What Is The Argument In John Searle's Chinese Room

Improved Essays
The argument in John Searle’s famous “Chinese room” experiment is that understanding or intelligence in general is not the same as teaching a computer symbols, recognition of them, or computations. In this experiment a man is instructed to translate a paper with squiggles by an answer key, through “if, then” statements such as if “squiggle” then “squiggle”. These squiggles are actually Chinese letters. But it is clear that the man does not understand or can even write Chinese, he is just following a set of instructions. It refutes that the computational theory of mind is true because it shows that we don’t need to understand something in order to carry out a task- a computation is different from understanding. He explains that even if there’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This study investigates the use of evaluative conditioning, Evaluative conditioning is the concern on how we can come to like or dislike something through an association. If something that we have no strong feelings towards such as an object or individual becomes associated with something that we strongly dislike such as a disliked taste then our feelings to that once not felt association become changed, this showing that we can come to dislike that thing too. This can also happen when something is paired with anything that is liked through association we can come to like the pairing even more. Such as names the individual associates dislikes to names through past experiences with a person whom shares the name. (Open University 2015)…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In a groundbreaking study, Baron-Cohen, Leslie, and Frith (1985) compared children with Autism aged between 6 and 16 to two other groups which were, children who suffered from down syndrome aged from 7 to 17, and the control group which were children with no cognitive or social disorders aged from 3 to 6. In comparing these three groups Baron-Cohen et al found the cognitive ability of the three different populations differed. After looking at two different standardized test which were the British Picture Vocabulary Test which tested verbal ability by measuring the ability to match words to line drawings, and the Leiter International Performance Scale that measured non-verbal ability such as memory and visualization. Normal children scored the lowest on nonverbal measures with down syndrome group coming in second and the autistic group placing the highest.…

    • 1640 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Good Earth is set in rural China in the early 20th century. During the novel, readers are transported from the fields with Wang Lung, working in the hot and boiling sun, to sitting with O-lan in her bedroom beside her coffin in her final hours. Pearl S. Buck describes how the characters deal with situations including floods,drought,death and much more. For example, readers can picture the struggle and the resilience the Wang family experiences during the period of the drought. Since their land was so parched and the family was so starved, they had to move to the south to make a better life for themselves because what they were experiencing at the time was very difficult.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Searle has argued that there is a significant difference between thinking and imitating a thinking process. For that he conducts a Chinese room experiment where he hypothesize that a machine will takes some Chinese characters as an input and outputs some Chinese characters based on set of given rules. He says that even if the program managed to pass the Turing test and convince the interrogator that it is a Chinese person, in reality it is just executing a set of formal rules. However, the machine cannot have a conversation with a Chinese person. Therefore we cannot say that after the test machine has understood the meaning of Chinese characters.…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “What Did Watson The Computer Do?” by Stanley Fish, it asserts: “Human beings have trouble keeping to the rules. Human beings are always thinking, “Yes, I know the rule, but surely those who crafted it would agree that in the situation I now face, it should be relaxed” or “I know the rules of this game but if I obey them slavishly…” (216). Computers on the other hand, lack this type of cognitive thinking skill. “Human thinking is a concrete biological phenomenon existing in actual human brains. This is as opposed to Watson, which is merely following an algorithm that enables it to manipulate formal symbols.”…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis

    • 216 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Are we soon enough to see intelligent machines rising? Robots can learn or be conscious? “Probabilities that machines could learn from data are not yet discovered”, but it…

    • 216 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    The many modes of processing thought listed above can be further rendered down to the firing of neurons, which as well can be said to be a binary system; consisting of being in the state of firing or not firing. There still remains however a very substantial difference between the two fundamental actions. That difference is rooted in the equipment used to engage in the two respective actions. Searle believes that no computer program will ever obtain intentionality because a computer is not composed of the same biological components as the human brain. This wetware that is the human brain may in fact be necessary for thinking.…

    • 1642 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Adam Gopnik

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Likewise, in the case of the Watson computer, if the computer lacks the database with straight answers, there would have been no way it would have defeated the human opponent in Jeopardy. Furthermore, there is a concept that I just learned in my first Psychology 101 class: If…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lee's Argumentative Essay

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages

    ed he “would rather die a thousand deaths” than surrender to Grant (Winik 168). Plus, when you take into consideration that the Confederate president, Jefferson Davis, had already supported the idea of guerilla warfare, it is obvious that Alexander’s plan was a tempting option from Lee’s point of view. Even with all the benefits guerilla warfare would have had for Lee, he still decided against it, largely due to his sense of duty to the country. Lee was the hero of the Confederates, and had he accepted the idea of guerilla warfare, many others resisting the Union would have followed him.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Critical Analysis: Inside Donoghue’s Room Jack is like a hamster. Each day, the hamster eats and grows, but does its cage ever get bigger? The answer is no; the cage will not become larger until the hamster is able to move to a different environment. Each day Jack grows, but his surroundings remain the same size. For this five-year-old, one hundred and twenty-one square feet are his entire world.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Eureka Hunt Analysis

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages

    When was the last time you sat in silence and reflected upon your life? I mean real silence and real reflection, not soft music in your headphones-silence and thinking about what to have for dinner-reflection. And even more than that: when was the last time you felt like you were in a space and time appropriate for silence and self-reflection? In a society where it is increasingly heard not to be overwhelmed with noise as soon as we step outside our house (and sometimes, even before that), it almost feels as if our right to silence, which should be indubitable, has been stripped away from us. Traffic, advertising, cellphones ringing, texting, tweeting, people working, always talking, always moving, always making noise.…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Steven Pinker’s Language Instinct chapter 7 “Talking Heads”, he explains the difference between human language acquisition and the ability for computers to perform the same. In the past, many people feared that computers would end up conquering humans due to the development of “artificial intelligence” in the 1950s. Research has debunked this myth with the simple fact that for computers “the hard problems are easy and the easy problems are hard” (191). For example, a simple question like “Do zebras wear underwear?” can confuse the computer.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Furthermore, his argument is defensible because the mental and physical states of what is receiving input does not need to be identical to that of a human. A dog can exhibit a state of being in pain, and even a child knows a dog is, at least physically, different from that of a human. The mind is still a functional state because it performs the same function that we have attributed the mind to do, because it does not matter the make-up of the mind, the function still remains the same. Lastly, one may argue instances of things, being able to perform two functions, for instance a stapler and…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In October of 1978 Mary Hiatt published an article, The Feminine Style: Theory and Fact, on her research on the differences between literature written by men and literature written by women. She explains that the style, diction, logic, and sentence structure is different among the sexes. Hiatt employs many different methods to obtain her results. The methods she uses, which include using multiple pieces of prose, separating fiction and nonfiction, her examination of literary elements and devices, and her decision to use a computer, to collect her data and analyze it was an effective choice to validate her research. Hiatt’s use of one hundred pieces of writing keeps her research valid and less susceptible to mistakes.…

    • 1656 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He believes that a digital computer does not resemble a mind because it is being run by a program, which is strictly syntactical, whereas minds have both syntax and semantical content. To simplify, syntax refers to the form or structure of a code or sentence whereas semantics refers to the meanings of those codes and sentences. Therefore, even though a digital computer may have a complex series of 0s and 1s which create the images on one’s computer screen, the digital computer does not understand what those 0s and 1s stand for or mean. All the computer “knows” is the code, not the content. Searle goes on to explain this even further through an outline.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays