Profiling: Serial Killers

Superior Essays
Profiling has captured the imaginations of Hollywood filmmakers and their audiences for well over a decade. Viewers are easily captivated by Sherlockian detectives who profile perpetrators with brilliant precision, making for bewitching plotlines and intriguing character developments. Yet experts are far more critical of this lasso-like investigative tool. Research suggests that investigators cannot simply walk into a crime scene, construct a profile based on whatever information is left behind, and make predictive observations that will inevitably lead them to the right suspect, as productions like “Criminal Minds” and “Silence of the Lambs” have led many viewers to believe. However, although profiling’s omnipotent abilities are exaggerated …show more content…
John E. Douglas, a retired FBI agent often referred to as “the godfather of profiling,” described BTK as “an equal opportunity killer” who victimized men, women, and children (Douglas and Dodd, 2007). Douglas profiled that BTK was turned on by having a high level of control over his victims, as he tied them up with whatever was available to him. His yearning for fame was reflected in the way he would position his victims’ bodies after the kill — in the fashion of detective magazine covers. Douglas also asserted that BTK’s “ego would eventually lead to his downfall,” encouraging detectives to “stroke his ego in public whenever possible, to give him the respect he craved, in the hopes that he would continue to communicate with them” (Douglas and Dodd, 2007). Yet Douglas’s initial profile analysis in 1979 failed to lead investigators to the killer by the time he retired in 1995, and it wasn’t until BTK resumed communicating with police in 2004 after falling off the grid in the 1990s that Dennis Rader was pinpointed as the man responsible for the horrific crimes. In “The Usefulness of Criminal Profiling,” authors Craig Jackson, David Wilson, and Baljit Kaur Rana state that their main issue with profiling was that Douglas’s claim to “‘delve inside the …show more content…
A 1997 report, “Validity, Utility, and Ethics of Profiling for Serial Violent and Sexual Offenders,” shows that the FBI also made this case nearly two decades ago, reporting success rates “in excess of 80 percent” (Wilson, Lincoln, and Kocsis, 1997). However, the FBI’s claims are inflated. In reality, Pinizzotto’s 1984 study shows that, out of 192 offender profile requests, only 46 percent were found useful to the investigation. Further more, profiling only aided in identifying suspects 17 percent of the time. Rather, what the profiles did was give investigators “a clearer focus…reinforcing [profiling’s] use as a tool rather than a crime-solving technique” (Wilson, Lincoln, and Kocsis, 1997). Profiling’s effectiveness did not fare much better in Gary Copson’s 1995 study into police use of this technique. Out of 184 cases, profiling was deemed helpful only 14 percent of the time and only helped identify suspects in 2.7 percent of cases (“Testing the Assumption of Behavioural Consistency in a New Zealand Sample of Serial Rapists,” Sarah Tapper, 2008).
In “Questioning the Validity of Criminal Profiling: An Evidence-Based Approach,” Pascale Chifflet states that the high accuracy claims by the FBI is “based on little more than unverifiable speculation, as supporting evidence has never been made publicly available” by FBI investigators, who are also generally reluctant to participate in profiling studies

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Criminal profiling is a method used to predict who is committing crimes and plays a role in catching many serial killers. Profiling begins with vague generalizations, which is probably why it is often attacked. In the instance of serial killers, they are commonly a white male who is somewhere in his twenties to forties. While this clearly is not always the case, it is often correct, although this could be attributed to a large part of the population fitting this demographic. However, profilers only begin with these generalizations.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first type of profiling mention in the textbook is behavior profiling, which is associated with the suspect’s assumptions and inferences. Within this profile, the detective relies on the methods and psychological stereotypes to identify the suspect. However, research has shown that this type of profiling is not accurate or helpful when catching criminals (Schwartz, 2016). The second type of profiling found in the textbook is one of the most controversial profiling techniques because is often associated with the suspects’ racial and religious identity. When a detective tries to use this type of racial profiling, they tend to rely on the racial, ethnic and religious stereotypes to identify the suspect (Schwartz, 2016).…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    East Area Rapists

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages

    These advancements have benefited the FBI by providing insights in to criminal psychology and the ability to predict behaviors in a way to enhance investigations and save lives. From interviews with criminals to analysis of their personal belongings, the methods of creating a criminal profile have greatly improved within the BAU. Behavioral analysts have gone from using clues to make guesses about the thoughts and methodology of criminals to using psychology and intensive analysis to make accurate predictions about the identity of a criminal. If investigators in the ‘40s as they do today, perhaps they could have stopped Hitler by predicting his actions rather than waiting for his inevitable…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Accurately measuring the level of profiling presents many methodological issues. Often police organizations rely on the public’s perception as a measure of police efficacy and…

    • 1604 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Criminal Profiling White Paper Ali Wiethe University of Dayton According to Kocsis (2010), criminal profiling is defined as “A forensic technique which seeks to provide investigative agencies with specific information which will help focus attention to individuals with personality traits that parallel traits of other perpetrators who have committed similar other offenses.” Through this definition, it is believed that profiling will help law enforcement officers pursue and interview suspects, because they can narrow in on the right suspects and use interviewing tips for the “type” of suspect being questioned. As a relatively new aspect of criminal investigation, criminal profiling has required several studies in which the accuracy…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Disorganized Profiling

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Organized vs. Disorganized Profiling The main purpose of using organized and disorganized profiling tactics is to establish the basis of the perpetrators personality in order to make a prediction of where they may fit into society when looking for suspects. An organized killer/perpetrator is classified by the FBI as an individual that is non-social, controlling, cunning, and a planner, along with having a smart sense of the law and forensics, making it easy for them to avoid being caught and maintain control. At the crime scene, an organized killer/perpetrator will position the body, will show control in the way they murdered their victim, they will usually purposely clothe the victim or unclothe, and they will have brought the weapon with…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Disorganized Dichotomy

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages

    FBI Criminal Profilers hasn’t established reliable methods of profiling due to their incomplete research on selected subjects and their misconception on criminal development. An example of one of the FBI unreliable methods is their criminal investigative analysis method (CIA). It is the process that identifies an offender’s personality and behavioral characteristics based upon the crime scene (Turvey, 2011). The origin of CIA was developed from the knowledge found in a FBI’s studying group. They conducted a study using a small sample pool to determine whether there were any consistent features across offenses that would help to classify future offenders.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Profiling is used to narrowing down list of suspect. This method cannot solve the case, but develops potential suspects and further investigative follow-up (Hadley, 2005). The profile seeks for the offender’s behaviors, psychological climate, and physical persona.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ted Bundy Research Paper

    • 1567 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Jeffrey Dahmer, Charles Manson, David Berkowitz, John Wayne Gacy, just some of the most infamous serial killers of the 21st century and yet oddly enough, are household names as well. The world is terrified of these names and sometimes shutter at the sound of them, yet fascinated all at the same time. We like to watch their trials and listen to their victims side of the story on the news and even base shows, movies and books featuring their lives and deeds (Why do Americans idolize serial killers?, 2006, para. 4). Unfortunately, these individuals committed very serious and heinous crimes that have helped law officials develop techniques and methods to track down these killers so that they do not become another character in a movie based on their…

    • 1567 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Accuracy of Criminal Profiling As society keeps expanding, through growth and technology, more opportunities for crimes pop up in our daily lives, ranging from internet gambling, all the way to insider trading. But as with any criminal movement, criminal justice is not far behind. Half the battle of fighting crime is knowing what to look for, and the other half is knowing how to stop it. Criminal profiling does both, and being in a generation with James Holmes and The Columbine shooting, there couldn’t be a better time for criminal profiling.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Topic: Psychological Profiling General Purpose: To inform Specific Purpose: To inform my audience about psychological profiling. Central Idea Statement/Thesis: I will discuss (1) what psychological profiling is, (2) the profiling of Jack the Ripper, and (3) the most important uses of psychological profiling. Introduction I. [Attention Getter] Which well-known murderer is not defined as a serial killer? (Pictures of known offenders) II.…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Unfair Lineups Make Witnesses More Likely to Confuse Innocent and Guilty Suspects A lineup is comprised of a suspect who is either guilty or innocent amongst various others who may or may not be in connection to the crime in which are deemed innocent. This article hypothesized how unfair lineups make witnesses more likely to confuse innocent and guilty suspects. This study was orchestrated by Melissa F. Colloff and Kimberley A. Wade in the Department of Psychology and University of Warwick and Deryn Strange in the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, City University of New York.…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jack the Ripper is arguably, the first serial killer to ever be profiled. The Whitechapel murders are infamous in the history of unsolved crimes and whodunit cases. The case of Jack the Ripper was influential in the conception of criminal profiling. Although, it was unsuccessful in the Ripper case, criminal profiling has come a long way since the 1900’s. Originally criminal profiling was considered an art form, however, it is slowly being accepted as a science.…

    • 179 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A more recent approach to profiling will also be investigated to establish whether the problems from previous approaches can be ameliorated: - Investigative (Statistical) Profiling (Canter, 2000) This report will aim to guide practitioners within the criminal justice system (e.g. police) by providing a succinct review of research around the approaches. The approaches should be considered with knowledge of the problems involved and what potential solutions are required to avoid them. The Criminal Investigative Approach: The National Centre for the Analysis of Violent Crime (Formerly known as FBI Behavioural Science Unit) described the Criminal Investigative approach as ‘trait based’ profiling.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Criminal Profiling Introduction Criminal profiling is a terminology coined to put a liable on criminals that commit a range of crimes. It helps give off information in regards to criminal investigations by narrowing suspects, providing tips to unsolved cases, and most importantly identify who the criminal is. This method is widely used amongst investigators, behavioral scientists, criminologists, and forensic psychologists. This process is very valuable to the criminal justice field by eliminating suspects and using the leads to arrest in most cases.…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays