Evaluating King David By David Bosworth

Improved Essays
The article I will be evaluating is “Evaluating King David: Old Problems and Recent Scholarship” by David A. Bosworth. At the time David Bosworth wrote the article he was a Professor at Barry University in Miami Shores, Florida. The article appeared in the Catholic Biblical Quarterly in 2006. The article addresses the controversies of King David. The Books of Samuel have caused the reputation of King David to come under question. The consequences to King David’s reputation have been caused by the way these books are interpreted. Pierre Bayle, an enlightenment philosopher, in an article in the Dictionnaire historique et critique, focuses on David’s moral failures and challenges instead of the traditional interpretation as David being a hero. …show more content…
There are two ways in which Biblical scholars characterize David. The first is the traditional version of David being a good shepherd who become the king of Israel. The second is the critical version with David scheming and murdering to become king of Israel. The characterization of David can be seen in two ways when reading the biblical text, naïve or suspicious. Bosworth points out that both readings of the biblical text are not contradictory. The first version follows the apologetic tone where David is described with good qualities and does not focus on his faults. Both David M. Howard, Jr. and D. F. Payne minimize David’s faults and focus on his good qualities, such as how he repents when he sins. David’s flaws of being deceitful, his actions with Bathsheba and indulgence with his sons cannot be condoned, but he was a good ruler. The naïve reading of David minimizes his flaws and overstates his virtues. Modern interpreters have challenged David being a hero and more of a “Stalin-like tyrant” (Bosworth 2006, 192). The article argues that both portraits of David form a selective reading of the biblical …show more content…
Steussy, whose critical attention is to the aesthetic, literary concerns of the text rather than historical matters behind the text. She identifies in detail how the text compares David and Saul. Her portrait of David is not one-sided as those of Halpern’s and McKenzie. Through these scholars, Bosworth is successful in providing proof of the different characterizations of David. The next claim that Bosworth discusses is the problem of assuming that David murdered his way to the throne. He provides three reasons and is able to provide evidence to back up his claims. Bosworth sums it up by stating “Great leaders have a mix of good and bad qualities. They are motivated by ambition and vision. In order to fulfill their ambitions, they commit crimes, and to realize their vision, they usurp old institutions to build new ones” (2006, 203). The last point he discusses is David compared to other royal figures. His proof is from Walter Dietrich, who examines the parallels to evaluate David’s image. He presents the biblical text of David as consulting with God on decisions to be made and his closeness to Yhwh compared to Saul. He also presents the text where Yhwh condemns David’s affair with Bathsheba. He presents a text that shows his good and bad qualities. These human touches and types of behavior are a standard part of the ancient Near Eastern presentations of royalty. Bosworth, through Dietrich’s comparative study, is able to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Walter Brueggemann essay’s Biblical authority Considered one of the most influential Old Testament scholars of the last several decades, Walter Brueggemann is the author of several books and publications, but our main focus is on the six facets of biblical interpretation he develops and considers crucial. The first facet he talked about was Inherency which describes the fact that people are all equal at church because they share the same engagement and energy concerning the truth said in the Bible. Also, each and every reader should be able to use his or her faith in order to make the difference between good news and lesser claims.…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In his book How to Read the Jewish Bible, Marc Brettler (2005) introduces the reader to the Bible employing the methods modern biblical scholars use to understand the Hebrew scriptures. How successfully he does this depends not only on the content of his book, but also on the intended audience. In order to ascertain how well Brettler accomplished the intended goals of the book, one must first decipher what the goals of the work are. In the preface to the paperback edition of the book Brettler asserts that he wishes to introduce the Jewish Bible to a wider audience than is normally brought into the circle of biblical scholars (Brettler, 2005, vii).…

    • 1779 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. In the opening paragraph, King has a very sarcastic tone but with some respect tied to it. He incorporates sarcasm because the audience knows that he does not have secretaries helping him and the only thing he can do is answer. He includes respect in this very sarcastic paragraph by saying that he does not answer many of his letters but they are “men of genuine good” so King feels it is necessary to respond.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are several main points easily touched upon once read. The audience of David…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    a. The theme of Updike’s story is change because throughout the story, David alters his perspective on the world. b. The point of view is in third person and this impacts the story because you understand how David’s mother and grandmother feel and think. c. David’s dilemma is his misconception of heaven and Jesus. He is constantly changing his perspective on the world and he also has individual changes.…

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Author, musician, and broadcaster, Miles Kington said, ”Knowledge is knowing that a tomato is a fruit. Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad.” This quote defines wisdom and knowledge simply, showing the difference between the two. The use of wisdom adds on to knowledge, not only knowing a tomato is a fruit, but also that it does not go with a regular fruit salad. Chaim Potok, author of The Chosen, writes about three characters, Reb Saunders, David Malter, and Danny Saunders.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Swords, shields, and spears loudly clank against each other as a troop advances on its enemies. Darkness shades the land as it moves forward to strike. It reaches its target, devastating the opponents and putting them to flight far from their own land. The leader of the troop—a man named Abram—retrieves all the spoil left behind by the enemy, rescues his cousin, Lot, and the women who were taken captive (Gen. 14:14-16). He returns south and is met by the distinguished king of Sodom and another, more mysterious king, Melchizedek (Gen. 14:17).…

    • 263 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Malcolm Gladwell’s nonfiction novel David and Goliath, Gladwell twists the stories of so called “underdogs” in an attempt to convince the reader that through manipulation and discernment one can change their trials to triumphs; and although this in and of itself is not false, Gladwell cherry picks specific instances while ignoring any situation contradictory. In reading David and Goliath, one must discern the difference between truth and exaggeration keeping in mind that not every disadvantage is an advantage and not every difficulty is “desirable.” The biblical story of David and Goliath is often told where David is the disadvantaged and Goliath is the advantaged; however, Gladwell points out that this may be a skewed telling of the story.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    David King Oral History

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Oral History Biography: David King David King has been many things over the course of seventy-two-year life. He has studied political science, and law, he has been a father, political activist, chairman, and has even served as the commander of the main battle tank, for the united states army but during all his undertakings he has always been a citizen of East Saint Louis. It was East Saint Louis that shaped his life and career, it has been his love and loyalty for East Saint Louis that has compelled him to use his many talents in services for his boyhood city and community. Over the course of my interview with Mr. King, I learned a great many things, but the lesson I found to be most valuable was the knowledge that there are some problems in this world that are well worth devoting most if not all, of your life to fighting against.…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    English Raleigh Odysseus’s Character Odysseus is truly one of the most brave and courageous leaders of mythology. He is undoubtedly a strong leader as he is in many roles that require good leadership such as a captain, a father, and a husband. We will be examining these characteristics through a biblical perspective. Here we will see how many leaders in the bible go through similar temptations and situations as Odysseus. Many men try to be leaders in various aspects of their lives, but only a few can be noble in doing so.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It was not in the glory of his reign, even though he had his portion of glory. However, his godliness was in his eagerness to accept the will of God and to humble his heart in repentance when he sinned. In addition, the Lord makes four covenants with David. These covenants that are established are a clear picture of a father-son relationship; a relationship that closely resembles what we have with…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    David knew he mattered to God. Many of his psalms were laments. He truly loved God, but struggled to believe him in many ways. He cried out to God when things went wrong. David was said to a man after God’s own heart.…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Both David and the Crooked Man wanted a better life and it caused many problems for David and caused the Crooked man to die a miserable death. The Crooked Man had several character traits that were important to the plot and he demonstrated them throughout the…

    • 1658 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During this time David seeked God in any area he could. David remained a student of God, and remained teachable. Saul was a broken and hurt man that was willing to do the same to the others. This lesson was ordered by God to teach David about brokenness and a humble attitude. With the Lord beside him, David managed to never get angry or acted out because of how Saul was treating him.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Old Testament, a theme that is widely reflected between people and God is obedience. The relationships found throughout Old Testament were based on people’s obedience towards God’s instruction; probably making it one of the most important relational aspect. According to International Standard Bible Encyclopedia, obedience is defined as, “the supreme test of faith in God and reverence for him” (Obedience). God uses many prominent people in the Old Testament who obey and listen to what he calls them to do. For this paper, I’ll be using the story of Abraham as an example of obedience and go more in details about how God used Abraham’s life because he was obedient.…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays