• Shuffle
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
  • Alphabetize
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
  • Front First
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
  • Both Sides
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
  • Read
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
Reading...
Front

How to study your flashcards.

Right/Left arrow keys: Navigate between flashcards.right arrow keyleft arrow key

Up/Down arrow keys: Flip the card between the front and back.down keyup key

H key: Show hint (3rd side).h key

A key: Read text to speech.a key

image

Play button

image

Play button

image

Progress

1/25

Click to flip

25 Cards in this Set

  • Front
  • Back
Turning Point Question: Which of the following costs would be included in the numerator of a societal CEA on a new drug treatment?
The cost of the drug

Changes in healthcare resources used as a result of the drug (such as side effects due to the drug, treatment failures due to the drug, and reduced healthcare resources consumed as a result of the drug)

Work productivity costs
If the question was worded to ask the same question from a payer perspective, what would the answer be?
The first two, but not work productivity costs due to the drug since productivity doesn't directly affect payers
What is a QALY? What is the advantage of using QALY's?
Quality Adjusted Life Years

Can compare cost effectiveness of a wide variety of interventions/healthcare programs
Who tends to use CEA data?
Not the american government - Although they are signaling that they are beginning to via funding CEA research and a bolus of funding

Healthplans do use it to make informed decisions such as adding interventions to their formulary
Hospitals will use CEA
When did Cost Effectiveness Analysis begin being used?
US PHS 1993 - To enhance perspectives for health-related decisions. To assess the current state of the art in CE methods and provide recommendations to improve quality and encourage comparability of results.
What did this panel recommend?
Using a societal perspective to include both direct and indirect cost.
However, also doing other perspectives also if relevent (payer perspective subanalysis)
Continuation of last answer
Using a reference case (gold standard - practices that will define the treatment of the disease) - In CEA you compare treatments to the standard of care
The reference case in this case is the standard of care you are comparing another intervention to.
Turning point question: In a CEA of new oral anti-coagulants, warfarin is an appropriate choice for the reference case.
True - Warfarin is the standard of care to which other interventions are compared to.
What are the 5 steps to conduct a CEA?
1) Define the problem and identify relevant treatment alternatives
2) Identify data sources
3) Measure costs and outcomes
4) Calculate cost effectiveness metrics (ACERs, ICERs)
5) Report the results
In defining the problem and identifying treatment alternatives, you want to determine the objectives of your CEA (including the studys persepctive) and all clinically relevant treatment options
Experimental studies (clinical trials) - These trials are not done with cost in mind, but only the effectiveness of the intervention. So, CEA researchers will piggyback clinical trials and covert their findings to cost variables.
Observational studies
Retrospective studies
The drawback of piggybacking is the lack of generalizability. The results are confined to the type of patient population in the study and doesn't translate well to society.
RCT's not generalizable but strong design
Observational studies generalizable but not strong design
Retrospective Databases (claims data - very poor for outcome data, registries - get better outcome data from but very expensive and so there are not a lot of them)
Electronic medical records hold a lot of promise as a data source
In measuring cost and outcomes, which goes in the numerator and which goes in the denominator?
Cost/Outcome
What goes in the numerator (costs)?
Selection of costs is based on perspective as well as characteristics of the disease and treatments being evaluated in the CEA
Societal = direct + indirect costs
Plan = Don't look at productivity (indirect costs)
Patient = Out of pocket costs (co-pays, deductibles, spending on your care as well as your work impact - costs that are relevant to you)
What goes in the denominator (outcomes)?
Selection of outcome is also based on perspective as well as characteristics of the disease and treatments being evaluated in the CEA
Outcome measures that would be used in a CEA study of anti-hypertensive medications.
Surrogate endpoints (Blood Pressure
Events prevented (Stroke, MI)
Survival (lives saved, years of life gained)
Quality of life (usually measured as quality adjusted life years)
What do ACER and ICER stand for?
Average Cost Effectiveness Ratio

Incremental Cost Effectiveness Ratio
What is the equation for ACER?
ACER = C/E

C = Total cost of the treatment/program

E = Effectiveness of the treatment/program
Provide an example of an ACER.
Treatment cost 500$
Lowers cholesterol 10 points
500/10 = 50$ per point lowered
What is the equation for an ICER?
ICER = Cost of Treatment B - Cost of Treatment A/ Effectiveness of Treatment B - Effectiveness of Treatment A
Provide an example of an ICER.
New antibiotic treatment (700$) yields 15 cures.
Standard of care (400$) yields 12 cures.
700-400/15-12 = 300/3 = 100$ per cure
Interpretation = It costs 100$ for each additional cure with Antibiotic B compared to Antibiotic A
***This is the preferred measure of CEA because it can be used to compare competing treatments/programs***
Cost Utility Analysis
Compares the total costs of a therapy to the utility of the outcome gained where utility is a measure of the quality and/or quantity of life gained before of the treatment/healthcare program
Usually quality and quantity are used together (QALY)
When is CUA appropriate?
1) When the treats/programs being compared effect morbidity and/or mortality (when the disease effects the persons quality of life long-term)
***QALY is not a good measure in short-term treatments such as antibiotic therapy***
2) When its required (by purchaser or regulatory body)
What is the equation for the QALY?
QALY = (quality of life) x (time in that quality of life state) x (individuals utility for life during that time)

***This is the primary effectiveness measure for CUA and is measured over a one year period***
The value of the treatment in a population can therefore be measured as the sum of QALYs experienced by individuals with the disease and receiving the treatments/programs of interest
The individuals utility for life during that state is how much they value that quality of life during that state.
Once the costs per QALY are defined, a willingness to pay threshold is determined and is usually around 50,000$.
There are however, instances such as cancer where society is willing to pay more.

***CUA is a subgroup of CEA***