The Negative Effects Of The Winner-Take-All Method

Improved Essays
In the current US election system, citizens do not directly vote for their next President. Instead, there is a group called The Electoral College that carries out that function. Citizens Cast their votes and then those votes are tallied up by state. Once tallied, the Electors, also known as Representatives, of the states go and place their votes. Each state has a certain amount of electoral votes placed by those electors. Whoever those Electors vote for is to whom all the electoral votes of that state count towards. This is known as the Winner-Take-All method. In the end, whichever candidate has the most electoral votes wins the election, regardless of whomever had the majority of the popular vote. If neither has the majority of electoral …show more content…
The spoiler effect is caused when a candidate loses a state that he or she should have won. This is caused when supporters of a third party decide to vote for the third party candidate instead of going with one of the two main party candidates that had similar political views. This draws votes away from that candidate, allowing the other major candidate to win. One major example of this is the Gore versus Bush election of 2000. According to Gary Bugh, in the 2000 election, Nader received around 90,000 votes in Florida, which resulted in George Bush winning Florida (51). Bugh also stated, that if the citizens who voted for Nader would have voted for their second choice, which would have been Al Gore, that Gore would have won Florida (51). The same thing happened in the state of New Hampshire that year. According to Robert Dudley, who has a Ph.D. in Political Science, and Eric Shiraev, who has a Ph.D. in Political Psychology, Bush had beaten Gore by only around 7,000 votes (141). Later on Dudley and Shiraev said that according to the polls 8,000 of the 22,000 who voted for Nader would have voted Gore before Bush (141). Many times by voting a third party, these citizens end up voting in a candidate farther from their views than their second choice (Bugh, …show more content…
The first way this may happen is that although one candidate may have received a majority of the popular vote, neither may have received the majority of the electoral vote. This means that the House of Representatives would choose between the candidates and they do not have to choose the candidate with the majority of the popular votes. According to Bugh, the 1824 election of Jackson versus Adams was the first occurrence of this (48). In this election, Jackson had more popular votes but neither had the majority of electoral votes (Bugh, 48). But instead of choosing Jackson, who had the majority of the popular votes, the House of Representatives chose Adams (Bugh, 48). Another way a wrong winner could be elected is if the candidate wins the majority of electoral votes, but not win the majority of the popular vote. Thus, a majority of the people may have actually wanted one candidate, but the other candidate would win. According to Lawrence Longley, a presidential scholar and political scientist, and Neal Pierce, an American journalist on local government, a wrong winner has been elected three times as of 1999

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Ronald Reagan received 50.7% of the popular vote, and won the presidential election by collecting 91% of the electoral votes. This big margin of difference shows how the electoral college does not accurately show what the people want. States like Idaho that have a population of over 1.5 million people will only get 4 electoral votes, making their opinion in the presidential election extremely small. George C. Edwards states in Document D that “the electoral college violates political equality. It is not a neutral counting device..…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Electoral College Dbq

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There are two different types of elections, a direct election, and a divided election (“Types of Voting Systems”). In a direct election, every voter’s vote counts as one. If a candidate receives a majority, or more than half, of the popular vote, then they would win. The voter’s vote would then count for one out of the total number of the population. In a divided election, the candidate needs to obtain a majority of votes, from the most states.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most electors from the states vote on the winner take all based on which candidate won their states election. That means the candidate that wins the most citizen votes from their state will then get all of the electoral votes from that…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Voting In New Mexico

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The citizens living there, wouldn’t have much say in who they vote for, for the state’s electoral votes don’t really make an impact as big as the swing states. The election process is lots of work. They have to change the amount of electoral votes a state had every so often because the population and the amount of representatives change. They have to have exactly 538 electoral votes in all, so when all the electoral votes from each state are added up, it would equal that amount.…

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The electoral college has made up our nation's election system. There are 538 electors in the United States. How it works is, if the nominee wins the majority vote, then they win the electoral vote for that whole state. The electoral number is based on the number of representatives and senates that state has. The electoral college should change because the citizens of America should count each vote, give the larger states more electoral votes, and by making sure there are no illegal actions taking place.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At the point when Americans vote in favor of a President and Vice President, they are really voting in favor of presidential electors, referred to all in all as the Electoral College. It is these voters, picked by the general population, who choose the President. The Constitution allocates every state a number of electors equivalent to the combined total of the state's Senate and House of Representatives commission at present, the quantity of electors per state ranges from three to 54, for a sum of 538. Individuals really vote in favor of a group of electors when they go to the voting polls on Election Day. These electors have agreed to support a party's nominee chosen for president.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Popular Vote Dbq

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Many Americans today say that they do not vote because their vote does not matter, and while others may oppose this view, people should truly ask their self if their vote does really matter? There are two different votes that come into play with each presidential election. They are the Electoral College and the popular vote. Popular vote is the number of actual individual votes that each candidate receives from American citizens. The Electoral College is a body of representatives from each state who make the decision on which presidential candidate will receive their states votes.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College, as stated above, is a system used by the United States government that allows an indirect election of the president. Each state has a specific amount of electors, and each elector votes for whomever…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Title: The Electoral College is Failing and should be Abolished Every four years, Americans elect a president and vice-president. Voters are not given the rights to vote directly for the presidential candidates. They actually vote for an elector in their respective state, who had pledged to cast a ballot on voters’ behalf in the election that actually chooses the president. This voting system is called the Electoral College.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If I were to choose to establish a twenty-eighth amendment, it would be the removal of the Electoral College. The founding fathers established the Electoral College as a compromise between election of the President by a vote in Congress and election of the President by a popular vote. Each state is given a specific number of electors based on the number of its United States representatives and senators. This allows for over-representation of small states and under-representation of large states, while the winner-takes-all format followed by most states could result in a candidate winning the popular vote but losing the election. This has occurred on various occasions.…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every four years, citizens of the United States of America choose their next president based off a unique system known as the electoral college. The way that this system works is interesting and is confused easily in the general public. In early November, when citizens go to the polls, they are not voting for the president directly, rather they are voting for their individual states to cast its electoral votes towards a certain presidential candidate. In the forty-eight of the fifty states where voting takes place, all the electoral votes go to the presidential candidate who wins the majority in their state. No matter how large or small the majority is, the presidential candidate gets all the votes.…

    • 1924 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The electoral college is an indirect way of voting. Americans do not directly vote, but choose from “slates of electors” that have been chosen many months before. “A group of electors who formally select the president of the United States” (Lowi and Ginsberg 253). Those chosen electors have to support a certain political party. Whichever political party or slate receive the most popular votes, also receive the electoral…

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Voting in a presidential election is one of the key duties of a citizen in the United States, but the method for choosing the president is outdated and unnecessary. The current method, the electoral college system, contains various flaws that can be solved by changing the voting system. In the electoral college system, there are 538 electors in total. This number comes from the 438 members of the House of Representatives, and the 100 members of the Senate. Each state gets one elector for each senator it has, and at least one to 53 more electors based on population.…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The winner of the popular vote in that state receives all of the electoral college votes for that state. The magic number of votes is 270. If no candidate reaches 270 votes, the decision of President and Vice President will go to Congress. The House of Representatives will choose the President of the United States. The…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Controversy has been raised recently over whether the deciding factor of who is to win the United States presidency should be the votes of electoral college or popular vote. The United States Constitution, population of the states, and election fraud give valid reasons as to why Electoral votes are counted in the elections instead of popular vote. Popular vote is based off of the opinions of each individual person in the United States. The Electoral College is made up of Electors from each state that are put into office by voters in each state.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays