The Pros And Cons Of Shark Baiting

Improved Essays
When people think of sharks, many think of a vicious killing monster that needs to be avoided at all costs, and this creates an irrational fear that enters the minds of the general populace. In an attempt to educate the public about this growing threat to sharks, a threatened species, the practice of cage-diving has started to become more popular. The mentality that sharks are evil beings has been spread far and wide through many mediums such as way of mouth, movies, and viral pictures/videos, such as the viral photo of the Great White Shark that sparked a debate, as explained by National Geographic. This picture showed a great white shark, which appeared to be lunging at a shark cage, and this stirred up a debate about whether or not cage-diving …show more content…
However, this current negative view of sharks must change to show what sharks really are, an apex predator of marine life and not human life, and this re-education of the public is the goal of shark baiting/cage diving. People need to change their attitude towards sharks because they are a vital part of ocean ecosystems as a top predator, and just mindlessly killing them is not smart or moral. Carl Safina, an ocean expert and author of many books about the ocean, has written Song for the Blue Ocean, in which he advocates for a “sea ethic.” This sea ethic is an idea that humans must respect the ocean and its inhabitants in every respect, much as we respect land animals. What cage diving and shark baiting does to help promote the sea ethic is that it helps people get close to ferocious sharks and to learn how sharks act. Once the people have been educated about sharks and learn to respect them through the first hand experience that cage diving provides, people will start to shed their misconceptions and care more about what happens to …show more content…
This would cause the sharks to be “more aggressive or start to approach fishers, looking for a meal.” and that means that human aggression towards sharks would also increase. In other words, would baiting sharks, a threatened species, be ethically wrong in light of the sea ethic? However, according to Dr Michael Scholl, “a world-famous marine biologist and conservationist”, there are many reasons why shark baiting is not conditioning sharks to go after humans. Included in these reasons is that sharks do not see the humans in the cage as a single object. Rather, the sharks see everything before them as all lumped into one big object. Another reason is that the sharks never actually catch a direct scent from the humans because the very strong smell of the bait masks the humans, thereby making the scent of humans invisible to sharks. To oppose the sayings of Dr.Scholl has been “very little data to support [that cage-diving conditions sharks to go after humans]...so Skomal says that has left the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Sharks have no bones and that ’s one of the reasons that sharks have so many rows of teeth. They have no jawbone so when they try to chomp fish the many teeth help them. Their teeth also have no roots which is another…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sharkwater Rhetorical Analysis Sharkwater is a 2006 documentary created by Rob Stewart, a young biologist and underwater photographer. Being passionate about the ocean and those who inhabit it, Stewart created his documentary with the intention of destroying the bad reputation that society and the media has put on sharks. Stewart also highlights in his documentary how humans have cruelly made sharks the prey and the enemy for decades. Ethos, pathos, and logos played a very important role in Sharkwater, and was strategically used throughout the documentary in order to persuade the audience that sharks aren’t the enemy, and shouldn’t be treated as such. Pathos, the appeal to one’s emotions, was heavily relied on throughout the documentary in…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Gabriela Cowperthwaite’s film, Blackfish (2013), Cowperthwaite captures the psychological torture killer whales, specifically Tilikum and Kasatka, face at Sea World after being brutally separated from their families. The film takes us through the journey of captured killer whales becoming mentally unstable and being used for entertainment purposes. This film displays archival footage and interviews with former trainers who had close experiences with killer whales at Sea World. The attacks at Sea World stem from the whales’ separation from their families, the trainer’s demand for the whales to do tricks in solitary confinement, and the punishment done to the whales when their tricks are not properly executed. All major accounts of killer whale attacks on trainers develop through the distress of the whales outside of their natural habitat.…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The plan was to release several bull sharks in order to lower the amount of carp. Bull sharks are the only sharks that are able to readily adjust to freshwater. They are usually found in warm, coastal waters - perfect in the summer. The scientist’s initial hope was that the harsh Canadian winter would eliminate the bull sharks from forming a colony in the Great Lakes.…

    • 293 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The premier of Western Australia, Colin Barnett, had announced the shark culling policy in 2014 in response to the shark attack fatalities. The shark culling policy authorizes sharks larger than three metres, such as: the great white, bull and tiger sharks to be slaughtered. Sharks smaller than three metres would be liberated offshore. I highly believe that sharks shouldn’t be culled no matter what size they are. We are in the sharks’ habitation and there are other procedures to prevent shark attacks.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Blackfish Analysis

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages

    SeaWorld is a multi-million dollar corporation that serves as home for 23 of arguably some of the oceans’ most beautiful creatures. Blackfish is trying to change that with a very captivating argument. Although emotionally compelling, Blackfish is an invalid argument against captivity, It offers a solution and demonstrates practicality, which makes it an argument of policy. However, it is not a valid one, for it lacks a strong and reliable foundation of evidence to support its reasoning for the solution it demands. Blackfish presents former trainers and scientific representatives who present facts about SeaWorld, as well as scientific claims that object to captivity.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    agrees with Barry D. Bruce when it states that despite the research results there was still not enough data to know for sure if shark cage diving would negatively impact shark populations(2873). Charlie Huveneers at the end of the article writes that from what has been observed there is a possibility that shark cage diving could reduce the over all health and fitness of the shark population at Neptune Islands and recommends for more research to be done(2873). Based on the information from both these articles it is clear that indeed more research must be done. As stated by Charlie Huveneers there is a real possibility that shark cage diving might have a negative effect on shark populations.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An article counteracting the renowned film, Blackfish, a documentary about the inhumane treatment and situation of orcas in captivity, was released by Seaworld Cares. Seaworld Cares is a foundation for animals supported by Seaworld. The article was the company’s retort against the film’s “ultimately false and misleading points”. The main purpose of the article is to persuade the reader, while providing some information to support their points. They wish to urge the reader to believe that not everything in the film, Blackfish, was true nor trustworthy.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Humanity has lost many beloved celebrities in the past year. David Bowie…Prince…Carrie Fisher… and, of course, Tilikum, the killer whale who stared in Blackfish. The thirty-five-year-old SeaWorld Orlando “employee” mysteriously died on January 6. Naturally, the death has sparked debate, as Blackfish portrayed the whale as a misunderstood and mistreated prisoner who murdered three people out of anger towards his captors. However, the sensationalist media has made a tragedy out of something inevitable.…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analysis Of Sharkwater

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Our understanding of sharks is mediatized and completely inaccurate. Not even twenty minutes into the film and you can see sharks for the beautiful creatures they really are, so graceful and shy. This…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thought to be from rummaging around in people’s garbage. At least great sharks spit out people, most of the…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The documentary Blackfish brings to the public attention the aggressive behaviors displayed by killer whales in captivity. In particular, they focus on an orca by the name of Tilikum held in captivity, by Sealand and later SeaWorld, for close to three decades. Tilikum has caused the death of three people, during his time in captivity--- the most recent being that of Dawn Brancheau, an expert trainer for SeaWorld Orlando. Dawn’s death has sparked increased controversy for the popular entertainment park, most of it revolves around the conditions that the orcas live in.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Orcas’ Behind Closed Tanks Imagine you are a four to eight year old child and you are on vacation with your family entering into a SeaWorld. The excitement has been building up from the commercials that show you these huge and majestic animals that are not like the everyday animal you see on a daily basis. The commercials have a way of taking your imagination to another level, and any child even an adult is at awe with the level of performance these orcas’ are putting on. Amongst the magic, laughter, and adrenaline that you feel you don’t question whether or not these wild animals should be contained like they are.…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why Do Sharks Hunt?

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages

    How Sharks Hunt Long viewed as dimwitted, bloodthirsty monsters, sharks are among the most intelligent species of fish. In fact, sharks have shown to be very versatile and efficient in their hunting methods. Sharks use a variety of hunting methods to capture their prey: adaptation, use of the senses, and strenuous power. Shark Adaptation. Adaptation for a shark is crucial for its hunting and more so for its survival.…

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fishermen harmfully reap the fins of sharks for money. This cruelty is only for one meal called shark fin soup. It is an old asian delicacy that is still around today. If shark finning continues and sharks are led to extinction, the ocean would not operate correctly causing the ecosystem to be put off balance. Shark finning is banned in some countries and it has improved their surrounding areas.…

    • 2517 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Improved Essays