Reading...
Play button
Play button
Use LEFT and RIGHT arrow keys to navigate between flashcards;
Use UP and DOWN arrow keys to flip the card;
H to show hint;
A reads text to speech;
15 Cards in this Set
- Front
- Back
|
Dishonesty for accessory liability:
|
Royal Brunei
1. Objective bit: not acting as an honest person would in the circumstances 2. Slight subjective bit: take into account context, experience and intelligence |
|
|
For accessory liability, not necessary for 3rd party to know he was dishonest
|
Royal Brunei
|
|
|
Not necessary for D to know details of breach, just that he is participating in illegal scheme
|
Barlow Clowes
|
|
|
Doubts cast on accessories as constructive trustees: they are merely wrongdoers
|
Paragon Finance
|
|
|
Recipient Liability:
|
1. T/F transferred to 3rd in breach
2. 3rd received for own benefit 3. Requisite degree of knowledge |
|
|
Requisite knowledge
|
- Knew it was in breach; or
- Came to know dealt inconsistently; or - “unconscionable” to retain property (Akindele) |
|
|
“unconscionable” to retain property
|
BCCI v Akindele
|
|
|
Intermeddling definition
|
Mara v Browne
When one who is not a trustee acts as though he were one, or an agent exceeds his authority he will be liable as if he were an express trustee |
|
|
Intermeddling example: agent of trustee continued to collect rent after trustee's death
|
Lyell v Kennedy
|
|
|
Personal common law restitution
|
Lipkin Gorman v Karpnale
- Is C the legal owner? (think companies too) - D unjustly enriched? - No mixing BEFORE D’s receipt - STRICT LIABILITY |
|
|
Defence to restitution: “Change of position by innocent D” Spaffed on a holiday...
|
Lipkin Gorman v Karpnale
|
|
|
For money mixed with D's own funds either (presumed against D):- D spent own money first
|
Re Hallet
|
|
|
D spent own money last
|
Re Oatway
|
|
|
Where property has been mixed into another asset, C can choose to take a charge over it or a proportion equivalent to contribution
|
Foskett v McKeown
|
|
|
If unjust, court will remedy appropriately
|
(Barlow Clowes)(Russell-Cooke)
|
