Use LEFT and RIGHT arrow keys to navigate between flashcards;
Use UP and DOWN arrow keys to flip the card;
H to show hint;
A reads text to speech;
73 Cards in this Set
- Front
- Back
Free movement of people Entry/Residence Articles? |
45 20 & 21 |
|
Workers |
Article 45 Economically Active |
|
Union Citizens |
Articles 20 & 21 no need to be economically active |
|
Article 45 |
- Free movement of workers shall be secured. - Abolition of discrimination based on nationality re employment - Derogations and specific rights. - Public service exemption |
|
Who is a worker? case |
Hoekstra - EU meaning |
|
Economic activity |
Walrave & Kock |
|
Effective and genuine activities. |
Levin |
|
Having character of gainful employment |
Lawrie-Blum Defines employment relationship as |
|
-Performs services |
-for or under the |
|
direction of another. - in return for |
remuneration |
|
Levin Only effective and |
genuine activities - no |
|
marginal or |
ancillary. |
|
Effective and genuine cases - |
Kempf Steymann Bettray Trojani |
|
Jobseekers Article Case |
45 Royer: includes the right to |
|
enter and reside to |
look for work. also only for |
|
a reasonable period of time - |
Antonissen. |
|
No expulsion Article of directive |
14 (4) (b), Directive 2004/38 No expulsion where |
|
- Evidence that continuing to seek employment - And has a |
genuine chance of being engaged. |
|
Union Citizens Articles |
20&21 (post 1992) contains |
|
- Right to move and reside freely: subject to |
the limitations and conditions in the Treaties and secondary measures. case: |
|
Grzelczyk Destined to be |
the fundamental status of nationals of the Member States. |
|
Directive 2004/38: Entry and Residence Articles for Union Citizens Family Members |
Article 2 (1) - Union citizens. Art. 2 (2) - Family members: include |
|
2(2)(a) - |
Spouse 2(2)(b) - |
|
Registered partner - 2(2)(c) - |
Direct descendants under 21 or dependant. and |
|
2(2)(d) - |
Dependant direct relatives in the ascending line. Also |
|
right of entry - |
Article 5 |
|
right of residence up to 3 months. |
article 6 |
|
Right of residence over 3 months |
Article 7 |
|
Article 5 - Right of Entry 5(1) |
Union Citizens Valid ID or passport; no visa or equivalent. also |
|
Non-EU Family Member - |
5(1) - Valid passport; 5(2) - Only required to have an entry visa in accordance with: |
|
Regulation 539/2001 or |
Where appropriate with national law. |
|
Right of Residence Up to 3 Months |
Union Citizens Article 6(1) Right of residence where: |
|
-Accompanying or joining Union Citizen and |
- in possession of a valid passport. |
|
Right of Residence over 3 Months - |
Union Citizen Article 7(1) a) |
|
worker or self-employed |
b) sufficient resources and sickness insurance c) |
|
Enrolled student d) |
Family member accompanying or joining Union Citizen. |
|
7(2) |
non-EU Family Member Family member accompanying or joining a Union Citizen. |
|
Further rights of residence: a) |
Retention of residence. b) Permanent residence. |
|
a) Retention of residence Union Citizen - Articles |
14(4)(b) Job seekers and |
|
7(3) |
no longer a worker or self-employed (subject to conditions in relevant article) |
|
Family Member cases |
Diatta - separation from spouse. Article: |
|
13 |
divorce or annulment article |
|
12 |
death or departure of Union Citizen (subject to conditions in the relevant article) |
|
b) Permanent Residence Article |
16 (1) |
|
Union Citizen - |
legally resided in host State for continuous period of 5 years. article |
|
16(4) |
right lost through absences for period exceeding two consecutive years. |
|
16(2) |
Non-EU Family Member legally resided in the host with union citizen for continuous period of 5 years. (4) lost through absence of more than 2 consecutive years. |
|
Right of permanent residence can be acquired before 5 years if: |
worker or self-employed: Article |
|
17(1) a) |
reached pension age or has retired, or b) |
|
permanent incapacity to work. or c) |
resident in host Member State but working in another MS. (subject to conditions) Family Member: |
|
also gains. article |
17(3). |
|
Other beneficiaries Directive |
2004/38 article |
|
3(2)(a) |
other family member where - |
|
dependant, or - member of household, or |
- serious health grounds. MS required to facilitate entry and residence only. |
|
Any partner with whom the union citizen has a 'durable relationship'. article |
3(2)(b) MS must facilitate entry and residence only. |
|
Public Service Exemption article |
45(4) [TFEU????] case |
|
Sotgui - EU meaning. defined in |
Commission v Belgium (Public Employees) |
|
exempted - |
local authority posts case |
|
Commission v Belgium Not exempted? - |
Railway posts case |
|
Commission v Belgium also |
Nurses case |
|
Commission v France also |
Trainee - |
|
Teachers case |
Lawrie-Blum |
|
Derogations - Articles Directive |
Article 45(3) TFEU 27 (1) Directive 2004/38 public: |
|
policy, |
security, health |
|
Public Policy & Security Article |
27(2) Directive 2004/38 case: |
|
Van Duyn must be |
based on personal conduct only, |
|
proportionate, |
not past convictions in themselves case |
|
Bouchereau also must represent |
genuine present and sufficiently serious threat. Also, can't be: |
|
to deter others case - |
Bonsignore and: |
|
not arbitrary case - |
Adoni & Cornuaille article |
|
27(1) |
must not serve economic ends. must be okay by |
|
general principles of EU Law. Compatible with Human Rights cases - |
Putili (Rutili?)/Orfanopoulos also article |
|
28 |
additional safeguards. |