The Worst Mistake In The History Of The Human Race

Brilliant Essays
Jullian Von Barbier
Professor Evans
English Composition
10/25/15
History: From Past to Progress Without historical advances in food or exploration, your life would not be as it is today. These faculties have drastically improved each and every one of our lives and will continue to do so as long as these pillars of civilization are kept erect. Sources that take issue with these topics include Kincaid’s “The Ugly Tourist,” and Diamond’s “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race.” These sources will be looked at critically and their arguments will be analyzed in a way to show that these authors have no merit in their arguments they present in regards to mistakes of mankind. Such important advancements like agriculture have had their
…show more content…
Jared Diamond in his article, “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race,” rattles off many negative implications left by this efficient and still followed practice. He claims that “the diets of hunter gatherers provided more protein and a better balance of nutrients” (Diamond 2). Diamond also asserts that hunter gatherers were more physically healthier before the emergence of producers with multiple health problems such as malnutrition, starvation and the like. Along with these problems, he saw class and gender divisions sprout during the onset of the agricultural revolution (Diamond 4). Diamond claims these issues resulted from the departure from hunting-gathering, but in all fairness, there are many factors that contribute to failures in health and social structures. There is no smoking gun that connects agriculture specifically to the problems Diamond outlines. If one looks at the evolution of human biology over many centuries, overall human health has improved dramatically. The only reason why the standard of health might have dipped with the adoption of agriculture was that it was a change that the human body was not used to, but we have balanced out over time to where today, we enjoy an overall higher standard of living than hunter-gatherers. It is clear that Diamond wants to shift away from producing and pivot back to foraging, but this …show more content…
Diamond and Kincaid are quick to criticize the activities of humans but the authors fail to see that progress betters the future and is not without temporary setbacks which are eventually solved later on. Many of these so called “problems” are only short term and should not take away from how far we have progressed in the area of food production which tremendously helped mankind. As humans, we are imperfect creatures and this quality transcends everything we accomplish. Learning from the past is important because it enables us to improve upon our successes and prevent problems from arising. As far as food production and exploration are concerned, these are aspects of life that improved upon the past by solving problems in the present. Exploration aided in discovery of new food which in turn aided in the creation of agriculture. This is why agriculture and exploration have stood the test of time. Learning from past practices helps to further advance solutions to better our

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    According to the article, “The worst mistake in the History of humans of the Human Race”, by Jared Diamond, he stated that agriculture was the a catastrophe. But according to the article,”Excerpted from Back of History”, by William Howells, he stated that agriculture was one of greatest discoveries Jared Diamond believes that agriculture was a mistake for mankind because “Agriculture came the gross social and sexual inequalities the disease and the despotism,that cursed our existence.” He claims that with the discovery of agriculture bad things started happening to mankind. Jared Diamond asked “Why did almost all our hunters gatherer ancestors adopt agriculture?”, answered “ They adopted it because agriculture is an efficient way to gather…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Intro: Food has shaped the world into what it is in the modern day, and food played a major role in the history of mankind. In An Edible History of Humanity, by Tom Standage, Standage focuses on how food has had an impact of food from when hunter-gatherers were around, to the present day. Standage’s goal is to teach the reader the overall importance of food in our world, more than just what it is to most people now, something that we eat to fuel ourselves, which usually tastes good. He wants to look beyond the eating aspect of the food and tell us the importance of it way before we were alive. His choice of teaching history based on food and food only is quite an interesting idea.…

    • 1762 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In This Fleeting World, author David Christian attempts to cover world history in a mere 120 pages. David divides his book into three periods: the era of foragers, the agrarian era, and the modern era. Within these periods he describes the various lifestyles our ancestors lived in, the advancements achieved, and what ultimately brought upon the succeeding era. In essence, David Christian goal in writing his novel is to filter out the unnecessary jargon in world history and convey a more concise history of humanity (p. XVII). Therefore, I believe David Christian has succeeded his goal of constructing a persuasive argument backed with solid evidence.…

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Scott was the first major proponent of the idea that was referenced in Lanchester’s article. “Against the Grain: A Deep History of the Earliest States,” written by Scott, concludes that humanity's’ downfall begins with the domestication of animals and the agricultural revolution in the late-neolithic period. Agriculture and domestication of animals was not always a bad thing as it allowed for more than one source of food for when one became unavailable. This was before humanity committed to intensive single-crop agriculture, however. After that point, the bones of the single crop producers show evidence that life became worse: they were shorter, sicker, and died at a much higher rate.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Even though we consider ourselves to be a highly advanced society today, I don’t think I can say that we are the better society. What this book has made me realize is that there is never a right way to structure your society that is better than all other societies. Every society is unique and has its share of benefits and drawbacks, including our own. Agrarian societies have complex ecological systems that utilize every last resource. Native American societies only took what they needed from the land to preserve nature as much as possible.…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As explained in his infamous essay, “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race,” Jared Diamond argues that the adoption of agriculture led to many negative consequences that have hindered the general livelihood of humans. His argument is based on the comparison of the lifestyles of agriculture-based societies and hunter-gatherers, claiming that the latter lacked many of the challenging aspects that emerged with the beginnings of domestication and civilization. Diamond’s main points of focus are the negative health effects of people’s new diet, the increased spread of diseases, and the development of societal inequalities. In general, I agree with Diamond’s claim that the adoption of agriculture had some negative effects on humans,…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Industrial farming poses dangers to our health, In Pleasures of Eating, Wendell Berry describes the importance of understanding the connection between eating and the land in order to extract pleasure from our food. When A Crop Becomes King is like Wendell Berry's article, however it focuses on corn and corn production in our food. Unlike the two articles listed above, David Barboza’s article: If You Pitch It They Will Eat It is about the advertisement part of the food industry, and how they manipulate us to buy there products. I agree that Industrial Farming is bad for our health and that this must be fixed or modified to fix eating habits. To grow all this corn we have to use a ton of pesticides to keep animals from eating the crop.…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Farming really changed how human’s lived and how the earth was impacted. As the authors said, “People now construct their own environments; concrete and steel supersede, dirt and trees. Heat exchange devises warm where it is cold and cool where it is hot. We can make water flow in deserts and create breathable atmospheres in the vacuum of space” (Ornstein and Ehrlich 44). The authors were right when they said that humans need to be proud of what they’ve accomplished but there’s a lot of work to be done to keep on accomplishing things.…

    • 1789 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jared Diamond’s article “The Worst Mistake in the Human Race” provides critical insight to what archaeologists and anthropologists alike have contested to be the pinnacle of human advancement. Agriculture to many people among academic settings has been mutually agreed as one of the turning points from primal to civilized (Diamond, 1999); and has been known to benefit humanity for it’s greater good. Jared Diamond challenges this point in his article. He begins by introducing a progressivist view, which is the held notion that agriculture was adopted simply because it is a means of getting more food for less work (Diamond, 1999). Diamond thoroughly explains that there are advantages to agriculture, being that of convenience and mass production…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As society and civilization have evolved, so has the human diet. Due to some revolutionary events that have occurred in human history, like Agriculture Revolution that ended the Stone Age and the Bronze Age which marked the end of Neolithic period, human diet was effected by changes in extraction and distribution of resources. One of the main periods that recorded the radical change was the Industrial Revolution. The progress in technology through many inventions that happened during this period helped the food industry both directly and indirectly. Throughout history humans have been searching to find better, safer and taster food.…

    • 247 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    From gathering and basic stone tools to hunt, to the creation of fire, to fishing, spears and bows, to the creation and then expansion of agriculture and then the socialization, ecological issues, and growth in population that has resulted from all of that, the modern humans diet has diversified and grown over the past two million years. This book is crucial to world history because it is tied into every civilization in every part of the world at any time in history, eating has and always will be a part of human life and that will never change. Ancestral Appetite is a book that goes back two million years ago but can still be understood and made relatable to a reader in the 21st…

    • 1546 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Trapped by the consequences of their own development, humans will desperately look for new ways to counteract factors which stand in the way of either further development, or the viability of the altered society. An example of a factor that would lead to this situation would be full utilization of a resource that was not exploited previously by humans, such as what is being seen in modern oil and gas extraction. As a result, society will try to develop a new technological “saving grace” to ensure the survival of constantly progressing society. Agriculture is described as a “progress trap” because agronomic advances have lessened the human reliance on the provisions of the natural environment, and to instead…

    • 2114 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    (HG) There are many positive aspects of the hunter and gatherer way of life. Hunter and Gatherers had an easier life than we do now. They didn’t have as much stress, they were healthier, they were able to move around freely and there was less sexual inequality. Jared Diamond, who wrote the article “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race” stated that hunter-gatherers worked much less than farmers.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Validity of argument When I think about the continued interest of integrating technology into human evolution, the first thought that comes to mind is chaos that the possibility of a hierarchy of genetically modified people would cause. The fear that Humans would become obsolete, and becoming highly dependent on technology; examples include sending emails rather instead of a letter, human labor is being replaced with machines in sectors like manufacturing with robots. When I think of all the problems that would be eliminated in a world of growing Transhumanism, the progress and the solutions it provides are just too enticing. Because of our need of survival, humans over time have used technology to improve their way of living.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    QUESTIONS: A. Prologue: What is Yali ’s question? Restate the question in Professor Diamond’s words or your own words. Yali’s question is “Why is it that you white people developed so much cargo and brought it to New Guinea, but we black people had little cargo of our own?”…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays