Will Herberg's Who Is Loyal To America

Improved Essays
Will Herberg, writer of Protestant, Catholic, Jew, was a Jewish philosopher. He had a distinctive religious and social perspective expressed in all his writings. Herberg turned his attention to the sociology of American religion with this book. His critique of diversity is still impressive today, as are his ideas about the prominence of group identities. Herberg 's book demonstrated the sociological study of religion in the United States. He discussed how immigration and American ethnic culture were mirrored in religious movements and institutions. His work has been said to be one of the most powerful books written about American religion. Herberg’s book, Protestant, Catholic, Jew, combined a review of his research on American’s …show more content…
He was a passionate defender of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. He helped to define modern liberalism in the United States with his many writings. His essay, Who Is Loyal to America, was written in a time period when America was going through a fight of anticommunism during the time of the cold war. In his essay Commager argues strongly the fact that this whole idea of “loyalty” is false. He feels that true patriotism and loyalty actually require what, to many, looks like disloyalty. It may require opposition to certain requirements of the Constitution itself and historians have not determined that those who subscribed to their moral or religious principles, that they believe overrule secular constitutions and laws, were lacking in patriotism. He states that the actual disloyal ones are those who do not believe in racial equality and the fact that all men are created equal. That disloyalty is in the hands of politicians who seek public office as for a private gain rather than a way to help others. Also when these politicians, in turn, let greed and corruption enter into politics. He believes this concept of “loyalty” is narrow and limiting. New patriotism should not forget that the American tradition is one that is founded on protest and rebellion. In Commager’s study, he noted that people who treated each other …show more content…
Commager spoke to the American principles of loyalty and patriotism, but, Herberg noted that many Americans seemed to identify more with their religious affiliations as opposed to one American identity. However, with Herberg 's religious background and his articulation, he was able to back up Commager and his way of thinking. Herberg was able to tell of the devastation first hand, which meant that he could honestly back up what Commager was trying to discuss. These religious leanings can help guide their political beliefs and more conservative views that could differ from what Commager is saying in his article. The main thing they both discussed was that equalitarianism, which brings loyalty, is very important with

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    During the 1960’s, Jim Jones started the People’s Temple, a racially integrated, socialist, Pentecostal worship-inspired church, which caused controversy after he led the mass religious suicide of over 900 people on November 17th, 1978 at Jonestown, Guyana. While some branded the People’s Temple as cult, David Chidester’s book Salvation and Suicide analyzes the People’s Temple from a religious perspective to understand the underpinnings of its values and ideologies. By doing so, he embraces the identities of those who were part of the People’s Temple, accepting them as part of the very fluid definition of what it means to be human. Chidester’s phenomenological approach successfully and cohesively analyzes the beliefs of the People’s Temple,…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1782 J. Hector St. John de Crevecoeur wrote a powerful essay on the colonial American society. Within this essay he portrays his thoughts about American life and simply defines the beloved country in a new perspective. He wrote this specifically to praise Americans, and their reasons for coming together and making such a great place. As a French aristocrat he shocks the world with his enlightening and brilliantly written essay about the American society. He makes a powerful argument by using comparisons, tone, word choice, and many other rhetorical strategies.…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a category of American religious history, African-American religious life and the history behind it has often forgotten or briefly summarized in most historians’ work. Prior to the 1970’s, most history written on African-American religion was vague, often just trivial paragraphs in textbooks and considered irrelevant to our nation’s religious history. But as time progressed, history was revisited to show African-American’s having a more prominent voice in America’s religious culture. One historian, Ulrich Bonnell Phillips wrote one of the earliest collections of slave history and life, American Negro Slavery. This book, written in 1918, shaped the perception of what slavery was like for most who did not experience the institution, but…

    • 1639 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Divided By Faith Analysis

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, the disestablishment of religion worked to hinder the unity God’s people are called to. In their work Divided By Faith, Michael Emerson and Christian Smith detail America’s eventual deconstruction of the centralization of religion. Emerson and Smith begin Chapter 7 of their work by highlighting how much of European culture during the 1600 and 1700s was marked by an overlap of church and state to the point where the two were virtually inseparable. One’s faith was determined by community in a sense. There was no real freedom of choice.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Comanche Empire

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The United States would no be anything it is today without the help of the 18th and 19th century. The battles fought and the lands expanded all helped the US create a better environment for its future. One major factor that helped the US was the Comanche Empire. The Comanches are one of the most empire back then in the 18th century. They dominated Majority of the southwest using violence to expand their empire.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Exam 1 In this essay I will be referring to the article, The Negro Church in America written by E. Franklin Frazier. I will be comparing the evolution and function of the Black Church in America with Emile Durkheim’s and Marx’s Theories of religion. I will do this by first providing the background of the African slaves that led to their loss of cultural identity. I will also describe both Emile Durkheim’s and Karl Marx’s theories of religion individually.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Author Mark Twain stated, “Loyalty to the Nation all the time, loyalty to government when it deserves it”. In his farewell address, George Washington expressed the importance of putting America above any local or foreign identity. We disagree with Washington's absolute take on patriotism as this may create a populous which blindly adopts the decree of an unjust government. A big concern during the time of Washington’s farewell address was the fear of Americans identifying more closely with their states than with the national government.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thomas Jefferson, one of the most popular founding fathers, the main author of the Declaration of Independence, and the third president of the United States of America was revered by his contemporaries and is still to this day a well respected figure in American history. But, this does not mean that the man had no faults. Often in todays world Thomas Jefferson is looked back upon and has been scrutinized by many for his apparent hypocrisy on matters such as slavery and on what he believed limitations of the federal government were to be. Although some of Jefferson’s past can be dark and questionable, he was no hypocrite, but a man who understood that his decisions would have lasting effects on the new country, and that putting his own personal…

    • 1033 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cults will help us to perceive how the overwhelming American religious society dismisses certain new religious developments in view of particulars parts of their teachings or enrollments the word. On account of these gatherings, we can perceive how the dominating religious groups in America can oppress different conventions in light of particular issues. Knowing this, we will perceive how such states of mind towards new religious developments impacted responses against the Branch Davidians amid the attack on Mount Carmel. It is intriguing to note what are viewed as "new religions. " Since the nation was established on basically Anglican and Puritan conventions, the sections that later advanced from these gatherings are currently invited.…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author thesis is breaking down the number of participants in church in the beginning of Religious organizations in America. Although, certain information was documented pertaining to the participation of church attendance. Information gathered from the text explains that there is additional text that provides proof of the rise in attendance for modern day churches. The text stated that "The backbone of this book consists of our attempt to explore and explain how and why America shifted from a nation in which most people took no part in organized religion to a nation in which nearly two-thirds of American adults do (Finke and Stark 1). " Explaining why more people are leaning to attending church, or the reason certain religions had more attendance than others are also explained in the text.…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Professor Alan Taylor’s topic in the first page of the essay is how the founding fathers, like many Americans at the time, clashed on many issues. He uses combative diction to not only suggest, but to force readers to understand that the parties clashed. He denounced the “mythic” misconception of the unity of the founding fathers to “violent” “enemies” in order to show his readers how cutthroat politics were back then. The way he would quote people would only include their party affiliation, which further deepens the gorge that divides the parties at the time.…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In modern times, the patriotism that started 250 years ago is still evident in our everyday lives. Almost all Americans are proud of the history and culture of the United States and show their pride to be an American everyday. The patriotism that the United States of America has proudly held since the mid 1700s has been a large factor in the foundation of the nation and will continue to play a part in longevity of the…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    What makes an American, ‘American’? The answer to this question will vary greatly depending on the respondent’s beliefs and cultural background. As the United States continues to grow and evolve in areas such as race, ethnicity and culture, the image of America changes as well. In an article entitled ‘Nation or Notion’ by Patrick J. Buchanan, he argues that Americans need a common identity based upon ancestry and culture to survive as a country. On the other hand, an article entitled ‘What Does It Mean to Be an “American”?’ by Michael Walzer argues that America does not need a common identity.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But I think that things such as secularization, equal rights, and abortion remain at the forfront of political quarils in todays society. This book most importantly brings to light the relavence of the opposition cultire in America in the 1960s and how the neoconservatives quickly became emersed in the rising…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The American political culture contains various concepts and values. Indeed, Americans share the same perspectives, the support in the ideals of individualism and liberty. The idea of individualism encompasses the idea that we as Americans have rights. For instance, we can make independent decisions, and we are responsible for our lives. We define liberty as having the freedom to do as we please with limits in the interest of having a stable society.…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays