This means that even though the Caroline Doctrine states that anticipatory self-defense is ineffective due the Article 51 because it narrows the focus of self-defense, which makes the United States’ attack against Iraq unlawful. On the other hand, counter-restrictionists like the United States and the United Kingdom believes that in fact the customary right of anticipatory self-defense is in fact covered under the Charter (Pierson, 157). The United States believes that the attack was imminent and therefore the use of force could be used. However, the restrictionists believe that there was no imminent threat and the United States was wrong to use force and attack Iraq (Pierson, 164). The “burden of self-defense… falls largely on each individual state with anticipatory self-defense as an indispensable tool for national survival (Pierson, 170).” The United States and the United Kingdom were right to use anticipatory self-defense because it is a crucial tool of each state to ensure peace and security not only for the countries involved but also for the citizens of
This means that even though the Caroline Doctrine states that anticipatory self-defense is ineffective due the Article 51 because it narrows the focus of self-defense, which makes the United States’ attack against Iraq unlawful. On the other hand, counter-restrictionists like the United States and the United Kingdom believes that in fact the customary right of anticipatory self-defense is in fact covered under the Charter (Pierson, 157). The United States believes that the attack was imminent and therefore the use of force could be used. However, the restrictionists believe that there was no imminent threat and the United States was wrong to use force and attack Iraq (Pierson, 164). The “burden of self-defense… falls largely on each individual state with anticipatory self-defense as an indispensable tool for national survival (Pierson, 170).” The United States and the United Kingdom were right to use anticipatory self-defense because it is a crucial tool of each state to ensure peace and security not only for the countries involved but also for the citizens of