What Is The History Of International Political Studies (IPE?

Improved Essays
The four texts that are discussed in this paper all had the same underlying theme. In the 21st century, the world has become more globalized than ever before, and with it, the fields of politics, the economy and the roles of statehood are evolving. It is now up to global political economists to figure out what consequences these changes entail. This is where the four papers either deal with different aspects of these consequences or simply disagree.
Cohen’s text is about the history of International Political Studies (IPE) and its different approaches. IPE originated from interna¬¬¬¬tional relations. As states were getting to be more interdependent, especially in the financial sector, the need for a new field of study to explain this trend
…show more content…
While he agrees that America is declining and China is rising, Wohlforth argues that Layne’s method of argument is flawed. The main gripe Wohlforth has with Layne’s essay is the severe deviation from the scientific method. He argues that many of Layne’s terms are not clearly defined, which generates ambiguity. Layne also makes many claims that are unfalsifiable, again something that goes against the scientific method. For example, he argues that on the global stage balancing powers are always on the way in the near future. This cannot be proven because the “near future” can always be extended. Layne also argues that economic growth has a causal relationship to military strength, for which there is a correlation, yet according to Wohlforth is not necessarily causal relationship. Wohlforth cites the fact that at the British Empire’s height, china had a much larger economy, yet Layne still considers the British Empire to be the sole Superpower of the time. This comes from the need to analyse more than just economics when evaluating …show more content…
As stated in the beginning of his text, a realist believes that the state and its national interests are the highest priority in keeping society away from anarchy. Therefore the state is held in very high regard, and economic activity is marked as less important. Yet in the late 20th and 21st century, power has been steadily eroding from states due to globalization, and in large part trade agreements. However, there is no guarantee that the current trend will continue. China is aggressively attempting to become a power that can rival America, and it will not be content with maintaining the US status quo. If Layne’s “Pax Americana” or exclusive American domination will indeed come to an end, international relations will decline. By consequence, military strength and national interests will once again take a higher priority, giving strength to the realist theory.
The main thing that I took away from reading these texts is that our world, politics and power are constantly changing. It is easy to assume that the current status quo is permanent because it is easy to look at how the world has changed in the past and forget that it will change as rapidly and drastically in the future as well. This is of course, a fallacy as is made clear by the fact that China is rising and soon ready to challenge America. Whether it succeeds or collapses before it can become the local hegemon, there will once

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    The Power Transition Theory

    • 2566 Words
    • 11 Pages

    While almost everyone can see that China is growing more powerful in the world and could possibly pass the United States as the greatest superpower if they continue the trends they are on now, nobody is certain if the transition will be a peaceful one or something like what was seen in 1914. With a declining Great Britain and a rising Germany that was not satisfied with the status quo, one can begin to see glaring similarities to the current situation between the United States and China. A major issue in most transitions of power that is likely to cause war is uncertainty of what will come when the transition actually begins taking place. A confusing transition does not bode well for the likelihood of war, as a major question for matters of war or peace while a transition is occurring is how the system will evolve (Gartzke 374). The period right before World War 1 is in no way a time that was without confusion with the failure of heads of states to make clear decisions.…

    • 2566 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The realist model explains the outcome but assumes a great deal. All we really know for sure is that the United States is in fact dominating world politics at the time. The realist application assumes that the Chinese leaders fear survival and thus builds up national security. There is no indication that China ever feared for its national security. Perhaps China was taking an evolutionary step to democracy.…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Superiority Of China

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The U.S. and other countries will continue to import Chinese goods for now, but the currency will eventually appreciate and make the Chinese currency less desirable. This will destroy one of China’s main drivers for economic growth. Lastly, it is time for the U.S. to realize that China does want to be a world power. As a result, the U.S. needs to widen the technology gap and show the world why no country will ever surpass the U.S.…

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rise Of China Case Study

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages

    As a result, both countries would expand their military increasing the likely chance of war in the future. Furthermore, optimistic realism argues that China is not as militarized as the U.S. For example, China is increasing its aircrafts, naval capabilities, and military budget, yet their military is not adequate to overthrow that of the U.S. With regards to optimistic realism, it supports the theory that the U.S does not fear their security dilemma because of factors that slow China’s progress, such as “ creating efficient, equitable, and open legal and financial institution” (Friedberg 19). As a result, this hinders China’s growth and “will most likely continue to lag and may even fall further behind” (Freidberg). All these factors result to a…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    As China now is a great power in the world of a humongous size and would only continue its own interest and respect. Academics speculate and fear that the introduction of democracy into the country will not only unleash strong nationalisms, popular nationalism will make China even more aggressive towards the US. Lastly, would be a scenario of the collapse of China which is in contrast to the above two perspectives. It is believed and there are concerns that if China were to suffer a sudden-death syndrome such as what happened in the Soviet Union and goes into chaos, an even tragic and worse situation would be created. This would be due to the enormous population size which would make refuge a problem, and a failed state and following crisis such as civil wars, crime and…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Confucianism, with its focus on pride and social unity, allowed China to develop inventions; however, the fear for chaos prevented the integration of technology into machines. On the other hand, individualism and fragmented power, as a result of Christianity, propelled competitions within European soil. The constant warring forced Europeans to develop machines to become more skilled and productive. Modern day societies may be more resourceful and economically powerful than societies in the past, but it cannot take history for granted. The Europe versus China scenario will always remind that to succeed in a global stage, a society must not care too much about defense of the whole but rather the accomplishment of the few.…

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In either perspective the West has been viewed as China’s competitor whether it be as the ideal model or as the enemy of tradition. A big debate surrounds China’s late economic growth as to why it occurred later than Europe’s sustainable economic growth. Knight (2012, pp.5) state how “China’s authoritarian political institutions normally regulated economic activity very tightly” making it difficult to improve, their government exercised strict constraints over many aspects of businesses and the economy. The government also restricted new players in the game of the economy as they brought the threat of new ideas and technologies that may conflict with their own. Another view of this can be seen in Weber’s theory of the spirit of…

    • 2186 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tu 95 Case Study

    • 1741 Words
    • 7 Pages

    China is continuing to grow and spread its borders as far as it can, but is threatening the sovereignty of other countries. The fact that China isn’t respecting territorial disputes among all these countries is a sign of disrespect in and of itself. Though, there isn’t much that we can do about it. The best we can attempt to do is scold them or to pressure them to the point that they don’t see it as profitable to continue expanding their borders. However, the world’s economy heavily relies on China, a fact that makes it hard to impose sanctions because our countries rely on them probably then they rely on themselves.…

    • 1741 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Us-China Relationship

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages

    U.S.-China relations have changed significantly over the last 65 years. The drastic changes from conflict to cooperation and from isolation to economic interdependence shows a lack of ideological consistency from either side. Although it is important to understand the ideology of both states, as it is how they perceive they world and make what is to them rational decisions, both the U.S and China are best understood as realist states. Rapprochement was sought in the middle of hostile relations to increase the security interests of both states, not to advance ideology. In the time after the initial move towards rapprochement, we can see through U.S-China relations that states will either contradict or change their ideology to suit their actions.…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Liberals believe that the US will allow China to do what it is doing peacefully. The realist perspective is completely different. They believe that the rise of China will lead to “intense competition.” Realists believe that as China continues to rise, other states such as the US will try and compete with them. They believe that this might lead to something similar to the Cold War. 2).…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays