Polanyi's Dependency Theory

Great Essays
For century’s societies have been fathoming the idea of “the good society” and idealizing theories and individuals for the hope that they bring to the table. All individuals and theories agree with the larger notion of the desire to create a decent life for the larger population however, they often disagree on the approach taken to achieve it. Hayek and Polanyi were both philosophers and economists who became extremely well-known for their foundational thoughts, however the Dependency theory was also very convincing to many. I will argue that Polanyi’s argument is the most convincing due to his consideration of social values, the importance he puts on government interference in the economy and the devastation he predicts will take place if …show more content…
The core is recognized as the powerful, developed countries that dominate the world economy. The semi-periphery includes the countries that have somewhat experienced some type of development but have not gotten to the success level of the core countries. And the periphery envelopes the poor countries that are extremely underdeveloped and largely lacking basic necessities for its citizens. The dependency theory claims that the third world needs to sever ties to the world economy to become self-sufficient. “Baran argued that the First world actually hindered the emergence from poverty of the Third World…Imperialism had not exported capitalism to the Third World; rather, it had drained the colonies of the resources that could have been used for investment.” One would’ve thought that the influence of western countries in the third world countries would’ve been positive and beneficial however it was only beneficial to the imperialist. This idea is further explored in Understanding …show more content…
The nature of the system creates and sustains disparities in the wealth between countries. The dependency theory does have strengths and powerfully acknowledges the repercussions of interactions between countries from different economic backgrounds however it also has many criticisms. The dependency theory doesn’t distinguish at all between peripheral countries, it neglects domestic policies and is very naïve about the possibilities and limits of social transformation. The theory also neglects to mention the positive aspects of interactions between countries, this isn’t a constructive

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Over the past two centuries, Europe’s grasp on the world has strengthened and tightened increasingly, the “Western” influence becoming one that is looming and inevitable. Europe’s pre-eminence emerged almost accidentally, the product of an incidental group of conditions in the world economic system that Europe and America were able to properly exploit. This western influence that they exhibited was one that gleamed of new technologies and modernization, expecting the eastern world to quickly adopt their version of idealistic treasures. In the 19th century, after an extended age of separation, China, Japan and Korea were burdened from the West to open to foreign trade and relations. Because of the Industrial Revolution in Europe and the United…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jared Diamond espouses the view that the “root of inequality” is the geographical location of a country and the resources it possesses. According to Diamond, all societies in the world were equally wealthy at one time in history. Unfortunately, global environmental changes made some parts of the world to experience harsh weather conditions that made traditional hunting and gathering inefficient in providing food for households. Regions that were geographically disadvantaged were unable to access adequate resources and skills for their development. Diamond uses New Guinea, which is a poor country, and the United States, a wealthy nation, for his analysis.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    European Imperialism DBQ

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For example, the spread of democracy was another factor pushing western countries, especially the U.S. to imperialism. For example, Albert Beveridge, U.S. Senator said in 1898, “we ought not to govern a people without their consent.” (Doc 7) This ideas were only a official positive alternative argument instead of exploitation. John Stuart Mill even utilized philosophical saying to justify the imperialism with benefits “to the collective economical interests of the human race.”…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Economic expansion became “both a means and an end” for American foreign policy makers (129). It was seen as a way to broaden markets, and to spread peace through prosperity. However, Williams explains, by expanding a U.S. economic system throughout the world they made it very difficult for other countries to maintain an economy independently (15). U.S. interference altered the power dynamic in other countries, which was usually detrimental to the other nations. Williams notes that other countries were also very well aware of this power imbalance, which furthered the tensions between the U.S. and other political bodies.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    World Economic Theory- Originated by Immanuel Wallerstein, some countries benefit from the economic system of the world and some countries miss out on these benefits. The theory has three levels on hierarchy: core, periphery, and semi-periphery. Core countries are dominant capitalist countries which exploit peripheral countries for labor and…

    • 224 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The wealth and Poverty of nations is a book that covers almost six centuries of long economic analysis of dozen of countries. The book has been written in a progression in economics throughout history. The main idea he believes the Western Nations became such wealthy nations because of political, economic institutions but most important social and culture. David S. Landes explains in the book by asking the big question, “why are some nations wealthily and other some nations poor? He explains Western America is better off the rest of the world.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    F. A. Hayek's Analysis

    • 2135 Words
    • 9 Pages

    To give credence to any argument, an author must impose a feeling of justice for the greater society upon the audience, or else be taken to account for the various pitfalls of their stance. Since we live in society largely based on a market model, the determination of how individuals come in act in systems of production, distribution, and exchange become subject to evaluations of justice. Many an argument is made in a vacuum of idealism where an author fails to realize the entirety of the scope of their given beliefs. Deciding the means in which an entire system of material interdependence is either composed or dispersed is by no means a short order. In trying his best to determine the preeminent arrangement for such a system, F.A. Hayek makes…

    • 2135 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Machiavelli's Summary

    • 2626 Words
    • 11 Pages

    It illustrates his belief that a free market alone is bad for society and the economy as a whole. His belief is that the market needs government intervention and regulation to work properly. The invisible hand, laissez faire economics, is a poor way of running an economy. The way the market naturally functions, Polanyi believes, cannot be what decides an individual 's socioeconomic status, and intervention by the government must be in place for an economy to be fair and successful and not demise and decide the fate of the people. Through the text it is evident that Polanyi believes that unbound market forces are a threat to the well being of people, nature, and the economy and therefore must be regulated in some way by the…

    • 2626 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    European Imperialism

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The history of mankind has always been the history of imperialism in myriad of its forms. In this context it must be said that the history of the modern world, to a large extent, is a history of European/Western expansion, colonization, and its decline. It is noteworthy that the expansionist policies that were implemented by the colonial powers eventually paved the way for the emergence of globalization and the decline of the process of colonialism made it possible for the emergence of capitalism as a new form of economic domination. However, irrespective of the types and forms, the history of the rise and decline of the Western global colonial empire must be known in order to know the history of the modern world thoroughly.…

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The focus in this theory is factors like political and economic links, modes of production, class systems and the elites of that country (Valenzuela and Valenzuela, 1978: 550). This is known as a macrosociological approach. Modernisation uses the national society as an indicator when analysis is done; dependency uses the global system when conducting analysis. The fundamental difference between these two theories is that the proponents of dependency theory consider human behaviour constant when it comes to economic matters. They follow the assumption that the differences in behaviour of the people are due to their situations differing from person to person(Valenzuela and Valenzuela, 1978: 550-551).Modernisation theorists assume human behaviour is relative and their behaviour is directly liked to their beliefs and cultural ideals, structures and economic patterns are not a factor according to the principles of the modernisation theory (Valenzuela and Valenzuela, 1978: 551).…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    World Systems Theory Essay

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Building on top of the Marxist ideas of exploitation and unequal exchanges championed by dependency theorists, Wallerstein argues that the semi-periphery is a crucial link in this system of unequal exchanges - the “intermediaries with the periphery, conveyor-belts of surplus value” (Wallerstein 1974: 241). The semi-periphery does not just act the “core” economically to some peripheral regions, they can exert influences politically and culturally through their limited hegemonic powers in the same fashion as core nations, sometimes to their own national agendas sometimes on behalf of core nations. They also serve as examples of economic development that peripheral nations aspire to become, overlooking the difficulties and challenges that accompanies being in such position. In this way, the power structure in the global economic system is obscured by the semi-periphery - it becomes difficult to see the full pictures, determining where economic and political decisions are stemming from and where surplus value is being transferred to (Wallerstein 1979:…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It was viewed as a western exploitation of their land as these western policies were seen to greatly profit the developed nations and leave the poor nations still undeveloped as argued by Edwardo Galiano in his book The Open Veins of Latin America (Anderson, 10/1). The backlash to the Washington Consensus created proposals of new global models such as the Beijing consensus based on a strong central government role in economics and the Himalayan Consensus that called for an emphasis on local employment and use of local resources (Anderson, 10/6). These different ideas of economic policies based on varying cultures follows Huntington’s theory but also is greatly influenced by a nations level of development and changes their opinion as they…

    • 1926 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Interdependence of an area allows a country to function on their own and have unique things that makes them their own country or region. These things can also allow their people to survive and prosper in the area they live in. Globalization is what allows the world…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The dependency theory was first developed in the late 1950’s under the guidance of the Director of the United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America, Rual Prebisch. He was troubled by the fact that economic growth in more advanced and industrialized countries did not also lead to the growth of much poorer countries. Instead it has been shown that the economic growth of much richer countries has often if not always le to serious economic issues for poor countries. This kind of situation was not predicted be the Neo-classical Theory which believed that “economic growth was beneficial to all even if the benefits were not always equally…

    • 1916 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Marie, Kristina (2014) the dependency south countries have with north countries is bad because south counties are vulnerable to cultural penetration. Cultural penetration is when the foreigners (corporations from the north) introduce their culture and try to replace it instead of the culture of the country. The dependency of the south countries also causes dualism. Dualism according to Marie, Kristina (2014) is the existence of two separate economic and social sectors operating side by side. This means that the country is divided in two because of the corporations of the north.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays