|
|
- 2012
- directed by Jem Cohen
- set in Vienna's Kunsthistorisches Museum
- starring Mary Margaret O'Hara and Bobby Sommers (not an actor)
- Cohen worked as a guard on Scorsese's After Hours
|
|
|
- opening hours of public institution
- time spent in the museum
- time and museum objects
- access to art is still regulate
- time of longevity/posterity
- city becomes a museum itself
- human lifetime
- signs of life now gone
|
|
|
- film about ways of seeing the past: Johann, Anne, dying cousin, pasts of figures in the paintings, Johann uses objects to explain his own past, everyday objects like cigarettes
- how grand narratives of history and everyday life relate together: where do they overlap?
- filming the museum: museum as a film in itself; captures passing of time
- art as mediator; Bruegel; wide panorama of everyday life
- film as a repository of past experience; makes palimpsestic nature of history apparent (Sochak); history that looks at the remains/detritus of the past
- offering training in the art of looking
- offering reflection of the role of the viewer: children; responses informed by what we see before and after viewing; main device is the figure of Johann always finding new things in the paintings
- offering reflection on how location affects ways of seeing
- critical of the museum as institution as well as celebrating it (cleaner)
- what is worth preserving
|
|
|
- to picture the past is to interpret the past
- to reflect upon picturing the past is to reflect upon how the past is interpreted and constructed
- skills needed to work with objects
- interpretation thinking about the theoretical framework
- translations between word and image
- ethics of working with visual material
- responses of spectators
- location of the past
|
|
Ways of Seeing: John Berger
|
- gap between how an object was originally seen and how we see it now: changes meaning and purpose; reproduction devalues the object; museums detach the object from its original purpose
- reflecting upon how we see the past reveals something about the way in which we live now
- seeing depends upon habit and convention: children look at objects for what they are, not how they have been trained to see them
- meaning is not stable, but changes according to time and location
|
|
|
- idea of history and the dialectical image (images placed together, i.e. in a montage)
- historical field which contained without resolving the contradictions of the image-object
- fossil: visible remains of the past
- fetish
- wish image: dream form of the potential for the dialectic of awakening
- ruins: the rubble of "loosened building blocks...out of which a new order can be constructed"
|
|
|
- historical meaning to be salvaged from urban environment
- comparison of Breugel paintings with litter and street scenes
- 'gleaners'
- ragpickers: historian as ragpicker; emblem of idea of history as material; flea market scenes in film
|
|
|
- Johann offers viewer new insight into looking at the past
- Anne offers Johann a new insight
- visual interpretation of art heavily influenced by history and context
- parallels drawn between paintings and modern world
- not just one perspective on history: multitude of attitudes, contexts and interpretations
|
|
The Insistent Fringe: Vivian Sobchak
|
- "historical discourse takes the form of both saying and showing moving images and written words"
- "historical consciousness is sparked and constituted from both showing and saying"
- cinematic images depicting historical objects are not reductions but are historical
- historical knowledge is a "palimpsest of ways of knowing the past" (multi-layered record)
- past constantly interrupted by present, just like viewing of paintings is interrupted by modern-day Vienna
|
|
Jim Cohen interview: Wandering in Vienna
|
- interaction of Johann and Anne allows Cohen to shift from distanced gaze to more intimate involvement with characters
- magic strength of the outsider: fresh eyes
- Breughel as a passageway into the film
- emotional ties to street art tradition
- "explore how the works on the way;s of the museum are important to people now, not how they've read about it"
- "it troubles me from a distance that people might think about it as elitist work about an elitist institution"
- rewrote script to incorporate earlier Bolex shoots
- "the street should be a free space, belonging to everyone, where anything can happen, where everything isn't controlled"
|
|
The World Viewed: Max Nelson
|
- lots of shots from Cohen's time spent wandering Vienna with a camera
- Breughel paintings have such a prominent place because their world is so disordered and "radically unconcentrated": 'The Conversion of Paul'
- something everyday about art
- contrast between constant motion of Vienna and absolute stillness of paintings
|