Why Killer Whales Should Be Kept In Captivity Essay

Improved Essays
SeaWorld of Hurt
The growing argument over if killer whales should or should not be kept in captivity is becoming more widespread and well-known, simply because of attractions like SeaWorld and improving technology that extend further opportunities for research. The first article Why Killer Whales Shouldn’t Be Kept in Captivity by the SOS Dolphins organization, written August 7th, 2017, portrays an argument over the negative effects of using Orcas on display in captivity. The second article Research Helps Wild Whales from the SeaWorld Cares entertainment organization, written in March 2017, explains the reasoning their efforts in captivating these Orcas and furthering research. While the both articles cover the same topic, Why Killer Whales
…show more content…
SeaWorld is trying to convey their purpose for their extensive research and how their care is beneficial to killer whales and guests that attend SeaWorld, but the first article immediately gives in depth factual evidence of how negative captivity naturally is. In the first paragraph of the first article, it is stated that “…killer whale research we conduct has direct benefit to science”, but people who are looking for the care of these animals are not given enough examples, specifically, on how SeaWorld can provide a steady environment (Research Helps). On the other hand, SOS Dolphin organization opens up with factual evidence that broadens the readers thinking. When deciding on what is better for killer whales vs what is not, the first articles allows natural thought process to occur when reading. The audience is looking for an answer. SOS Dolphins provides that when stating that” Killer Whales are energetic and dynamic animals. Gifted with a high emotional intelligence, their life is based on family and social relations…” (Why Killer Whales Shouldn’t). They use a technique that pulls on their hearts of when writing to pursued all ages of audience; which is much more …show more content…
For example, in the paragraph about mortality, it is said that “[t]he levels of mortality of these animals in captivity are 2.5 times higher than in nature…” then that is followed up with explanations that is based on information about killer whales on what is needed for their health to be positively impacted (Why Killer Whales Shouldn’t). While in the second article, SeaWorld bases their claims mostly on hope for furthering research. There isn’t a “now” factor that gives inspiration like the first article, because SeaWorld apparently cares more about scientist and conservationist rather than the actual future well-being of killer whales. When in the paragraph about “Understanding the Life History of Killer Whales” SeaWorld explains that “Those insights are critical to understanding the reproduction and development of whales in the wild, where these patterns would be virtually impossible to study” then directly address how it positively impacts scientist and conservatives. The audience would question the “why” putting killer whales at risk for further endangerment. Although, when reading the first article, everything is directed towards the well-being of these animals, rather than simply furthering research. SOS Dolphin also gives history that shuts down most of SeaWorld’s ideas. The history of attacks like “…at

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Killer Whales Captivity

    • 1864 Words
    • 8 Pages

    If the handlers were abiding to animal welfare standards, it would have been more appropriate to euthanize her 2. While the reports of sick killer whales being denied treatment may very well be true, it is also possible that they were assumed to be in good health until they died9. Unfortunately, finding actual vet records for these animals proved impossible. Since these examples were found on the internet, their information should be taken with a grain of salt. Regardless of the validity of the accusations pertaining to the appropriateness of the care of the killer whales, it is clear that several killer whales kept in captivity have fallen ill…

    • 1864 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whales and Dolphins in Danger In 2007, a film called “The Cove” was released revealing the savage hunt of dolphins in Taiji, Japan. In 2013, “Blackfish” was released, revealing the monstrosities of keeping killer whales captive at SeaWorld. Both films received award nominations and massive media attention for their call to action and revelation of the endangerments of marine mammals. However, there are so many more dangers to whales and dolphins than just dolphin slaughter, or circus shows at SeaWorld. This paper will cover the threats to these marine mammals, and why the world should care about their endangerment.…

    • 2256 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With having a biologist that specializes in sharks support Stewart’s facts and main points, this makes the documentary much more believable and credible. Rather than just speaking of past studies though, Stewart also takes the documentary to the Galapagos Island, where he produces a live study on hammerhead sharks just for his documentary. While filming for his movie underwater, he shows the audience how hammerhead sharks are actually afraid of humans. Whenever he would approach with his camera, they would shy away until they began to trust him enough to let him film. Doing a live study just for his documentary makes him even more credible, because it actually visually proves his facts, rather than just him speaking facts to the camera.…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If oceanarias are worried about losing profit they could try redesigning orca enclosures to satisfy a Killer Whales’ needs better (Rose, 10). However, for change to happen it needs to bring attention to the media and public. Raising awareness of the dangers of captivity is surfacing more, documentaries like The Cove and Blackfish showed the public what really is going on to these creatures. Due to those films SeaWorld’s profits have dropped and more companies have broken ties with them. Slowly it is becoming accepted that Orcas cannot live in their current tanks, in the future they could have a better living condition whether in a marine theme park or in the…

    • 1064 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “SeaWorld reported that a trainer slipped and fell into the water and drowned.” Then eye witnesses reported that this was not how it happened and they switched their story to “that the killer whale pulled her in the water...” (Blackfish). The lies that SeaWorld used at first to explain what had happened reveals that they put in effort to come up with stories that will fool the public so their name will not lose its reputation. After fixing the original story they chose to bring the blame on her saying her pony tail is what caused the orca to be aggressive. “The film, however, does blame Ms. Brancheau, and it accomplishes this through former trainers with little or no relevant experience” (TRUTH ABOUT BLACKFISH). By switching the story many times after the witnesses came out with the truth shows they will say anything to make SeaWorld a good place.…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The greater risk that is promoted with everything and anything that is involved with their health. Not only is their health decreased when taken out of the wild, but their life expectancy is as well. An author who studied killer whales in captivity was able to claim that their life seems to be shorter when being captive, “Large carnivorous orcas do poorly in captivity, dying at young ages. Kirby notes that orcas at SeaWorld die at a rate two and a half times higher than orcas in the wild. And they can lash out at their trainers, with fatal results.” (PALMER, 55) So from the big scheme of things, not only are the whales lives in danger, but the trainers who attempt to domesticate these animals are in danger at all times as well.…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mannina states mostly facts with topics such as: The Role of Public Display Facilities, The Value of Education, Teaching the Importance of Conservation, and The Need for Research. These topics do not make the reader feel compelled to go out and help these animals like the WDCS does. One emotional appeal that the WDCS uses is when the parks say ¨whales and dolphins in captivity have forgotten how to live in the wild¨ (page 204) and the WDCS comes back and says ¨Whales and dolphins are intelligent creatures, if they can learn tricks that aren't necessary for survival then they can learn how to be wild again.¨ (page 204) Another emotional appeal is when the park says ¨our animals are happy¨ (page 203) and the WDCS comes back with ¨dolphins have a natural smile on their face, they also die smiling.¨ (page 203) These emotional appeals make the reader feel sorry for the animal and maybe make the reader feel wrong if they have participated in watching captive marine…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The experts bring up the fact that at Sea World employees are told to say, “Killer whales in the wild live a shorter life than in captivity” (Blackfish). While in captivity, killer whales only live to be around the age of 30 (Blackfish). According to one of the experts in the film who is an OSHA expert witness and whale researcher, Dave Duffus, he says, “Killer whales that live their life in the wild have the same life span of humans” (Blackfish). By using someone who has experience in this specific field, the director shows that Sea World will lie about how long the whales are supposed to live to make Sea World look good. She shows that Sea World wants the world to believe that they are the best option for the whales and that the whales are safer in captivity.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They present their claims and back up the argument through video clips where whales evidently attack their trainers in a moment of aggression. Their stance is not challenged but criticized for the lack of variety in point of view and one-sidedness that is strongly found throughout the film. They fail to acknowledge the veterinary care provided to them and the fact that Seaworld has rescued thousands of animals over the years. However, the sources do agree with most claims presented by the documentary despite the exaggeration of human importance on whether a whale should be held captive or…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also, the whaler that captured Tillikum is interviewed, and he says that the male whales stayed by the nets to try and help their families escape. This scene shows just how intelligent and aware the killer whales are. The interview of the whaler that captured Tillikum is an important ethos found in this movie because he was there on the day that Tillikum was captured, and he saw the emotions and actions of all of the whales in person. This influences the viewer to better understand just how smart the killer whales are and the problems of keeping the killer whales in small environments away from their…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays