Zinn's Argument Analysis

Improved Essays
Zinn´s major argument takes on American History using a heavy view of the Marxist lens, defining Early American History as one of the struggles between the wealthy elite and the poor masses. Zinn goes on to say how the rich were the group who prospered from the war in exchange for the blood and the hardship of the poor. By no means is Zinn wrong in this interpretation, however, in my own opinion, I believe that the American Revolution was a major turning point in a unique way. While the Marxist view of class struggles did not change drastically, there was a profound change within the Socio-economic viewpoint of history, especially in terms of the ideologies of politics and humans. Zinn puts his argument nicely into one sentence, ¨The Founding Fathers...did not want a balance, except one which kept things as they were, a balance among dominant powers at that time.¨ Zinn argues that the Revolutionary War had no true effect on the poor masses except for …show more content…
Much has changed in terms of politics and social issues, such as the birth of an entirely new government system. This birth created an age of revolutions across the globe, creating a new concept of human liberty. That is a big impact from a bunch of little colonies on the eastern seaboard. However, on a closer level of analysis, one can clearly observe the attributes of class issues. The rich still rule over the poor same as under English rule, and practically all minority groups failed to obtain any rights at all, such as women and blacks. Whether the Revolution was a turning point, no human can say for sure. You could say that it led to a turning point in the long run. Perhaps we are still in that turning point. Whether or not we are, the seed of Liberty has been planted into the minds of the many and someday that seed will flower, whether it takes 10 minutes or 10,000

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Workers went from the domestic system to working in factories. The upper classes who owned these factories then hired people to manage their factories, this lead to many people leaving their homes in the countryside and moving into the city. As a result, the middle class was created. This is important because these new changes created a pressure for politicians to change British politics, as the middle…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I agree with Howard Zinn’s viewpoint of objectivity and subjectivity in a way. In Zinn’s excerpt he proclaims how “One, that it’s not possible. Two, it's not desirable”. Zinn was talking about how If you were to take a history book of some sort and start putting certain facts into the book and big ideas it’s already subjective. For a history book, website or museum to be objective it would need to have every fact of every story from every angle of that event.…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He interrupts the American story to explain how historians have lost the rectitude of telling history accurately. Zealous rhetorics about “...the quiet acceptance of conquest and murder in the name of progress...” (Zinn 9) deteriorate Zinn’s argument. These points do not belong in the middle of an account of history and should be saved for the afterword or prelude of the book. By the same token, the obnoxious use of first person in what is supposed to be an unbiased historic work vitiates what is otherwise a compelling argument.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The working class was the poorest of all class, which were factory workers and other low status workers. Also it led to the rise of immigrant. Most of the immigrants came from Europe and settle in major cities like (NYC, Boston, etc.). There were more development in schools and higher education. Few Working class children received education, but they didn’t receive the best one.…

    • 1681 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    European history has obviously a lot of history that build up to modern day Europe. Many turning points in their history has a lot of significances to them, especially during 1789-1791 where the French Revolution occurred. Many events that happened during the French Revolution showed political and social effects. The political effects was the event of the Tennis Court Oath and the . The social effects that happened was the publication of The Declaration of the Rights of Women and the event of the Tennis Court Oath.…

    • 240 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But Some historian like Gordon Wood an Alfred E Young argue that it was revolutionary. They believe that revolution brought a lot of big change other than getting independence (Background Essay). The American Revolution was revolutionary in terms of political independence, but it wasn’t revolutionary socially for groups such as slaves and women's.…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zinn said “that they could not count on the national government. True, this was the “progressive period” the start of the age of reform; but it was a reluctant reform, aimed at quieting the popular risings, not making fundamental changes. (In a people’s history…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The reason why Zinn’s argument is most attracting is because it disproves the American textbook argument with realistic and valid points. For example, the point in which the United States claimed it was joined the war to help defenseless nations can be easily disproved. Normally, it would not make sense for the United States to show empathy for foreign nations when it ignored the Haitian Revolution, the slave struggle domestically in the U.S., and the Armenian genocide in 1915. So why would the United States now, suddenly care for the mass extermination of Jews or the brutal and relenting invasions of minor countries by Axis war powers.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    emotion-regulation motives as potential” describes that, “There could be a connection between peoples mind thinking that they would be aware that texting and driving is dangerous for them but they also argue they in their thesis that texting-while-driving may help to see that relevant targets reduce this dangerous behavior”(856). The author quotes Kabat-Zinn which she suggests that, “Individuals who are mindful in daily life are be expected to place a higher score on being aware of their internal and external present moment experiences and show greater openness to accepting emotional states rather than suppressing them with high-tech distractions”.(856) The author goes into depth about their research and studies to find that young adult…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This revolution in the Americas caused many immigrants to come and to be part of society there. This change in the economy had a huge impact on many minority groups like, Germans who came and played a big role in shaping American society, Irishmen who were able to raise their social status in some cases, women who began to get jobs before marriage and no longer learned to knit, sew, and how to do housework from their mothers, and laborers who lost many rights and had lower income because of the strong economy and manpower availability. It also had a huge effect on work habits of people who began to work the longs days that factory life require, family life which changed from large families from an arranged marriage to a smaller family where the spouses chose each other, class distinction which only had some social mobility at these times, new forms of transportation like highways, steamboats, canals, and most importantly, trains, and consumption patterns which left scattered markets and farms to a network of…

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Supreme Court, as Justice Madison puts it, is the Supreme interpreter of the law, and all laws that are not constitutional must be strike down. Brandeis also thinks this way. He thinks the interpreter of the law has supervisory powers. They must be impartial and not allow a citizen or government official to break the law. If citizens break the law, then the appropriate punishment applies according to the statutes; however, if the government breaks the law, then sanctions applies to uphold the integrity of the law.…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    During the antebellum many economic changes occurred that impacted the American development both socially and politically. The nation that period was going through the industrial revolution, which caused the nation to grow apart due to the north being very industrialized and the south remaining to an agricultural economy. These economic changes impacted both social and political developments because socially, it created gender and education reform, labor unions and politically,caused the americans to enforced laws that benefitted the economy. The Industrial Revolution was the move to new assembling procedures in the period from around 1760 to at some point somewhere around 1820 and 1840.…

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Bruce Batista While there was no tyrannical, violent king that was overthrown like King Louis XVI during the French Revolution, or no oppressed proletariat class that replaced the ruling class like in the Russian Revolution, the American Revolution was still truly revolutionary because it changed nearly every aspect of life for the colonists, and America as we know it today would not exist. There economic, political, and social upheaval as a result of gaining independence from England. The Treaty of Paris was signed on September 3, 1783, and it marked the end of the Revolutionary War. Great Britain had to recognize American independence and gave up the land between the Allegheny Mountains in Pennsylvania and the Mississippi River.…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Between the years 1750 - 1914, the American Revolution, French Revolution, and Haitian Revolution were all similar due to what sparked the revolutions and the social groups during, yet differed in the outcome of the revolutions. Between the years 1750 and 1914 the American Revolution the French Revolution and Haitian Revolution were all similar due to what sparked the revolution. The beginning of the start of these revolutions were mainly due to the over taxation of put in place by political leaders for example Parliament in the case of the British American colonists and King Louis XVI and the nobles in the French Revolution and Haitian Revolution. Over taxation came from the 7 years war in which the British and French fought.…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social Class In Persepolis

    • 1508 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Social classes were still prevalent and the political determinations to change this circumstance was still…

    • 1508 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays