What's The Matter With College Analysis

Good Essays
Overtime, college has adjusted to an infinite number of changes. To the point where every year something is different than the last. Many wonder if college is worth the time and money at this point. Accordingly from two different generations, Rick Perlstein wrote “What’s the Matter with College?” and Liz Addison composed the essay, “Two Years are Better Than Four” to debate the college experience, who the college market is directed to, and the overall value of college to American society, which depicts how much college has changed in effectiveness throughout the years. While the college experience is different for everyone, both writers have distinct ideas as to what a student’s experience entails during their time at college. Perlstein …show more content…
Perlstein elaborates that college is depicted as a place for 18 years olds where they can discover themselves as well as in a “mystic” environment, but he knows this is a false image that colleges use to entice people to apply. So when Perlstein posed the question to a student he knew, they replied “They’re assuming the market is for students, it’s not. It’s for parents” (Perlstein). In the same way, many students only attend college as a result of their parents, because those parents decide their children’s future career. Nevertheless Addison replies, “This college brochure is not marketing for the parents-because the parents, nor grandparents, probably never went to college themselves” (Addison 212). More recently, students are able to decide for themselves, choosing what they are passionate about, and what college they want to attend to determine their career path. In brief, this debate reveals a shift in the independence of students, showing that many are in college now of their own accord, rather than because their parents force them to …show more content…
While Perlstein does address that some students enjoy college and understand the benefits, he still questions its importance and value to students. As Perlstein talked with students on campus, he noticed they “described college as a small town they’re eager to escape” (Perlstein). The quality of the college is an effective factor to consider. Another student Perlstein conversed with, named Hamilton, told Perlstein he was frustrated with school work, so he talked to the counselor. That counselor told Hamilton that he was not meant for college, and should drop out. If this was a quality school, they would not give up on their students, instead give advice as to what other options a student may have to choose from. In contrast, Addison believes college, especially community college, upholds importance. She states, “They offer a network of affordable future, of accessible hope, and an option to dream” (Addison, 214). There are multiple advantages to college that Addison believes make the time and money spent in college worth

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    I do not agree with this statement, I believe that college will help you in the long run with the job you are looking at no matter what kind of job it is. But, when Bird says “My unnerving conclusion is that students are sad because they are not needed”(Bird 430). She is correct, most high schools willnot treat you correctly in order for you to be “college ready.” Some high schools will still be asking seniors to turn in their work that was due four days ago. That is not preparing them for college at all, they need to grow up and realize they will not be treated like that in college. So, when they get to college and they are not getting babied anymore, they feel like they are “not needed.” They are not sure how to live in the real world since they have been treated like this their whole life.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It also allows student to be independent but still be financially dependent on their parent. In the essay the writer claims that college is a waste of time and money, but is it really? Once our nation desired to higher education, parents and high school counselors began to push kids towards getting a college degree. Parents feels that if their child goes off to college, they will have a better future ahead of them and be financially set. Most colleges want kids to go to their school, so they have to do whatever it takes to convince them to attend.…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    According to the Children’s Defense Fund director Marian Wright Edelman cautioned that if we have college diploma at hand do not work for money because it will not help us to sleep at night and save our soul (Hansen). People who had a college degree at hand should know use it in proper place than only they will worth the cost. There were many ways to get money to attain college to get education that is why…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I think both Trudeau and Reeves believe that college students do not understand how important a college education is. Another point both of these authors think is that college is not for everyone and that every person should not have the right to attend any college that they please. Some colleges spend more money on remedial classes for students, because those students do not put any effort into their education to eventually make the world a better place. Trudeau and Reeves make a major point in both of their essays that are similar. Both Trudeau and Reeves believe that even though students attend class, some of them do not put in the additional time and effort to make the class beneficial for them.…

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “When experts and journalists spend so much time talking about the limitations of education, they almost certainly are discouraging some teenagers from going to college” (Leondhart 2). Even though that may be true, society should not let them decide what to do and what they cannot do , this is our life and people learn from their mistakes and that is a benefit because that is a part of growing up. We cannot let experts decide our future, we are in control and can choose to go to college to better our future and have better…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I have observed many children who have dropped out of college because they were not ready for the freedom of being on their own. I remember my next door neighbor only let her son attend a local community college. The other children attended colleges and universities far away from home, but he went to school nearby. The reason behind that is because his mom wanted to make sure her child was prepared for college mentally. She didn’t want her son to drop out because of parties, and not keeping up academically because of the work.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Whereas Dale Stephens argues that today’s college system is not what it used to be and challenges students to learn outside of a classroom. To explore your interests, learning first-hand what the experience is really like. But if students wanted to become a doctor or engineer, of course going to medical or graduate school would be the best option for that student. He also makes a point that college is not for everyone and informs his audience to discover themselves. He also provides evidence by sociology professors, stating that thirty-six percent of college graduates do not improve any skills throughout their four years of college.…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “The value of a college education is not the learning of many facts but the training of the mind to think” (Albert Einstein). Most believe a successful future comes from education, specifically a higher education like college. Children grow up with the notion that in order to be successful, you must go to college. When a person hears “college degree”, they connect it with a good job, benefits, and what people think is the most important, a good salary. When it comes to attending college, more and more students are becoming hesitant.…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Preconceived notions of college As a senior in high school before going to college it is important to distinguish truth between myths regarding the college experience. As one get older they become increasingly excited to move on and go off to college. However, the movies and stories do not put it into the true perspective. It is difficult to comprehend in high school that virtually every action and decision one makes over those four years can either make or break their adjustment to college. Although each individual’s adjustment and thoughts on college differ, the primary attribute that everyone holds in common is, that individuals believe they know what to do and how to adjust.…

    • 1796 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    College doesn’t teach you anything vocationally useful, just how students can be a better person. They realize that college is not what they want to do with their time. Bird interviewed professors and students across the nation to find out. That most students said that college only taught them to create goals in life. College is not for everyone.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays