Burqa Ban Essay

Improved Essays
Articles A and B address the conflicting opinions on the Burqa ban. In article A written by Jean-Francois Coupe, he pushes for the implementation of the ban, however in Article B written by Nabila Ramdani, she strongly opposes the ban. If someone were to formulate an opinion on the burqa ban based of these articles they would be forming it on misinformation . Neither of these articles properly represent the perceived pros and cons of the ban due to their faulty evidence and reasoning.
In her article, “Don’t Follow France’s Burqa Ban. It Has Curbed Liberty and Justice”, Nabila Ramdani claims the ban stifles freedom, and allows the persecution and stigmatization of Muslim women. Ramdani supports her claim with flawed pieces of evidence, the first
…show more content…
However there is not enough data supporting her four pieces of anecdotal evidence such as statistics that compare the number of attacks before and after the ban. Her evidence is specifically picked to evict an emotional response from the reader and detract attention from the anecdotally nature and unclear reasoning that do not back up her claim. Another one of her prominent claims states that women in these garments do not make others uncomfortable or feel unsafe. To support her claim she creates a piece of evidence about how no, “...veiled woman in the National Health Service...has unsettled patients…” and there is no “...teacher who refuses to take of her niqab in front of children when asked…”(Ramdani 3) She continues on to mention that women will …show more content…
However, as when digging through his polished writing, it becomes clear that is evidence and reasoning are sub par. For instance he claims that these “face coverings” create safety issues because of securities reliance on cameras. Although it may seem logical, this ban is on burqas and niqabs, not masks. Coupe provides only one incidence of the use of a burqa in a robbery, and there is not enough data to predict that it may happen again, which certainly does not warrant drastic measure of a burqa ban. Even if the ban is in place, robbers can use ski masks or other methods of concealing their face, which effectively renders the ban useless. Coupe’s other argument claims that the ban displays France's ideals of freedom. He believes that banning the burqa is a compromise that is necessary to live together as a community. In fact in response to the idea that the ban is against freedom, Jean-Francois equates “...The fact that people are prohibited from strolling down Fifth Avenue in the nude…” to being banned from, “wearing headgear that fully covers the face…” because neither of those, “constitute as a fundamental liberty”(Cope 2). His reasoning is flawed, he is comparing a religious garment being banned to nudism being banned which in no sense is tied to any religion, and is generally viewed as a shameful action. He implies that the burqa and niqab are something shameful. Although this is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    He even mentions having to play along with the new rules and nine pm curfew for about two years, until Al-Solaylee left to study in England in 1985. Using the same rationalization on the topic, I could use my personal experience with people living in Canada dressed in full burkas to debate the author’s claim. After all, if the people were really objectified to this change, they have no reason to even continue Muslim traditions in the privacy of their own home or here in Canada despite being free from sharia law. Based on the emotional and current relevance to the topic, this article…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Jazmin Lara Ms.Matlen ERWC, Period 1 15 September 2016 Racial Profiling In the United States of America today, racial profiling has violated everything the United States of America stands for and represents. Authorities do not have the right to be allowed to stop, arrest, disrespect or harass any individual in America based on their appearance. The general statement made by Timothy Garton Ash in his work, Behind the ban, is that burkas in a free society is a form of expression and it needs be allowed.…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Muslim Women In America

    • 1536 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This intersection of gender, religion and ethnicity, creates issues which Muslim women face on a daily basis. These Americans are constantly barraged with comments that vacillate between being called oppressed or labeled a terrorist, all due to a simple piece of clothing; the hijab. Interestingly, it is hard to imagine a devout Catholic or Baptist, who wears a hat to services, being subjected to the same remarks. Nevertheless, Muslim American women are often asked why they wear a hijab and or if they feel oppressed by it? Dalia Mogahed, Director of Research at the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding, responded with the following: I wear the hijab, “because it’s an act of devotion to God.…

    • 1536 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    People suspect the burkas can cause a place to bomb or being a threat to the public. Women assume the cartoon of Mohammad, who wear the burkas find it disturbing. They found it offensive and…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Charter Of Rights

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In essence, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is the sole piece of legislature which balances equality and liberty, whilst taking into perspective individual rights in opposition to the needs of society. The manner with which the charter is composed upholds the balance of liberty and equality justly; however, in practise the charter is implemented with the neither the honour nor the justice for which the spirit of the law intended. Furthermore, sections one, twenty four, and eight of the charter aptly demonstrate the misinterpretation with which the charter has been dealt. Overall, the faults within the charter are not within the legislature; a societal change in ideology is necessary in which the interpreters and enforcers of the…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In some places in the world, the government is capable of denying citizens their autonomy and limiting their opportunities. However, in American, most individuals are legally free to make their own choices without fear of persecution. Americans are able to watch any television program we choose or read any book we wish to – whether the content of the media has been challenged or not. We can wear almost any article of clothing in public that we wish, be it a dress or even religious garb, at least as long as it’s not considered inappropriate for public eyes. In the case of wearing religious clothing items, such as a hijab or kippah, being able to wear an article of clothing that expresses their religious freedom without being limited by fear of religious persecution is an extremely important aspect that many people cherish in…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “France’s headscarf war: ‘It’s an attack on freedom’”, Angelique Chrisafis describes experiences of racial discrimination through arbitrary regulations that prevent them from having religious freedom. For instance, Chrisafis explains how Youssra’s was prohibited from joining her son on a school trip because the French Republic saw headscarves as an aggression that puts children in danger. Youssra’s felt humiliated, while her child, like many other children, experienced secondary effects such as psychological difficulties. This frustrated me because some Muslims felt inferior to other ethnic groups due to having more restrictions. These regulations gave Muslims the wrong message that they would have to eliminate a part of themselves…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Niqab Research Paper

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Long Newspaper Article- Assignment Part one: Summary This article is about the controversial debate concerning the Niqab (a garment concealing the entire body with the exclusion of the eyes and hands). The article states the stances of various parties on this garment, it states that the Conservative party is considering implementing a law, similar to Quebec’s Bill 62.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction: This paper will cover the subject of the wearing of cultural and religious apparel in Canadian sports, based on Sheema Khan’s essay “Hijabs: Don’t Kick Up a Fuss “ A. Thesis: Writer’s position is one that is in favor of permitting Hijabs to be worn by participants that are engaged in organized sports. B. Roles/Arguments: Khan with the use of literary humor and satire makes for a persuasive argument in her paper for the wearing of the Hijab. The writer quickly dispatches the only reason given for not allowing the Hijab, that being a “Safety concern” as being entirely without merit. In addition, the writer has researched FIFA’s formal rules and found no prohibition against the Hijab, as the wording is sufficiently vague where…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “White feminism” is a term that has become a hot topic in recent years. In the article “Shit White Feminists Need To Stop Doing” by Anne Theriault describes white feminism as feminist women who are cisgender and white only fighting for issues that directly affect their lives, while ignoring issues that affect women of color, LGBT women, and disabled women. Theriault claims at the beginning of her article that she is a feminist herself, yet effectively insults and oppresses other women throughout her article. Anne Theriault wrote a biased article filled with opinions and no facts showing that white, feminist women are less than anyone else.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Niqab Debate

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The conservative party feels the wearing of a Niqab allows inequality to…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Religious Face Covers

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Everyone has the right to express their religion and their beliefs. They have a right to practice it like everyone else in society. The niqab, burqa, and other religious face coverings represent modesty, piety, and subservience to God. One does not need to agree with their religious beliefs, however, one does not have the right to restrict everything that they hold dear. Bill 94 does not unite the province, rather, it isolates the individual by not giving them basic services that they are entitled to.…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This article is entitled, “Niqab ban for public servants would be considered, says Stephen Harper” and is about the controversial debate concerning the niqab. The article discusses the viewpoints of various political parties on this garment. First, It states that the Conservative party is considering implementing a law, similar to Quebec’s Bill 62. This law will require persons wearing this garment to unveil their faces as employees of the government and while receiving one’s Canadian citizenship. In regards to his reasoning for implementing such a law, when asked by a CBC host why it is acceptable for the government to tell one how to dress Harper replied that there are times when one needs to review the identity of those wearing niqabs.…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paquete Habana Case Study

    • 1715 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Please illustrate using Paquete Habana, found at DRW pp. 82-85, and related readings. In the case of the Paquete Habana, the U.S. Navy captured two fishing vessels (the Paquete Habana and the Lola) during the Spanish-American War, both of which were sailing under the Spanish flag in and out of Havana while there was a blockade in effect. The Paquete’s crew was unaware of the blockade.…

    • 1715 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The three reasons provided by the author to support her thesis statement are: There is a stereotyping of Muslim women and of the burqa; The battle against the burqa is evident and reverberant in Western nations, but there is no involvement of Muslim women in this discussion; Burqa-clad women experience marginalization in Western cycles and in progressive Muslim communities. The first reason claimed by the writer is supported by her assumption that the burqa is considered by most people an opponent symbol of the Western values, and the women who wear it are controlled by men, they do not have control over their bodies and this garb is imprisoning all their rights. According to Hasan, the association of the burqa as a symbol of Islam is so strong that this topic receives more attention than other issues faced by Muslims. In order to support this assumption, she uses as an example the burqa ban request made by the Muslim Canadian Congress, which justified this request by declaring that the burqa is a political symbol of Islamic extremism. As a final appeal, Hasan resorts to loaded questions in a tentative to demonstrate how insensate this request is.…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays