Beef Eating As The Root Cause Of Untouchability

Improved Essays
Part II
Dalit History with reference to Beef

In the article “beef eating as the root cause of untouchability” Dr. B. R. Ambedkar has explained and linked beef eating practices with Untouchability in Indian society. He gave an account of Census Commissioner of 1910 who have issued a circular to divide the population of India into various categories. In that circular he have mentioned 10 test to differentiate Hindu and non Hindus on the basis of their lifestyle practices. In that test the 10 test is stated “Eat beef and do no reverence to the cow”
The Census reports show that the beef forms the chief item of food consumed by communities that are usually classified as untouchable communities. No Hindu community,
…show more content…
The co-relation between untouchability and additionally the utilization of the dead cow is so nice therefore shut that the thesis that it is the foundation of untouchability seems to be incontrovertible. Within the second place if there is one thing that separates the Untouchables from the Hindus, it's beef-eating. Even a superficial read of the food taboos of the Hindus will show that there is a pair of taboos regarding food that that operate as dividing lines. There is one taboo against meat-eating. Due to this Hindus are divided into two types which are vegetarians and flesh eaters. There is another taboo that's against beef intake. It divides Hindus into those who eat cow's flesh and other people who do not. From the aim of view of untouchability the first distinction is not so important as compared to the second. For it absolutely marks off the tangible from the Untouchables. The tangible whether or not they are vegetarians or flesh-eaters are united in their objection to eat cow's flesh. As against them stand the Untouchables who eat cow's flesh whereas not regret and as a matter finally and habit
The Untouchables have the feeling of the accusation has levelled against them by the Hindus for consumption of beef. Rather than discarding the habit, the Untouchables
…show more content…
However this case is exception. For in this case, Veda Vyas does justify the reason for untouchability. The clause "as well as others who eat cow's flesh" is extremely vital. It shows that the Smritikars knew that the origin of untouchability is to be found within the consumption of beef. The dictum of Veda Vyas should shut the argument. It comes, so to say, straight from the horse's mouth and what's vital is that it's conjointly rational for it accords with facts as we all know

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The way Arundhati writes is very sophisticated and descriptive. She use a lot of large vocabulary. Some of the words she uses I had to goole to be able to understand what she was trying to say. For example the first sentence in the book she says “May in Ayemenem is a hot, brooding month. ” I had no idea what brooding month until I looked it up and found that is meant showing deep unhappiness.…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the essay written by Catherine Pigott, Chicken-Hips it is quite evident that the processes of acculturation of an american raised had taken place through external pressure and discomfort. Infact, the process had taken such a toll on the author as she describes the returning experience as stressful, and as though the sudden change in external values caused a great deal of distress. As it would be for one whom modified and adjusted to a social norm so utterly different from that of which you would otherwise be accustomed. Comparatively, Catherine Pigott’s story is about a girl whom had been raised in a society where meat on women is seen as a flawed, and people would go through strenuous activities in order to reduce or rid themselves of any…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people don't understand why there are so many Indians going hungry when they have an abundance of cows. Marvin Harris was trying to help people understand the reason behind why cows are considered sacred to the Hindu in India. In the article Harris explains why many Indians that worship Hinduism don't consume cow meat (Harris 1). People from western societies consider this tradition taboo, but they are failing to realize that life can be used for reasons other than food. In the article Harris explain the valuable role that the cow plays the Hindu society.…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Religious Symbols are visual pieces of art or iconic presentation, used to represent a specific religion. A taboo is an act that is prohibited by the mainstream mostly based upon lack of social acceptance. This may due to its profound nature and how people analyze and interpret it morally. When looking at the Mescalero Apache, the base metaphor Farrer states ,that it represents the daily movement of the sun east to west and its annual movement south to north. “Balance and harmony are expressed in circularity” (Farrer 29).…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cultured meat was created not only to provide health products with the necessary nutrients to consumers but it also to stop the miss ethical abuse and suffering of any living species. The purpose is to change the way of producing meat in order to save the live of many animals such as pork, chicken, cows that are being constantly abuse and used as cattle. Most of these animals have spent their lives being hit, maltreated, suffering enormous pain in crated, boxed and force-fed grain and living in such horrendous, inhumane conditions until the time of being slaughter and even until that moment these animals suffer since they are killed in the easiest and brutal way. On the documentary Food Inc, they gave an example of the changes that the industry…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The pleasure people receive from eating meat is far outweighed…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Globalization has changed the face of the world as we know it; not simply technologically or economically, but socially and politically. Contact with people around the world has brought new clothing, languages, and people across the globe. Along with these people come new cultures and norms; one of the most important of these being food. Food plays such a large part in a person’s identity and how other people perceive them. While slurping and burping during a meal shows signs of enjoyment for one culture, it is taken as signs of disrespect in others.…

    • 1989 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the 2014 British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) article, “Ethics Guide: Eating Animals,” it examines three different ethical perspectives – the rights argument, the consequential (utilitarian) argument, and the virtue argument – against the rearing and killing of animals for human consumption in layman’s terms primarily for the average contemporary reader in Anglo-American societies (such as Canada, the United States and the United Kingdom). Furthermore, the BBC, a leading worldwide media corporation, contends that the process of rearing, killing and eating animals is “morally wrong” or unjustifiable because these acts disregard the rights of the animal to live by its own interests. Its aim is to inform the reader of these perspectives so…

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Eating animals has been a regular meal for humans for many centuries, but it has also been opposed by veganists for many years. Although consuming animals has been opposed by vegan aficionados, it has also been a source of controversy because of how factory farming produces the meat we eat in our daily meals. In the book “Eating Animals” we get the sense that the author will be arguing and encouraging veganism, but instead he argues about how the meat we consume is produced. The author Jonathan Safran Foer’s main claim in the book is about boycotting animal factory farming and encouraging traditional husbandry because factory farm animals are stuffed with antibiotics, mutilated, tightly confined, and deprived of stimulation. While traditional…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Food allows a culture to express and share their creativity and history. Its nature as a commodity has brought others together in celebration and driven them to war at its worst. Due to a culture’s passion for their own food, it can become a highly debated and even violent topic to discuss in a critical manner. This issue…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Balram compares himself to a Buddha because he “has woken up while the rest of you are sleeping” (270-271). When the British left India in 1947, and everyone was freed from their “cage” (54), however, the “chicken coop” soon developed as society placed constraints on one’s actions. However, Balram, as the white tiger, becomes enlightened like the Buddha when he realized the existence and the possibility of escape from his current chicken coop, albeit with some sacrifices which did not outweigh the outcomes. After the British left, the caste system was replaced by two castes which determined one’s fate: “Men with Big Bellies, and Men with Small Bellies” (54).…

    • 1520 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Nations and countries are frequently associated with certain types of foods. For instance, many people associate Italy with pizzas and pastas. Yet Italians not only eat those few dishes but eat many other various types of foods, and types of pasta dishes are prepared differently in Italy. Many families in the United States prefer to eat "meat with potatoes," however "meat with potatoes" are not eaten on a regular basis, nor even a preferred choice, by many others living in the United States.…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Race and Religion have emerged in the society since the last 1500 years and has divided our society ever since. Various revolutions and movements have taken place against these problems but they still exist somewhere or the other and while they exist they have given a rise to harsh movements. In The Kite Runner, religion and racial segregation was playing a major part. Pashtuns or Sunnis were the superior, dominant class while Shi’as were the ones being dominated.…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I have always believed that eating meat can be okay, until i realized the bad consequences. I agree that eating meat is ethical, if is peppered properly because my experience becoming a vegetarian, and knowing the raising process confirms it. “Is there an ethical distinction between the deaths caused by a yeoman farmer who grimly butchers a hog in the fall and a minimum-wage factory worker who mechanically butchers six thousand in a morning?” (Schwennesen 179).…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article India’s Sacred Cow the author, Marvin Harris, attempts to explain the rationale behind the Indian culture’s admiration and worship of the cow, a practice which is often questioned by Westerners. He is able to illustrate that keeping cows alive is actually vital to the survival of many Indians and given their economic climate, is actually the most sustainable use of their resources. Harris brings up a number of factors that would indicate that defining the cow as sacred is a necessity for human survival in India. Cows serve many purposes to Indian farmers while they are alive and these benefits are what make cow slaughtering a highly restricted process in India. As simple as it might sound, according to Harris one of the best…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays