Compare And Contrast The Spanish French And Dutch Colonies

Improved Essays
The Spanish, French, and Dutch colonies in North America all interacted with the Native Americans during the 16th century. Spain’s extreme subjugating approach and views on freedom and religion differed from the accepting and collaborative views of the French and the Dutch. Although the French and Dutch had apparent positive approaches compared to Spain, oppression of the Native Americans occurred under the control of all three colonies.
The Spanish were the first to colonize North America and their approach lacked moral compass. This quote, taken from the writings of a Dominican priest, only scratches the surface of the relationship between the Natives and the Spanish. “The Indians [of hispaniola] were totally deprived of their freedom and
…show more content…
They took pride in the freedom of allowing the private practice of all religions and did not indoctrinate the indian culture on one religion. This resulted in a wide diversity of religions practiced compared to the Spanish colony: such as Jews, Quakers, and Lutherans.
The French Colonies approach on freedom furthered the regime of the Dutch. The french had a more economical approach to the contact with the Natives. They valued a friendly relationship with the Natives, because they understood the positive effects it would have on their economic goals for the fur trade and their search for gold. The French didn’t make the Natives slaves or steal their land; they won the affection of the Indians and benefited largely from their positive relationship by creating honest wealth and long lasting relationships.
The French alike the Spanish made efforts to spread Catholicism, but like the Dutch, did not eradicate the practicing of other religions. They had a friendly and respectful approach in their evangelism and did not punish any independence from the Catholic beliefs. Catholicism was not widely used to make decisions in their

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    During the colonial era England strove to cash in on the riches being found and exported from the "new world. " In an effort to do this, the Jamestowne and Plymouth colonies would be formed. Though these colonies were similar in some ways they were largely different. Economically, Jamestowne was the most profitable of the two colonies even though Jamestowne did not always return a profit to England.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By converting the natives, the Europeans opened up trade agreements as well as land reforms. Jacques Cartier, a French explorer, described his first contact with the indians, explained how as soon as the French had reached the New World called the natives “wild men,”(Document 2) and to remedy this, they attempted to press their religion, Catholicism onto them. An image, in Document 4, depicts a scene where the natives appear to be praying on their knees at a bounty of food and gifts. Salesmen, whose purpose is first and foremost to make a profit, first entice with small gifts, and then proceed to take their money. This is exactly what happened with the natives.…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although their sole purpose was not to convert others to their religious practices, there were some settlers who took it upon themselves to teach their ways. These mission trips weren’t extremely successful, but some Indians did convert. They used religion to try and help cope with their ever altered lifestyles. The settlers had intruded on every aspect of their lives and that created much stress for the tribes. The New England colonies were more successful in their settlement for longer periods of time than the Chesapeake colonies, because of their family lifestyles, and their more nurturing climate.…

    • 1368 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The key difference between the colonies of New Spain and New France and those of Virginia and New England was the way their settlers interacted with the surrounding Native Americans. Whether it be through exploiting the Indians for labor, as was done by the Spanish, or forging alliances with them, like the French, both New Spain and New France became frontiers of inclusion, where natives were incorporated into colonial society. On the contrary, England began massive immigration to Virginia and New England in order to provide workers for tobacco cultivation. Because its colonies were populated with families, there was no need for Indians to be incorporated into society, neither as workers nor as marriage partners. Therefore, the English set…

    • 131 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To their advantage, the Puritans made friends with the Indians. They helped each other, teaching survival skills and sharing goods. The men of Jamestown were not friendly to the Indians, which was another…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout history, many European countries formed colonies in the Americas. The most well-known countries were, Spain, England, and France, who all claimed land and worked to serve the mother country. However, they encountered many problems such as; a lack of knowledge of the land, unknown food sources, and, the Native Americans. The two books, A People’s History of the United States, by Howard Zinn, and, A Patriot’s History of the United States, by Larry Schweikart, discussed different view about how the Natives were treated by the explorers. Zinn’s book had a critical view of the explorers and their treatment of the natives, while Schweikart’s book had a more conservative view, due to each author’s opinions and research.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During 1650 to 1750, the English and Spanish tried to gain control of North America for many different reasons. Both had very different governments that tried to colonize the continent. Spain’s government was ruled by an autocratic leader, in other words, someone who uses fear to threaten and control their people for power. On the other hand, the English governed themselves along the guidelines of the English law and were loyal to their king. They had much more freedom than the Spanish, and supported immigration from other countries which increased their colonial population.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Spanish came to the New World with the goals to prosper in wealth and to serve for God, and this newly founded New World gave the Spanish Colonies the chance to regain it's religious followers after the followers were lost to the colonies Protestant “heresy” that it once had; the Spanish colony became ‘fully catholic’ by 1492 by expelling the Muslims and Jews after 1492. The Spanish firmly believed that colony had rights to conquer and colonize the New World to spread Christianity to the Natives inhabiting the land. In the minds of the Spanish Colonists, they were saving the souls of the Native peoples even if it meant destroying their bodies. The colonists used this to justify for practically every one of the actions that they did in the New World along with the act of forced conversion on the Natives, sending out priests to aid in the conversion. The Spanish, in order to aid conversion, created the Mission System; a religious mission to convert Native peoples throughout the American Southwest and into California.…

    • 1798 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Collision Of Cultures

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The French tended to be more tolerant of the Native Americans. For instance, the French were willing to allow the natives to keep their own languages and cultures, whereas on the other hand, the Europeans intentionally wanted to convert the native’s religion and ways. The Collision of Cultures brought distress to the natives economically and religiously. The outcome of the time period has proven the Europeans to strive solely for “a source of economic opportunity” and the native’s obliviousness to the unknown has caused them to obey the commands of everyone (Foner, “A New World”,…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Both countries obtained wealth, but in different ways. The Spanish gained wealth through the discovery of gold and the English through investors and cash crops like tobacco. Spanish religious efforts focused greatly on religious unity and the conversion of natives to Catholicism, while the English colonists saw America as a safe haven for their different religious beliefs. Lastly, the Spanish believed that the native people were meant to be slaves, and this belief led to slavery for the natives as well as poor treatment. The English, on the other hand, befriended the native people in hopes of peace and survival.…

    • 1255 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Directly following the start of the Commercial Revolution in the 1400s, Spain and England began to colonize the Americas, which was often referred to as the New World. The Spanish and English colonies were both similar and different in several ways. The Spanish and English colonies were slightly alike in the poor and unfair treatment of indigenous people and substantially different in religion and economic base. The Spanish and English were slightly comparable in terms of treatment of indigenous people because of enslavement of native people and taking their land.…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1492, Christopher Columbus, an Italian explorer, initiated colonization by Europe in the New World when he sailed across the Atlantic Ocean to the Americas. English and Spanish colonies grew to become very different from one another with frequent similarities. The Spanish colonies and New England greatly differed in terms of control by a European government, were both vastly similar and extremely different in terms of religion, and were largely similar in terms of treatment of indigenous people. The Spanish colonies and New England were slightly similar and greatly different in terms of control by European government due to supporting their European country and their acceptance of European religion.…

    • 2387 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Spaniards came to the New World in hopes of finding gold. Once they get here they realize there is not any, and the Spaniards realize they are going to have to work in order to survive and make money. They quickly force the Indian communities to work for them. The treatment of the Indians by the Spaniards was unimaginable and explained thoroughly by Las Casas who was a Dominican priest against this treatment. Religion played a major role in the treatment of the Indians and also later on in the Pueblo Revolt.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When Jesuits arrived in North America in the early seventeenth century, neither they nor their Native American neighbors had any idea of the vast cultural and religious boundaries that separated them. Throughout their encounters, the Jesuits failed to see the Native Americans as anything but inferior. This hindered their ability to understand the native culture and to accomplish their goal of converting Indians to Catholicism. The Native Americans had no frame of reference with which to regard the Jesuits and were therefore unable to develop a thorough understanding of European life. Through trial, communication and conflict French missionaries and Native Americans did eventually develop a limited understanding of each other’s language, religion…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Teresa Nguyen Mrs. Pante and Mr. McWaters 10th Grade Honors English and History 18 November 2016 Comparison of the Colonial Regions Before there was America, it was just thirteen colonies divided into three regions under the control of the British government, known as the New England Colonies, the Middle Colonies, and the Southern Colonies. People came to the new colonies to create a new society and economy. Each region had their own lifestyle.…

    • 1550 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays

Related Topics