Essay on Utopia, by Thomas More and Communist Manifesto, by Karl Marx

1939 Words 8 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
George Gilliam Marx/More Comparative Essay English 215 In both Thomas More’s Utopia and Karl Marx’s Communist Manifesto, we see the authors portray two different visions of an improved reality in which all citizens are on an equal plane with one another. Both works stem from the authors’ own grievances regarding the ‘status quo’, and seek to provoke serious thought and (in Marx’s case) action about the existing state of affairs in their respective times. The context of both of these works is

middle of document…

First, Hythloday explains that maintaining a standing army merely allows for a population of soldiers who could potentially become very good thieves. He also explains that the peasants in Europe are greatly exploited by the nobles, and are left with almost no other options for survival other than “banditry”. Essentially, Hythloday proclaims that the European society “manufactures thieves and then blames them for being thieves.” Hythloday then goes on to explain that there can be no ‘ideal world’ without the abolishment of public property – communal property must be established. Hythloday argues that private property alone is the cause for a large majority of people who are dissatisfied. He also brings up Plato, who in The Republic proclaims that communal property is the foundation for the ultimate city. More, in the story of Utopia, responds negatively to Hythloday’s call for common property – I should note, however, that More’s character in the story shares very different opinions than Sir Thomas More himself. Hythloday continues to explain Utopian society in detail. Everything in Utopia is strikingly analogous. All of the cities in this land are almost indistinguishable from one another. The layouts, customs, architecture and populations of these cities are essentially identical. Hythloday also describes the agricultural system of Utopia – almost every single being in Utopia puts in some sort of time on the farm.
CRAM Exclusive
May84447Dog

Related Documents

  • Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx Essay

    taking on a life of its own. Individual craftsmen were tossed aside in exchange for the manufacturers, to maintain supply for the demand. The chain reaction of larger supply meant lower prices. The prices became affordable, and the people spent more, and in doing so, the demand for production rose. Subsequently, steam and machinery transformed manufacturing. Inevitably, the manufacture of goods gave way to the creation of entire industries. For the owners of the businesses within these industries

    Words: 751 - Pages: 4
  • Private and Corporate Vocations in Utopia by Thomas More Essay

    and creation. Keeping in touch with nature is a way of connecting to God. Not only then, but today too. Farming was the main vocation in Utopia. The people farmed to produce food so that they can eat. With this vocation came prayer because as said earlier it was a way to connect with God and creation. Farming was a private vocation. Everybody in Utopia shared his or her wealth and physical labor. To go along with this, they also balanced work with prayer. Into that calculation, you can fit

    Words: 679 - Pages: 3
  • Essay on Karl Marx

    year, he studied Hegel’s ideas and viewed history as a human and labor struggle (Ball, Dagger, O’Neill 144). While editing in Paris, he became a revolutionary communist and a long term collaborator of Friedrich Engels. They shared a philosophical and political partnership, but were later expelled from France and moved to Brussels where Marx dedicated his study of history and elaborated on his materialistic conception of history. In Brussels, he also developed a basic thesis that stated “the nature

    Words: 1855 - Pages: 8
  • Biography of Karl Marx Essay

    Even in college, Karl and his father maintained a very close relationship. This relationship can be seen through this letter written by Marx’s father in November of 1835: I wish to see you in you what I might have become, had I first seen the light of day under move favorable auspices…it may be unjust and ill-advised as well to put one’s greatest hopes in a single person and thus perhaps undermine one’s own equanimity.6 However, Marx took up drinking and found himself

    Words: 1086 - Pages: 5
  • Karl Marx Essay

    Once the Revolution of February 1848 took place, Marx was again banished, except this time from Belgium. He returned to France for the March Revolution, and then traveled to Germany where he published the Neue Rheinische Zeitung, from June 1, 1848 to May 19, 1849. Again Marx was banished from Germany, and again he returned to Paris. After the demonstration of June 13 1849, Karl Marx, was banished once again. That would be the last time Karl Marx was banished anywhere. His last trip would take him

    Words: 1209 - Pages: 5
  • Karl Marx Essay

    Russia, one built on the ideas of Marx, where everyone was equal, where all property was owned by 'the people' rather than by capitalists and where the two were in control of the government. Not long afterward, Communist Russia was attacked by Britain, America and France, who wanted to get rid of the communist government. They were afraid the workers in their own countries might be inspired to imitate the example of Rus Trotsky, a highly intelligent and energetic communist leader, led the defence Russia

    Words: 973 - Pages: 4
  • Essay on Karl Marx

    Marx’s opinion. According to Marx after this violent revolution people would come together and help one another. People would be valued on the basis of how much they could produce. In other words, Who ever produced the most would be highly revered amongst all the other communists, and then this highly revered person would then keep only what he needed from what he produced and give the rest to those who needed it most. Everything would be wonderful in communist society. People would do what

    Words: 943 - Pages: 4
  • Karl Marx Essay

    sort of a division subsisted till the French revolution when the rights of the third order were claimed. With the rise of the mercantile class in Europe, the fourth class too emerged which was immensely wealthy. Thus class distinction in Europe was more fluid and often depended on the economic status of individuals. It was hence possible for an individual to move up and down the ladder as they profited or incurred losses. The Bicycle Thief ( Ladri di Biciclette ) by Vittorio de Sica raises pertinent

    Words: 907 - Pages: 4
  • Karl Marx and His Ideas Essay

    Ideology, which was not published until 1932. They then joined a communistic society called the League of Communists. When the society met in London in 1847, Marx and Engels were both present. There they wrote the Communist Manifesto. Engels wrote a first draft which was rewritten by Marx. Soon after its publication, the February Revolution of 1848 broke out in France. Marx and Engels visited France while on their way to Cologne to help the revolution there. They then founded

    Words: 1210 - Pages: 5
  • Essay about Karl Marx and Frederick Engels

    The society defined by Marx and Engel in the Communist Manifesto and the U.S. society overlap in many of their ideas. Marx begins the Manifesto by declaring the proletariats responsibility to overthrow the current government.[v] Similarly, the U.S. declares that it “is the right of the people to alter or abolish” any government that is abusing its power.[vi] This similar responsibility of the people to see that their rights are not being abused and that if the government is abusing their power

    Words: 1630 - Pages: 7