What's Wrong With Cinderella Summary

Improved Essays
In Peggy Orenstein’s article, “What’s Wrong with Cinderella?” she states that the princess story is only doing damage to young girls and women. Orenstein discusses her encounters with the princess wave and how she observes it affecting her daughter. As a mother and a feminist, Orenstein feels as if it’s her duty to rescue her daughter from becoming trapped in the princess mindset. Peggy Orenstein illustrates her claim with the endless pink, princess, and sparkles offered to her daughter. She discusses the common standards that fairytales have placed on females and how they have transferred their way into a way of life and thinking. Orenstein continues to point out the pressures Cinderella provides, but fails to acknowledge how girls now seem …show more content…
Fairytales send subliminal messages to young girls that they must look and act certain way to be worthy of a man’s attention. These tales teach girls that finding a manpage 3 is the answer to all of their problems. Orenstein uses diction such as “conventional” and “perpetual” to illustrate her point that these beliefs are all too common and never ending. She indicates that this way of thinking is not only common in princess movies, but is seen in various children movies, stores, and even in adult television shows. The popular TV show, “Sex and the City,” Orenstein claims, is a prime example of these conventional beliefs. The protagonist is fearful of “losing male love, of not having children, of being deprived of something…female”(page 4) While some may argue that fairytales don’t hold all the blame for creating these standards, they are the root of the problem. The fairy tale phase doesn’t end when girls outgrow them, they take a new form. Magazines plastered with headlines such as “50 Ways to Wow the Man of Your Dreams,” or “Shrink Your Waist in Just One Week!” are on every shelf proving that these princess standards never seem to stop. Fairytales establish what it means to be female. The obsession with Ariel, Cinderella, and Belle may fade as girls grow older, but the same morals will follow them in the new phases they grow …show more content…
When Peggy Orenstein wrote this article, things could’ve been different. At that time, princesses generally had aryan features and the stories usually ended in the girl finding love. However, now we have new princesses that stray from the classic aryan features that past princesses displayed. Movies starring girls with nationalities including African American to Hawaiian are now present in the Disney princesses. Disney has even begun creating movies where the princess is unconcerned about finding male love. For example, Disney’s Frozen is about the love of two sisters rather than the typical romance. The common beliefs that were created by fairytales are slowly, but surely being broken. Even Peggy Orenstein’s own daughter, is making strides away from the conventional beliefs about what it means to be a female. She adds after she finishes gushing about Ariel, yet another disney princess, that she wants to become a fireman when she grows up. Perhaps we haven’t fixed the entire problem of the suffocating definition of a woman, but as a generation, we have made strides into solving this

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Peggy Orenstein’s point is that she is expressively disappointed on how today’s society labels young girls wanted to be girly, princesses, ext. She gives many examples that have happened to her daughter. She states that multiple people had called her daughter princess, been given a pink balloon without her having any say in what color she wanted. Labeling her as the “Ideal” female child by today’s standards. Mrs. Orenstein then continues that it’s not only towards female girls but to boys as well.…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While Poniewozik argues that modern princess movies teach children how to be strong and independent and are ultimately good role models, Orenstein expresses her opinion on non-princess characters becoming more feminine and why it is teaching girls the wrong ideals. Poniewozik spends a majority of his article portraying recent princess stories as a perfect contrast between fantasy and feminism, in hopes of showing other feminists why they do not need to be cautious when it comes to modern princesses influencing their children in today’s society. Poniewozik writes “it’s not the girl who must prove herself worthy of princesshood; princesshood must prove itself worthy of the girl” (Poniewozik 325). To Poniewozik, this depicts how modern princesses have transformed into role models for girls, teaching them that they can choose to be whatever they set their minds to. When comparing the two authors, Orenstein takes a very different approach to princesses and role models.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Toddlers In Tiaras Summary

    • 1712 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Beauty standards are a common struggle in girls and always have been. Throughout the years the standards have changed, and they are now becoming more prominent in young girls. Research has been done, and it has shown that young girls no longer want to do “little” girl activities; but want to change their looks, wait for their prince charming, and become big girls. Stephanie Hanes, with a background in play therapy, wrote an article concerning Disney Princesses effects on young girls. Hanes has a young daughter who is not herself anymore because she “is waiting on her prince”; a concerned and confused mother is able to create an article pointing out her research on what has changed in her three year old daughter, and it all comes back to Disney…

    • 1712 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He discusses how Hollywood feeds into the princess craze by continuing to release princess related movies. However, he claims that today’s modern movies have made their female characters less dependent on men and more individual and confident in themselves, unlike the older princess movies. Even though these movies end with the girl getting the guy at the end, he claims that girls are okay with it because the movies are balanced with “varied depictions of young women” (Poniewozik 667). He states that even though these movies are taking a step into feminism, they are still setting standards for girls.…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These younger generations of girls/ladies have learned that not only can they be a princess and look beautiful both inside and out, but they are strong young ladies that have the world at their finger tip. This generation can become whatever their hearts desire as they increase their learning and social involvement. Parents should take it upon themselves to discuss with their children the visual display that is exposed by media such as Disney’s Princesses and today's modern idols; because their child might be going through the discovering phase or like Orenstein's daughter understands that, being a princess is a phase, but being a fireman is for…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The stories such as Cinderella and tales you’re told or read to that give the sense of goodness in life that no matter what in life you’re dealt with such as being poor or treated different does not define you. It symbolizes in American culture how you handle and carry yourself, by being polite, honest, having the strength, power, and will to go on and not giving up. Fairy tale, happily ever after is what woman look forward too. Prince charming comes to the rescue; saving her from our cruel and sad world. (Gibbons, Kaye)…

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fairytales’, being around for several generations, have evolved through time and caught the attention of many folklorists, and demands an explanation of how feminism plays an essential role in today 's culture. Folklorist and author, James Poniewozik wrote, “The Princess Paradox” to raise an attempt to explain the “girls-kick-ass culture” (323). Peggy Orenstein published, “Cinderella and the Princess Culture” to examine and identify the belief of feminism within fairytales. Even though two different authors studied and evaluated the same topic, being feminism in fairytales, their approaches and conclusions on the topic tend to differentiate slightly, but also come to an agreeance in other areas.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The original version provide a narrower outlook on the story and can easily set up unrealistic expectations for young girls. This change alters the theme from good conquering evil to a story between a mother and daughter. As part of Maitland’s new theme, she promotes a feminist message within her version of the fairytale. This allows her to establish a moral with a larger meaning. Because of this version, more people can come to the realization that there is a far greater “happily ever after” for the princess who doesn’t wait around for the prince to come sweet her off her feet, but instead who is strong enough to provide herself with her own happy…

    • 2228 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Almost all girls have either seen or have heard the “Cinderella” story before. Being a princess has been most girl 's dreams as a child, but little do they think about the theme and the message the “Cinderella” story creates. Elisabeth Panttaja, professor from Tufts University and author of the article “Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior,” explains a theme that people may find unsettling because she claims that Cinderella and the prince may not have been in love. She hints at the fact that Cinderella’s mother may have been the culprit in scheming and seducing the prince into marrying her.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is mentioned how a mother hates the idea of Disney princesses for multiple reasons and how they are surrounding her daughters life in an awful way. Some of the reasons given in the article I have seen mentioned before and entirely agree with even though as a child I was a fan of princesses and dolls. One of my personal favorite inaccuracies with Disney princesses is their dependence. Disney has given each of their princesses a dependence on men, whether it be their fathers or the man they “love” in the story, the princess has to be saved by a man. First of all, a woman can have just as much strength and independence as a man can and certainly can survive without one, as many woman have.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A classic princess story, Cinderella remains to be one of Disney’s most popular movies. However, what is disturbing is the manner in which this movie imposes gender roles by depicting women in a negative manner. This film seems to be reinforcing the notion that women are weaklings and that the only way in which any society can survive is by upholding male dominance and embracing female submissiveness. The movie begins by showing Cinderella living happily with her parents in a faraway kingdom.…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Responding to the Critic’s idea: Young girls tend to imagine and dream of being whisked away by a charming and wealthy prince because of fairytales like Cinderella that show and encourage it. I agree with Jack Zipes’ analysis on the decisions that women in fairy tales make. This supports the fairytale Cinderella and the decision that Cinderella made. Jack Zipes says that “comic endings call upon young females to value communal stability over individual needs.” meaning that the women in fairy tales made the decision to chose communal stability which is marrying a wealthy and handsome prince instead of individual needs, which is being an independent woman who looks after herself, provides her herself and creates her own wealth instead of…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Perrault version of Cinderella Vs the Grimm brothers’ version of Cinderella. “Fairy tale” is the term also used to describe something containing unusual happiness, like “fairy tale ending” a happing ending, or “fairy tale romance”, though not all fairy tales have a happy ending. According to Arthur Schlesinger, classical tales “tell children what they unconsciously know-that human nature is not innately good, that conflict is real, that life is harsh before it is, happy-and thereby reassure them about their own fears and their own sense of self” (229). Despite the fact that both Perrault and the Grimm brothers versions of Cinderella are fundamentally similar to each other, but the differences between them show two different moral universes.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyone knows the famous story of Cinderella. In 1950, Disney produced the animation of this story, and it became the most famous version of the story (Corliss 54). Just like any other artworks, the animation Cinderella sends hidden messages throughout the story. The messages perpetuate the gender roles and stereotypes. One way to analyze the gender roles and stereotypes is by addressing the class identity.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Cinderella Research Paper

    • 2157 Words
    • 9 Pages

    “Cinderella is considered one of the most influential because we like Cinderella not because of her character traits, but by what she receives in the end for being kind and compassionate. We wish that Cinderella’s story was actually true, but in reality, we know that Cinderella was never never really a fairy tale, but a myth” (Baum). Cinderella is only a story of what we all want to be true, but sadly, it is not. “We discover that the way to win a prince is over the ugly bodies of our competitors, who are similarly trying to cut our throats. Beauty on its own is not enough: you have to be seen by the right people.…

    • 2157 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays