |
|
gardasil
|
- HPV vaccine protects agai70% of cervical cancersnst high risk HPVs
- approved for females 9-26 -quadrivalent, protects against 90% of genital warts, - virus like particles stimulate immune response |
|
gardasil vs. cervarix
|
-cervarix protects against a bit more cervical cancers
|
|
why was gardasil developed?
|
- Merck had financial desparation and expiring patents
- it is a potential blockbuster drug |
|
Quebec's HPV vaccination program
|
- free for girls 9-17, not mandatory, administered gr 4
- not free for boys - |
|
critiques of HPV vaccination (4)
|
1) Long term risks unknown
2) Money could be better spent elsewhere-- on preventive health 3) Girls as guinea pigs- gendered argument (are they the test subjects??) 4) Reduce number of annual exams, pap smears, routine gynecological exams |
|
why were aprents initially declining to have girls vaccinated??
|
possibly a denial of female adoescent sexuality, but this is changing as we get used to he idea that cancer can be caused by sex
|
|
most women are ____ (accepting/not accepting) of the HPV vaccine because
|
accepting, Family support
Caregiver support Destigmatized Cancer prevention less accepting: -selfefficacy barriers. other ways to prevent. stigmatized. mistrust of vaccines |
|
zavetoski et al (environmental breast cancer movement)
|
- the BCM is gender discrimination cause it puts the fault on women (personal lifestyle and genetics)
- the media sexualizes breast cancer -pharmas commodify it - research objectifies breasts |
|
sick of pink(feswick)
|
- breast cnacer is marketable because:
-women cant impact the largest risk factors (age & genetics) - women are large purchasing power - saving the breast is saving female sexuality - people are less likely to make direct donations cause they feel they contribute by buying pink |
|
lippman (2007) (gardasil critisms)
|
- cervical cancer is not a huge health concern, and is largely treatable
- most expensive child vaccine |
|
polzer and knabe (2012) (HPV vaccine and medicalization)
|
this configuration of medicalization positions the
emergence of sexuality itself as the basis of risk and pathologization |
|
colgrove 2006 (mandatory HPV vaccination)
|
- is it ethical to mandate this on parents, also what is the power of public health to do this? political power given to public health
|
|
hopfer and clippard (2010) HPV vaccination attitudes in college students
|
1) relationship
status frames relevance of HPV to women, that 2) vaccine accessibility is an important factor amongvaccine accepting college women, 3) that exploring family HPV vaccine norms might prove useful 4) dispelling myths about HPV transmission |
|
body work becomes mandatory
|
- its gendered
- good health is conflated with the work you do on your body - you have a moral imperative to care for yourself |
|
masculinity, health, and consumption
|
- sports supplements change the ideas about masculinity
|
|
atkinson (2007) supplements
|
- guys take them so that they can adhere to trad. masculine images in a non-threatening way (ie. without expresssing aggression or violence)
- reclaiming masculinity through bodybuilding - supplements are a cure for masculine anxiety - to have bodily control is to have control over your life |
|
stats with excersize in boys/girls
|
- 91% of boys excersize to gain muscle (9 to 16 years old)
- 43% of boys change eating to gain muscle - most of these boys are Hmong (minorties) |
|
marwick 2010 (how culture operates on the body)
|
this example tells us how culture operates on the body
- reality TV shows demonstrating how aesthetic work on the body is morally justified "The Swan", "Biggest Loser", "Fat March". - low self esteem is caused by the body -so you must change it (medical gaze: compartmentalizing the body) |
|
schepher hughes and lock (1987)
|
Health is increasingly viewed as an achieved rather than an ascribed status and each individual is expected to ‘work hard’ at being strong, fit, and healthy
|
|
genital cosmetic surgery (problems: 3)
|
- medicalization of sexual problems
-narrowing the view of what is considered normal - the idea that female sexual drive is important only to equal that of the man/preserve social relationships |
|
barker (pharmaceutical determinism)
|
- lyrica, a medication for fibromyalgia
- we are not evn sure if fibromyalgia even exists - the existence of a medication for it provides fibromyalgia some legitimacy |
|
fishman (role of the researcher in FSD)
|
-drugs, diseases, biomedical knowledge, expertise, and the researchers themselves become commodified as they mediate the marketing of new drugs to treat female sexual dysfunction
- the medical area only escaped commodification because it was actively resisted (medical exceptionalism) -now the front as if this is still the case is what allows medicine to profit |
|
Fitzpatrick (2008) (female cosmetic sex surgery)
|
- the increasing trend of sexual plastic cosmetic surgery
- to make up for a feeling of poor body image - has risks associated with it... can be likened to female genital mutilation - getting a boyfriend is easier and ebtter solution than surgery |
|
critiques of pharma (4)
|
1) Profiteering
Profits as a percent of revenue (2011) Pharma- 15.9% Fortune 500- 4.2% 2) Drug safety concerns 3) Uncontrolled Use and Cost of Drugs 4) Undue Influence on Physicians and Researchers |
|
pharmaceutical marketing
|
- spend twice as much on advertising than reseach
|
|
medicalization of impotence
|
1900-30s: impotence natural
1930-50s: disease of young (psychoanalytic) and condition of the old 1960-80s: Impotence is a psychological condition (based in anxiety or fear) 1980-90s: medical and physiological condition (urologists needed more patients) |
|
lifestyle drugs
|
- treat "life limiting" conditions
- require a diagnosis and FDA approval - diagnostic creep - onften treats symptoms related to aging |
|
4 assumptions in phizer's marketing of viagara:
|
1) Erectile Dysfunction is a Medical Problem
2) Viagara is a natural solution to ED 3) Viagara is for Heterosexual men 4) Viagara cures relationship problems |
|
technological inscription
|
- technologies are developed with particular users in mind
- they are still flexible after leaving the lab/factory - gendered norms and assumptions are both inputs and outputs of the construction of Viagra |
|
black box of technological development
|
- obscures the social relationships behind the design of a technology, make it seem like intrinsic and inherent parts of the technology
|
|
scripts in Viagra (6)
|
- assumption that viagara will be used one when having sex with someone (not alone)
- that it will be used by couples - that the couple will be monogamous - woman as the caregiver, man in control - impotence is constructed as a coupled phenomenon - generalizability over time to superpotence as the market expands |
|
viagra wives
|
- as a result of their husbands on viagra, they cant kep up with the libido of their partner
|
|
sexuality and menopause paper
|
- reproductive experiences thought of in a cumulative way up till menopause
- their race informs it (black women more hysterectomies, whites more infertility) - relationship status as well - age at childbearing has to do with interpretation of fertility |
|
carr and utz (widowhood research)
|
- macrosocial conditions influence widowhood
- slower deaths of spouses these days makes higher anxiety (for men esp.) -deaths with physical pain are also hard for the spouse to endure (for women esp.) - women are more socially connected once widowed - research requires longitutdinal studies comapres with non-widows |
|
marshall 2006 (viagra, male aging)
|
- male menopause explained as andogen deficiency post-viagra impact on mens health
- manhood changes rather than diminishes with age |
|
calasanti (2007)
|
- using feminism to examine old men's health
- that young men are more likely to have poor health when they are old because of social norms for young men - not being a man is more scary than death for many - yougn men have priviledge over old men but all men have priviledge over women |