Youth Justice And Reoffending Juveniles

Improved Essays
In 2014 the LNP Government introduced the Youth Justice and Other Legislations Amendment Act which made changes to the legislation surrounding juveniles aged between 10 and 16 years of age. These new amendments have been changed to improve juvenile justice and created a fairer option for minors.
The Youth Justice and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2014 states that the Children’s Court is an open court when reoffenders are admitted. (Department of Justice and Attorney General, 2014) This act allows the court to be held open in a case of a reoffending juvenile. Although the court may be opened for repeat offenders, the court is closed in interest of a complainant or when the victim is giving evidence about sexual offence.
Justice and Attorney
…show more content…
Department of Justice and Attorney general (2014) this act could alter how first time offenders feel and could make the first time offenders commit further crimes in the future because they may have been influenced by other juveniles in the detention centres. This could also make reoffending juveniles commit more crimes as they may not have had a chance to be rehabilitated. But this change could also help the offending juveniles have a life without crimes earlier on because a first time offender could go to a detention centre and be rehabilitated and not commit a second crime. The Queensland Law society states that “The government’s proposal to remove detention as a last resort is troubling, particularly as it states that courts cannot regard this principle in decision making and that this will impact upon the judiciary’s ability to make sentencing orders that are appropriate to meet children’s individual circumstances.” But a recommendation that could be made to improve this amendment would be that only reoffending juveniles go to these detention centres so that first time offenders don’t get influenced by other

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Bechtold and Cauffman argued that youth tried as adults while still considered, youth should not be housed with adults until they actually reach adulthood. Housing young impressionable teenagers in adult prison have the potential to increase criminal behavior in young adults. Youth who are housed with adult offenders are at risk for a host of factors not limited to rape, manipulation, suicide an violence in general (Bechtold & Cauffman, 20014).. Bechtold and Cauffman believe there are specific prototypes that are sent to adult prison over others. Their data reflected those youth who committed violent crime were more likely to transfer to adult facilities to serve time. Their result also looked more specifically at the court systems in which youth offenders receive their sentencing.…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Statistics and research provide a strong prescription for the juvenile system, and its use in these cases can improve society through rehabilitation of young offenders. Though it may emotionally satisfy some, punishing teenaged criminals in the same way their parents would be punished is not a wise or moral choice in society today. New knowledge about the brain coupled with research on recidivism in these cases points society away from this model, revealing it to be antiquated. Society needs a plan of action that works as these crimes increase, rather than an investment in an outdated…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Juvenile Court System

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Secondly, rehabilitation through harsh punishments are more likely to create a greater change in attitude. An article from Aspecsec states, “Spending a few nights in jail can often be a wake up call, causing the Juvenile to make necessary life style changes”. Implementing more serious consequences such as trying youth in adult courts, is likely to cause a direct life style change. These life style changes are crucial in inspiring and deterring fellow youth from committing these nonsensical crimes. Implementing harsh punishments for juveniles within the adult court is an effective way to work towards a solution to lowering overall crime…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The dilemma is whether juveniles are too under developed to receive maximum punishment or if they commit a heinous crime they should receive punishment worthy of the crime. Which is directly related to my question. Appelbaum seems to think that the severity of punishment for minors should be lowered and that we should look into further restrictions on the juvenile court. He suggests more restrictions on the juvenile justice system, to ban the death penalty and life without parole, and to focus on the rehabilitation model. This article seems to be reliable because of its use of facts instead of bias opinions.…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    17 Year Olds Case Study

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Queensland government must change the tougher on crime approach, boot camps, naming and shaming, publishing juvenile crime in adult courts, allowing the public into the children’s court and sending 17 year olds to adult correctional centers have demonstrated unsuccessful in reducing juvenile crime. The Queensland government needs to change its approach by examining alternative approaches juvenile offenders. An approach to reducing youth crime could be instead of spending the money sending 17 year olds to prison they could invest into implementing early rehabilitation programs that could assist youths in getting jobs, helping them with substance abuse, helping them with their family issues and encourage education among juvenile offenders. If these programs are implemented early then it will positively affect the behavior of the juvenile, before it deteriorates any further. If the problem is resolved at an early stage, then the crime rates will reduce not only for juvenile crimes but adult crimes because if the juvenile has support early then they will not carry on in criminal activity in later life.…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Adult minds are more mature therefore, they are more likely to think about the consequences of their actions and behaviors. It is stated in the International Journal of Adolescent Medicine and Health (2015) there is a great quantity of proof that in many ways, youth who commit crimes are dissimilar to adults who commit crimes. In the United States of America, the age for criminal court control differs from state to state. The justice system for juveniles was initially established to restore the offenders back to normal life and reform the offender rather than punish him or her. It was outlined so they could find stability.…

    • 1817 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The juvenile justice system is no different. A positive attitude towards the juvenile justice system would include that with sentencing the young offender with the right punishment could help deter them from making any more criminal acts as they age. Although, this thought also brings along a flaw. A juvenile with a too hard or too little sentence could cause a negative effect. If the juvenile is sentenced too hard, they could face many mental disorders from the trauma experienced.…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many victims in a sex abuse case are being deprived of these rights and not enough people are trying to change that all. If they were then a changed would have happen by now, more inmates will feel safer and less like that they are targets to rape and assault. Think about the victim for once, it’s like police press the issue for a victim to report rape, but the end result may be they walk away from a crime that 's committed. The journal Crime Victims’ Rights During Criminal investigations, states ,” if prosecutors work out a no prosecution agreement with an offender, they will have to notify his victims of what they are doing or the fact of that potential charges will never be…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Arlington Teen Court, defendants are assessed by the jury and sentenced to community service hours or a set number of jury terms for their offense. In addition, the judge may order additional sanctions such as: an apology letter, essays, theft intervention class, counseling, anger management, or a drug intervention class to complete. One of the many benefits teen court offers to offenders, is the opportunity to address illegal behavior early on. Typically, formal juvenile justice systems are unable to hold youth offenders accountable due to lack of time and resources, and the seriousness of other crimes committed (Godwin, 1998). Another advantage of teen court is its restorative justice approach.…

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is a debate between the verdict of whether or not juvenile convicts should have a life with or without parole. A child is not an adult therefore their actions should not justify the way they are tried in a court. If a jury is reluctant to give minors the same rights as adults, it would be inequitable to try them as an adult. In lieu of spending millions of dollars to keep an adolescent incarcerated, the parole board can assess one after they have matured into adulthood and decide whether it is appropriate to return to society. Many cases have been accidental, therefore if one did not deliberately commit a crime they deserve another chance.…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays