Noll - The Rise Of Evangelicalism

Front 1

Mark Noll (Position and Church Affiliation)

Back 1

Francis A. McAnaney Professor of History at the University of Notre Dame.

Attends South Bend Christian Reformed Church (Immanuel Presbyterian, Warrenville, IL)

Front 2

Mark Noll (Education)

Back 2

B. A. (English), Wheaton College (1968)
M.A. (Comparative Literature), University of Iowa (1970)
M.A. (History of Christianity), Trinity Evangelical Divinity School (1972)
Ph.D. (History of Christianity), Vanderbilt University (1975)

Front 3

Purpose of "Rise"

Back 3

In The Rise of Evangelicalism, Noll purposes to “provide a coherent, multinational narrative of the origin, development, and rapid diffusion of evangelical movements in their first two generations” (24).

Front 4

Noll Thesis:

Back 4

CULTURAL roots

Evangelicalism is a work of the Spirit through convergent forces because the gospel is spread, and the schismatic and anti-intellectual tendencies inherent in a movement largely lacking either liturgical or ecclesiastical integrity, are merely different “languages” by which the conversation of the meaning of Christianity progresses in a pluralistic society.

or

Evangelicalism arose during the mid to late 18th century out of pietism and puritanism as a spiritually but not organizationally unified network of leaders, churches, organizations, publications, causes, and projects directed by the Holy Spirit.

or

Evangelicalism is a work of the Spirit (139) through convergent social, ecclesial, intellectual, and psychological forces that revitalized Protestantism (153-54), while sometimes neglecting and distorting the inherited tradition (292).

Front 5

Key Point: Three Connections between American Evangelical Christianity and the Enlightenment

Back 5

1. Personal Experience (John Lock) and turn to individual.
2. Evangelical trust in affections.
3. Eschewing received tradition for practical results.

Front 6

Key Point: Sociological effects

Back 6

1. Voluntary societies lose authority for discipline
2. Anti-intellectual tendency
3. Schismatic trends

Front 7

Chapter 1: Landscapes: Political, Ecclesiastical, Spiritual

Back 7

State-Church situations and Enlightenment/Diest challenges created a need for a "more emotionally satisfying Christianity" (41). This combined with "a vast superstructure of prejudice" against "Catholics and Catholic states" was a legacy of the past that grew even stronger over the course of the eighteenth century. (49)

Front 8

Chapter 2: Antecedents, Stirrings

Back 8

This need for a more emotionally satisfying Christianity led to "poorly organized transformations of practical religion among individuals and in local communities. This involved a private interpretation of scripture and individual experiences of worship and piety, often called "the religion of the heart" These movements lead directly to evangelicalism (53) Originally, Piatists conceived of this personal religion only in the context of a reformed Church, State and Society (54)

Front 9

Chapter 3: Revival, 1734–1738

Back 9

Revival proper begins in the fall of 1735 with the preaching of Jonathan Edwards in Northhampton, with many conversions and unheralded unity among the populace (77–78). For Noll despite unprecedented ecumenical cooperation, America lacks either the ecclesiastical history or liturgical grounding of European counties, and becomes subject to an entrepreneurial remaking of Christian faith and practice.

Front 10

Chapter 4: Revival, Fragmentation, Consolidation, 1738–1745

Back 10

Noll here identifies evangelical weaknesses that emerged and continued to afflict the movement: disregard for tradition, empire building,judgmentalism, and lack of organizational planning and continuity.

Front 11

Chapter 5: Explanations

Back 11

evangelicalism was grounded religiously in the innovative preaching of justifying faith. It was promoted and maintained by the effective exertions of capable spiritual leaders. It offered a compelling picture of direct fellowship with God for believers as individuals and in groups. It represented a shift in religiosity away from the inherited established churches toward spiritual communities constructed by believers themselves. It featured a form of conversion as much focused on personal experience, as much convinced of the plasticity of human nature and as much preoccupied with claims of certainty as any manifestation of the Enlightenment. And because its spirituality was ad-
justed to an opening world of commerce, communications and empire, that spirituality effectively resolved the psychological dilemmas created by this opening world. (154)

Front 12

Chapter 6: Development 1745–1770

Back 12

xc

Front 13

Chapter 7: Diversification 1770–1795

Back 13

Chapter 7: Diversification 1770–1795

Front 14

Chapter 8: In the World

Back 14

acknowledges that evangelicalism V as a pietistic movement in which the relationship of the self to God eclipsed all other con-cerns" (234).

Front 15

Chapter 9: True Religion

Back 15

Noll explains the pervasiveness of the foundational themes of personal salvation, the power of grace, deliverance from sin, celebration of God and his saving work, and life in the Spirit—all amply illustrated by the prolific, perceptive evangelical hymnody of the period. As he has in other places, Noll exposes evangelicalism's intellectual deficiencies and its frequent emphasis on the faith of the heart at the expense of the faith of the mind.

Front 16

Afterward

Back 16

The emphasis on conversion and on the active presence of the Holy Spirit has led at least some evangelicals to deny the value of intellectual effort itself.’ Noll argues that their distrust of ecclesiastical and educational authorities and strong tendency to define the church in voluntary terms has deprived evangelicals of benefiting from ‘inter-generational intellectual nurture’ which has resulted in, at its best, much evangelical thought reflecting ‘savvy practical wisdom rather than foundational reasoning’ (244).

Front 17

Key Point (Benefits)

Back 17

1. Gospel Spread
2. Counter-reformation of denominations
3.

Front 18

Noll defines Evangelical as:

Back 18

“designating a set of convictions, practices, habits and oppositions that resemble what Europeans describe as “pietism” (17).

He refers to the Bebbington quadrilateral to outline these convictions as
1.) personal salvation,
2.) biblical emphasis,
3.) evangelism and mission, and
4.) crucicentrism (19).

Front 19

Key Point: Causes

Back 19

1. State Church issues
2. Enlightenment Philosophy
3. Puritan, Pietist and Anglican movements
4. Lack of ministers in the colonies

Front 20

Key Factors for the Rise of Evangelicalism

Back 20

1. Movement of the Holy Spirit
2. Skilled and committed preacher, revivalists, and leaders
3. Flow of History-E. followed in the heals of the Puritan revolution, new Roman Catholic challenges set the stage for E.
4. Social-ecclesial--growing individualism and anti-ecclesial authority, Lack of ministers in expanding colonies
5. Intellectual--Enlightenment Philosophy
6. Psychological--cause of guilt in seeking wealth and the way to escape it.

Front 21

Noll's critique of E.

Back 21

1. anti-ecclesiasticism
2. anti-intellectual
3. individualism
4. pragmatism
5. voluntary participation in the church