In this essay we will discuss the topic about why Adnan Syed is not Guilty and should be considered a re-trial. Adnan Syed should be given another trial because of his innocence was not proven correctly and the case was just unfair. The evidence that backs this statement and claim is the Call Logs, Jay's testimony/interviews and Best Buy/Timeline/Covering. The first Piece of evidence to introduce is the call logs. The call logs did not match the states timeline nor Jay’s perspective on the timeline how he told the story. If the call logs did not match the timeline how was the police to get hard evidence like Hae’s Car. If they dont matter how can they say Adnan is guilty the timeline can prove his innocence because the incoming/outgoing calls on January 13th are nowhere close to the states timeline. Furthermore, how did Jay know where Hae’s car was and not Adnan.
…show more content…
Best Buy is supposedly stated by Jay that Adnan killed Hae and called from a payphone to pick him up. Timeline is the timing of how the day went. Covering is why Jay wiped the shovels and threw away the clothes. Sarah Koenig looked at the Blueprints of the Bestbuy and there was never a payphone there. The timeline of Jay story does not match with call logs and the day described. There is too much leisure time in the way Jay has described the timeline. Also, if Jay is telling the police that he is innocent and Adnan is guilty why wipe the fingerprints and throw the clothes away. The payphone must’ve been somewhere else. Jay probably forgot how the day went for there to be leisure time. He probably did not want to be involved in the first place and did not want to go to the cops at first. Rebuttal Conclusion: If the payphone where to be somewhere else why not mention the place where it was. The amount of leisure time for the day is to suspicious on Jay’s side. The timing of it was very non parallel with the call
Best Buy is supposedly stated by Jay that Adnan killed Hae and called from a payphone to pick him up. Timeline is the timing of how the day went. Covering is why Jay wiped the shovels and threw away the clothes. Sarah Koenig looked at the Blueprints of the Bestbuy and there was never a payphone there. The timeline of Jay story does not match with call logs and the day described. There is too much leisure time in the way Jay has described the timeline. Also, if Jay is telling the police that he is innocent and Adnan is guilty why wipe the fingerprints and throw the clothes away. The payphone must’ve been somewhere else. Jay probably forgot how the day went for there to be leisure time. He probably did not want to be involved in the first place and did not want to go to the cops at first. Rebuttal Conclusion: If the payphone where to be somewhere else why not mention the place where it was. The amount of leisure time for the day is to suspicious on Jay’s side. The timing of it was very non parallel with the call