Family Law Case Analysis

Superior Essays
There are always many disputes after the breakdown of marriage between the two parties, such as custody and spousal support. The issue of spousal support often generates significant controversy and discussion. The new Divorce Act, which was enacted in 1985 and still remain effective today, is the federal Act that governs divorce including the order of spousal support in Canada (Boyd, 2015). This essay will discuss how the courts views the issue of spousal support in Lee v Lee (2014), a family law case that was held in British Columbia, as well as the reasons why I agree with the judicial application of the law.

Lee v Lee (2014) is a family law case which the former husband appeal from the apportionment of family assets and the dismissal of
…show more content…
Lee did not suffer from marked decline of living standard arising from marriage breakdown since he had lived with a new partner who had similar economic condition as his ex-wife. Section 15.2(6)(a) of the Divorce Act provides the objective of spousal support, that the provision of spousal support should recognize the economic advantages or disadvantages to the spouses caused by the marriage or the divorce. Section 15.2(6)(c) also stated that spousal support should relieve the economic hardship of the spouse due to divorce. In this circumstance, Mr. Lee did not really encounter financial disadvantages or even hardship arising from the marriage breakdown, as he could still live in a house that was similar to his ex-wife in terms of size and location. Therefore, Mr. Lee should not be granted for permanent spousal support. Secondly, the reasons for income disparity between the parties were not due to the marriage or the breakdown itself. During the marriage, Ms. Lee did not take advantages of Mr. Lee in getting the high-paid job, instead, it was evident that he chose to be underemployed and refused to get higher education voluntarily. It was obvious that the significant income gap between the parties was due to Mr. Lee reluctant in exploring other job and/or increasing his working hours. In addition, Sections 15.2(6)(d) and 17(7)(d) of Divorce Act set out an expectation of spousal support: promoting self-sufficiency “within a reasonable period of time”. It means the …show more content…
In Lee v Lee (2014) where significant income disparity between both parties and the reverse of traditional gender role existed, it is expected that more debates and discussions related to spousal support would be created in Canada especially British Columbia.

References

Boyd, N. (2015) Canadian Law: An Introduction. (6th) Toronto, Canada: Nelson Education.

Divorce Act, RSC 1985, c 3 (2nd Supp), s. 15.2(6)(a)

Divorce Act, RSC 1985, c 3 (2nd Supp), s. 15.2(6)(c)

Divorce Act, RSC 1985, c 3 (2nd Supp), s. 15.2(6)(d)

Divorce Act, RSC 1985, c 3 (2nd Supp), s. 17(7)(d)

Lee v. Lee [2014] B.C.J. No.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The New Mating Market, we see divorce as a major killer in every aspect of life; finances are affected, children are emotionally torn, social lives are left on the fence, and family members are in limbo. Porter informs the audience “Marriage is also a form of insurance. Families with two sources of income are more financially secure than one and are thus more willing to take financial risks”(268). Aside from the lovely…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The children should still remain supported however so if an increase in child support is necessary, so be…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The case being addressed in this essay is: Winnipeg Child and Family Services (Northwest Area) v. D.F.G. The topics being addressed in this essay will be provided through a summary and an analysis, explaining the case through legal liberalism and feminist legal theory in relation to the majority decision and the dissenting decision. I personally, agree with the reasoning of the majority decision and will prove why. Summary…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Divorce In Canada Essay

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Divorce has been an increasing trend in Canada. Approximately 5 million Canadians have separated or divorced within the last 20 years, according to 2011 General Social Survey on Families. In 2001 studies have shown Canada’s divorce rate at 71,110, then dropping to 69,644 in 2004 and quickly spiralling back up to 71,269 in 2005. Ontario was where the biggest increase hit, following 26,516 divorces in 2001 to 28,805 in 2005. Between 2008 and 2009, there has been 56,100 new divorce cases.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Joyner V. Joyner Essay

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Good morning. My name is James Davis, and I am the prosecutor representing Jane Smith, age 36 of Raleigh, North Carolina. Our honorable judge, I trust that you will engage in the entire judging process in a rational, complete way, just as you would as the chief evaluator of any other case under your jurisdiction. After applying relevant rules and significant precedents to our current case, you will undoubtedly arrive at a solution where you will inevitably side with either the husband, the wife, or remain neutral and keep the government out from locked doors and closed curtains. Bear in mind, however, that many precedents in the past may look the same on paper, but are vastly different from what we are due to discuss in this particular courtroom.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Can you imagine being a son and having your hands cut off if you struck your father? Yes this was a thing that happened 4,000 years ago when Hammurabi became king of Babylon in the Fertile Crescent around 1800 bce he claims he got these laws from the god of justice Shamash . Were these laws just? I believe that these laws were just.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Australian Family Law

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages

    TO WHAT EXTENT DOES THE LAW REFLECT MORAL AND ETHICAL STANDARDS OF AUSTRALIAN SOCIETY IN RELATION TO FAMILY MEMBERS? Family law refers to the area of the Australian Legal System (ALS) which is responsible for issues involving family members including domestic violence, divorce, marriage, surrogacy, and equality between de facto and same sex couples. It is of extreme importance that the ALS protects all family members with a main emphasis on the rights and obligations of parents and children. In regards to a reflection of the moral and ethical standards of Australian society in relation to family members, the ALS has displayed effectiveness towards the reform of laws surrounding domestic violence, divorce, and marriage, however, the ALS is…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, held that the dispute over the primary agreement did not prohibit “an application for periodical payments” as it would not be fair on the basis of her contribution being the primary carer of the child; thus an award satisfying the need were settled upon. Therefore, the argument stands, with a change of circumstance a couple especially if there are children cannot be bound to stand by the agreement as it is unlikely the parties would have thought of the future. If one party decides to give up work to be the primary child carer, this would have a big impact on their earing capacity. As a result, even with a prenuptial agreement in place, the principle of fairness would be ignored; ultimately relying on the courts to interpret a suitable financial…

    • 1510 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Canadian family as we knew it has crumbled for the better of society and family life. The improvement of families and society as a whole is shown through Blended families, Adoptive families, and Same-sex parent families Blended families help to improve society and families within the society. An article on the Global Post about single parents says, “You may have to adjust to living on less money than you are accustomed. This can result in juggling bills and possibly working more than one job. Working multiple jobs leaves little time to spend with your child, which could result in the parent feeling guilty” (The Disadvantages of Being a Single Parent & Raising a Child, 2009).…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    R V Labaye Case Study

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This essay will discuss the case of R v. Labaye. A summary of the nature of the proceeding and the judges writing decision, facts, legal issues, the decision, judicial reasoning and a thorough analysis will be addressed in this essay. I prefer the reasoning of the majority decision as it is reasonable and ethical. The nature of the proceeding is an appeal heard from the Supreme Court of Canada.…

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Child Custody Case Study

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages

    CHILD CUSTODY I. THE COURT ERRED IN GRANTING EQUAL TIMESHARING WITH FATHER. Child Custody is regulated by §61.13, Fla. Stat. Under §61.13(3), Fla. Stat. are listed the factors that the court should consider in granting custody in a child custody presiding and the relevant factors in this case are: The demonstrated capacity and disposition of each parent to facilitate and encourage a close and continuing parent-child relationship ..., The length of time the child has lived in a stable, satisfactory environment and the desirability of maintaining continuity, the geographic viability of the parenting plan, with special attention paid to the needs of school-age children and the amount of time to be spent traveling to effectuate the parenting plan,…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Limitations Clause: Halpern v. Canada Over the past decade, the debate on same-sex marriage has been ongoing, but lately people are becoming more open minded about the idea that two women or two men getting married. In the case of Halpern v. Canada [2003], seven gay and denied lesbian couples from getting civil marriage licenses in the City of Toronto. Claiming that the actions of Clerk of the City of Toronto violated their s.15(1) Equal Rights in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, they decided to take the case to the Divisional Courts, where they would decide whether the common law definition of marriage violates the couples’ rights under s.15(1) of the Charter or not and if it is justified by s.1 Limitations Clause of the Charter.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Blair v. Blair Blair v. Blair demonstrates what the material change in circumstances standard means when it comes to modifying spousal support. In this case, the ex-husband petitioned the court to modify the amount of alimony he was paying his ex-wife. The husband reasoned that he had retired and was no longer receiving income from employment. He also claimed that since the time of their divorce, the ex-wife’s income had increased.…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Savitri Bhama

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Plaintiff Savitri Bhama and defendant Rajendra Bhama were married until they got a divorce in 1977, they both are psychiatrists. While married they had two kids together. After the divorce custody of both kids was given to Savitri. Which led to a custody battle between the defendant and the plaintiff. In 1981, custody of both children was given to the defendant.…

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Arguments Against Divorce

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages

    There comes a time in life when a person finds another whom they admire and feel as though they are meant for each other. Acting on their feelings for each other, a couple will find the need to marry and live happily ever after. It’s very rare that a couple will come to find that their instincts of one another are correct and they, indeed, are meant for each other. When it does not work out in a marriage, the best solution is to file for divorce. In 1857, a divorce law was created to allow the general public to file for a divorce.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays