Roman Revival Vs Gothic Revival Analysis

Improved Essays
Architecture does not come out of nowhere. Architects always absorb knowledge from a certain typology that they favor in the past, digest the knowledge and apply them to their own design. It is significant that architects carry classical ideas throughout generations in order to project designs in their ages powerfully, and leave heritage for next generation. During 18th and 19th century, several classical revivals occurred in America. Due to the increasing demands of housing and the eagerness of finding the identity of American architecture, domestic architecture emerged from “non-designed” to professionally designed work. Two major ones were Roman Revival verses Gothic Revival. Led by Thomas Jefferson (Figure 1) and his own estate Monticello, …show more content…
With enormous sources about architecture came from Europe to America, “architects” learned and applied them differently. Some were called “the untutored folk builders” who only followed the builders’ handbook repeating traditions. Some “master builders” , on the contrary, ditched the traditions completely to build out without foundation knowledge. Neither of them were as successful as “the gentleman amateurs” , who learned from classical styles, and applied them in ways that best fit the local context of the time. Thomas Jefferson successfully learned from elaborate drawings of Pantheon by Andrea Palladio, invented his own Pantheon- Monticello- in Charlottesville, Virginia, which in 1987 with the nearby University of Virginia, also designed by Jefferson, were together designated a UNESCO World Heritage Site. His success required not only his devotion of architecture, but his understanding of culture identities behind the architecture and architects that he learned from. He preferred Roman culture that, in his opinion, could project an American democracy that the new country should head for. Among many talented minds, he was the one who first imagined an identity of American …show more content…
In his The Four Books on Architecture, he stated his will to build “well and gracefully” . He found himself deeply attracted to Vitruvius’s perfect geometry and proportion. “…finding myself moved and inflamed by my profound studies of Virtu of this type and having, with the highest hopes, applied all my powers of thought to it, I also set myself the task of writing about the essential principles that must be followed by all intelligent men eager to build well and gracefully, and beyond that to illustrate through drawings many of those buildings that I have seen up till now.” This also explained his inclination to pass on his perspective of perfect architecture to architects later on by writing The Four Books on Architecture. His Book I was on preparations, foundations, materials, and the description of the orders of architecture. Then he discussed complete dwellings, starting with the Greeks and Roman private house, and illustrating how his own designs adapted such precedents in his Book II. Book III was about public works, also balanced between ancient examples and his own work, while Book IV focused on ancient sacred architecture, such as the temples of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Louis Sullivan Introduction Among the first great modern architect, Louis Sullivan was the first to introduce a powerful vocabulary at early age. He was the most imaginative and articulate figure among a small group of creative men in Europe and America. Initially, many architecture were known to use traditional forms of medieval heritage and classical but Sullivan struck out in a new direction. He managed to develop an introductory terms of his organic theory of building art.…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Monticello by Thomas Jefferson and the Pantheon appear to have similar features but are quite different overall. The Pantheon was build between A.D 118 to 125 and its style is ancient Roman. Monticello on the other hand was build a long time after in 1772 and its style is neoclassical. Monticello is a revival of ancient roman architecture which why they have many similar features. The time differences between the two buildings can be clearly seen since the Pantheon has a rusty worn out appearance, whereas Monticello still has a clean fresh appearance.…

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Alexander Jackson Davis During the mid nineteenth century America, American renowned architect, Alexander Jackson Davis, began a new revival of architecture known as Gothic Revival. Gothic Revival is a style of architecture that used traditional styles of thirteenth century Gothic architecture such as; ornamented facades, high pitched roofs, and pointed arches to revive medieval architecture and applied to a modern time. Alexander Jackson Davis was one of the most successful and influential American architects in nineteenth century America, known for his picturesque Gothic Revival architecture. Early Life…

    • 1866 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas Jefferson’s numerous accomplishments had profound effects on the history of the United States. Most of his actions positively affected the course of the nation, while some had a negative impact. His influence at a crucial historical time helped start the country towards where it is today. One of Jefferson’s most important contributions was his authorship of the Declaration of Independence. By outlining John Locke’s Theory of Natural Rights and logically laying out the case against King George for violating them, he provided the international community with a justification for the Revolution.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello begins with the architecture of Monticello, Thomas Jefferson's mountaintop home in Charlottesville, Virginia. The book describes the story of Monticello architecture, an inside look at the house, the furnishings, the gardens and the plantation. The authors of this book are William L. Beiswanger, Peter J. Hatch, Lucia C. Stanton, Susan R. Stein. These four members are part of Monticello’s Scholarly staff.…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Thomas Jefferson house has a lot of classical features that are described in the architecture of the building. If we first look at the middle of the building, we see a triangle right above the columns. Right in between the triangle and the columns is a large slab known as the abacus which is to support the architrave that is right about it. The triangle that is above of the columns is known as the frieze. The frieze is the widest and central part of a piece and is often richly decorated with relief sculpture.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the emergence of the Renaissance in Italy, the wealthy elite wanted to associate themselves with the intellectuals, politicians, and rules of Ancient civilizations of Greece and Rome. As such, the Gothic architecture style began to fall out of fashion. Gothic was difficult to describe, instruct, and obtain. It was associated with the divine realm. At a time when the importance of man and humanity flourished, the population preferred structures that reminded them of the great men of the past, and thus connected them to this history.…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Changes of Architecture Architecture is not only a form of shelter but of culture. It is also a practice of expression and art. During the 1880s United States architecture was customary to be built of the current style and theme. Today’s architecture is more constructed of what is individual and authentic. Architecture today unlike 1880s is to be more unique and professional.…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    President Thomas Jefferson was the chief driving force behind the newly created United States embracing Neoclassism as its architectural style. Serving a symbolic function, Jefferson believed that America must cast off the old English architectural style and embrace the style of the old Greek and Roman Republics. Jefferson constructed his own estate at Monticello in Virginia and the Virginia State Capitol building using classical revivalism, yet added many details that were commonly found in France at the time. President Jefferson drew his inspiration for neoclassical design directly from 16th-century Italian architect Andrea Palladio. With Jefferson shunning both the traditional English blueprints of building government and country houses,…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    with a proper architecture. He realized that that the legacy of all great kingdoms was exemplified over their architectural memorials. Jefferson committed hunt for this ideal led him to journey the south of France to study the antique Roman remnants. Of particular was the ruin of the Maison Carree at Nimes which he defines as the greatest attractive and valuable piece of architecture left to us by ancient times. This ruin influenced his plan for the government center of Virginia.…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Thomas Jefferson Influence

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As Americans, we know that Thomas Jefferson was a founding father and was the United States third president. Although do we honestly know who Thomas Jefferson was as an individual, before and after the presidency? Thomas Jefferson was more than a president and was important in aspects of our government, American architecture, and the American educational system. He was a historical Politian, He designed and founded the University of Virginia, believed in equality in schooling (public school system), and believed to sustain the United States government idea education was the key. He would go on to impact our education system with many ideas from the enlightenment period.…

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Roman architecture has long been a defining model for some of the greatest works during Renaissance and Neoclassical revival eras. The Pantheon, Maison Carrée, and other such temples and buildings of the late BCE-early CE period have their clear influence on works like Jefferson’s Virginia State Capitol. However, not all Ancient Roman designs saw their full potential of influence on future works, leaving only the ancient architecture as just a ruin to be preserved through the ages. One such work, the Flavian Amphitheater, or Roman Colosseum as it is more commonly known, can be considered the greatest amphitheater ever designed. Not only based on its size, but also the intricacy of its hypogeum and importance in Roman culture support this,…

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Frank Lloyd Wright Essay

    • 1973 Words
    • 8 Pages

    First let’s begin with great Roman architecture that was constructed in 70-80 AD----the Colosseum. (Image 1). This building have strong influence on us today, such building structure had been used as model for many sport stadium. It is significant in Architecture not only because it is the first building in history where concrete was used for construction, but also the thoughtful detail choice that the architect made. As shown in the image 2 and 3, the building had divided into different section and level to maximize its utility, and serve better function.…

    • 1973 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Vitruvius Research Paper

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages

    According to Vitruvius, beauty in architecture is derived from proportion and order in relation to a building’s function and appearance. Mississippi State’s Chapel of Memories is a shining example of form and function, serving as an important part of campus history and a beautiful landmark that can be seen from almost anywhere. The first and most important of Vitruvius’ three principles of architecture is function; without it, a building is a statue, rather than real architecture. Not only is the Chapel of Memories a place for worship, fellowship, and reflection, it is also often used as a wedding venue for alumni and students alike. Because of the Chapel’s tall bell tower, it is also used by new students and visitors as a way of navigating.…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pantheon Symbols

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Religion and the divine play large roles in many of the most influential Empires of the ancient world, including Rome. The Pantheon demonstrates this through its structure, history, and most importantly, function. The Pantheon is a prominent symbol of the Roman Empire in its advanced structural design shown through its incredible unsupported dome, rich elements of history such as being consecrated into a church to save the structure, and the Roman people’s manic devotion to religion. Located in Rome, Italy, the Pantheon was built by Marcus Agrippa and designed by Apollodorus of Damascus in 125 AD. The Pantheon has always had a rich connection to the divine as it was formerly a Roman temple dedicated to gods of pagan Rome and currently stands…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays