The Puritan Dilemma In The Puritan Dilemma

Superior Essays
The Puritan Dilemma
Imagine living in a world where someone’s own personal and religious life was being affected by that of the country that they lived in. In most cases that was not a life they wanted to live, and some people looked for a way out. In the case of the Puritans of England, they willingly sailed across three thousand mile Atlantic Ocean, for a chance to set up a settlement where they could live and worship the way they believed was the right way without the pressures of the crown.
Puritanism was the belief that the Church of England should be purged of its hierarchy and of the traditions and ceremonies inherited from Rome. Putting this aside it demanded more of the individual than it did of the church. A puritan had to dedicate
…show more content…
Once Elizabeth took the throne, Puritans were somewhere at a standstill. While her government did not satisfy them, did not purify the church of its ceremonies and vestments, did not get rid of the bishops and archbishops, but she did defy the pope and made England the mainstay for Protestantism against the catholic church of Spain. With her also accepting Puritans among her advisors, Puritans believed things were moving the way they were supposed to (p. 16). Although they thought things were coming along James I kind of crushed those spirits. James I disliked Puritans and allowed no further reformation of the church (p. 17). Parliament became the bright hope for puritans as they thought its efforts would save them from God’s wrath (p. 22). The when Charles I took the throne things started to plummet both religiously and in the government. Charles, being married to a catholic princess, and a supporter of Arminianism alarmed the Puritans greatly. As evils in church and state multiplied, Puritans looked more and more to Parliament for relief (page 24). Then on March 10, 1629, Charles got rid of Parliament. With that being done there was no hope left for England (page …show more content…
They knew they had to punish every sin committed in Massachusetts. This was not taken lightly as the whole community agreed to this because a sin unpunished might expose them all to the wrath of God (p. 64). Families became places of virtue where the mother and father had to discipline not only their children but also their servants and any boarders they had taken in. It became forbidden for anyone to live alone, unmarried men and women were required to place themselves in some sort of family. Parents were obliged teach all their children and apprentices to read so that everyone would be able to see for themselves in the bible the opportunities of salvation God offered to man and what sins he forbade. The churches were filled every Sunday with willing and unwilling worshippers considering everyone was required to attend (p.64). In Massachusetts, the most important requirement of the colony was the establishment of churches organized as God commanded. The problem was they had to come to some sort of an agreement on what it was that God wanted, while they all knew there must be an end to bishops and archbishops, an end to the idolatrous ritual and trappings that dignified the clergy instead of God in the divine service, they disagreed on two different things which caused them to split into two groups. One group the Presbyterians insisted that the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Not all colonists in New England were Puritans but the Puritan religion was a major influence on the establishment of the colonies. Puritans were not satisfied with the Protestant Reformation and believed that the Church of England had to many Catholic rituals. They believed neither the church nor the nation were living up to their ideals. In order to seek the truth they urged the people to read the Bible and listen to their sermons. Puritans followed the teachings of John Calvin in which he taught that the world was divided between the elect and the damned.…

    • 1227 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the 1600s, Puritans traveled across to the colonies, the Massachusetts Bay Colony, to get away from the Church of England and the Catholics. They wanted to purify the church and change it because they were Protestant and they had different beliefs/issues. Along with their change came many ideas and values. These ideas influenced colonies through their social, economical, political, and religious beliefs between the 1630s and the 1660s. Religion was a big deal during this time period.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Early New England colonies built their foundation on puritan views and ideas. The puritans helped develop most of what we know today of the New England colonies. They influenced politics, economics, and the social lives of colonies In the New England territory, especially during 1630 through the 1660s. Puritans, mainly separatist Puritans, helped build up the New England colonies, especially politically. Puritans believed that people need to be united to efficiently work as a governing body.…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Religion was so vital to the Puritans that they decided to leave England when it created its own church. At first the Puritans were willing to stay if reforms were made to the Church of England, but unfortunately, the king at the time, King Charles I, threatened the Puritans if they did not respect the Catholic church. The Puritans left to freely practice their own religion without interference from the Catholic church. Little did they know that citizens of their community would be faced with sinning through witchcraft. Puritans lived in the town in order to be close to always walk to church.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    American Pageant Chapter 4

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages

    1. The Puritans were able to leave all they had in England to seek religious, political, and economical freedom from the English throne by building a new civilization in Massachusetts, an unexplored and foreign terrain for almost all the Puritans. First of all, the Puritans were English protestants, who wanted the Church of England reformed and perished of all Roman Catholic remnants but did not want to separate from the Church; they were “non-separatists” unlike the Pilgrims ("Religion and the Founding of the American Republic"). Then, in the 1620s, the Puritans faced religious persecution for not following religious beliefs that they absolutely hated ("Religion and the Founding of the American Republic").…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The puritans established the colony of Massachusetts bay in 1630.They hoped to purify the church of England and then return to Europe within a new and improved religion. The Massachusetts bay puritans were more immediately successful than other colonies. They brought enough supplies. They arrived in the spring time. They had good leadership (including john Winthrop).…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The English had unified Church and state- demanding that every citizen support the official Church of England with taxes and regular attendance. Any religious dissent or violation of taxes would be considered treason and heresy. There were church courts established, without juries, to punish those who strayed from the Church. These systems were designed to oppress the citizens of England- forcing everyone into uniformity. The Puritans, who sought reform, separated from the Church in order to pursue a simpler worship.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Puritans faced many trials and persecutions, the hardest part was trying to stay alive. These puritans stood up for what they believed in and did not ask questions and they undeniably had outstanding faith. In the end It’s what they believed in that pushed them to survive. It all began with the corruption of the Catholic church and when Thomas Cartwright (An English Puritan) wanted to reform the church.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to our notes and lectures, the Puritans believed in pure bible and believed in predestination. If a person didn’t go to church or practice religious things than they were looked down upon. This can have its positive effects though. If everybody is supposed to go to church then they know how to act kindly, and they know the laws. It also kept them busy and out of trouble.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Puritanism, superficially thought to be a belief in which the Church of England should be removed from Catholicism and its hierarchy, demands more of the individual than the church. It demanded the faith, strength, and determination to please God. The Puritan Dilemma, by Edmund S. Morgan, is the biography of John Winthrop, a Puritan who departs from England so as to create a haven and an example of a community where the laws of God were followed diligently. Within the Puritan Dilemma, Morgan outlines the dilemma that plagues all Puritans. Morgan speaks of the paradox that troubled Winthrop that was “... the paradox that required a man to live in the world without being of it.…

    • 943 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Puritans adopted Europe’s concept and forced it onto others. They are what we call hypocrites, because they did not like what happened to them in Europe but they came to the North and did it to others. In the areas where Puritans dominated, there was no religious freedom. And like England they too merged their church with politics.…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Early Jamestown Settlers

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages

    They had pulled apart from Henry XIII and the Church of England, who had recently pulled away from the Catholic Church, because of how corrupt Henry was. They wanted everyone to believe the way they did, they wished to purify people, “Seeing that we daily pray for the conversion of the heathens,we must consider whether there be some ordinary means and course for us to take to convert them… To us they cannot come our land is full; to them, we may go, their land is empty.” (The Puritan Logic of Migration, 5). When the Puritans were still on the Mayflower the came up with a self governing document, The Mayflower Compact, and once they were off the ship they settled in New England.…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Puritans are religion people they were similar to Christians. The Puritans believe that they should separate themselves from the “corrupt of England.” The puritans Believe that God has a chosen few for salvation ,” this is saying that God has picked certain people to bring to his kingdom (heaven).Anne Bradstreet wrote a poem entitled “ “Upon the Burning of our House” and also a sermon written by Jonathan Edward ,” sinners in the hands of an angry God ,” the two describe puritain ways and illustrate the thoughts of the consequences of puritain from God. In Bradstreet's poem A young lady and her husband are trapped inside of their house as it burn down into the ashes.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Puritans in New England and Their Connection to The Handmaid’s Tale The Puritan movement arose in England in the 1600s. Members either sought reform or complete separation from the Church of England (Campbell). Puritans believed the Church of England was “a product of political struggles and man-made doctrines”. Puritanism was the attempt to “purify” the Church of England by eliminating the “traditional trappings and formalities” (Kizer).…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This abuse of power was echoed in England’s Anglican church. The Puritans, out of whom became the pilgrims, desired to leave England because of its lack of religious toleration and because the Anglican religion had not so much reformed the Catholic church as it had replaced the Pope with a king (Deverell 64-65). Eventually, though, the New England Puritans themselves had also created a religiously-dominated society, one in which “Church attendance was mandatory…”, law-breakers were…

    • 1648 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays