A Definition of Collaborative vs Cooperative Learning Essay

1519 Words Apr 12th, 2011 7 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
A Definition of Collaborative vs Cooperative Learning Ted Panitz (1996) [pic] I have been searching for many years for the Holy Grail of interactive learning, a distinction between collaborative and cooperative learning definitions. I am getting closer to my elusive goal all the time but I am still not completely satisfied with my perception of the two concepts. I believe my confusion arises when I look at processes associated with each concept and see some overlap or inter-concept usage. I

middle of document…

Myers points out some differences between the two concepts:
"Supporters of co-operative learning tend to be more teacher-centered, for example when forming heterogeneous groups, structuring positive inter- dependence, and teaching co-operative skills. Collaborative learning advocates distrust structure and allow students more say if forming friendhip and interest groups. Student talk is stressed as a means for working things out. Discovery and contextural approaches are used to teach interpersonal skills."
"Such differences can lead to disagreements.... I contend the dispute is not about research, but more about the morality of what should happen in the schools. Beliefs as to whast should happen in the schools can be viewed as a continuum of orientations toward curriculum from "transmission" to "transaction" to "transmission". At one end is the transmission position. As the name suggests, the aim of this orientation is to transmit knowledge to students in the form of facts, skills and values. The transformation position at the other end of the continuum stresses personal and social change in which the person is said to be interrelated with the environment rather than having control over it. The aim of this orientation is self-actualization, personal or organizational change."
Rocky Rockwood (National Teaching and Learning Forum vol 4 #6, 1995 part 1) describes the differences by acknowledging the parallels they both have in that they both use
CRAM Exclusive

Related Documents

  • Collaborative Learning Essay

    consideration. Therefore, collaborative learning will establish a sense of understanding on thinking and help students to use this method in their workplace. To sum up, collaborative learning is a new interaction for instructors and students to improve educational community development. It is not only can help students to learn essential social skills, but also assist them to be good workforces for the society. Those students, who are familiar with collaborative learning, can provide a critical

    Words: 1469 - Pages: 6
  • Cooperative Learning Essay

    CL was first developed but Johnson and Johnson believe that the idea of CL is very old, linking it to the Hebrew Talmud and the Roman Philosopher Seneca, who ‘advocated cooperative learning through statements such as, "Qui Docet Discet" (when you teach, you learn twice)’(Johnson and Johnson, retrieved 2010). Cooperative learning can also be traced to Joseph Lancaster and Andrew Bell in the 1700s and through quite a few different ventures in America such as the Common School Movement in the 1800s

    Words: 1165 - Pages: 5
  • Essay on Cooperative Learning

    Next is assigning students to either heterogeneous or homogeneous groups. “When working on a specific skill, procedure, or set of facts, homogeneous groups may be useful. When working on problem-solving tasks and learning how to communicate mathematically, heterogeneous groups are most appropriate” (Davidson 113). Third is planning how long the groups will work together; this depends on the teacher’s preference of whether or not to give the students the opportunity to eventually work with every

    Words: 1507 - Pages: 7
  • Essay Antecedent of Cooperative Learning and Its Outcome

    There are no study linking organizational learning to organizational performance (Jashpara 2003).There are few studies on management elements that facilitate the transfer of knowledge (Molina, Montes & Moreno 2006). This study is an effort to find out how to make the cooperative learning possible in organization and how the cooperative learning affects the organizational outcome. This study is an effort to contribute in a big picture of cooperative learning. As Zarraga and Gracia-Falcon (2003) stated

    Words: 1493 - Pages: 6
  • Essay about Cooperative Learning and Technology Integration

    another way to incorporate both cooperative learning and technology into classroom instruction. Blogs can use both formal and informal cooperative learning strategies. In a formal cooperative learning group the instructor specifies requirements, observes throughout the process, and offers assistance when needed. In an informal cooperative learning group the instructor explains how blogs can be used when working together and then allows pupils to articulate their own learning and engage in discussion with

    Words: 993 - Pages: 4

    302). Positive reinforcement allows the learners to gain a sense of confidence in the work they completed and recognizes the achievement the group made by working together to obtain their goal. The purpose of cooperative learning is to have a group of individuals interact with each other and utilize each member as a resource. Leadership the one social skill required which is not always forthcoming with a group of learners. Motivation is a tool used both by the group to support those would

    Words: 1430 - Pages: 6
  • Learning Styles vs. Academic Performance Essay

    Education. The learning environment is the place where teaching and learning takes place in the most effective and productive manner. It is a product of the physical and psychological as well as social atmosphere created by the interaction between the learners and the one who facilitate the learning (teacher) and among the learner’s themselves. Every individual learner makes their own strategies in learning new things or better understands of facts. The learners’ varied learning styles make them

    Words: 2601 - Pages: 11
  • Essay on Collaborative Technology

    However, few people agree on a solid definition of collaborative technology. An attempt to provide a common framework used to categorize these systems is that of DeSanctis and Gallupe (DeSanctis and Gallupe 1987). This framework identifies four quadrants using a TimefPlace metaphor (See Figure I). Any systems used at different times are often referred to as asynchronous technologies, an example of this would be e-mail where the users send messages at different times, an example of a synchronous

    Words: 4386 - Pages: 18
  • The Art of Collaborative Learning Essay example

    In my personal experience, I had a mentor who I talked with every day after school. He spoke to me like I was an adult and in return; I learned how to have mature conversations with adults. I was already prepared to communicate with people of higher education. My experience shows how a little help from a trusted mentor can help the development of a student’s life. Rose had a chance to communicate with his professors said, “I rang the doorbell and heard steps on a hardwood floor. Mr. Johnson opened

    Words: 924 - Pages: 4
  • Essay on Cooperative Code

    "ART. 4. Cooperative Principles. - Every cooperative shall conduct its affairs in accordance with Filipino culture, good values and experience and the universally accepted principles of cooperation which include, but are not limited to, the following: "(1) Voluntary and Open Membership - Cooperatives are voluntary organizations, open to all persons able to use their services and willing to accept the responsibilities of membership, without gender, social, racial, cultural, political or religious

    Words: 23779 - Pages: 96