Essay on Prescriptive Packages Do Not Help Developing Nations

2261 Words 10 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
A common form of development aid to the Global South has been distributed as “the prescriptive package”. Whether presented as a Structural Adjustment Program (SAP) and the reform of the state, TVA dams and the harnessing of nature, or the Green Revolution and the push towards agricultural modernity—the prescriptive package is a “cookie-cutter” model of development prescribed to the developing world regardless of local context and often with disastrous results. Without modification for local

middle of document…

And finally, the first world’s underlying rationality of development is a third flaw. It is asked rhetorically: “Why wouldn’t they want what we have? And aren’t we the ones to give it to them?” Too often, good-hearted development projects are put into effect by well-meaning people with an ignorance of local needs and desires. And even in other cases these well-meaning people aren’t entirely altruistic; the “we can do it anywhere, for anyone” attitude is arrogant and costly yes, but it is also allows a foot in the door for the developer to access previously unexploited economies.
The first example is that of the World Bank and International Monetary Fund’s SAPs—Structural Adjustment Programs. SAPs were put into effect during the 1970s and 1980s as a condition of a developing country receiving a loan from the World Bank or IMF. Armed with the goal of jump-starting capitalism and entrance into the world economy, SAPs were prescriptive packages whose flaws led them to fail socially and economically.
SAPs were “a new euphemism for modernization and growth at all costs…often consisting of a package of actions that include currency devaluation, reducing inflation, downsizing the public service, drastic cutbacks on government expenditures on education, health care and welfare, financial reform, privatization of public enterprises, export promotion, and other policies…” (Konadu-Agyemang 2000: 473). The implementation of these modifications was supposed to remove
CRAM Exclusive

Related Documents

  • Problems Of Modernization In Developing Nations Essay

    receive revenue, it cannot provide sanitation, or health care, and cannot build or repair roads or buildings. Also, political instability can result in the control of a nation "switching hands". For example, frequently in Latin America, Coup d'etat occur and military dictators take control. The second problem which exists in the developing world today is rapid urbanization. Rapid urbanization can be defined as the sudden growth in city population. It results in problems such as congested streets and poverty

    Words: 635 - Pages: 3
  • Association of Southeast Asian Nations: What do They do? Essay

    Australia will be the main basis of the relationship with ASEAN, including the economic, political interaction and cooperation in the development of a wider regional dialogue. ASEAN progress development ASEAN is an association of Southeast Asian nations that have been operating with other groups and the government both. Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) grouping is economic association was inaugurated in 1989 with 21 members in East Asia, North America and Latin America. APEC was established

    Words: 1457 - Pages: 6
  • Why Do Nations Go to War Essay

    the United States. The result of this war is that the country over come the depression and strived financially and economically. War is an instrument to expand economic power by destroying the national institutions, and people of the victimized nation. Wars separate and destroy families, joy, and happiness that God has granted us, and wars only fill people’s heart with hatred, fear, and deception for ours neighbor instead of love, and unity. Why fighting for territorial, when the earth doesn’t

    Words: 641 - Pages: 3
  • Essay on Prescriptive View of Strategy

    the needs of emerging markets by using its fundamental technological strengths in electronic components to progress from supplying TVs and car radios to offering telecommunications services. From a contrary perspective, Johnson states that the prescriptive model contains many assumptions that are unsustainable in today's business world. The logical approach implies that strategy development is

    Words: 957 - Pages: 4
  • Essay on Agile vs. Prescriptive Processes

    stay on requirement until they have create good enough requirement and once they progress through this part, The team won't go back or revisit the requirement again unless there are some type of critical flaw in the Requirement. AGILE Vs. PRESCRIPTIVE(Waterfall) PROCESSES From my understanding, in Agile Model are more dynamic where everything is flexible and it welcome all the change at any point in progress. The advantage of using this method is fast and stable delivery and constant

    Words: 768 - Pages: 4
  • Is the West Imposing Its Values on Developing Nations through the Universal Declaration of Human Rights

    Finally, this essay will address cases between 2000 and the present, where western human rights groups have acted imperialistically in non-west societies, and how their actions either caused more chaos, or proved to be beneficial for the parties involved because of the imposition of western morals. The concept of human rights, as it is known today, expresses western liberal values and is not compatible with other parts of the world. In fact, to transplant the ideals of western society onto non-western

    Words: 1925 - Pages: 8
  • Nation and True Patriot Essay

    comparison to said “Pseudo-Patriot” in Goldsmiths essay, he might have turned his cheek to someone in need simply based on the color of their skin. It might be humiliating to such a person and cause reason for embarrassment. I will start this opinion by saying that no nation is perfect in any sense of the word. Though as I said before, a patriot should have pride in their country and they also need to realize the faults in it. Though many nations are strong and can support themselves very well,

    Words: 632 - Pages: 3
  • Aid Dependency in the Developing World Essay

    In addition to reviewing the economic aspect on the aid-revenue relationship, this essay brings in the longstanding political science view particularly in relation to corruption with in the aid recipients nation. Another focus will be on state-building to consider the potential impact of aid dependence on the relationship between state and institutions as well as their relations to the aid distribution process as a whole. We then recognize that dependent states which can raise a substantial proportion

    Words: 2144 - Pages: 9
  • Customer Benefit Package Essay

    with your purchase. In Walmart they have their house brand, “George” which provides the customer with reasonable priced products. They do carry other brands so there is more for the consumer to choose from, but nothing to compare to a luxury clothier. The difference here would be the preference of the customer, do you want a good fitting piece of clothing, and do you care about the brand name. A luxury clothier will have the variety of choices in clothing, and in accessories to go well with the

    Words: 994 - Pages: 4
  • Why Do Nations Fail? by Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson

    with a complex political history, inequitable income distribution, an ailing economy and rampant corruption. Acemoglu and Robinson would state the issue does not lie in the geography of Nigeria, the culture or even the ignorance of policies that could help enrich Nigeria. According to Acemoglu and Robinson’s thesis, Nigeria is poor because those in power made choices that resulted in a great consequence: poverty (Acemoglu & Robinson 2012). Due to oil, there has been high economic growth in Nigeria, and

    Words: 1446 - Pages: 6