The Pursuit Of Knowledge Roger Scruton Analysis

Improved Essays
Kate Martin
English 111_00
10/27/14
WP1: Summary and Response

The core reading I chose to summarize and respond to is “The Pursuit of Knowledge: The Idea of a University” by Roger Scruton. This article discusses John Henry Newman’s original idea of a university, how it has changed, and the author’s future expectations of scholarly life. Scruton opens the article with a brief background of John Henry Newman, including his conversion into Catholicism in 1845 and his status as rector of the Catholic University of Ireland. Over his five years of being the head of the university, he gave a series of seminars now known as “The Idea of a University.” From reading the text, the reader gains a clear understanding of Newman’s initial vision of the
…show more content…
This is not to say that all incoming students are only worried about what party they are going to attend upon arrival. It is just one of the many examples that support the new idea Scruton suggests has become of the university experience. He does a wonderful job of portraying the possible experiences through hypothetical scenarios that every reader can relate to. First, a situation in which the middle class father of an independent feminist daughter would inherently focuses on the positive aspects of sending his little girl to college only to be disappointed by the seemingly inconclusive result of such a high cost. The author then humors the opposite scenario in which the young student “against all odds” (2010) manages to stay focused, study, surround herself with a successful environment of people and behaviors, and resist the many temptations that infest campus life. In the latter instance, the experience of university would be well worth the funds invested; however, the first scenario does raise the question of how valuable a sound education is. In my opinion it would obviously depend on the individual, their motivation, and their ability to focus on intellectual

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The value of higher education, in today's society, is almost exclusively judged by the prospect of attaining a job upon graduation. This evaluation, however, is not unbiased, as it does not account for skills, connections, and other benefits that are obtained through higher education. Exemplifying that a college experience is not purely vocational training and cannot be quantified solely on such a restricting basis. "My View: Should Everyone Go to College?" by Mike Rose–a professor at UCLA–focuses on this notion with a focus on his personal college experience (CNN 2012). He draws the audience in with the idea that anyone should have the opportunity, and can benefit from the experience, of a higher education.…

    • 1227 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    For the majority of college students, their social life is one of two situations, either a blooming social life or in most cases of being busy constantly, a significant loss of friendship or family life. Being involved as a student is so important as its been a tradition in colleges across the world for decades to be involved in something. Be it a special club or a wonderful tumultuous relationship. However, being stuck in an endless loop of trials to receive a piece of paper saying that you are allowed to be paid more than someone without that modest piece of paper. That’s all high and mighty until you look at where you are at the end after obtaining a paper of the highest degree of…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Several times throughout the article, Murray uses emotionally-charged words and phrases that create a sympathetic image; he notes that “We will lure large numbers of people...to try to achieve the goal and then fail. We will then stigmatize everyone who fails” (253). The image he evokes of the challenges and loss of self-confidence of not being able to succeed in college effectively establishes his argument that college is not for everyone. His goal is to make the reader feel sympathy for students who lack the skill to succeed and consider the possibility that perhaps too many people are going to college. Adding to this idea are words and phrases such as, “less fun” (239), “dispassionately” (240), “masochism” (240), “brutal” (245), “unlikely to have a job” (249), and “fail to achieve” (253).…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Compare and Contrast the views of Higher Education From a general point of view, higher education can be beneficial to some college students. As I compare and contrast the article, “Should Everyone Go To College” to Freeman A. Hrabowski’s “Colleges Prepare People for Life”, I realized Hrabowski’s article has primarily focused on how higher education leads to many opportunities, and does not go in depth on the negative aspects of why college cannot be suited for everyone. In contrast, the article, Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill’s “Should Everyone Go to College” contains both sides of the argument. This article explains how college may not be the ‘right’ choice for everyone because every career path or goal is different,…

    • 1392 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some factors that come into play when deciding to go to college include; the monitary gain and burden, the actual need for a degree depending on the desired field of work, as well as the confidence and emotional value that a degree will give. Deciding if college is worth the time and money is a large factor that many potential college students struggle with. there are many resources and support provided by colleges to make the experience easier. By going through the imprtatnt factors, a student can make a confident decision on continuing their education. Many people believe there is no other option but to get a college degree.…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article “Indoctrination U.? Faculty Ideology and Changes in Student Political Orientation (Excerpt)” by Mack D. Mariani and Gordon J. Hewitt discusses the article “Indoctrination U.” by David Horowitz and proceed to display their own findings of political indoctrination in universities. Mariani and Hewitt use very effective means to portray their argument and manage to do so in a seemingly unbiased way. The authors argue that little evidence shows faculty ideology affecting students and is presented in the way of high amounts of logos and ethos, in the absence of pathos. The levels of ethos, logos, and pathos within the article also help to develop tone.…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In their book Paying for the party, Armstrong and Hamilton discusses how universities take class differences and class projects of distinct women to define what will be their college experience. In their book, Armstrong and Hamilton defines class projects as individual and class characteristics that defines a person’s agenda and orientation to school. Hence, people with similar class projects not only shared the same financial, cultural and social capital, but also the same expectations toward school. As a result, Armstrong and Hamilton claims that students with similar class projects end up becoming a collective constituency and a representative group for the university, whom in turn must take their interests to form a college pathway for…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a high school student, I all too frequently find myself bombarded with emails and postcards detailing the exuberant life of a college campus. Within the last week, I have received an email from Sarah Lawrence College that described their welcoming community and their high rating among the LGBT community, an email from University of Richmond that details their very own internship program, and an email from Soka University that proclaimed their devotion to diversity in all things. They want to sell me their college experience, not a college education. Edmundson’s article is correct in it argument that University education is tainted by consumerism. College has become a playtoy for the rich and smart students that have freely given up the opportunity to learn and excel.…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    American ideals place a large portion of success on productivity, progress, success, and accomplishment. While there are a variety of means to achieving such principles, one of the most commonly chosen paths is secondary education. Over 65% of recent high school graduates chose to go to college for at least some amount of time. Many colleges and universities across the nation use what people have coined liberal education. This type of education is supposed to provide a broad base on all subject matters.…

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Paying for the Party, Armstrong and Hamilton developed a theoretical framework, namely “college pathway,” to depict and interpret the differences of the college women’s campus experiences. Pathways are ways that constitute as instituted tracks that lead the individuals to go in certain directions. In the study, the authors use this term to describe, on the one hand, the administration relies on students to help resolve its own operational problems (gaining academic prestige (inter)nationally, responding to social expectations of upward mobility, or cuts to financial aids for school,) through the continuous distribution of resources(including energy, time and money sent to a certain advertisements of academic programs, internship opportunities,…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The lap of luxury is not miles away on a coastal sea. Of course, it is in a modern American dorm room, complete with bathroom and expensive food services. The times of studying are long gone when students could instead participate in Nudity Week and simply email professors instead of attending class. These are just some of the examples Tom Nichols utilizes while taking a firm stance on the structure of universities and the students of today. In The Death of Expertise, the chapter “Higher Education: The Customer is Always Right” is where author Tom Nichols, US Naval War College Professor of National Security Affairs, conveys his thoughts on today’s system of higher education by utilizing strategies such as ethical appeals, as well as fallacies…

    • 1672 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Price Of Admission

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Are Colleges worth the Price of Admission? Every parent wants the best for their children, and they want their children to go and study in college, in order to get a dream career. Now days it’s not a cinch as the costs of colleges are rising, and quality of education is dropping. In the article ‘‘Are Colleges worth the Price of Admission’’, by Andrew Hacker and Claudia Dreifus, the underlying thesis is simple: college is too expensive, and return on investment of college is rapidly decreasing, constraining some extreme changes in order for college to remain practical and logical for potential college students.…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College is Not for Everyone Today, more people than ever are attending community colleges and universities. Often, a collegiate degree is a prerequisite to meaningful employment (Pincus, 341). There is even social pressure pushing many to attend. I feel that the university education system has many structural shortcomings, and that institutions of higher learning often do not have students ' best interests at heart.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When is College your Friend When growing up, college has been so ingrained in my family that the idea of not doing so never even occurred to me. However for others, attending college has become one of the most paramount decisions in our life as a result of its extensive potential for consequence of both favorable and not. Due to its deeply controversial nature, the answer is not just in black and white. In Caroline Bird’s article “College is a Waste of Time and Money”, she has created a sensational work, but one that simply can’t hold up to scrutiny upon a closer inspection.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Roger Scruton and Louis Dupre express their opinions on culture, and how culture cannot continue when people forsake it. Scruton claims the identity of a culture comes from the interest of the people in the culture that originates from the elites. Dupre contrasts with Scruton by saying the people within the culture find their identity by their nature. If culture is to survive, Scruton believes it must be passed on to future generations through education. For culture to survive in Dupre’s view, he emphasis nature again and how people should evaluate their nature to find their identity.…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays